Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
A lie that Groussin, O. et al., 2015 supports his comets are rock, etc. delusions

47. Groussin, O. et al., 2015, Gravitational slopes geomorphology, and material strengths of the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko from OSIRIS observations, A&A, 583,A32 (doi:10.1051/00046361/201526379
26 February 2018: A lie that Groussin, O. et al., 2015 supports his comets are rock, etc. delusions

Groussin, O. et al., 2015, Gravitational slopes geomorphology, and material strengths of the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko from OSIRIS observations, A&A, 583,A32
Aims. We study the link between gravitational slopes and the surface morphology on the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko and provide constraints on the mechanical properties of the cometary material (tensile, shear, and compressive strengths).

Methods. We computed the gravitational slopes for five regions on the nucleus that are representative of the different morphologies observed on the surface (Imhotep, Ash, Seth, Hathor, and Agilkia), using two shape models computed from OSIRIS images by the stereo-photoclinometry (SPC) and stereo-photogrammetry (SPG) techniques. We estimated the tensile, shear, and compressive strengths using different surface morphologies (overhangs, collapsed structures, boulders, cliffs, and Philae’s footprint) and mechanical considerations.

Results. The different regions show a similar general pattern in terms of the relation between gravitational slopes and terrain morphology: i) low-slope terrains (0−20°) are covered by a fine material and contain a few large (>10 m) and isolated boulders; ii) intermediate-slope terrains (20−45°) are mainly fallen consolidated materials and debris fields, with numerous intermediate-size boulders from <1 m to 10 m for the majority of them; and iii) high-slope terrains (45−90°) are cliffs that expose a consolidated material and do not show boulders or fine materials. The best range for the tensile strength of overhangs is 3−15 Pa (upper limit of 150 Pa), 4−30 Pa for the shear strength of fine surface materials and boulders, and 30−150 Pa for the compressive strength of overhangs (upper limit of 1500 Pa). The strength-to-gravity ratio is similar for 67P and weak rocks on Earth. As a result of the low compressive strength, the interior of the nucleus may have been compressed sufficiently to initiate diagenesis, which could have contributed to the formation of layers. Our value for the tensile strength is comparable to that of dust aggregates formed by gravitational instability and tends to favor a formation of comets by the accrection of pebbles at low velocities.
 
A lie about a M. P¨atzold et al. paper

We'll start here Gravity field determination of a Comet Nucleus: Rosetta at P/Wirtanen M. P¨atzold and mob
He has known since close to the beginning of this thread how the density of comets is measured in various ways.
26 February 2018: A lie about a M. P¨atzold et al. paper.
This is about a proposal for the in situ measurement of the density of 46P/Wirtanen which never happened because Rosetta was sent to 67P instead :eek:!
It includes real science, e.g. the effects of radiation pressure and how to minimize effects of outgassing from the comet.

26 February 2018: A lie that the density of comets is guessed at.

26 February 2018: Blind parroting of insane Thunderbolts delusions about electromagnetism.

26 February 2018: Abysmal stupidity of "low mass, high density" = mass measurement by gravitational perturbation must be wrong.
Asteroid 21 Lutetia: low mass, high density is low mass divided by low volume = high density of (3.4 ± 0.3) × 10(3) kilograms per cubic meter.
Doubly stupid because the same technique was used to measure the density of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko as
0.533 ± 0.006 g/cm3.
 
Last edited:
A lie about "electricity in space" doing nothing.

.............and there's the problem folks
26 February 2018: A lie about "electricity in space" doing nothing.

26 February 2018: Insults and lies about jonesdave116
jonesdave116 states there is a calculation from "a very bright chap on the Rosetta blog" doing a calculation of how much "electricity in space" there would be to do a lot and the probable results (a totally screwed up mission :eye-poppi!).

Then there is:
Electric Comets II. Of Water & Ice
Electric Comets: More Failures of the Electric Comet Model

Electric Comets III: Mass vs. Charge
That is a blog article doing the basic EM that Sol88 and the deluded Thunderbolts authors are unable to do.
 
A paranoiac delusion that the density of 67P was made to fit Whipple's model

...It was just the mainstream agreeing the figure “fits” with the paradigm of Whipples ‘dirtysnowball”
26 February 2018: A paranoiac delusion that the density of 67P (or all comets!) was made to fit Whipple's model.
The density of 67P was measured before Rosetta arrived. The volume of 67P was measured using the usual assumption of an ovoid shape. The "rubber duck" shape quickly resulted n a new density calculation, e.g.
The global shape, density and rotation of Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko from preperihelion Rosetta/OSIRIS observations
Using this model, we could calculate accurate nucleus parameters including a volume of 18.8 ± 0.3 km3 and a density of 532 ± 7 kg m−3.
That was refined by gravitational measurements to be 0.533 ± 0.006 g/cm3.
 
Last edited:
A double lie that radiation pressure "balls up the guestimation..."

Seems it may also balls up the guestimation on bulk density/comets mass.
26 February 2018: A double lie that radiation pressure "balls up the guestimation..."
The first lie is that radiation pressure "balls up" anything because he cited a paper where its effects are predictable (but not to the totally ignorant Thunderbolts cult).
The second lie is "guestimation". The calculation of the density of comets is the application of laws of physics known to work. And we have in situ confirmation for 67P - the CONSERT radio waves through material that cannot be rock!
NASA can send spacecraft throughout the Solar system using only Newton's law of gravity, including similar obits as comets, e.g. multiple spacecraft to comets - so much for the Thunderbolts delusion of EM screwing up things :eek:!
This cult follower cited Asteroid 21 Lutetia: low mass, high density measuring a high density of (3.4 ± 0.3) × 10(3) kilograms per cubic meter for an asteroid.

Gravity field determination of a Comet Nucleus: Rosetta at P/Wirtanen by M. Pätzold, et. al. Published online 15 August 2001, Rosetta mission, launched on 2 March 2004.
Based on an estimate of the background Doppler noise, it is expected that a mass determination (assuming a representative radius of 700 m and a bulk density of 500 kg/m3) at an accuracy of 0.1% can be achieved if the spacecraft's orbit is iteratively reduced below 7 km altitude. The gravity field of degree and order two can be detected for reasonable tracking times below 5 km altitude. The major competing forces acting on the spacecraft are the radiation pressure and the gas mass flux from cometary activity. While the radiation pressure may be predicted, it is recommended to begin a gravity mapping campaign well before the onset of outgassing activity (>3.25 AU heliocentric distance). Radial acceleration by water outgassing is larger by orders of magnitude than the accelerations from the low degree and order gravity field and will mask the contributions from the gravity field.
 
Last edited:
EDIT:
Actually, the Prof. seems like a decent sort. Here he is tearing a strip of the handyman/ gardener Crothers:
https://crackpotwatch.wordpress.com/2015/05/20/rutt-nails-sam-spade-to-the-wall/
For lurkers: Stephen J. Crothers
Stephen J. Crothers (born 1957) is a handyman/gardener and part-time amateur scientist who claims that black holes do not exist, and are neither predicted by nor compatible with General Relativity.[2] His body of work consists primarily of articles that he posts at either viXra or his own personal website,[3][4] thus steering clear of the peer review process. He has also been a frequent guest speaker at the annual EU conferences held by the Electric Universe crowd.[5][6][7]
...
In 2005, Crothers was expelled from the University of New South Wales; all the sordid details of the incident are chronicled at his website, which he falsely attributes to "suppression of science".[14]
(my emphasis added).

That expelling was an interesting event as described on Crothers' web site.
Basically Crothers started a PhD with a standard astrophysics subject. After a year sometime in 2004 he started to study GR as a sideline and thought he had found errors by asserting errors in historical papers. His supervisor Professor John K. Webb initially supported this line of research and put him contact with Professor Paul Davies and others.
  • Davies disagreed and becomes maybe the first "inept" in Crothers' mind.
  • Professor Peter Szekeres (son of George Szekeres of the Kruskal-Szekeres extension) also disagreed and so becomes also "inept".
  • Abandons a chat with a Professor Michael Kruchiev after 10 minutes as "obviously pointless".
  • Professor Victor Flambaum refuses to meet with him as he has no chance of being right (obviously because black holes are textbook physics verified by maybe millions of students).
  • An unnamed visitor is mentioned.
Webb "understood nothing" but allowed continued research and the thesis subject was changed to GR. 2005 and Webb discusses the thesis with John Barrow and Joao Magueijo and withdraws his support.

Crothers is now researching a PhD without a supervisor and trying to submit it early. Some bureaucracy then a Professor Chris Hamer of UNSW is asked to review his papers and cannot "understand anything" because Hamer wrote that it was an "apprentice" work, not ready to submit and Crothers should go back to his original subject. An appeal to the University Academic Committee fails because they are whitewashing alleged misconduct of just about everyone else!

By the end of 2005, "expelled de facto from PhD candidature" because Webb and other professors would not be his supervisor. This is not a surprise given his insulting behavior and weak thesis. Emeritus Professor Heinrich Hora writes a letter about that behavior.

He engages M.H.A. MacCallum in some discussion and another "rude and condescending, and quite inept" scientist.

Dismisses letters from J. Berkenstein and J. Pullin (members of the International Committee for General Relativity and Gravitation).

The idiocy of writing to "Mr. Roy Kerr" , who told him that his work was rubbish and we get an "too sophisticated for his poor brain" insult.
 
And if you read the Lutetia paper you would know that they take such things into consideration. And at the time they arrived the outgassing rate was considerably less than 1 l/s.
The density was 533 kg/m3, get over it.


1l/s globally? From all the surface “ice”?

What about the dust? Oh, that’s right a fair bit was repelled by Rosetta!

Same as Rosetta being repelled by the nucleus!

:rolleyes:
 
1l/s globally? From all the surface “ice”?

What about the dust? Oh, that’s right a fair bit was repelled by Rosetta!

Same as Rosetta being repelled by the nucleus!

:rolleyes:

Sorry? Do that in understandable English and I'll try to figure it out.
 
Nothing. It is irrelevant.



Nope. There was a very bright chap on the Rosetta blog who got sick of hearing that crap, so did the maths. Given the charge on Rosetta, you'd need ~ 35 GV on the comet. Lol. And every time the spacecraft charged up differently; its orbit would be all over the place! And according to the EU cranks, isn't the comet supposed to pick up more charge as it nears the Sun? Or is it the other way round? Either way, the orbital parameters would be screwed up, and the flight control would be wondering what the hell was going on. They weren't, because it didn't happen, due to it being a very silly idea by someone who doesn't understand much science.

Lutetia:


Asteroid 21 Lutetia: Low Mass, High Density
Pätzold, M. et al
http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.466.4102&rep=rep1&type=pdf

No, you are thinking more along the lines of the electrostatic E-Glider or even electrodynamic tether proposulsion! :D

It’s what they use! ;)

So you guess at mass and therefore density is flawed. :D

Same as your outgassing quesses :blush:
 
@rc

How consolidated does the nucleus have to be before it’s not porous any more?

Better still, answer me this riddle, how porous is the consolidated terrain/material?

Because, you know....
7 regions were added to the 19 previously identified to complete the full region classification of comet 67P [129]. The southern hemisphere appears quite different to the northern hemisphere and is predominantly characterised by consolidated terrains, devoid of wide scale smooth terrains, dust coatings and depressions, somewhat contrary to the expectations of [126].
says Matt Taylor

6 SUMMARY Our geomorphologic mapping reveals a complex terrain of consolidated bedrock material overlain by sedimentary deposits. The northern half of the nucleus is covered in sedimentary materials, while the landscapes of the Southern hemisphere are relatively free of sediment, revealing the underlying bedrock of the nucleus.
along with Samuel P. D. Birch
 
Last edited:
Let's highlight the key word in your quote:

Here consolidated is used to refer to areas that appear rocky in appearance and are cohesive enough to display lineaments and fractures.


Ooh, look Sol, a squirrel bunny!!

The surface of 67P/C-G is generally broken into rough and smooth terrains (e.g. Auger et al. 2015; La Forgia et al. 2015; Giacomini et al. 2016;Pajolaetal.2016b). The rough terrain is predominantly exposed bedrock, while the smooth terrain represents disaggregated, transported remnants of formerly consolidated bedrock (Sierks et al. 2015). The main control responsible for the breakdown of the solid bedrock are large gradients in solar insolation both as the nucleus orbits the Sun, and as the nucleus rotates over 12.5 hcycles(Keller et al. 2015;Pajolaetal.2017).

Holger Sierks, bunny hunter!


Dear ‘ol Freddy, nice try. :confused:
 
Last edited:
@rc

How consolidated does the nucleus have to be before it’s not porous any more?

Better still, answer me this riddle, how porous is the consolidated terrain/material?

Because, you know.... says Matt Taylor

along with Samuel P. D. Birch

[rhetorical]And.............?[/rhetorical]
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom