The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory

Implications you may ask? For who’s model, mainstream or electric comet?
As he has been told hundreds of times: Mainstream comets are irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory.

An utterly lying question because
  1. A mainstream ices and dust comets paper is about the implications for the mainstream.
  2. A set of insane fantasies is not a model (electric comet).
  3. Few astronomers know about these insane fantasies spewed by a "cult" with prophets, holy books and religious followers :eye-poppi.
  4. Those few astronomers know that the electric comet is insane, e.g. 70 years of evidence that comets are not rock including non-rocky planet dust samples returned in Stardust :jaw-dropp!
 
Irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory

Don’t know why jonesdave116 ...
As he has been told hundreds of times: Mainstream comets are irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory.

The mainstream comet model does not need defending. Any knowledgeable, rational person can understand the 70 years of evidence that comets are made of ices and dust.

What needs defending, is not being defended and is having its insanity emphasized with every post from Sol88 is the insanity in the electric comet theory :jaw-dropp!
 
... electric comet hypothesis becoming the new and surprising mainstream model of comets...
The set of insane fantasies that is the insanity in the electric comet theory has no physics or math. Not one of its deluded authors has even attempted to create a model in the last 45 years :eye-poppi!
The electric comet will never become mainstream because it is insanely deluded about real comets.
The electric comet will never become mainstream because its authors are too cowardly/incompetent/deluded/whatever to publish it in mainstream journals.
 
Last edited:
Irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory

This in course would have to question the nebula collapse theory, one would wonder, which of in course entails the Sun being a thermonuclear bomb about half way through its rather unremarkable life.
As he has been told hundreds of times: Mainstream comets are irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory.

As he has been told many times: Mainstream stellar system formation is irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory.

As he has been told many times: Mainstream solar physics is irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory.
Relevant to the SAFIRE insanity in addition to his electric comet insanity which is the just as external powered Sun that a 1st year astronomy student knows turns the Sun into a white dwarf :jaw-dropp!
 
Irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory

DeepImpact:ExcavatingCometTempel1
As he has been told hundreds of times: Mainstream comets are irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory.

Sol88 once again emphasizes the insanity of the electric comet which is that comets are at least partly terrestrial rock insanely blasted from the Earth and other rocky planets in insane electrical discharges between planets, the insanity of jets being electrical discharges, insane EDM cleaning comet surfaces so that even more insanely they are clean (none of the detected dust!).
As he has been told hundreds of times: Deep Impact excavated water ices and dust from Tempel 1.
 
Are you sure you want to hang your hat on this paper?
Lies about jonesdave116's post which was about the insanity in the electric comet theory and the evidence for ices on comets.
There is no electric comet 'model'. Just a bunch of failed junk on a woo site. Supported only by scientifically illiterate wooists. No science, no mechanisms. No evidence.
And there is plenty of evidence for ice. You continually refuse to address it, as it contradicts your religious beliefs.

As he has been told hundreds of times: This and other papers are about ices on Tempel 1 and 67P and other comets :jaw-dropp!
 
Last edited:
Irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory

We now have sufficient data that makes this presumption totally incorrect.
Lies about the paper he cites and quotes.

Deep Impact: Excavating Comet Tempel 1 14 Oct 2005
Abstract
Deep Impact collided with comet Tempel 1, excavating a crater controlled by gravity. The comet's outer layer is composed of 1- to 100-micrometer fine particles with negligible strength (<65 pascals). Local gravitational field and average nucleus density (600 kilograms per cubic meter) are estimated from ejecta fallback. Initial ejecta were hot (>1000 kelvins). A large increase in organic material occurred during and after the event, with smaller changes in carbon dioxide relative to water. On approach, the spacecraft observed frequent natural outbursts, a mean radius of 3.0 ± 0.1 kilometers, smooth and rough terrain, scarps, and impact craters. A thermal map indicates a surface in equilibrium with sunlight.
...
Because the nucleus also has little thermal inertia, this activity must be driven by material that is near the surface. We suspect that such activity maybe common on other comets, but there are not sufficient data for any other comets to confirm this presumption
This is a paper that makes the authors of the electric comet insanity into liars. He does not cite any later papers saying the presumption is wrong, e.g. the literature on 67P.
 
Last edited:
Irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory

Stop moving the goal posts and you’ll see your ice is all assumptions, as they thought comets were composed mostly of ice...
A lie of moving the goalposts as the subject of this thread is "The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE". Both are obviously insane and indefensible, thus he moves the goalposts to irrelevant and dumb attacks on the mainstream.

A lie as he has been told maybe hundreds of times that ices have been detected on comets. On Tempel 1 as in this paper he cited. On 67P as in the 67P papers he has cited.

As he has been told hundreds of times: Mainstream comets and lies about them emphasizes the insanity in the electric comet theory.
 
Last edited:
Irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory

Overtime, and from this paper the PI’s understanding had been EVOLVING toward mostly rock.
The evidence of an obvious lie and insult about Michael A'Hearn who was an astronomer who wrote 377 papers about ices and dust comets and 8 about comets and "rock".

No rational, knowledgeable person such as astronomers believes in the insanity in the electric comet theory which is that comets are at least partly terrestrial rock insanely blasted from the Earth and other rocky planets in insane electrical discharges between planets, the insanity of jets being electrical discharges, insane EDM cleaning comet surfaces so that even more insanely they are clean (none of the detected dust!).
 
Last edited:
Poor old Sol is well beyond his pay grade with this stuff. He wants a putative ambipolar field to explain all sorts of EC woo.
Another basic fact that Sol88 has not been able to understand for months if not years is that the ambipolar electric field will only exist inside a comet coma :jaw-dropp!
An ice grain or a dust grain on the surface of a comet nucleus should not be affected because the coma does not get to the surface. There are plenty of papers about what the ambipolar electric field does inside comet coma.

Each delusion stated about the ambipolar electric field is a lie about the insanity of the electric comet theory which is that comets are at least partly terrestrial rock insanely blasted from the Earth and other rocky planets in insane electrical discharges between planets, the insanity of jets being electrical discharges, insane EDM cleaning comet surfaces so that even more insanely they are clean (none of the detected dust!) and a solar electric field powering all of those insane discharges.
 
I'll just leave this here;

[qimg]https://smd-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/science-red/s3fs-public/mnt/medialibrary/2010/11/17/snowstorm_strip.jpg[/qimg]

Ummmm....
In summary, the simplistic model of dust production resulting from gas drag overcoming gravity is no longer tenable. However, the dominant mechanism is still unclear. While activity from “cliffs” has been observed by Rosetta (Vincent et al. 2016a;Pajolaetal.2017b), it remains difficult to prove that it dominates the emission.


So how is your "ice" getting there?

Its not sublimation. :D

End of your "ice" fantasy champ!

in fact,
ot a ripper for you to put me out of my misery, as the only ELECTRIC COMET proponent here.

Quote:
However, this assumption is surprisingly simple to challenge.

So let’s challenge it, ay?

Quote:
In summary, the simplistic model of dust production resulting from gas drag overcoming gravity is no longer tenable. However, the dominant mechanism is still unclear. While activity from “cliffs” has been observed by Rosetta (Vincent et al. 2016a;Pajolaetal.2017b), it remains difficult to prove that it dominates the emission. The relationship of the uppermost (optically visible) surface to icy material just below the surface and the means of releasing the dust component remains a subject of speculation. Outburst phenomena are of interest as a means of lifting large chunks of material but it appears proven that the outbursts observed and quantified at 67P/C-G do not dominate the total visible particle emission of the comet. The exact mechanism is unknown and multiple mechanisms cannot be ruled out.
Cometary Dust




NO LONGER TENABLE, so why are you still here jonesdave116?

(tenable
/ˈtɛnəb(ə)l/
adjective
adjective: tenable

1.
able to be maintained or defended against attack or objection.
"such a simplistic approach is no longer tenable"
synonyms: defensible, justifiable, defendable, supportable, sustainable, maintainable, arguable, able to hold water, reasonable, rational, sound, viable, workable, plausible, credible, believable, conceivable, acceptable, imaginable
"this politically convenient view is no longer tenable")
 
Last edited:
Poor old Sol is well beyond his pay grade with this stuff. He wants a putative ambipolar field to explain all sorts of EC woo. Including his rather deranged continued claims of charged dust. However, the field, if it exists, is pointing the wrong way to accelerate negatively charged dust. He has been asked umpteen times to explain this, and can't. We are left with lying and strawmen. Thread should be put out of its misery.

Your still thinking electrostatics 'ol mate.

How does a Birkeland current/current sheets keep - and + separate?

for a plasma ignoramus such as a few posters here, it's a difficult concept to get your head around.
 
Irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory

As he has been told hundreds of times: Mainstream comets and his lies about them emphasizes the insanity in the electric comet theory.

This is not his lie of sublimating ices being untenable: In summary, the simplistic model of dust production resulting from gas drag overcoming gravity is no longer tenable.

Cometary Dust is a mainstream ices and dust comet paper.
 
Irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory

Your still thinking electrostatics 'ol mate.
As he has been told many times: Delusions about physics emphasizes the insanity in the electric comet theory.

This is jonesdave116 listing a couple of the deluded claims.
Poor old Sol is well beyond his pay grade with this stuff. He wants a putative ambipolar field to explain all sorts of EC woo. Including his rather deranged continued claims of charged dust. However, the field, if it exists, is pointing the wrong way to accelerate negatively charged dust. He has been asked umpteen times to explain this, and can't. We are left with lying and strawmen. Thread should be put out of its misery.

Sol88 is lying about the insanity in the electric comet theory which does not include the ambipolar electric field. Ignorant delusions about what the ambipolar electric field inside a comet coma does are irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory.
Ignorant delusions about what charged dust inside a comet coma does are irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory.

As a totally irrelevant aside, I suspect that the ambipolar electric field will be always changing direction. The comet coma is turbulent both physically and magnetically. It may be that on average it has no net acceleration on negatively charged dust and ice grains (the usual lie by omission).
Cold electrons at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko suggests that the ambipolar electric field acts as a damper for electrons
We suggest that the ambipolar electric field keeps electrons in the inner coma for a much longer time, giving them time to dissipate energy by collisions with the neutrals.

Suprathermal electrons near the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov‐Gerasimenko at 3 AU: Model comparisons with Rosetta data
Not surprisingly, electrons, from either the coma gas or surface, must be partially confined to the vicinity of the nucleus by an ambipolar electric field as described by the generalized Ohm's law.
 
Last edited:
Irrelevant to the insanity in the electric comet theory

How does a Birkeland current/current sheets keep - and + separate?
As he has been told many times: Delusions and 45 years of abysmal ignorance about physics emphasizes the insanity in the electric comet theory.

Birkeland currents do not happen at comets and are not part of the electric comet insanity which is that comets are at least partly terrestrial rock insanely blasted from the Earth and other rocky planets in insane electrical discharges between planets, the insanity of jets being electrical discharges, insane EDM cleaning comet surfaces so that even more insanely they are clean (none of the detected dust!) and a solar electric field powering all of those insane discharges.

The authors of the electric comet are so insanely obsessed with Birkeland currents that they see them everywhere inkling physically impossible places. From memory, they have the insane idea that they can see then in comet tails.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom