Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
This is a serious question - do you have Alzheimer's? It can be the only excuse for me continually having to repeat this:

AN IMPACTOR HIT THE NUCLEUS, AND EXCAVATED A SHED LOAD OF SOLID ICE GRAINS. SO IT IS NO LONGER 'HIDDEN', IS IT?

Alzheimer's? Not yet :boggled:

So you are prepared to take J Sunshines findings and bank them as the only adsorption features 1.5, 2.0, and 3.0 um?

The relative intensities of ice absorptions at 1.5, 2.0, and 3.0 um change as a function of particle size (25). In spectra of larger grain sizes, absorptions at longer wavelengths saturate (i.e., they have near zero reflectance). Because absorptions at 3.0 mm are nearly absent in the spectra of the ice-rich regions of the nucleus, their particle size cannot be less than
5 um (Fig. 4A).

ice and only H2O ice?

There are other more simple explanations.

but your cranium is so firmly wedged into your date you have trouble comprehending it's a big bad PLASMA universe out there!
 
There are other more simple explanations.

No there aren't. And only an idiot would believe that there was. Given that the ice was also seen by XMM-Newton in different wavelengths (UV, iirc), and we see shed loads of it at Hartley 2, just floating around, and we see it underground on 67P, then I can see no other explanation. Neither could Jessica Sunshine, if you recall;

33x78gh.jpg


It was also seen at Hale-Bopp and 17P Holmes. So, no, there really are no other explanations. If there were we'd have heard them by now.
 
but your cranium is so firmly wedged into your date you have trouble comprehending it's a big bad PLASMA universe out there!

The reason for this being that one side has a viable model, which is backed up by numerous measurements and observations. The plasma woo side have got the square root of zero, and their model is scientifically asinine. As one would expect, given who dreamed it up.
 
So. let's just have a little recap on ice in cometary comae prior to the Rosetta mission. This is what I've managed to find over a few years:

Comet 17P/Holmes in Outburst: The Near Infrared Spectrum
Yang, B. et al
https://arxiv.org/pdf/0903.1317.pdf

Evidence for water ice and estimate of dust production rate in comet Hale-Bopp at 2.9 AU from the Sun
Lellouch, E. et al
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/full/1998A&A...339L...9L

The Detection of water ice in comet Hale-Bopp
Davies, J. K. et al
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/19970011266.pdf

Detection of water ice grains after the DEEP IMPACT onto Comet 9P/Tempel 1
Schulz, R. et al
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/ps/2006/12/aahi281.ps.gz

The distribution of water ice in the interior of Comet Tempel 1
Sunshine, J. M. et al, 2007
http://www.planetary.brown.edu/pdfs/3546.pdf

Water ice and dust in the innermost coma of comet 103P/Hartley 2
Protopapa, S., et al, 2014
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1406.3382.pdf

EVIDENCE OF ICY GRAINS IN COMET C/2002 T7 (LINEAR) AT 3.52 AU
Kawakita, H. et al.
http://sasakitakanori.com/wp-content/uploads/2006/08/kawakita_et_al_2004_apjl.pdf
 
A lie of "other more simple explanations" for the detection of water ice grains

There are other more simple explanations.
28 February 2018: A lie of "other more simple explanations" for the detection of water ice grains in comet coma when all we have is his abysmally ignorant delusions about comets.

This post includes the real insanity of:
28 February 2018: A lie about his cult - Thunderbolts is an electric universe cult.

The plasma universe people are differently wrong. They are not so totally deluded to think that comets are rocks blasted from the Earth in recent times, etc. They have several different delusions, e.g. that plasma dominates physics in the universe when basic plasma physics says that is wrong.

28 February 2018: A lie of his source being about the Deep Impact ejecta
In reply to AN IMPACTOR HIT THE NUCLEUS, AND EXCAVATED A SHED LOAD OF SOLID ICE GRAINS. SO IT IS NO LONGER 'HIDDEN', IS IT?
he lies by quoting from Exposed Water Ice Deposits on the Surface of Comet 9P/Tempel 1
We report the direct detection of solid water ice deposits exposed on the surface of comet 9P/Tempel 1, as observed by the Deep Impact mission. Three anomalously colored areas are shown to include water ice on the basis of their near-infrared spectra, which include diagnostic water ice absorptions at wavelengths of 1.5 and 2.0 micrometers. These absorptions are well modeled as a mixture of nearby non-ice regions and 3 to 6% water ice particles 10 to 50 micrometers in diameter. These particle sizes are larger than those ejected during the impact experiment, which suggests that the surface deposits are loose aggregates. The total area of exposed water ice is substantially less than that required to support the observed ambient outgassing from the comet, which likely has additional source regions below the surface.


His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock.
 
Last edited:
So. let's just have a little recap on ice in cometary comae prior to the Rosetta mission. This is what I've managed to find over a few years:

Comet 17P/Holmes in Outburst: The Near Infrared Spectrum
Yang, B. et al
https://arxiv.org/pdf/0903.1317.pdf

Evidence for water ice and estimate of dust production rate in comet Hale-Bopp at 2.9 AU from the Sun
Lellouch, E. et al
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/full/1998A&A...339L...9L

The Detection of water ice in comet Hale-Bopp
Davies, J. K. et al
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/19970011266.pdf

Detection of water ice grains after the DEEP IMPACT onto Comet 9P/Tempel 1
Schulz, R. et al
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/ps/2006/12/aahi281.ps.gz

The distribution of water ice in the interior of Comet Tempel 1
Sunshine, J. M. et al, 2007
http://www.planetary.brown.edu/pdfs/3546.pdf

Water ice and dust in the innermost coma of comet 103P/Hartley 2
Protopapa, S., et al, 2014
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1406.3382.pdf

EVIDENCE OF ICY GRAINS IN COMET C/2002 T7 (LINEAR) AT 3.52 AU
Kawakita, H. et al.
http://sasakitakanori.com/wp-content/uploads/2006/08/kawakita_et_al_2004_apjl.pdf

Mmmmmm....seems like they've got their hand on it jd116, along with yourself.

There are other explanations.

but what would you care? mainstream needs 'ice', some was detected on the surface (not enough for the out gassing guessed at)

so wheel out the wine and chocolate, Whipple was right! :D

but the comet contains hydrated minerals on the nucleus...

Changes everything.
 
At greater depths, which are thermally isolated from the surface, water ice is present. Up to depths of 10 to 20 m, the maximum depths
excavated by the impact, these pristine materials consist of very fine grained (∼1 ± 1 μm) water ice particles, which are free from refractory
impurities.
The distribution of water ice in the interior of Comet Tempel 1

so a solid 'ice' layer somewhere below the surface? Hows that gel with the bulk density estimates?

interesting to note again the size of the "ice".
 
There are other explanations.

No there are not, unless you show us detailed papers actually describing these other explanations. I am sure after tens of years your EC friends will have published something.
 
so a solid 'ice' layer somewhere below the surface? Hows that gel with the bulk density estimates?

clearly your interpretation of the quote is incorrect, probably because you cannot read comprehensively, it does not say a "solid ice layer" that is YOUR misinterpretation.
 
clearly your interpretation of the quote is incorrect, probably because you cannot read comprehensively, it does not say a "solid ice layer" that is YOUR misinterpretation.

So it’s porous “ice”?

With a dust to “ice” ratio of at least 6:1 upto 100:1, how is this “ice” pure?

YOU MUST MODEL THE NUCLEUS AS MAJORITY DUST WITH SCANT “ICE”.

A large dust-to-water mass ratio implies that the nucleus matrix is non-volatile, so that ground-based experiments (Gr¨un et al. 1993) and thermo-physical models of cometary nuclei (Prialnik, Benkoff &Podolak 2004), assuming an ice matrix, may provide misleading results: they should be repeated assuming a refractory matrix,which has micro-properties far from ices. The larger the dust-to-water ratio, the larger the porosity required to t the observed nucleus bulk density.

The mainstream are finding harder and harder to include ice in any realistic model.

Or better still

Model it as a ROCK in SPACE PLASMA!

We are listening :D
 
Last edited:
Sorry Tusenfem, you are correct again all Sunshine says is
Up to depths of 10 to 20 m, the maximum depths excavated by the impact, these pristine materials consist of very fine grained (∼1 ± 1 μm) water ice particles, which are free from refractory impurities.

So what kind of "ice" do you think she waffleing on about? amorphous or crystalline?


6. Implications of the physical structure of the ejected water ice The spectral modeling above reveals that the water ice in the ejecta from Tempel 1 is dominated by 1 ± 1 μm diameter, pure particles. The combination of small particles and lack of impurities within the ice is consistent with the preservation of water ice grains on the order of an hour after ejection.
The distribution of water ice in the interior of Comet Tempel 1

Ok Sunshine says.

but Marco Fulle says

The larger the dust-to-water ratio, the larger the porosity required to fit the observed nucleus bulk density.

which also fits with Yu. V. Skorov assertion
the dust removal by a gas drag force is not a plausible physical mechanism

but we saw "ice" i tells ya!
 
Oh dear. Bore off with this nonsense, Sol. It was ice. 100%. Forgotten this, have we?

snowstorm_strip.jpg


https://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2010/18nov_cometsnowstorm

Water Ice and Dust in the Innermost Coma of Comet 103P/Hartley 2
Protopapa, S. et al.
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1406.3382.pdf

And it was ice at Tempel 1 after the impact. And it is ice at 67P on the exposed cliffs and boulders therefrom. Proving, definitively, that there is ice below as well as on the surface. Now, what are these 'other possibilities'?
 
but the comet contains hydrated minerals on the nucleus...
Changes everything.

No, it changes nothing. There is ice below the surface; 100% proven. There is no rock; 100% proven. There is no EDM (lol); 100% proven. The electric comet woo is dead; 100% proven.
Continuation of this thread is a complete waste of pixels; 100% proven.
 
.....which also fits with Yu. V. Skorov assertion

And I already pointed out to you that he believes the smaller grains must come from the disintegration of larger grains:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=12151504&postcount=1312

To add to that I just emailed him, and said:

I just wanted to clear up the conclusions you reach in those papers, regarding the possible mechanisms for lifting the smaller grains from the comet. It seems that gas drag, as currently modelled, cannot explain it. My take on your conclusions is that the smaller grains detected in the coma must have come from the disaggregation of larger grains. Would that be a fair summary, or is that too simplistic? Any advice would be much appreciated.

To which he replied:

I'm glad that you love the physics of comets. Both of your assumptions
are acceptable:

a) we can not explain the removal of small particles consistently,

c) at the same time we can admit their secondary origin, but we can
not firmly prove this

I'm not sure what happened to b), but he's probably busy! Happy to take an image of the emails and post them. No point, though, as Sol will then label Skorov as a mainstream lackey, or words to that effect.
In summary; let's forget the Skorov papers as being anything to do with EU woo. Next.
 
No, neither does it state that, can you actually read?

What does Jessica Sunshine state in her paper regarding the structure of the "ice" subsurface? From a proper fair dinkum employed space plasma physicist?

These results indicate that the water ice ejected from the interior of Tempel 1 is free of impurities. When compared to the linear mixing model fit (a), the Deep Impact data also show evidence of emissions due to organics in the 3.3–3.5 μm range. More detailed characterizations of the refractory components in the ejecta are the subject of on-going efforts.

Much of the ejecta seen by DI originates at greater depths, which are pristine and contain pure water ice that is physically separated from other materials rendering the remaining components anhydrous.
Similarly, if Wild 2 and Tempel 1 have a generally comparable bulk composition and stratigraphy, then the dominance of anhydrous minerals in theWild 2 samples, which were presumably carried from the comet by jet activity, argues that the jets must have a depth of origin below the upper ∼1 m of
altered substrate.

This finding is consistent with the results from the samples returned from Wild 2 (Brownlee et al., 2006; Zolensky et al., 2006), yet seemingly at odds with the identification of aqueously altered materials in ∼20% of the DI ejecta as inferred from Spitzer Space Telescope (SST) observations (Lisse et al., 2006).

3.1. At impact A¡¯Hearn et al. (2005) describe in detail the first component from the impact event, highly shocked material moving downrange at a velocity of ¡<10 km s.1. The brightness of the visible data suggest the melting of silicates (Melosh, 2006)

snip

The quantity of hot water detected in the vapor plume is considerably greater than the water in the ambient coma. Thus, the vapor plume must have sources that include water ice.

snip

Like the visible images (Fig. 1a), the ¡«1.5 ¦Ìm image records the brightness of reflected sunlight and is correlated to dust. This image clearly shows the lateral spreading of the ejected dust over time. In contrast the image representing water ice, calculated as the depth of the 3 ìm absorption band (Fig. 1c), is highly collimated and centered directly downrange from the impact site.

The distribution of water ice in the interior of Comet Tempel 1
Jessica M. Sunshine a,∗, Olivier Groussin b, Peter H. Schultz c, Michael F. A’Hearn a,Lori M. Feaga a, Tony L. Farnham a, Kenneth P. Klaasen d

but

The continuous curve shown is the brightness expected in the clear filter passband of the MRI camera system from a 4000 kg cloud of 160 ìm diameter incandescent spherical liquid silicate droplets, density 2500 kg/m3, expanding at a radial velocity of 1.7 km/sec. The initial temperature is 3500 K, and the droplet’s albedo is 0.1.ed and centered directly downrange from the impact site.

snip

We conclude that the parachute-shaped bright arc that expanded rapidly away from the impact site during the first second after contact was an incandescent cloud of condensed, probably liquid, droplets that cooled from an initial temperature of about 3500 K down to 1000 K after about 0.42 second. It remained in view for another 0.4 sec, illuminated by reflected sunlight. Assuming an albedo of 0.1, appropriate for mafic silicate liquids, the total mass of the droplets was about 4000 kg. Because this is 10 times the mass of the impactor, we assume that the glowing material originated mainly from the comet and is thus probably silicate in composition.

DEEP IMPACT: THE FIRST SECOND. H. J. Melosh



This backyard hack still has trouble picturing the make up/structure of the nucleus subsurface. Is it an intimate mixture or an areal mixture of "dust" and ALL the "ices"?

Also if it was into a highly porous fluffy nucleus, then why the 10km initial ejecta speed?

A fast-moving, parachute-shaped arc of incandescent material precedes the bulk of the impact ejecta 0.46 seconds after the first light recorded from the impact.

The leading edge of the arc moved very rapidly, with an apparent velocity in the plane of the sky of approximately 4.8 km/sec
(if the arc material is assumed to ricochet from the surface at an angle equal to the approach angle of about 30°, then it moved toward the camera at an angle of about 60° out of the viewing plane, implying an actual velocity of 9.6 km/sec relative to the initial bright pixel, similar to the velocity of the impactor itself).

interesting to note also is the apparent correlation between the highly collimated

Water ice abundance is displayed linearly with the strongest absorptions (ice-rich) shown in white. Note that the water ice is highly collimated and centered directly downrange from the impact site, while the dust expands laterally.




I'm basically saying Sunshine has interpreted the dissociation of hydrated silicates (clays) into h2o vapour which spontaneously forms elongated water ice of 1um. We then see anhydrous minerals as a result of this process. This would include CO and CO2 from the carbonates, as evidence for sub-surface "ice" as is REQUIRED for the dirtysnowball model.

Spontaneous formation of nonspherical water ice grains in a plasma environment Kil-Byoung Chai1 and Paul M. Bellan1


You must do this sorta thing for breakfast.
 
Last edited:
Ahhh jeez. More nonsense. Chai and Bellan inject liquid water into their chamber! Where are you getting that in the vacuum of space? They refer to a previous experiment by Shimizu et al*, where water ice particles are synthesised using plasma by injecting H2 (or D2) and O2 into the chamber. You'll find that H2 is exceedingly rare close to the nucleus of a comet. If it weren't the RPC would have detected it. So, what are we saying? H+ comes along and somehow combines with another H+ to form H2 (impossible), and then goes on to locate an O atom to combine with, and they then instantly form ice? 8-18 000 tonnes of it?** Yeah, right. Somebody hasn't done their homework.
Apart from all that, it is a slam dunk that there is ice beneath the surface anyway. So why go looking for impossible mechanisms to explain something that is perfectly obvious in the first place - impactor hits surface, blows out a bunch of dust and ice. Both of which we know to be there. Sounds like desperation to support a failed, silly idea, which is only based on mythological woo to start with.


*Synthesis of water ice particles in a plasma chamber
Shimizu, S. et al.
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1029/2009JD013375/full

**Investigation of dust and water ice in comet 9P/Tempel 1 from Spitzer observations of the Deep Impact event
Gicquel, A. et al.
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/full_html/2012/06/aa18718-11/aa18718-11.html
 
Last edited:
I'm basically saying Sunshine has interpreted the dissociation of hydrated silicates (clays) into h2o vapour which spontaneously forms elongated water ice of 1um.

In which case you'd be wrong. However, there is nothing stopping anybody from challenging their conclusions within the same scientific literature in which she published. We know that won't happen, because this is all an impossible fairy tale, only meant to keep the scientifically illiterate EU followers believing (and buying books, DVDs, conference tickets, etc). It is utter nonsense, and has been debunked to hell and back. It is dead.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom