Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
So, how hard was this layer? [rhetorical]Why not read the literature?[/rhetorical]

So bloody hard the MUPUS-PEN failed! In fact it was so hard the PEN recoiled of the “consolidated” layer!

Taking together the evidence from MUPUS, CIVA, ROLIS, CON- SERT, and SESAME, as well as the results of the KOSI experiments, we find that all these instruments, on a set of nested length scales from millimeters to tens of meters, are consistent with a structure of a body that has a thin, consolidated shell around a less rigid interior.

In order to better simulate the topography at the Philae landing site, we simulated the evolution of the material when the solar ux is reduced by 25%. In both cases, also when the illumination was deliberately overestimated, our simulations indicate that the coarse{grained material should not undergo signicant sintering. However, the failed attempt to penetrate the subsurface later by MUPUS-PEN probably indicates high strength.

And there’s your deep fried ice cream champ! :D
 
Last edited:
So bloody hard the MUPUS-PEN failed! In fact it was so hard the PEN recoiled of the “consolidated” layer!

Aaaaaaaannnnnnnddddd again. [rhetorical]Why not read the literature?[/rhetorical]
 
What happened when the impactor hit Tempel 1? It's in the literature. [rhetorical]Why don't you read it?[/rhetorical]

So you are saying 9P is different from 67P?

Where did all the molten silica come from?

Fair enough :blush:
 
Your mass guestimations are about as useful tits on a bull!

Idiot. If those mass estimations were off, the spacecraft couldn't have completed bound orbits, could it? Think before you type.
 
Aaaaaaaannnnnnnddddd again. [rhetorical]Why not read the literature?[/rhetorical]


I have over and over.

Looks like the engineers couldn’t even work out how hard “ice” is at the temps expected at a comet.

Must of been the same mob in charge of the harpoons, thrusters and ice screws! :eye-poppi
 
Dust, you loon. Where did all the ice come from?

Ummmmm......from the OH

Abstract Weapplyrecently updated scaling laws for impact cratering and ejecta to interpret observations of the Deep Impact event. An important question is whether the cratering event was gravity or strength-dominated; the answer gives important clues about the properties of the surface material of Tempel 1. Gravity scaling was assumed in pre-event calculations and has been asserted in initial studies of the mission results. Because the gravity eld of Tempel 1 is extremely weak, a gravity-dominated event necessarily implies a surface with essentially zero strength. The conclusion of gravity scaling was based mainly on the interpretation that the impact ejecta plume remained attached to the comet during its evolution. We address that feature here, and conclude that even strength-dominated craters would result in a plume that appeared to remain attached to the surface. We then calculate the plume characteristics from scaling laws for a variety of material types, and for gravity and strength-dominated cases. We nd that no model of cratering alone can match the reported observation of plume mass and brightness history. Instead, comet-like acceleration mechanisms such as expanding vapor clouds are required to move the ejected mass to the far eld in a few-hour time frame. With such mechanisms, and to within the large uncertainties, either gravity or strength craters can provide the levels of estimated observed mass. Thus, the observations are unlikely to answer the questions about the mechanical nature of the Tempel 1 surface.
 
Dust, you loon. Where did all the ice come from?


It came from the “ice cliffs”! In plain site you did’nt even have to smack an impactor into the nucleus to “see” that :rolleyes:

Tempel_1
NASA / JPL-Caltech / Cornell

Look at all that “ice” :eye-poppi
 
Last edited:
It came from the “ice cliffs”! In plain site you did’nt even have to smack an impactor into the nucleus to “see” that :rolleyes:

[qimg]https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tempel_1#/media/File%3APIA13862_Tempel_1_annotated.jpg[/qimg] NASA / JPL-Caltech / Cornell

Look at all that “ice” :eye-poppi

Good. Then we are all agreed that there is shed loads of ice at comets. Wal won't like you saying that, but hey ho.

snowstorm_strip.jpg
 
No?

He does like h4s prediction of a double flash though!

DEEP IMPACT: THE FIRST SECOND. H. J. Melosh and the Deep Impact Team, Lunar and Planetary Lab (University of Arizona, Tucson AZ 85721, [email protected]).

Although the arc expanded at constant velocity, within measurement errors (roughly ±100 m), extrapolation back to the origin suggests that expansion began about 0.1 sec after the first bright pixel was observed. This period of time is far too long to represent expansion of an initial hot volume of gas (this time scale is only a few ms, according to hydrocode simulations of an expanding sphere of SiO2 vapor)
 
No?

He does like h4s prediction of a double flash though!

DEEP IMPACT: THE FIRST SECOND. H. J. Melosh and the Deep Impact Team, Lunar and Planetary Lab (University of Arizona, Tucson AZ 85721, [email protected]).

Nobody is arguing about a double 'flash'. Pete Schultz had seen it in experiments, and wrote it up and had it published prior to Thornhill's woo. The difference is that Wal claimed it would be pre-impact (it wasn't), and that it'd be some kind of electrical woo (it wasn't). So it is all a bit irrelevant.
 
Good. Then we are all agreed that there is shed loads of ice at comets. Wal won't like you saying that, but hey ho.

[qimg]https://smd-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/science-pink/s3fs-public/mnt/medialibrary/2010/11/17/snowstorm_strip.jpg[/qimg]

Are we agreeing on comets having a well consolidated surface that “looks” like bedrock while we’re at it?
 
Are we agreeing on comets having a well consolidated surface that “looks” like bedrock while we’re at it?

Doesn't matter what it looks like. That is pareidolia. It is what it is made of that counts, and what its strength is, and how it behaves, etc, etc. 'Looks like' isn't science. It is for woo merchants.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom