The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

An insane "crock" statement about textbook plasma physics (mass loading).
Mass loading is textbook plasma physics. Any plasma encountering a massive gas or plasma or even solid body can pick up mass from that gas or body. The solar wind is predominantly electrons and protons. When the solar wind hits a comet coma containing massive molecules (H2O, CO, CO2, etc.), some of those molecules are picked up by the solar wind. This is mass loading.
PHYSICS OF MASS LOADED PLASMAS (PDF)

Welcome back, RC. However, as usual, quoting actual science is pointless at this stage. Sol is in the "I want to believe" mode. Science and observation is irrelevant to his quasi-religion.
 
A lie that the Haser model is a model of outgassing production rate

Exobase from the overestimation from using the outdated Haser model of cometary “outgassing” production rate.
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

A lie that the Haser model is a model of outgassing production rate.
The Haser model is an old, simple model for the dissociated ions in a comet coma used to predict comet spectra.
Sol88 knows this because he was given A re-evaluation of the Haser model scale lengths for comets (1985) which describes the Haser model in the introduction.

The outgassing production rates of parent species for the dissociated ions are inputs to the model.
 
Lies about irrelevant, mainstream ices and dust papers

So arguing with someone who’s not even sure how the diamagnetic cavity is formed and maintained, giving me jip about the solar wind not reaching the surface.
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Lies about irrelevant, mainstream ices and dust papers.
Again Sol88 lies about the On the ion-neutral coupling in cometary comae (that states that it is that the ambipolar electric field that stops the solar wind from getting to the nucleus). The evidence for the ambipolar electric field is ion velocities hundreds of kilometers from the nucleus.

Idiocy of irrelevant to Sol88's electric comet insanity, already answered questions.
The formation and sustaining of the ambipolar electric field has been explained dozens of times.

Insanity of citing the deluded and lying Thunderbolts cult, e.g. electrochemistry delusions that have already been addressed.
 
Last edited:
Deluded demand for us to support Sol88's electric comet insanity

Go dig it and show me up.
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Deluded demand for us to support Sol88's electric comet insanity :jaw-dropp!
He is the believer in his Thunderbolts cult electric comet insanity . It is his task to produce rational, science based evidence to support it. More than 12 years and all we have is ignorant parroting of the insanity with no sign of learning. It only takes about 6 or 7 years to get a PhD in astronomy :p! Or 3 years to get a BSc in astronomy :eye-poppi!
 
idiocy that "electric fields" do what the electric comet insanity demands

You do know what an electric field is and how it effects charged particles?
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Insults, the idiocy that mentioning "electric fields" does whatever Sol88's electric comet insanity demands, and idiocy of asking irrelevant, ignorant, already answered questions again and again (ambipolar electric field).
 
Insults and usual deluded derail from Sol88's electric comet insanity

You don’t even know what model your supposed to be using....:confused:
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Insults and usual deluded derail from Sol88's electric comet insanity.
This thread is about Sol88's electric comet insanity. Sol88's abysmal ignorance admitted confusion, delusions and lies about the mainstream comet model and its scientific literature just emphasizes how insane Sol88's electric comet is. Sol88 is so totally incapable of supporting the electric comet insanity that Sol88 has to resort to delusions, lies and insults about mainstream physics and astronomers.
For example there are his repeated delusions about the ambipolar electric fields doing whatever he wants when he is in total denial of what they are!
 
Here is a post from David Talbott that just goes to show how ill-informed the EU high priests are about previous cometary missions;
The Thunderbolts high priests and followers are even ignorant of the existence of Google :jaw-dropp!

Googling 'surface water ice' does list the recent 67P detections of surface water ice first. But it just takes a couple of brain cells to add 'Tempel 1' to focus on earlier missions. I get the first result of Exposed Water Ice Deposits on the Surface of Comet 9P/Tempel 1 !
 
idiocy of asking irrelevant, ignorant, already answered questions again and again

So, you are happy to state that 67P has no ambipolar electric field?
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

idiocy of asking irrelevant, ignorant, already answered questions again and again (ambipolar electric field).

Lies about jonesdave116's many replies to that question which are clear that the question is irrelevant (in a thread about Sol88's electric comet insanity which has no ambipolar electric field). But Sol88 is free to assume the existence of a ambipolar electric field and make it relevant by showing how it answers many unanswered for months or years questions about the electric comet insanity.
 
Stupidity of citing again a paper stating the comets contain ices

Comets are mostly REFRACTORY The Refractory-to-Ice Mass Ratio in Comets
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Delusion that we do not know that some astronomers think that comets are more dust (refractory material) than ices and there are papers stating this.
Stupidity of citing again a mainstream ices and dust comet paper stating the comets contain ices :jaw-dropp!
A possibility that Sol88 is extending the insane insult of Michael O'Hearn stating that comets are actual rock to the authors of this paper.
 
Last edited:
A lie that a paper stating comets contain ices is not good for the mainstream model

Ice? Not looking good at all for your model, jonesdave116, not good at all.
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Stupidity of citing again a mainstream ices and dust comet paper stating the comets contain ices leads to:
A lie that a paper stating comets contain ices is not good for the mainstream model of comets containing ices and dust.
 
Utter idiocy of a paper about the planet Venus in a electric comet insanity thread

The electric wind of Venus: A global and persistent “polar wind”-like ambipolar electric field sufficient for the direct escape of heavy ionospheric ions
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Utter idiocy of a paper about the planet Venus in a thread about Sol88's electric comet insanity.
 
Abysmal ignorance of what "ionospheric" and "ions" means

The electric wind of Venus: A global and persistent “polar wind”-like ambipolar electric field sufficient for the direct escape of heavy ionospheric ions applicable at comets if you believe there is an ambipolar electric field in operation at 67P
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Abysmal ignorance of what "ionospheric" and "ions" means.
The applicability of the escape of heavy ionospheric ions from the ionosphere of Venus would be to explain the escape of heavy coma ions from comet coma!
 
Just a little reminder for Sol of what his model says;



Lol. Nope. They are gas and dust and (sometimes) ice grains, all heading away from the nucleus. No signatures of EDM (lol). No signatures of discharges to the nucleus. Or anywhere else. Fail.



More lols! No wandering arcs seen eroding the surface. The surface is black due to the observed organics. Fail.



Nope. The comet is producing more dust in the active phase. As would be expected for insolation driven ejection. And the majority of the dust ejected appears to be falling back to the nucleus. So, this supposedly negatively charged dust is being ejected from a supposedly negatively charged comet, and then being attracted back toward the comet? I think not. Fail.






Asteroid and Comet Exploration
Arrhenius, G., Alfven, H., Fitzgerald, R.
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/19730018994.pdf

So, who do we believe? A couple of scientifically illiterate woo merchants who say that it is improbable? Or this Alfven bloke and his co-authors? Fail.



Whoops! So, why aren't asteroids on elliptical orbits doing this? Why do main belt comets exist, that have low eccentricities? Fail.



See the previous re eccentricity. And cometary material is nothing like any planet or moon known to man. Density is wrong. Ice would not survive impossible electrical woo blasting it off a planet.

So, to summarise - a complete and utter failure. Which could have been avoided had the authors bothered to avail themselves of the data from the Halley missions 20 years previous to that pile of fail being written.

http://thunderbolts.info/pdf/ElectricComet.pdf

This is the commonly held belief for dust leaving the nucleus, the sublimation model...
7.2.3. Force comparison Aquantitative comparison of the forces acting on a dust grain near the nucleus surface (Figs. 7 and 8) clearly shows that gas drag dominates other effects by several orders of magnitude. The ratio of gas drag and radiation pressure, both proportional to the effective cross-section of dust aggregates, varies in the size range considered here, but is always much greater than unity.
Acceleration of cometary dust near the nucleus: Application to 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko.[/b Yuri Skorov, Volodymyr Reshetnykb,c, Pedro Lacerdaa, Paul Hartogha, J¨urgen Blum

Gas drag?

The dust is charged and responding to the electric field. :boggled:

Although Yuri Skorov did go on the say
Conclusions. In the framework of the presented model, which can be considered common in terms of assumptions and physical parameters in the cometary community, the dust removal by a gas drag force is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding to 1.3 AU. Awayoutof this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.
Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-GerasimenkoYu. V. Skorov1, L. Rezac1, P. Hartogh1, and H. U. Keller

So that’s kind of an about face but that’s science evolving because the latest papers reinforce this

ABSTRACT The gas-driven dust activity of comets is still an unresolved question in cometary science. In the past, it was believed that comets are dirty snowballs and that the dust is ejected when the ice retreats. However, thanks to the various space missions to comets, it has become evident that comets have a much higher dust-to-ice ratio than previously thought and that most of the dust mass is ejected in large particles. Here we report on new comet-simulation experiments dedicated to the study of the ejection of dust aggregates caused by the sublimation of solid water ice. We find that dust ejection exactly occurs when the pressure of the water vapor above the ice surface exceeds the tensile strength plus the gravitational load of the covering dust layer. Furthermore, we observed the ejection of clusters of dust aggregates, whose sizes increase with increasing thickness of the ice-covering dust-aggregate layer. In addition, the trajectories of the ejected aggregates suggest that most of the aggregates obtained a non-vanishing initial velocity from the ejection event.
Experiments on cometary activity: ejection of dust aggregates from a sublimating water-ice surface D. Bischoff,B. Gundlach, M. Neuhaus, J. Blum



Abstract The charge state of dust particles on regolith surfaces exposed to ultraviolet radiation or plasma is investigated for understanding the role of electrostatic dust transport in the surface evolution of airless planetary bodies. Our charge measurement shows that the regolith dust that can be electrostatically transported or lofted carries large negative charges. This result is consistent with our “patched charge model,” which predicts that dust particles forming microcavities in the regolith surfaces can attain large negative charges bycollecting photoelectrons and/or secondary electrons emitted from neighboring particles and the resulting repulsive forces between these negatively charged particles lead to their mobilization. The observed negative charge polarity is contrary to the generally expected positive charges on the regolith dust emitting photoelectrons. The measured negative charges are orders of magnitude larger than the prediction by classical charging models. Our laboratory measurements provide critical initial charging conditions for regolith dust dynamics studies.

The charge state of electrostatically transported dust on regolith surfaces

I wonder how charged the dust is, this new paper says
The fundamental physics of charged cometary dust has been studied for a long time (Mendis and Horányi 2013). Dust charging is a delicate interplay between several currents, including electron and ion collection currents from the surrounding plasma, ultraviolet induced photoelectron currents, secondary electron emission (due to energetic ion and/or electron bombardment), thermo-ionic emission, field emission (due to large surface fields), etc. Asaruleofthumb,adustparticle collects about 700 extra electrons per unit particle volumeequivalent radius (measured in µm) and unit electric potential difference between the particle surface and the surrounding plasma (measured in V). This means that in the solar wind a particle of 1 µm size can have about 104 extra electrons. Based on our experience with mesospheric dust charging at Earth it can be assumed that most of the extra electrons are deep inside the dust particle and they can electrostatically disrupt fluffy, highly friable dust particles (Hill and Mendis 1981)
Cometary Dust


In summary, the simplistic model of dust production resulting from gas drag overcoming gravity is no longer tenable. However, the dominant mechanism is still unclear.


Being all honesty there is bugger all “ice” in the first place as this NEW paper states
We review the Refractory-to-Ice mass ratios available for the comet nuclei visited by space missions, and for the Kuiper Belt Objects with well defined bulk density, finding the 1-σ lower limit of 3. Therefore, comets and KBOs may have less water than CI-chondrites, as predicted by models of comet formation by the gravitational collapse of cm-sized pebbles driven by streaming instabilities in the protoplanetary disc.
The Refractory-to-Ice Mass Ratio in CometsMarco Fulle,1J. Blum,2 S. F. Green,3 B. Gundlach,2 A. Herique,4 F. Moreno,5 S. Mottola,6 A. Rotundi,7 and C. Snodgrass


Abstract. Dust on and near the surface of small planetary bodies (e.g. asteroids, the Moon, Mars’ moons) is subject to gravity, cohesion and electrostatic forces. Due to the very low gravity on small bodies, the behavior of small dust grains is driven by non-gravitational forces. Recent work by Scheeres et al. has shown that cohesion, specifically van der Waals force, is significant for grains on asteroids. In addition to van der Waals cohesion, dust grains also experience electrostatic forces, arising from their interaction with each other (through tribocharging) and the solar wind plasma (which produces both grain charging and an external electric f ield). Electrostatic forces influence both the interactions of grains on the surface of small bodies as well as the dynamics of grains in the plasma sheath above the surface. While tribocharging between identical dielectric grains remains poorly understood, we have recently expanded an existing charge transfer model to consider continuous size distributions of grains and are planning an experiment to test the charge predictions produced. Additionally, we will present predictions of the size of dust grains that are capable of detaching from the surface of small bodies.
Electrostatic forces on grains near asteroids and comets

:D
 
Last edited:
Ignorant delusions and lies about irrelevant "huge" potential drops

The potential drops found at at 1P were huge, to big for someone like tusenfem and his ilk to believe, as H.Laakso found but was poo pooed. Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Ignorant delusions and lies about irrelevant "huge" potential drops.
It is a lie that anyone "poo pooed" Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley by Laakso, Harri (1991). We accepted the scale and sizes of the potential drops that were detected by the instruments.

The abysmal ignorant in posts from Sol88 of stating that these are evidence of double layers is what was pointed out many times.

I wrote that the scale of the potential drops was too big for double layers in plasma (some tens of Debye lengths) as anyone who knows Google exists can find out. It is that word huge that makes Sol88's posts on the Laakso paper abysmally ignorant :eye-poppi!

tusenfem wrote this is a turbulent magnetic environment which high school science students know makes double layers physically impossible. The know what a changing magnetic field does to charged particles :eye-poppi! Magnetic fields changing in all sorts of direction and magnitude (turbulent) moves charges in all sorts of direction and magnitude. Those mixed up charges do not form layers.
 
Last edited:
A "massively overestimated water production" lie

The fact that your outdated model is no longer relevant, e.g the massively overestimated water production?
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

A "massively overestimated water production" lie because he gives no sources
A "outdated model is no longer relevant" lie when the mainstream comet model is current and valid.
Usual deluded derail into the mainstream comet model when this is a thread on Sol88's electric comet insanity.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom