The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
The usual gibberish not to be answered

Persistent lies about astronomers and insults of astronomers.
The usual gibberish not to be answered. It is one or more of
 
Last edited:
You make too easy Reality Check!

sublimation is unable to remove anything , ergo scrap that as a mechanism for "jet"/activity and comets as mostly ice is incorrect.

As the NEW raft of papers show!

Still funny as fark to watch you too hang onto the old days religiously!

Comets are MOSTLY ROCK.


Simple :)
 
sublimation is unable to remove anything , ergo scrap that as a mechanism for "jet"/activity and comets as mostly ice is incorrect.
Even if it is true, it does not make the Electric Comet fantasy true. Scientists would need to come up with something that is possible in physics, rather than EU.

Comets are MOSTLY ROCK.
And this rock miraculously turns into ice when struck with a pellet?
 
Even if it is true, it does not make the Electric Comet fantasy true. Scientists would need to come up with something that is possible in physics, rather than EU.


And this rock miraculously turns into ice when struck with a pellet?

Mainstream are the one trying to preform miracles. ;)

Comets are mostly rock with very little ice...

Please tell me you’ve read The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications before you chime in with comments, much like reality check’s.

Please someone other than, reality check and jonesdave116, please give a concise summary of what the implications are for Whipple’s Dirtysnowball model.

Would settle this endless loop right there.

Steenkh?

What’s your take on the possibilities other than sublimation and comets are mostly ice?
 
Last edited:
Mainstream are the one trying to preform miracles. ;)

Comets are mostly rock with very little ice...

Please tell me you’ve read The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications before you chime in with comments, much like reality check’s.

Please someone other than, reality check and jonesdave116, please give a concise summary of what the implications are for Whipple’s Dirtysnowball model.

Would settle this endless loop right there.

Steenkh?

What’s your take on the possibilities other than sublimation and comets are mostly ice?


More deliberate lying. There is no rock. How many times do you need to be told before you stop lying? Lies are all you have left, aren't they?
 
You make too easy Reality Check!

sublimation is unable to remove anything , ergo scrap that as a mechanism for "jet"/activity and comets as mostly ice is incorrect.

As the NEW raft of papers show!

Still funny as fark to watch you too hang onto the old days religiously!

Comets are MOSTLY ROCK.


Simple :)

More lying. No rock, and plenty of ice. And sublimation can most certainly remove dust, as shown in lab experiments. Just quit with these pathetic lies.
 
Absolute tripe!

But you,jonesdave116 would believe a paper from 2012 :rolleyes:

Thousands of tonnes of ice ejected, which you yourself said would kill your woo. Why are you still here, still refusing to address the evidence, and still lying?
Sol, all you have ever done about this idiotic model is lie and obfuscate and gish-gallop. It is pathetic. You even make some of the most dogmatic EUists look bad, and that really takes some doing. You have absolutely nothing. No science, no mechanisms and no evidence. You are all talk. You have clue zero about any science, and rely purely on a quasi-religious belief in the unscientific garbage of non-scientists with a Velikovskian agenda.
Your woo is long dead. Nobody believes it. It has totally failed. Not a single piece of evidence for it. And a shed load against. Complete failure.
 
So either Tempel 1 and Hartley 2 were ice comets and 67P is a dusty comet or there are a few glaring problems with the mainstream model.

Liar. There is no such thing as 'ice comets' according to the idiot Thornhill. They are all rock, blasted off of planets. Ergo, you admit that you, and your woo, are a complete failure. And Tempel 1 was outgassing less than 67P at the time of encounter. Therefore, 67P is icier than Tempel 1, from which thousands of tonnes of ice were excavated! Your own post from 2007 shows that you now agree that your woo has completely failed. You can lie all you like, but the internet never forgets. Your problem is that you lie so often that you cannot keep track of all the lies you've told, and get tripped up by them coming back to haunt you.
And this thread is not about the mainstream model - it is about the 100% failed EC woo.
 
But you,jonesdave116 would believe a paper from 2012

They detected thousands of tonnes of ice being ejected. What is not to believe, given that other studies confirm this? You failed, based on your own post from 2007. Now you are off on another gish-gallop of lying to hide from the fact that your woo has failed by your own standards.
 
The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications

Steenkh?
 
They detected thousands of tonnes of ice being ejected. What is not to believe, given that other studies confirm this? You failed, based on your own post from 2007. Now you are off on another gish-gallop of lying to hide from the fact that your woo has failed by your own standards.

Do you OR do you not believe Martin Pätzold
The nucleus is thus a highly porous very dusty body with very little ice.
jonesdave116?

The Deep Impact onto comet 9P/Tempel 1, did enable an estimate of the bulk density of 400 kg/m³ from the dynamics of the impact ejecta, albeit with a high uncertainty (A'Hearn et al., 2005).
jd116?

Pony up. :blush:
 
Last edited:
Do you OR do you not believe Martin Pätzold jonesdave116?

jd116?

Pony up. :blush:

I believe the observations that detected thousands of tonnes of ice. It is indisputable.
And I find it far more likely that Patzold et al have made a wrong assumption somewhere along the line, than every single gas estimate from various instruments, and Earth-based observations, are wrong. As I've already pointed out here;

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=12561981&postcount=2623
 
Mainstream are the one trying to preform miracles. ;)
First of all, you carefully avoid the very telling result of Deep Impact on Tempel 1. Secondly, any failure of the mainstream view is not an endorsement of EU. You have been told this for years, and yet you continue treating the Electric Comet as the default theory if mainstream fails.

Comets are mostly rock with very little ice...
Except, of course, Tempel 1.

Please tell me you’ve read The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications before you chime in with comments, much like reality check’s.
OK, I have. It says that there is little ice, lots of dust, and it does not mention rock at all. I see no problem for the mainstream view that cannot be overcome, but the Electric Comet view fails by the lack of rock.

What’s your take on the possibilities other than sublimation and comets are mostly ice?
I am not sure that sublimation has been ruled out by the one single study that you like to quote, and in any case sublimation then only fails as the engine for moving the dust particles, not the water particles. As far as I gather, Electric Comet fails in moving both.

In my view, the porosity of comets has made it clear that comets do not have to be mostly ice for mainstream mechanisms to hold, and we can probably find burnt-out comets that no longer outgas because the ice has mostly gone. Oumuamua was probably such an example. If we want to know if Oumuamua is a former comet or a present asteroid, we need to know its porosity. We know that asteroids are much more dense than comets - another blow to Electric Comet.
 
Usual lies not to be answered

This post is one or more of
 
Usual lies not to be answered

This post is one or more of
 
Usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

Usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
 
Usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

Usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
 
First of all, you carefully avoid the very telling result of Deep Impact on Tempel 1. Secondly, any failure of the mainstream view is not an endorsement of EU. You have been told this for years, and yet you continue treating the Electric Comet as the default theory if mainstream fails.


Except, of course, Tempel 1.


OK, I have. It says that there is little ice, lots of dust, and it does not mention rock at all. I see no problem for the mainstream view that cannot be overcome, but the Electric Comet view fails by the lack of rock.


I am not sure that sublimation has been ruled out by the one single study that you like to quote, and in any case sublimation then only fails as the engine for moving the dust particles, not the water particles. As far as I gather, Electric Comet fails in moving both.

In my view, the porosity of comets has made it clear that comets do not have to be mostly ice for mainstream mechanisms to hold, and we can probably find burnt-out comets that no longer outgas because the ice has mostly gone. Oumuamua was probably such an example. If we want to know if Oumuamua is a former comet or a present asteroid, we need to know its porosity. We know that asteroids are much more dense than comets - another blow to Electric Comet.

So the ONLY difference between asteroids and comets is thier bulk density?

Researchers find water in samples from asteroid Itokawa

The team's findings suggest that impacts early in Earth's history by similar asteroids could have delivered as much as half of our planet's ocean water.

Thought comets were supposed to deliver water to Earth?


So if I understand you correctly, that Tempel 1 is a standard garden variety Whipple Dirtysnowball icy comet and 67p is a dusty comet with minimal to no ice?

And that sublimation is a viable mechanism for the release of ice grains only?

And asteroids are extinct comets and active asteroids are non extinct comets?

Or have I misinterpreted your understanding of comets?

But our general understanding is that comets are mostly ice and asteroids are mostly rock?
 
Last edited:
Steenkh, you may have also read
From the discussion above it seems to be clear that the lost gas mass was strongly overestimated by the gas instruments and these teams work all on more realistic estimates.
from Patzold’s paper?

This has implications for Tempel 1’s “tons and tons” of ice (gas) released during deep impact.

Deep Impact Was a Dust-up, Not a Gusher
SWAS operators were puzzled by the lack of increased water vapor from Tempel 1.

So Tempel 1 is a special standard mostly ice type comet? And all other comets visted are anomalies...mostly rock/stony/refractory dust with a density of terrestrial rock and minimal to no ice.

Right think I’ve got it now.
 
Last edited:
I am not sure that sublimation has been ruled out by the one single study that you like to quote, and in any case sublimation then only fails as the engine for moving the dust particles, not the water particles. As far as I gather, Electric Comet fails in moving both.
The situation is worse than an deluded obsession with 1 study, steenkh.

Sol88 lies by cherry picking one possibility out of a range that is dismissed by the authors. jonesdave116 wrote on 1st March 2019
Lying again. Learn to read. From the summary and conclusions;
Larger porosities (> 80%) require very high dust-to-ice ratios (Fnucleus >> 7), where the ice content decreases rapidly from a few percent to ultimately zero, representing a highly porous dusty nucleus with little to no ice. This is probably unrealistic in the case of 67P, but not unreasonable because it is the ultimate fate of a comet nucleus at the end of its "active life".
The part you cherry-picked was from a list of possible porosities. They dismiss this in the summary.

Sol88 lies because this study has ices sublimating! That "lost gas mass" in the abstract is gas from sublimating ices in this mainstream ices and dust paper.

Sol88 lies because the ices we have detected at 67P will sublimate. It is textbook physics backed up by experiments that ices in the conditions of comets close to the Sun will sublimate.
Water ice found on the surface of comet 67P (January 14, 2016)

As you have seen it is useless trying to answer Sol88's stupidity of asking about mainstream comets in a thread about the electric comet insanity. 10 years of this thread says all you will get back is more stupidity and lies. That 10 years gives us:
The insane delusion that density alone is what separates comets from asteroids.
The insane delusion that an asteroid having some water as expected in the mainstream is relevant to the electric comet insanity of comets being rock blasted from rocky planets, etc..
A deluded lie about ices on Tempel 1 by citing the production of water vapor and still denying that the millions of kilograms of ejecta contained 20-50% water!
A deluded "Thought comets were supposed to deliver water to Earth?" lie. Internal production, comets and asteroids are the mechanisms proposed for the oceans on Earth. Years ago, we found that water on comets had a range of isotope ratios that included the predictions for the early oceans (Now researchers find that water seen in Comet Hartley 2 is very close to Earth's, with about 1,610 deuterium atoms per 10 million regular hydrogen atoms from 2011). But years ago we found this was not the case for 67P (Rosetta Comet Mission Reveals Clues About the Origin of Earth’s Water from 2014).
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom