That is another question. You criticised the use of a model that was not used. I asked, what is your take on that, and you just raise another issue.Daughter products assumed to be from parents.
Where do all the organics come from? For instance CN?
You do not think that the measurement of ice had anything to do with it?This has lead the mainstream to assume comets MUST be mostly ice.
In your Electric Comet, comets are supposed to be rock (not dust, but rock), so the same issue is pertinent to your theory: Where does all the water come from? The Electric Comet has no viable mechanism for producing this from rock without electric forces that would have been very apparent, if they had been there.
