The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
6 CONCLUSION
This chapter has reviewed what is currently known about local manifestations of cometary activity. We presented a revised nomenclature of active features, rec- ommending the usage of descriptive but neutral terms to describe physical phe- nomenon we observe but do not yet understand. Throughout the paper, we use jet- like feature when referring to perennial collimated streams, and transient plumes for sudden events.
We listed historical in-situ observations of cometary activity over a 30 years period, from the Giotto mission in 1984 to Rosetta in 2014-216.
Finally, we dwelved into the ”activity paradox”, which is that current models of dust release and subsequent acceleration by gas streams formed by sublimating volatiles are not sufficient to explain our observations. While we do not have an answer to this conundrum, we do propose several ways forward, to be investigated further.

Local manifestations of cometary activity

30 years and still struggling with the basics.

Poor show, jonesdave116, poor show.

But happy to see you trumpet the sublimation model as an undisputable FACT.

Your same mob are stumped by the jet mechanism’s.
 
More than happy to get stuck into the stardust missions findings, if you’d like.

The first mission to throw a spanner into the mainstream Whipple’s model.

Another admission of failure. Stardust has no relevance to your failed woo. Still batting zero. Just answer the questions I posed. You can't.
 
Define A’Hearns comet rock...

As per


What is this special comet rock?

Undefined moving target according to jd116.

Lighter than water rock?

The dust we observe and measure is from rock so.... what’s your point, jd116.

My point is that you are lying. There is no rock at comets. As observed. Show me the detection of granite, sandstone, basalt, etc. You can't.
 
Local manifestations of cometary activity

30 years and still struggling with the basics.

Poor show, jonesdave116, poor show.

But happy to see you trumpet the sublimation model as an undisputable FACT.

Your same mob are stumped by the jet mechanism’s.

And another admission of failure. You need EDM and electric discharges. Where are they? Answer, please. For the umpteenth time. You are simply trolling, and not addressing the complete failure of your puerile model.
 
Comets and asteroids, the line blurry even further!

Key points:
• The largest low-albedo asteroids appear to be unrepresented in the meteorite collection
• Reflectance spectra in the 3-μm spectral region, and presumably compositions, similar to Ceres and Themis appear to be common in low-albedo asteroids > 200 km diameter
• The asteroid 324 Bamberga appears to have hemispherical-scale variation in its reflectance spectrum, and in places has a spectrum reminiscent of Comet 67P.

Infrared Spectroscopy of Large, Low-Albedo Asteroids: Are Ceres and Themis Archetypes or Outliers?


Is Ceres a comet or an active asteroid, jonesdave116?

Density seems the only difference.
 
Comets and asteroids, the line blurry even further!



Infrared Spectroscopy of Large, Low-Albedo Asteroids: Are Ceres and Themis Archetypes or Outliers?


Is Ceres a comet or an active asteroid, jonesdave116?

Density seems the only difference.

Another admission of failure. I asked you to explain how an elliptical orbit would determine activity. You can't, which is why you continually avoid such questions, and Gish-gallop with complete irrelevancies. Your stupid model has failed. Why are you still here, if not purely for the sake of trolling?
 
After all this time, you still struggle with the basics.

Quasi neutral plasma, Charge separation, Electric fields, Birkeland currents.

Simple :D
 
Actually, talking about continually avoid such questions, and Gish-gallop with complete irrelevancies, let’s see how you go with the basics,

Is there an electric field at 67P?

Are there electric currents at 67P?

Is charge separation happening to the solar wind at comet 67P?

Please show us how an expert really Gish-gallops...

You can’t answer simple questions, so I don’t hold hold my breath with you being able to understand the more complex plasma phenomena.
 
After all this time, you still struggle with the basics.

Quasi neutral plasma, Charge separation, Electric fields, Birkeland currents.

Simple :D

Sorry? What has any of that got to do with giant lightning bolts blasting bits of planets into orbit, a week ago last Tuesday, due to impossible Velikovskian woo? You have no idea about plasma physics. You have no idea about astrophysics. You are a troll.
 
Actually, talking about continually avoid such questions, and Gish-gallop with complete irrelevancies, let’s see how you go with the basics,

Is there an electric field at 67P?

Are there electric currents at 67P?

Is charge separation happening to the solar wind at comet 67P?

Please show us how an expert really Gish-gallops...

You can’t answer simple questions, so I don’t hold hold my breath with you being able to understand the more complex plasma phenomena.

Whoops. Another admission of defeat. Remind me Sol; what are your qualifications in the relevant subjects? What are those of the clueless clowns who invented this woo? And lied about it?
 
I will repeat, for the terminally stupid;


For the hard of thinking, I do not want idiotic games with wording; I want papers that show;

  • Planetary type rock has been detected. After all, your clueless cult leaders expressly say that comets were blasted off of planets by impossible, giant lightning bolts (lol). So, detections of basalt, granite and sandstone would be a good start.
  • Electric Discharge Machining has been detected at comets (deary me!). Electric discharges (i.e. lightning bolts) have been detected at comets. After all the jets we (barely) see, are supposed to be electric discharges to the nucleus, according to the thickos that head your cult. Try to refer to the magnetometer data, if you can. What do the observations of jets tell us? What direction are they headed in? Were any bizarre, unexpected signals seen in the mag data prior to, or during, the observations of said jets?
  • Was H20 detected by various instruments at the times that the solar wind was getting nowhere near the comet? The dates you need to be looking at are roughly April 2015 - Dec 2015. If so, refer to the scientific literature to show how a comet could produce any gas in this scenario that isn't due to sublimating ices.
  • Explain, with reference to the scientific literature, how the ice ejected by an impact at Tempel 1 could have come from anywhere other than the comet itself. Explain, with reference to the scientific literature, how the water ice entrained in CO2 jets, and seen in visible light creating a veritable snowstorm around Hartley 2, can be explained without the ice being from the comet.

That'll do for now. Anything you post that is not related to the questions I've asked you to answer, will be taken as an admission that your woo has failed 100%.

Get on with it woo boy.
 
Sorry? What has any of that got to do with giant lightning bolts blasting bits of planets into orbit, a week ago last Tuesday, due to impossible Velikovskian woo? You have no idea about plasma physics. You have no idea about astrophysics. You are a troll.

:D

So, as shown before your clueless.

Mainstream can’t even explain lightning here on Earth. So I’ve got no hope explaining complex plasma phenomena to a simpleton.

Are you capable of answering very basic yes no questions?

Is there an electric field at 67P?

Are there electric currents at 67P?

Is charge separation happening to the solar wind at comet 67P?

Appears not because that would be akin to admitting defeat.

Please show us how an expert really Gish-gallops...And he did
 
Last edited:
Finally, we dwelved into the “activity paradox”, which is that current models of dust release and subsequent acceleration by gas streams formed by sublimating volatiles are not sufficient to explain our observations. While we do not have an answer to this conundrum, we do propose several ways forward, to be investigated further.

Again, from a NEW paper current models of dust release and subsequent acceleration by gas streams formed by sublimating volatiles are not sufficient to explain our observations. Local manifestations of cometary activity




And


From an OLD paper
Conclusions. In the framework of the presented model, which can be considered common in terms of assumptions and physical parameters in the cometary community, the dust removal by a gas drag force is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding to 1.3 AU. Awayoutof this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.
Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Sublimation :p
 
Last edited:
What’s needed for these gigantic lightning bolts to remove rock from planets?


If you’re feeling brave, perhaps you could tell us how upper level lightning is produced?

You know like sprites, blue jets, elves... This will be fun.
 
Last edited:
Define rock while your at it champ.

Clays and carbonates were a surprise at comets and asteroids!

Or your specifically after basalt and granite?
 
:D

So, as shown before your clueless.

Mainstream can’t even explain lightning here on Earth. So I’ve got no hope explaining complex plasma phenomena to a simpleton.

Are you capable of answering very basic yes no questions?

Is there an electric field at 67P?

Are there electric currents at 67P?

Is charge separation happening to the solar wind at comet 67P?

Appears not because that would be akin to admitting defeat.

Please show us how an expert really Gish-gallops...And he did

Another admission of defeat. This is getting boring. There are no discharges, no EDM (lol). Which proves conclusively that you have failed. You have been asked umpteen times to show the evidence for such, and you can't. Your continued presence here is merely a trolling episode.
 
Again, from a NEW paper current models of dust release and subsequent acceleration by gas streams formed by sublimating volatiles are not sufficient to explain our observations. Local manifestations of cometary activity




And


From an OLD paper Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Sublimation :p

Lol. More defeatism. Nothing in there about EDM (lol), or electric discharges. Plenty in there about gas, sublimation and ice. Fail. Again. Still batting zero. No science, no mechanisms, no evidence. Just trolling.
 
What’s needed for these gigantic lightning bolts to remove rock from planets?


If you’re feeling brave, perhaps you could tell us how upper level lightning is produced?

You know like sprites, blue jets, elves... This will be fun.

Blasting rock into space, are they? Off-topic.
 
Define rock while your at it champ.

Clays and carbonates were a surprise at comets and asteroids!

Or your (sic) specifically after basalt and granite?

More Gish-galloping, and another admission of defeat. There is dust, and it has never been near a planet. No science, no mechanisms, no evidence. Just continued trolling. I've never seen anyone so devoted to a religion.
 
Last edited:
Charge separation (of ubiquitous quasi neutral plasma), electric fields, Birkeland currents (FAC’s). All are required and observed at comet 67p.

What more are you after exactly?

You’re still stuck at point 1 and just row your boat down the river denial.

Pointless unless you get out of your boat.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom