The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Haser model, Hapke scattering model, Mie theory, Bruggeman mixing formula, scattering model, Hapke’s radiative transfer model....

Assumptions on spherical grains, assumed abundant fine grains in the coma.


So the detection of pure water ice grains CONFIRMS comets are mostly ice. :D

Hapke’s radiative transfer model, we characterize the type of mixing (areal vs. intimate), relative abundance, grain size, and spatial distribution of water ice and refractories. Our modeling suggests that the dust, which dominates the innermost coma of Hartley 2 and is at a temperature of 300K, is thermally and physically decoupled from the fine-grained water ice particles, which are on the order of 1 μm in size

Our observations of 17P/Holmes resemble those of P/Tempel 1 from NASA’s Deep Impact mission, in the sense that both comets showed small, pure ice grains coexisting with hot refractory grains in the coma.
:rolleyes:

This was A’Hearns understanding based on Whipple’s Dirtysnowball model. Seems his understanding had EVOLVED with all the new data returned.

So, links please jonesdave116, were the 1um pure water ice grains are observed and modeled for comet 67P.

Good luck.


Ice spontaneously forms in a plasma. All we need is hydrated minerals.
 
Last edited:
That was in 2005. Do you have the final results?

I not that even without impact, Comet Tempel 1 is releasing 550 pounds of water per second. That is pretty good for a body with little to no ice.


Haser model :(

Does a comet nucleus “outgass” homogeneously and perfectly spherically? :blush:

You have over estimated the water component based on incorrect assumptions.

Bit silly. :boxedin:
 
No. Where did I say that?


I believe that idea has run into problems after the finding that the water on comets has different ratios of isotopes than water on Earth.

Finding water on asteroids does not in any way validate Electric Comet.


No, you did not understand me correctly. Where did you get the idea that there was minimal to no ice? Did you not read the conclusion that "This is probably unrealistic in the case of 67P"?


And how does that support Electric Comet?


I think that some asteroids could be extinct comets, but I do not know if we have found any. As I pointed out with Oumuamua, we do not know their porosity. As far as I know, a comet that sublimates all of its water does not turn its dust into rock.


Probably.


I do not know about "mostly". Your favourite quote from A'Hearn indicates otherwise, but he is conveniently dead, so it is difficult to get that cleared up. I am sure you would tell us if any living scientist would say something similar. I just note that there is sufficient water on comets to keep them outgassing through sublimation.

If all asteroids are extinct comets, how could that happen when they are on orbits that do not bring them near the Sun?

You have much to learn I see. Would you care to keep discussing Oumuamua and it’s no gravitational acceleration and the lack of outgassing to drive it? Everyone here was to scared.

sublimation is no longer tenable
:D
 
Last edited:
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
 
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
 
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
 
That was in 2005. Do you have the final results?

I not that even without impact, Comet Tempel 1 is releasing 550 pounds of water per second. That is pretty good for a body with little to no ice.
FYI, steenkh. Sol88's reply to you is one of his many persistent deluded lies.

The mainstream Haser model first stated in 1957 is a simple model of the the gas distribution of comet coma. It takes the observed production rate Q for a comet and other parameters and gives n the number density of a species. It has an assumption of a spherically symmetric comet coma.
See for example A re-evaluation of the Haser model scale lengths for comets (1985).

These specific deluded lies are outgassing in quotes about a mainstream model where comets outgas, lying about the model itself (no assumption about the nucleus) and the repeated deluded lie that Q is the result of the model :jaw-dropp.
 
No. Where did I say that?...
FYI, steenkh. Sol88's reply to you is one of his many persistent deluded lies.
He has a delusion that ʻOumuamua is a comet when it is an interstellar object of unknown nature. We do not know its composition or mass or even a precise idea of its size ("100 m–1,000 m × 35 m–167 m × 35 m–167 m").
He lies about a non gravitational acceleration caused by outgassing - that speculation has been discarded for months (September 2018). The current contender is "a push from solar radiation pressure".

He has repeated that delusion and lie many times and been corrected many times, making this a persistent deluded lie.

He ends with an utterly deluded lie by quote mining an irrelevant mainstream ices and dust comet paper - no surprise there.
 
Last edited:
Reckon steenkh is cluey enough.

Assumption are not good for facts.

Easy to put you in your place with your absolute evangelical desire to defend OITDATED models.

They see ice/water no question. The rest is interpretation and assumptions plugged into models.
 
You and jd116 already concede that the model, Whipples is in neee of an update.
 
Haser model :(

Does a comet nucleus “outgass” homogeneously and perfectly spherically? :blush:

You have over estimated the water component based on incorrect assumptions.

Bit silly. :boxedin:

And more lying. Show me where the Haser model is wrong. Show me where it has anything to do with detections of solid ice.
 
Reckon steenkh is cluey enough.

Assumption are not good for facts.

Easy to put you in your place with your absolute evangelical desire to defend OITDATED models.

They see ice/water no question. The rest is interpretation and assumptions plugged into models.

Really? According to whom? You? Don't make me laugh. You haven't got clue one about any of the relevant science. Ice and gas killed your woo. Get over it.
 
Haser model, Hapke scattering model, Mie theory, Bruggeman mixing formula, scattering model, Hapke’s radiative transfer model....

Assumptions on spherical grains, assumed abundant fine grains in the coma.


So the detection of pure water ice grains CONFIRMS comets are mostly ice. :D



:rolleyes:

This was A’Hearns understanding based on Whipple’s Dirtysnowball model. Seems his understanding had EVOLVED with all the new data returned.

So, links please jonesdave116, were the 1um pure water ice grains are observed and modeled for comet 67P.

Good luck.


Ice spontaneously forms in a plasma. All we need is hydrated minerals.

Liar. The detection of icy grains shows that there is ice below the surface. Learn to read. And nobody has claimed that comets are mostly ice for decades. That is your own strawman. And you keep lying about it, despite being shown the evidence that you are a liar. And do please show how ice is forming in the plasma conditions around a comet. And where have the detections at comets been ascribed to this? In the scientific literature. You are lying again.
 
Last edited:
Liar liar pants on fire...:D

I like your low ball scientific debating, so much easier than actually facing the facts.

Ice inferred under the surface.

You have heard of the “activity paradox” I hope?

How much ice is observed in the coma of 67P, jonesdave116?

You know the comet we had been orbiting, quite close at times, for 2 odd years.

Where’s the gas used in the Haser model comming from? Goose.

Sublimation is no longer tenable. Why is this so hard for you to accept? All from mainstream peer reviewed papers no less.

How is the dust getting into the coma?
 
Liar liar pants on fire...:D

I like your low ball scientific debating, so much easier than actually facing the facts.

Ice inferred under the surface.

You have heard of the “activity paradox” I hope?

How much ice is observed in the coma of 67P, jonesdave116?

You know the comet we had been orbiting, quite close at times, for 2 odd years.

Where’s the gas used in the Haser model comming from? Goose.

Sublimation is no longer tenable. Why is this so hard for you to accept? All from mainstream peer reviewed papers no less.

How is the dust getting into the coma?

Lying again. Ice is not inferred under the surface. It is detected. And we don't need to see ice in the coma of 67P, because we can see the sublimation products from the ice. Duh! And we do see it below the surface of 67P when it is exposed by cliff collapse, and in the debris therefrom.
Sublimation is fine, as has been proven. You are still batting zero. Your woo has failed. Why are you still here? Trolling, as far as I can see.
 
We’ve gone over this before I’m sure but let’s have another go..

These observations represent the first measurements of energetic charged submicron-sized dust or ice grains (nanograins) in a cometary environment.

Observation of charged nanograins at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Dust or ice grains???

Energetic charged grains...welcome to the ELECTRIC COMET.:D
 
Lying again. Ice is not inferred under the surface. It is detected. And we don't need to see ice in the coma of 67P, because we can see the sublimation products from the ice. Duh! And we do see it below the surface of 67P when it is exposed by cliff collapse, and in the debris therefrom.
Sublimation is fine, as has been proven. You are still batting zero. Your woo has failed. Why are you still here? Trolling, as far as I can see.

Little to no ice champ. You’ve been out played.

Reasonable porosities are within 65% (for dust = 2000 kg/m3; Fnucleus = 3; dust = 20%; ice = 15%) to 80% (for dust = 3500 kg/m3; Fnucleus = 7; dust = 13%; ice = 7%), corresponding to a highly porous dusty nucleus. Larger porosities (> 80%) require very high dust-to-ice ratios (Fnucleus >> 7), where the ice content decreases rapidly from a few percent to ultimately zero, representing a highly porous dusty nucleus with little to no ice. This is probably unrealistic in the case of 67P, but not unreasonable because it is the ultimate fate of a comet nucleus at the end of its "active life".


What’s the porosity of 67P again...:thumbsup:
 
We’ve gone over this before I’m sure but let’s have another go..



Observation of charged nanograins at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Dust or ice grains???

Energetic charged grains...welcome to the ELECTRIC COMET.:D

Nope, lying again. EC woo requires EDM (lol), electric discharges and rock. Given that none of those things are present, we can safely assume that the scientifically impossible EC woo has failed.
 
Little to no ice champ. You’ve been out played.




What’s the porosity of 67P again...:thumbsup:

And more lies. What does Patzold say?

This is probably unrealistic in the case of 67P.....................the gas instruments work hard on realistic final values. There is a strict threshold: the lost gas mass shall be 5.25·109 kg for Fcoma = 1. For any other gas mass values > 5.25·109 kg, Fcoma is < 1.

5 x 109 kg = 5 million tonnes! Of stuff that shouldn't be there according to your failed woo.

You need to learn to read before you copy/ paste stuff.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom