The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science

pretty common experience on earth to watch snow melt and a great kiddies science trick to see dry ice sublimate, so it would stand to reason to exclude the new data to keep the party going.

Sublimation, good one.
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

A delusion that physics observed on Earth (dry ice sublimating) should be excluded. A slight lie because what scientists do is put ices into the same conditions as space and observe them sublimate.

Active asteroids being explained by sublimating ices is a rational, scientific mechanism.
 
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science

The asteroid missions to Benn and Ryugu killed that little gravy train off.
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

A lie that the asteroid missions to Bennu and Ryugu killed off ices sublimating as a cause of rare active asteroids. Bennu has dust plumes with many possible causes which include possible ices sublimating
It's not impossible that Bennu contains ice under its surface, although its orbital position is too warm for it to have formed there. The only way it could contain ice is if it formed farther out in the Solar System, and somehow made its way closer in.

Repeated delusion that asteroids are comets: Bennu and Ryugu are not comets. They do not have coma. They do not have tails.
 
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science

Active asteroid science here we come...oh wait, mainstream were “surprised” to find Bennu active and have limited suite of instruments.
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

Repeated delusion that asteroids are comets: Bennu is not a comet. Bennu does not have a coma. Bennu does not have tails. Bennu is not even designated as an active asteroid (yet) :eye-poppi!

Repeated delusion that science cannot be "surprised" when we get new data.

We have detected a few active asteroids out of hundreds of thousands of observed asteroids. The rational conclusion is that active asteroids are rare. Thus it was rational to assume that Bennu would not have dust plumes.
 
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science

So comets are mostly ice as per the mainstream Dirtysnowball, 1950’s Whipple model?
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

Basically trolling because he knows the answer as explained many times.
A delusion that science stopped in the 1950's - the modern comet model is more than Whipple's model. We know that 2 visited comets have more dust than ices. Tempel 1 was 20-50% water ices. 67P was ~16% ices.

Part of the electric comet insanity is the deluded fantasy of no or little ices on comet nuclei surfaces because they want them to be rock blasted from Earth, etc. Deep Impact on Tempel 1 in 2005 showed that to be deluded. Measurements at 67P showed turned that delusion into insanity.
 
Usual blind faith in Mills book of delusions and lies

Science is in, charge separation and electric fields and the plasma phenomena that that entails is the THE ELECTRIC COMET regardless of thier origin.
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

Lies about the science and the electric comet insanity.
The "charge separation and electric fields and the plasma phenomena" are standard physics for and inside comet coma.
The electric comet insanity has only deluded fantasies about comet coma.
 
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science

Not real rock blasted from planets by giant lightning bolts or whatever fantasy you’ve conjured up but that special comet ROCK.
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

Lies about the electric comet insanity which is actually "real rock blasted from planets by giant lightning bolts".
A deluded fantasy of "special comet ROCK" when astronomers such as A’Hearn use "rock" to describe mineral grains, e.g. the ones detected at 67P and returned by the Stardust mission.
 
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science

No sublimation obserserved.
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

A lie. We have images of ices sublimating on 67P, e.g. jets issuing from inside pits. We have detected the gases from ices sublimating. He has been given these facts many times.

Alternately a delusion that we have to have a camera on the surface of a comet filming ices sublimating?
 
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science

Perhaps an expert in the subject like jonesdave116, is able to tell us the what the current model is after he confirmed they are no longer Dirtysnowballs....
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

Basically trolling by asking yet another irrelevant question yet again. This is a thread abut the electric comet: The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE.
 
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science

As they are now NOT mostly ice but ARE mostly ROCK.
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

A bit of a troll by lying about the irrelevant mainstream model.
The current mainstream model is still that comets are made of mostly ices and dust. That may change as A'Hearn wrote in the future. His opinion in his last paper was that astronomers are evolving toward comets made of more dust ("rock") than ices.
 
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science

Now this ROCK is not rock like we see on Earth but special low density comet rock, all other properties seem similar to Earth rock though.
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

A "special low density comet rock" lie.
Nothing he has cited says that as explained to him many times. Not even the insult A'Hearn's as in that quote in A'Hearn's last paper which is about the ratio of ices and dust ("rock").
The evidence is that cometary dust is made of minerals made in space and in the early solar system as explained to him many times.

A "similar to Earth rock" lie. Terrestrial rock (basalt, granite, sandstone, limestone, etc.) does not form in outer space and his personal, version of the electric comet insanity agrees that it is insane to have comets blasted from the Earth by lightning bolts between planets.
 
Last edited:
Reality check, Is any kind of electric field required by the sublimation model?

Is the charge seperation of the solar winds quasi-neutral plasma reqired by the sublimation model?
 
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science

This leaves the mainstream with no model...
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

A lie because the mainstream model still exists and works as in the many papers he has cited including A'Hearn's mainstream ices and dust paper. The expectation in the 1950's was that comets would have more ices and dust and so that was part of the model. We have visited 2 comets with more dust than ices and so that ratio may be revised in the future.
 
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science

So comets are mostly rock/dirt/refractory material with minimal ice....jonesdave116 is correct! Whipple’s model, The Dirtysnowball, is dead.
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

Delusion that science stopped in the 1950's (Whipple's 1950's model has been updated).

A lie that jonesdave116 wrote "are mostly rock/dirt/refractory material with minimal ice" or hat makes the mainstream model wrong..
It has been known for some decades that dust is more prevalent than ice.
Deep Impact found 20-50% water ices in 2005 :eye-poppi!
 
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

A lie because the mainstream model still exists and works as in the many papers he has cited including A'Hearn's mainstream ices and dust paper. The expectation in the 1950's was that comets would have more ices and dust and so that was part of the model. We have visited 2 comets with more dust than ices and so that ratio may be revised in the future.

Reality disconnect, the direct quote
(c) Whatarecometsmadeof? At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].

Can’t see dust in the quote anywhere??? Oversight?

And even if he meant to say dust instead of mostly rock/dirt/refractory material, it just presents more problems than answers.

Such as my newly discovered favourite the ”activity paradox”.

Although the basic principles are well established, most details remain elusive, especially regarding the mechanisms by which dust is detached from the surface and subsequently accelerated by the gas flows surrounding the nucleus.

Conclusions. In the framework of the presented model, which can be considered common in terms of assumptions and physical parameters in the cometary community, the dust removal by a gas drag force is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding to 1.3 AU. Awayoutof this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.
Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Dust accelerated? The charged dust? the first direct evidence for the presence of electrically charged dust particles in a coma.


I wonder...electric fields anyone? :D

How much dust did Philea collect again?
 
Last edited:
Usual electric comet insanity rather than science.

A lie because the mainstream model still exists and works as in the many papers he has cited including A'Hearn's mainstream ices and dust paper. The expectation in the 1950's was that comets would have more ices and dust and so that was part of the model. We have visited 2 comets with more dust than ices and so that ratio may be revised in the future.


Revised or evolved?

our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock
M.A’Hearn.


Not evolving more toward mostly dust.
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed to comply with Rules 12, 0, and mod box


:D
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You able answer these simply questions, jonesdave116?

Short answer is yes to all.

As for being blasted of planted by giant lightning bolts, well it’s as good a story as comets are the left overs from some fictitious nebula collapse.

As is now being observed in situ by probes orbiting asteroids, one of which is a comet (active asteroid Bennu).

Another admission of failure. None of that has anything whatsoever to do with your failed woo. If it had, you would be able to describe, scientifically, what the relevance is. Despite many invitations to do so, you haven't. Fail.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom