The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Or if that’s just too hard a question, here’s another. Iis the plasma in the coma ofthe comet quasi neutral?

And another admission that his puerile model has failed. Nothing to do with the lack of rock, is it? Or the lack of EDM? Or the non-existence of electric discharges? Thanks for the further admission that you cannot defend your 100% failed model.
 
No not really, just happy the mainstream are still “discovering” surprises!


The implications for the mainstream are quite severe.

Your more than comfortable for there to be charge separation and the associated ELECTRIC FIELDS, I take it?

That’s not just “mentioning” electrical forces, sport. Which if your interested is some 39 orders of magnitude.

Nice try though, it’s a classic. :D

Complete gibberish. Your model has totally failed, and your high priests were 100% wrong. Why are you still here? This is not about the mainstream model. It is about the idiotic EC woo. And it is a complete failure. You have zero understanding of any of the relevant science. You are incapable, therefore, of making any coherent posts on the subject. You failed. Horribly. Why don't you find a physics forum for under-10s, and try to convince them that comets were blasted off of planets by impossible electrical woo? Anybody that believes that is, by definition, scientifically illiterate. And yet you were sucked in by it. Why is that? Due to not having a clue about any sort of science, correct? (rhetorical).
 
The ambipolar electric field is killing the Dirtysnowball. :D

Is the dust charged?


Edited by zooterkin: 
<SNIP>
Edited for rule 0 and rule 12.
pretty common experience on earth to watch snow melt and a great kiddies science trick to see dry ice sublimate, so it would stand to reason to exclude the new data to keep the party going.

Sublimation, good one.

The asteroid missions to Benn and Ryugu killed that little gravy train off.

Active asteroid science here we come...oh wait, mainstream were “surprised” to find Bennu active and have limited suite of instruments.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Complete gibberish. Your model has totally failed, and your high priests were 100% wrong. Why are you still here? This is not about the mainstream model. It is about the idiotic EC woo. And it is a complete failure. You have zero understanding of any of the relevant science. You are incapable, therefore, of making any coherent posts on the subject. You failed. Horribly. Why don't you find a physics forum for under-10s, and try to convince them that comets were blasted off of planets by impossible electrical woo? Anybody that believes that is, by definition, scientifically illiterate. And yet you were sucked in by it. Why is that? Due to not having a clue about any sort of science, correct? (rhetorical).

So comets are mostly ice as per the mainstream Dirtysnowball, 1950’s Whipple model?

Science is in, charge separation and electric fields and the plasma phenomena that that entails is the THE ELECTRIC COMET regardless of thier origin.

Sublimation not observed or needed. :rolleyes:
 
The ambipolar electric field is killing the Dirtysnowball. :D

Is the dust charged?


Edited by zooterkin: 
<SNIP>
Edited for rule 0 and rule 12.
pretty common experience on earth to watch snow melt and a great kiddies science trick to see dry ice sublimate, so it would stand to reason to exclude the new data to keep the party going.

Sublimation, good one.

The asteroid missions to Benn and Ryugu killed that little gravy train off.

Active asteroid science here we come...oh wait, mainstream were “surprised” to find Bennu active and have limited suite of instruments.

And another admission that your 'model' failed. There is nothing from those asteroid missions that has any support for you unscientific woo.
 
So comets are mostly ice as per the mainstream Dirtysnowball, 1950’s Whipple model?

And another admission that your model has failed. I have told you until I'm sick to death of saying it, that that is a strawman of your own making. It has been known for some decades that dust is more prevalent than ice.

Science is in, charge separation and electric fields and the plasma phenomena that that entails is the THE ELECTRIC COMET regardless of thier origin.

No, it entails nothing about your idiotic model. That has failed, 100%, as you have admitted. It is scientifically impossible woo.

Sublimation not observed or needed. :rolleyes:

Which is an outright lie, as has also been pointed out to you previously. Repeating the same strawmen, lies and scientific illiteracy is not going to alter the fact that your woo has failed totally. Is it?
 
And another admission that your model has failed. I have told you until I'm sick to death of saying it, that that is a strawman of your own making. It has been known for some decades that dust is more prevalent than ice.

Sorry, sorry you are 100% correct, again, jonesdave116. A’Hearn already, quite some time ago said the same thing...
(c) What are comets made of? At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].

Not real rock blasted from planets by giant lightning bolts or whatever fantasy you’ve conjured up but that special comet ROCK.

Comets are rocky objects as observed.


No sublimation obserserved.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps an expert in the subject like jonesdave116, is able to tell us the what the current model is after he confirmed they are no longer Dirtysnowballs. As per Whipple’s sublimation model from the ‘50’s.

As they are now NOT mostly ice but ARE mostly ROCK.

Now this ROCK is not rock like we see on Earth but special low density comet rock, all other properties seem similar to Earth rock though.

So comets are mostly rock/dirt/refractory material with minimal ice....jonesdave116 is correct! Whipple’s model, The Dirtysnowball, is dead.

This leaves the mainstream with no model, as Whipple Dirtysnowball model was was the model in favour, now jonesdave116 Dave says this is incorrect.

Comets seem more like asteroids, as evidenced by in situ observations on active asteroid Bennu (a COMET).
 
Sorry, sorry you are 100% correct, again, jonesdave116. A’Hearn already, quite some time ago said the same thing...

Not real rock blasted from planets by giant lightning bolts or whatever fantasy you’ve conjured up but that special comet ROCK.

Comets are rocky objects as observed.


No sublimation obserserved.

Another lie. I linked to the papers that showed that the dust:ice ration was shown to be likely >1;1 a number of times. Yet you keep lying, and bringing up this pathetic strawman. And then you lie again about sublimation being unobserved. I am getting sick of it. I asked you specific questions. Answer them, or admit, once again, that your woo has failed 100%. This is pathetic. Why are you still here? You lost. In 2005 at the latest.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps an expert in the subject like jonesdave116, is able to tell us the what the current model is after he confirmed they are no longer Dirtysnowballs. As per Whipple’s sublimation model from the ‘50’s.

As they are now NOT mostly ice but ARE mostly ROCK.

Now this ROCK is not rock like we see on Earth but special low density comet rock, all other properties seem similar to Earth rock though.

So comets are mostly rock/dirt/refractory material with minimal ice....jonesdave116 is correct! Whipple’s model, The Dirtysnowball, is dead.

This leaves the mainstream with no model, as Whipple Dirtysnowball model was was the model in favour, now jonesdave116 Dave says this is incorrect.

Comets seem more like asteroids, as evidenced by in situ observations on active asteroid Bennu (a COMET).

And another admission of defeat. There is no rock. Read my question;

I want papers that show;

  • Planetary type rock has been detected. After all, your clueless cult leaders expressly say that comets were blasted off of planets by impossible, giant lightning bolts (lol). So, detections of basalt, granite and sandstone would be a good start.

Get on with it. Remember the part I wrote about;

For the hard of thinking, I do not want idiotic games with wording;

Show me the detection of planetary rock, or admit, once again, that your model failed.
 
Last edited:
Not real rock blasted from planets by giant lightning bolts or whatever fantasy you’ve conjured up but that special comet ROCK.

And another lie! This is truly pathetic. I did not conjure it up - the idiot Thornhill and his co-author, whose model you religiously support, conjured it up. Can you please stop with this pathetic lying? Your model is falsified. Go away.

• Comets are debris produced during violent electrical interactions of planets
and moons in an earlier phase of solar system history.

From the idiotic model you believe. Need a link?
 
They are simply “asteroids on eccentric orbits."

Some more from the aforementioned clowns. Why don't you explain why an asteroid on an elliptical orbit would behave like a comet, when asteroids on elliptical orbits don't? Indagator asked this an aeon ago, and you keep chickening out of answering it. Another admission that your woo is scientifically impossible.
 
Last edited:
....active asteroid Bennu (a COMET).

Another lie. How does this asteroid, with an eccentricity of ~ 0.2, conform to a comet in the idiocy I have previously quoted from your high priests? With a density ~ 2.5 times that of 67P? Explain this re your failed model. Why do asteroids with much higher eccentricity not become active? Why do we have comets with very low eccentricity? Want me to quote the aforementioned clowns again?
 
Last edited:
So, where were we? Oh yes! According to Sol's woo, he should be able to supply the evidence that it isn't a total failure, by answering these requests;

For the hard of thinking, I do not want idiotic games with wording; I want papers that show;

Planetary type rock has been detected. After all, your clueless cult leaders expressly say that comets were blasted off of planets by impossible, giant lightning bolts (lol). So, detections of basalt, granite and sandstone would be a good start.
Electric Discharge Machining has been detected at comets (deary me!). Electric discharges (i.e. lightning bolts) have been detected at comets. After all the jets we (barely) see, are supposed to be electric discharges to the nucleus, according to the thickos that head your cult. Try to refer to the magnetometer data, if you can. What do the observations of jets tell us? What direction are they headed in? Were any bizarre, unexpected signals seen in the mag data prior to, or during, the observations of said jets?
Was H20 detected by various instruments at the times that the solar wind was getting nowhere near the comet? The dates you need to be looking at are roughly April 2015 - Dec 2015. If so, refer to the scientific literature to show how a comet could produce any gas in this scenario that isn't due to sublimating ices.
Explain, with reference to the scientific literature, how the ice ejected by an impact at Tempel 1 could have come from anywhere other than the comet itself. Explain, with reference to the scientific literature, how the water ice entrained in CO2 jets, and seen in visible light creating a veritable snowstorm around Hartley 2, can be explained without the ice being from the comet.

As the silence is deafening, I think we can safely conclude that Sol admits that his impossible woo lies in tatters. Given its impossibility, that is hardly surprising.
What we have here is a clash between people who don't understand the square root of zero about any relevant science, and those that do. It is why Sol's woo only exists on crackpot websites, and Youtube. Whereas real science, by real scientists, is in the peer-reviewed scientific literature. And is backed up by evidence. As opposed to a quasi-religious belief in the garbage spouted by Velikovskian loons, such as the idiot Thornhill.
There was only ever going to be one winner.
 
In addition, the best fit to the spectral data depends on the basis set of minerals selected for inclusion in the fitting routine. With these limitations, the spectrum was best fit by 18.2% of the emission from forsterite, 10% from amorphous silicate, 18.8% from Mg–Fe-sulfide, 8.2% from clay, 6.8% from diopside, 5.9% from orthoenstatite, 5.0% from fayalite, 4.7% from carbonates, 4.0% from amorphous carbon, 2.3% from ionized PAHs, and only 2.9% from water ice crystals, with the remainder from gaseous water and minor phases (Lisse et al. 2006).
Cometary Dust

Rock...

These phenocrysts usually are of olivine or a calcium-rich plagioclase, which have the highest melting temperatures of the typical minerals that can crystallize from the melt.
basalt wiki

Olivine...how’s this minerals relationship with comets?

On Earth, most basalt magmas have formed by decompression melting of the mantle. Basalt commonly erupts on Io (the third largest moon of Jupiter),[25] and has also formed on the Moon, Mars, Venus, and the asteroid Vesta.


Perhaps not giant lightning bolts but mainstreams favourite, impacts.

Generally gets the nods to remove material from planets..

Duck, duck goose!
 
Last edited:
More than happy to get stuck into the stardust missions findings, if you’d like.

The first mission to throw a spanner into the mainstream Whipple’s model.
 
Define A’Hearns comet rock...

As per
(c) What are comets made of? At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4]


What is this special comet rock?

Undefined moving target according to jd116.

Lighter than water rock?

The dust we observe and measure is from rock so.... what’s your point, jd116.
 
Last edited:
Some more from the aforementioned clowns. Why don't you explain why an asteroid on an elliptical orbit would behave like a comet, when asteroids on elliptical orbits don't? Indagator asked this an aeon ago, and you keep chickening out of answering it. Another admission that your woo is scientifically impossible.

Ta da active asteroid Bennu, surprise!

Let’s see what the “official” cause of the particle ejection now confirmed by OSIRIS-REX.
 
And another lie! This is truly pathetic. I did not conjure it up - the idiot Thornhill and his co-author, whose model you religiously support, conjured it up. Can you please stop with this pathetic lying? Your model is falsified. Go away.

For the hard of thinking, I do not want idiotic games with wording; I want papers that show;

Planetary type rock has been detected. After all, your clueless cult leaders expressly say that comets were blasted off of planets by impossible, giant lightning bolts (lol). So, detections of basalt, granite and sandstone would be a good start.

From the idiotic model you believe. Need a link?

Or clays, carbonates, refractory minerals, that type of thing you mean?

The same as we see in asteroids, those ones?
 
Cometary Dust

Rock...

basalt wiki

Olivine...how’s this minerals relationship with comets?




Perhaps not giant lightning bolts but mainstreams favourite, impacts.

Generally gets the nods to remove material from planets..

Duck, duck goose!

Gibberish. All those materials are seen in space. I'll take that as another admission of failure.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom