Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
There is electricity in space, it just doesn't do anything!!!!

What an asinine comment. Please explain what you want this 'electricity' to do. It isn't doing anything in the context that you posted it, i.e. electrostatic repulsion woo. So, yes, it is irrelevant.
 
Last edited:
Lol. I've just shown you up to be completely wrong, and I'm spitting the dummy? No, you're the dummy, dummy.
Here is Prof. Harvey Rutt's calculation on the idiot Thornhill's electrostatic garbage:
http://blogs.esa.int/rosetta/2015/04/09/giada-investigates-comets-fluffy-dust-grains/#comment-432278

Go cry to Wal. Get him to check the maths. Oh, yeah, he doesn't do maths, does he? None of you lot do.

He’s wrong of course by a fair bit!

What was Rosetta’s electrical potential again?
 
He’s wrong of course by a fair bit!

What was Rosetta’s electrical potential again?

No, he isn't. If you know he's wrong, then you've checked the link I provided. In which case you'd know the figures he used. Including the potential.
 
Did Rosetta “discharge” it’s -16v potential? In fact did it’s potential stay the same thru the mission?

So without even doing the maths Proff knucklescone has got it wrong, like most mainstream electricity does not do anything in space camp!

The comet is in a time varying magnetic field and different plasma regions. He’s calculation, like your h2o production from solar wind H, are so simplistic...well there crap!
 
Abstract. One of the prime objectives of the Rosetta Radio Science Investigations (RSI) experiment is the determination of the mass, the bulk density and the low degree and order gravity of the nucleus of comet P/Wirtanen, the target object of the international Rosetta mission.

The RSI experiment will use the spacecraft's radio carrier frequencies at X-band (8.4 GHz) and S-band (2.3 GHz) in order to measure slight changes of the orbit velocity via the classical Doppler effect induced by the gravity attraction of the comet nucleus. Based on an estimate of the background Doppler noise, it is expected that a mass determination (assuming a representative radius of 700 m and a bulk density of 500 kg/m3) at an accuracy of 0.1% can be achieved if the spacecraft's orbit is iteratively reduced below 7 km altitude.

The gravity field of degree and order two can be detected for reasonable tracking times below 5 km altitude. The major competing forces acting on the spacecraft are the radiation pressure and the gas mass flux from cometary activity. While the radiation pressure may be predicted, it is recommended to begin a gravity mapping campaign well before the onset of outgassing activity (>3.25 AU heliocentric distance). Radial acceleration by water outgassing is larger by orders of magnitude than the accelerations from the low degree and order gravity field and will mask the contributions from the gravity Field. .
Gravity field determination of a Comet Nucleus: Rosetta at P/Wirtanen
M. P¨atzold and mob

Pity it was already out gassing when Rosetta arrived.

radiation pressure,aay! Mmmmm.....how much force does that exert on the probe?

It was just the mainstream agreeing the figure “fits” with the paradigm of Whipples ‘dirtysnowball”
 
Did Rosetta “discharge” it’s -16v potential? In fact did it’s potential stay the same thru the mission?

So without even doing the maths Proff knucklescone has got it wrong, like most mainstream electricity does not do anything in space camp!

The comet is in a time varying magnetic field and different plasma regions. He’s calculation, like your h2o production from solar wind H, are so simplistic...well there crap!

How would Rosetta discharge the potential? It was anywhere between a few volts positive to ~ -20 volts negative. The rest of your post is meaningless word salad.
The calculation is correct. Show where he's made a mistake. Or get the idiot Thornhill to do it. Show us what the EU nutjobs think was going on. With the relevant equations. Not going to happen is it? All because a couple of scientifically illiterate woo merchants want to base their worldview on the inane ramblings of the equally scientifically illiterate moron, Velikovsky!
 
Pity it was already out gassing when Rosetta arrived.

radiation pressure,aay! Mmmmm.....how much force does that exert on the probe?

It was just the mainstream agreeing the figure “fits” with the paradigm of Whipples ‘dirtysnowball”

Jesus, what an idiot. The probe was around the comet for over 2 years, woo boy. They landed on it. Twice. Where was your electric woo? On this extremely non-magnetic body?
 
Whilst we're waiting for the next batch of scientific illiteracy from Sol, let's glory in the sight of all that ice at Hartley 2, that the idiot Thornhill said wouldn't be there:

snowstorm_strip.jpg
 
Also, despite this insane voltage, 67P only has a charge of 10^4 Coulombs.
So a pathetically weak 1A discharge (recall, my kettle takes 13A…) would discharge it completely in just under three hours; so not only would the ‘discharges’ stop, the electrostatic force would go away.

Ha ha nOOb!
 
like your h2o production from solar wind H, are so simplistic...well there they're crap
!

So, redo the calculations how you think they should be done. It's an irrelevance because you ain't got no O-, and your H+ is traveling waaaaay too quickly. Go ahead, though. Should be fun.
 
So, what are we to think?
In the one corner we have Prof. Harvey Rutt, FREng, FInstP, FOSA, FIEE, SMIEEE, CEng, CPhys, University of Southampton, U.K.
In the other corner, we have Sol88, ...................err.

Yep. know who my money's on.

As the good Prof. said on the Rosetta blog re the EU fraudsters (and he said a lot of good things on there):

Another thing one might look at is the qualifications of the 'leading lights'. None of them has a substantial academic pedigree in this field in terms of qualifications, publications, Fellow of major Societies etc. So either they are brilliant Mavericks, bravely carving out a new route - or those who couldn't make it in real science, living in a fantasy world, running content free, incestuous conferences where no one ever asks difficult questions, with a distinctly commercial look to them.

I'll stick with real science.

EDIT:
Actually, the Prof. seems like a decent sort. Here he is tearing a strip of the handyman/ gardener Crothers:
https://crackpotwatch.wordpress.com/2015/05/20/rutt-nails-sam-spade-to-the-wall/
 
Last edited:
Pity it was already out gassing when Rosetta arrived.

radiation pressure,aay! Mmmmm.....how much force does that exert on the probe?

It was just the mainstream agreeing the figure “fits” with the paradigm of Whipples ‘dirtysnowball”

quite a bit it seems...

Solar radiation pressure may cause the orbiter to either
crash into the nucleus or get ejected from a bound orbit
in a reasonably short time span. As shown by Scheeres
et al. (1998), this can be avoided by choosing special orbits.
At distances from the nucleus where the solar radiation
pressure is the dominant perturbation

Seems it may also balls up the guestimation on bulk density/comets mass.
 
Last edited:
quite a bit it seems...



Seems it may also balls up the guestimation on bulk density/comets mass.

And if you read the Lutetia paper you would know that they take such things into consideration. And at the time they arrived the outgassing rate was considerably less than 1 l/s.
The density was 533 kg/m3, get over it.
 
Lie that consolidated terrain of ices and dust on 67P = rock

Oh, thread is still open??????
This thread has had you writing ignorant, deluded and even lying posts here for many years. More of the same should not close it. We need to record your lies, etc. for everyone to read forever.

Here we have a lie that the consolidated terrain of ices and dust on 67P has anything to do with your many delusions about comets.

26 February 2018: Lie that consolidated terrain of ices and dust on 67P = rock.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, etc. etc
 
His irrelevant stupidity about dust

Dust! There are, as Matt Taylor quotes, two populations..
26 February 2018: His irrelevant stupidity about dust.
There are fluffy dust grains up to 2 cm in size outflowing from the comet.
There are clumps of dust grains that have gathered in orbit around the comet and they can be up to 2 m in size.

The Rosetta mission orbiter science overview: the comet phase
Early observations revealed two populations of dust: one up to 2 cm in size and outflowing from the comet, and detected within about 20 km of the spacecraft; and a bound population, with particles ranging in size from 4 cm to approximately 2 m, detected at distances more than 130 km from the spacecraft [56]. The overall population collected by Rosetta at heliocentric distances greater than 3 AU was rather fluffy and devoid of volatiles, with the coating of dust covering parts of the nucleus surface thought to be a result of build-up since the previous perihelion, and early activity was beginning to remove this layer [57].

Dust measurements in the coma of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko inbound to the Sun
...The largest orbiting clumps are meter-sized, confirming the dust/gas ratio of 3 inferred at perihelion from models of dust comae and trails.

Nothing to do with:
His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, etc. etc
 
A lie that NUPAS could penetrate into "ANY ice dust mixture"

There bull..... MUPUS would have made progress into ANY ice dust mixture and sublimation can not lift even dust in the true interpretation of dust, off the surface of a comet!
26 February 2018: A lie that NUPAS could penetrate into "ANY ice dust mixture"
He knows that the MNUPAS results are consistent with a layer of sintered ices and dust that could not be penetrated.

26 February 2018: A delusion of a "true interpretation of dust"

26 February 2018:Repeated lie that sublimation can not lift dust off the surface of a comet.
One paper found that their model could not lift dust of a specific size off the surface of 67P.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom