Sol88
Philosopher
- Joined
- Mar 23, 2009
- Messages
- 8,437
Haser model, Hapke scattering model, Mie theory, Bruggeman mixing formula, scattering model, Hapke’s radiative transfer model....
Assumptions on spherical grains, assumed abundant fine grains in the coma.
So the detection of pure water ice grains CONFIRMS comets are mostly ice.

This was A’Hearns understanding based on Whipple’s Dirtysnowball model. Seems his understanding had EVOLVED with all the new data returned.
So, links please jonesdave116, were the 1um pure water ice grains are observed and modeled for comet 67P.
Good luck.
Ice spontaneously forms in a plasma. All we need is hydrated minerals.
Assumptions on spherical grains, assumed abundant fine grains in the coma.
So the detection of pure water ice grains CONFIRMS comets are mostly ice.
Hapke’s radiative transfer model, we characterize the type of mixing (areal vs. intimate), relative abundance, grain size, and spatial distribution of water ice and refractories. Our modeling suggests that the dust, which dominates the innermost coma of Hartley 2 and is at a temperature of 300K, is thermally and physically decoupled from the fine-grained water ice particles, which are on the order of 1 μm in size
Our observations of 17P/Holmes resemble those of P/Tempel 1 from NASA’s Deep Impact mission, in the sense that both comets showed small, pure ice grains coexisting with hot refractory grains in the coma.
This was A’Hearns understanding based on Whipple’s Dirtysnowball model. Seems his understanding had EVOLVED with all the new data returned.
So, links please jonesdave116, were the 1um pure water ice grains are observed and modeled for comet 67P.
Good luck.
Ice spontaneously forms in a plasma. All we need is hydrated minerals.
Last edited:


.