The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

Usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
 
Usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

Usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
 
Last edited:
The situation is worse than an deluded obsession with 1 study, steenkh.

Sol88 lies by cherry picking one possibility out of a range that is dismissed by the authors. jonesdave116 wrote on 1st March 2019


Sol88 lies because this study has ices sublimating! That "lost gas mass" in the abstract is gas from sublimating ices in this mainstream ices and dust paper.

Sol88 lies because the ices we have detected at 67P will sublimate. It is textbook physics backed up by experiments that ices in the conditions of comets close to the Sun will sublimate.
Water ice found on the surface of comet 67P (January 14, 2016) f

I fear you fear debating this particular paper reality check? :confused:

Lying again. Learn to read. From the summary and conclusions;
Larger porosities (> 80%) require very high dust-to-ice ratios (Fnucleus >> 7), where the ice content decreases rapidly from a few percent to ultimately zero, representing a highly porous dusty nucleus with little to no ice. This is probably unrealistic in the case of 67P, but not unreasonable because it is the ultimate fate of a comet nucleus at the end of its "active life".
The part you cherry-picked was from a list of possible porosities. They dismiss this in the summary.

So,....how far through it’s “life” span is comet 67P? Avitive asteroid Bennu is the other side of that equation. So it stands 85% porosity for 67P.

Comet 67P is a stony(rocky/refractory material) highly porous agglomeration of organics with little to no volatiles.


The implications are fatal to Whipple’s sublimation model for anyone with a spare neutron or two to inferr from the data received in situ and the visual pictures of fractured rock, along with the complete failure to provide a plausible explanation for the production of said debatable mas loss from “gas” and dust.

These were thought to be as per Whipple’s model in the production of gas and dust from sublimation under solar illumination.

Your Dirtysnowball. :D


Keen to have a real dig at the paper reality check?
 
Last edited:
We’ve forgotten all about the ELECTRIC COMET also postulating the nucleus is NOT in charge equilibrium with its current PLASMA (that magical fourth state (the FUNDAMENTAL state) of matter ) environment.

Effectively it’s a charged rock. This would manifest as a polarised electric field centred on the nucleus.

Ambipolar electric fields, surface electric fields, polarised electric fields, hall currents, fields aligned current these are just a few of my favourite things...

Oh, look Size of a plasma cloud matters. The polarisation electric field of a small-scale comet ionosphere

Conclusions: The same process gives rise to a tailward directed electric field with a strength of the order of 10% of the solar wind electric field. Using a simple cloud model we have shown that the polarisation electric field, which arises because of the small size of the comet ionosphere as compared to the pick up ion gyroradius, can explain the observed significant tailward acceleration of cometary ions and is consistent with the observed lack of influence of the solar wind electric field in the inner coma.

Silly us in our kerfufflle to argue of A’Hearns definition of ROCK.


As in
(c) Whatarecometsmadeof? At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].
 
Last edited:
Usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

Usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
 
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
 
Persistent lies about comets.
Ices have been found on comets as in the papers he has cited.

:deadhorse

Not in dispute. The amount of ice at Tempel 1 was deduced from the dust observed from an incoorect assumption on the dust to gas ratio.

Seems they were out by quite a bit.

Tempel 1 seems very much like an outlier, in the mainstream thinking.

67P is NOTHING like Tempel 1 according to Reality Check and jonesdave116.

But 67P is like Bennu an asteroid, active at that!

Lying again. Learn to read. From the summary and conclusions;
Larger porosities (> 80%) require very high dust-to-ice ratios (Fnucleus >> 7), where the ice content decreases rapidly from a few percent to ultimately zero, representing a highly porous dusty nucleus with little to no ice. This is probably unrealistic in the case of 67P, but not unreasonable because it is the ultimate fate of a comet nucleus at the end of its "active life".
The part you cherry-picked was from a list of possible porosities. They dismiss this in the summary
.

They did not dismiss this fatal piece of data for the dirtysnowball, you just have trouble accepting the new data.

Funny as!
 
Last edited:
So the ONLY difference between asteroids and comets is thier bulk density?
No. Where did I say that?

Researchers find water in samples from asteroid Itokawa

Thought comets were supposed to deliver water to Earth?
I believe that idea has run into problems after the finding that the water on comets has different ratios of isotopes than water on Earth.

Finding water on asteroids does not in any way validate Electric Comet.

So if I understand you correctly, that Tempel 1 is a standard garden variety Whipple Dirtysnowball icy comet and 67p is a dusty comet with minimal to no ice?
No, you did not understand me correctly. Where did you get the idea that there was minimal to no ice? Did you not read the conclusion that "This is probably unrealistic in the case of 67P"?

And that sublimation is a viable mechanism for the release of ice grains only?
And how does that support Electric Comet?

And asteroids are extinct comets and active asteroids are non extinct comets?
I think that some asteroids could be extinct comets, but I do not know if we have found any. As I pointed out with Oumuamua, we do not know their porosity. As far as I know, a comet that sublimates all of its water does not turn its dust into rock.

Or have I misinterpreted your understanding of comets?
Probably.

But our general understanding is that comets are mostly ice and asteroids are mostly rock?
I do not know about "mostly". Your favourite quote from A'Hearn indicates otherwise, but he is conveniently dead, so it is difficult to get that cleared up. I am sure you would tell us if any living scientist would say something similar. I just note that there is sufficient water on comets to keep them outgassing through sublimation.

If all asteroids are extinct comets, how could that happen when they are on orbits that do not bring them near the Sun?
 
Steenkh, you may have also read from Patzold’s paper?

This has implications for Tempel 1’s “tons and tons” of ice (gas) released during deep impact.

Deep Impact Was a Dust-up, Not a Gusher
That was in 2005. Do you have the final results?

I not that even without impact, Comet Tempel 1 is releasing 550 pounds of water per second. That is pretty good for a body with little to no ice.
 
Not in dispute. The amount of ice at Tempel 1 was deduced from the dust observed from an incoorect assumption on the dust to gas ratio.

And another lie. The ice was detected in IR from the absorption spectrum at 3 μm by the in-situ spacecraft. Spitzer used the v2 vibrational band of water at 6.4 μm to calculate the amount of ice released into the coma.
 
Last edited:
Tempel 1 seems very much like an outlier, in the mainstream thinking.

And that is another lie. Tempel 1 was outgassing roughly the same amount as 67P at the time of encounter.

But 67P is like Bennu an asteroid, active at that!

Is also a lie.

They did not dismiss this fatal piece of data for the dirtysnowball, you just have trouble accepting the new data.

Is also a lie. They certainly did for the case of 67P. As they wrote. Learn to read.
 
Last edited:
Effectively it’s a charged rock. This would manifest as a polarised electric field centred on the nucleus.

Is a lie. And there is zero evidence for any electric comet woo. It is 100% debunked.

Ambipolar electric fields, surface electric fields, polarised electric fields, hall currents, fields aligned current these are just a few of my favourite things...

None of which has anything to do with the failed EC woo. You need EDM (lol), and discharges, and rock. There are none of those things. Ergo, the EC woo has failed.

The implications are fatal to Whipple’s sublimation model for anyone with a spare neutron or two to inferr from the data received in situ and the visual pictures of fractured rock, along with the complete failure to provide a plausible explanation for the production of said debatable mas loss from “gas” and dust.

Strawman and lies. What is 'debatable'? You haven't a clue about the relevant science, so show me where this has been called into question.
 
Last edited:
And another lie. The ice was detected in IR from the absorption spectrum at 3 μm by the in-situ spacecraft. Spitzer used the v2 vibrational band of water at 6.4 μm to calculate the amount of ice released into the coma.

Well there your problem. :D

What model did they use?
 
Icy Grains from the Nucleus of Comet C/2013 US10 (Catalina)
Protopapa, S. et al. (2018)
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1807.08215.pdf

Water Ice and Dust in the Innermost Coma of Comet103P/Hartley 2
Protopapa, S. et al. (2014)
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1406.3382.pdf

Comet Hale–Bopp in outburst: Imaging the dynamics of icy particles with HST/NICMOS
McCarthy Jr, D. W. et al. (2007)
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0019103507000541

Comet 17P/Holmes in Outburst: The Near Infrared Spectrum
Yang, B. et al. (2009)
https://arxiv.org/pdf/0903.1317.pdf
 
Last edited:
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
 
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years. This post is one or more of
 
For other posters:
Why Sol88's "What model did they use?" post was the usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

The first reason is that he has been posting about comets for over 10 years and has never learned basic astronomy, physics or even science in that decade or more!

jonesdave116 wrote:
And another lie. The ice was detected in IR from the absorption spectrum at 3 μm by the in-situ spacecraft. Spitzer used the v2 vibrational band of water at 6.4 μm to calculate the amount of ice released into the coma.
This is basic physics that high school science students know about - spectroscopy. Atoms, molecules and materials reflect and emit light at energies that collectively are a signature of the atom, molecule or material.
When we detect the spectra of water ice grains being emitted from a comet, that is detection of water ice grains at that comet :eye-poppi!
When we detect the spectra of water molecules being emitted from a comet, that is detection of water molecules at that comet :eye-poppi!
When we detect the spectra of dust grains being emitted from a comet,that is detection of dust grains at that comet :eye-poppi!

Thus "What model did they use?" is an insanely deluded question. No comet model is used in spectroscopy.

Astronomers do tend to write "consistent with" rather than "detection of" in scientific papers which is downplaying usual for scientific papers. For example, from
Icy Grains from the Nucleus of Comet C/2013 US10 (Catalina)
Protopapa, S. et al. (2018)
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1807.08215.pdf

Water Ice and Dust in the Innermost Coma of Comet103P/Hartley 2
Protopapa, S. et al. (2014)
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1406.3382.pdf

Comet Hale–Bopp in outburst: Imaging the dynamics of icy particles with HST/NICMOS
McCarthy Jr, D. W. et al. (2007)
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0019103507000541

Comet 17P/Holmes in Outburst: The Near Infrared Spectrum
Yang, B. et al. (2009)
https://arxiv.org/pdf/0903.1317.pdf
Water Ice and Dust in the Innermost Coma of Comet 103P/Hartley 2
The extracted reflectance spectra include well defined absorption bands near 1.5, 2.0, and 3.0 m consistent in position, bandwidth, and shape with the presence of water ice grains.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom