The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Charge separation (of ubiquitous quasi neutral plasma), electric fields, Birkeland currents (FAC’s). All are required and observed at comet 67p.

What more are you after exactly?

You’re still stuck at point 1 and just row your boat down the river denial.

Pointless unless you get out of your boat.


There are no Birkeland currents. And the rest of your nonsense has nothing to do with the total failure of your impossible woo. You are the one in denial, as proven.

Where is your impossible EDM?
Where are your impossible discharges?
Where is the rock?
Why is there ice?
Why is there gas when the solar wind you need to create it is getting nowhere near the comet for long periods?
Why do asteroids on very elliptical orbits not outgas? And why would they anyway?
How are giant, impossible lightning bolts lifting enormous bodies of 'rock' off of planets?
Etc.

You're continued refusal to address these points is obviously due to you acknowledging that said idiotic model has failed.
 
Knock off the personal attacks. If you are at the point where you feel that only by violating Rule 12 can your point be made, you really should reconsider your involvement in this thread. This is your final warning.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: kmortis
 
Is there an ambipolar electric field at comets?

Is there charge separation at a comet?

Is there charged dust at comets along with charged particles?

Three very simply yes/no answers. No math involved, no long winded deep explanations, just yes or no.


You able answer these simply questions, jonesdave116?

Short answer is yes to all.

As for being blasted of planted by giant lightning bolts, well it’s as good a story as comets are the left overs from some fictitious nebula collapse.

As is now being observed in situ by probes orbiting asteroids, one of which is a comet (active asteroid Bennu).
 
Last edited:
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science

Electric fields have everything to do with the electric comets and active asteroids!....
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

A delusion that mentioning electric fields make comets rocks, etc.

A delusion that electric fields have anything to do with active asteroids. Active asteroids debunk the electric comet insanity by not having cometary orbits :jaw-dropp!

The main scientific causes of comet-like activity on a few asteroids is ices sublimating, impacts and spin up. Electrostatic repulsion from a rational, scientific mechanism may have a role in ejecting dust. That mechanism is not a deluded fantasy about an imaginary solar eclectic field doing magic (a small part of the insanity within the electric comet).
 
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science

If you agree there is an ambipolar electric field and charge separation at comet 67P, I could have a crack at the Sun if you’d like.
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

A delusion that there is any question about a ambipolar electric field and charge separation in the coma at comet 67P.
All plasmas such as a comet coma have a ambipolar electric field and charge separation.
 
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science

Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet Jan Deca
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

Repeated stupidity of citing an irrelevant mainstream ices and dust comet paper and lying about what he quotes. There are no "beams of negatively charged dust" in the quote.
 
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science

Now how we going with the charge separation, as per Decca’s paper?
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

Edited by kmortis: 
Removed to comply with Rules 12, 0, and mod box

Decca's paper is mainstream science abut real comets. Plasma have electrons and ions - separated charges. interacting plasmas have interaction that separate charges.

The electric comet insanity has nothing but deluded fantasies that do not include the dynamics of comet coma :jaw-dropp!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science

What is the ambipolar electric field doing, jonesdave116?
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

[SNIP] sources about the ambipolar electric field present in plasmas such as comet coma have supplied to him many times. Also Google exist :eye-poppi!
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed to comply with Rules 12, 0, and mod box
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science

Or even better still describe what’s going on in FIG. 2. 3D overview of the four-fluid behavior of the solar wind interaction with a weakly outgassing comet, in Decca’s paper
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

Usual waste of our time with an irrelevant mainstream ices and dust comet paper.
 
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science

Or if that’s just too hard a question, here’s another. Iis the plasma in the coma ofthe comet quasi neutral?
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

[SNIP] the properties of plasma have been given to him many times. Plasma is quasi-natural (acts as neutral on a scale called the Debye length)
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed to comply with Rules 12, 0, and mod box
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science

No not really, just happy the mainstream are still “discovering” surprises!
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

The delusion that surprises that the mainstream finds and often resolves are bad - that is how science works :jaw-dropp!

Part of the electric comet inanity is that everything that is found is a surprise since all it has is deluded fantasies explaining nothing.
 
Last edited:
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science

NoThat’s not just “mentioning” electrical forces, sport. Which if your interested is some 39 orders of magnitude.
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

The electric comet insanity of "39 orders of magnitude". This part of the insanity is that the electromagnetic forces are always stronger than gravitational forces. The electromagnetic force between massive neutral objects is zero while the gravitational force is not zero :jaw-dropp!

Another part of the electric comet insanity is the utter madness of the measured density of comets (~0.6 g/cc compared to ~3.0 g/cc for asteroids) being wrong just because electric fields exist!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom