Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh, thread is still open??????

Wilful ignorance??

Jd116, you are going to need a bigger hammer! It’s getting harder harder to smash that square peg into the round hole.

Are you prepared to discuss , without resorting to chuck’n a hissy fit, the consolidated terrain of 67P?

And just so you are under no illusions from me, i’ll quote Matt Taylor on consolidated terrain.
Here consolidated is used to refer to areas that appear rocky in appearance and are cohesive enough to display lineaments and fractures.

Shall we dance, jd116? One of us we look like a complete dick, who will it be I wonder?

My position is and has always been clear, the nucleus of 67P, and all comets, is ROCK!

I think we should state our interpretation on “consolidated” in the context of the material and terrain of 67P.

In your own time jd116.
 
Last edited:
My position is and has always been clear, the nucleus of 67P, and all comets, is ROCK!

In which case you'd be wrong. As pointed out countless times. Based on scientific observation and measurement. Which trumps pareidolia every time. Nothing to talk about here. If you think they've detected (measured) something with the density of, say, granite, then let's hear about it. Otherwise we are just going to be repeating the links to the same papers, from various instruments, that show, definitively, that there is no rock.
I'll save you looking; there is nothing.
 
No, you are wrong!

Consolidated material, what is it jd116?

Should be good for a laugh ��
 
Oh, thread is still open??????

Wilful ignorance??

Jd116, you are going to need a bigger hammer! It’s getting harder harder to smash that square peg into the round hole.

Are you prepared to discuss , without resorting to chuck’n a hissy fit, the consolidated terrain of 67P?

And just so you are under no illusions from me, i’ll quote Matt Taylor on consolidated terrain.

Shall we dance, jd116? One of us we look like a complete dick, who will it be I wonder?

My position is and has always been clear, the nucleus of 67P, and all comets, is ROCK!

I think we should state our interpretation on “consolidated” in the context of the material and terrain of 67P.

In your own time jd116.


Let's highlight the key word in your quote:

Here consolidated is used to refer to areas that appear rocky in appearance and are cohesive enough to display lineaments and fractures.


Ooh, look Sol, a squirrel bunny!!
 
No, you are wrong!

Consolidated material, what is it jd116?

Dust. And ice, And organics. As is to be expected. As per the papers from comet simulation studies I've linked seemingly endlessly. Now quit this nonsense. There is no rock.
 
,

Dust. And ice, And organics. As is to be expected. As per the papers from comet simulation studies I've linked seemingly endlessly. Now quit this nonsense. There is no rock.


Dust! There are, as Matt Taylor quotes, two populations...
Early observations revealed two populations of dust: one up to 2 cm in size and outflowing from the comet and detected within about 20 km of the spacecraft and a bound population, with particles ranging in size from 4 cm to ~2 m, detected at distances > 130 km from the spacecraft [59].

Now, not only do you have to define consolidated, which you can not do, you now have define “dust”! Dust up to 2m????:boggled:

Soon you will have to acknowledge “consolidated dust”! :rolleyes:
 
^^^^^^^Give it a rest. Read the bloody sublimation experiment papers. I've linked them often enough. If you don't understand them, then just admit that, instead of carrying on this endlessly idiocy
 
^^^^^^^Give it a rest. Read the bloody sublimation experiment papers. I've linked them often enough. If you don't understand them, then just admit that, instead of carrying on this endlessly idiocy

There bull..... MUPUS would have made progress into ANY ice dust mixture and sublimation can not lift even dust in the true interpretation of dust, off the surface of a comet!

Nice story but utter cow excrement!
 
So what is “dust” wrt comets?

How consolidated is the highly porous nucleus?

Entertaining if anything are the mainstream excuses for GUESSING the nucleus is made of ICE with a little dust mixed in!
 
Aaaaaaaannnnndddd..........off we go again! The same rubbish that has been explained countless times before. Seriously, for everybody's sake, we should close this thread. If Sol really wanted answers, he could just do a word search on .....whatever....and read the previous answers. This is nothing more than wilful ignorance, and granstanding for uneducated, possibly imaginary, lurkers. Get it closed.
 
^^^^^^^thought so^^^^


47. Groussin, O. et al., 2015, Gravitational slopes geomorphology, and material strengths of the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko from OSIRIS observations, A&A, 583,A32 (doi:10.1051/00046361/201526379

Go knock yourself out, your a smart arse cookie, you’ll find the assumption in this paper that snookers your dirtysnowball model!
 
Last edited:
Go knock yourself out, your a smart arse cookie, you’ll find the assumption in this paper that snookers your dirtysnowball model!

Nope. You summarise your misunderstandings of this paper, and then somebody can show you where you've gone wrong. As usual. That's the way it works.
 
oh, ok then. Let's back the truck up. ;)

We'll start here
Abstract. One of the prime objectives of the Rosetta Radio Science Investigations (RSI) experiment is the determination of the mass, the bulk density and the low degree and order gravity of the nucleus of comet P/Wirtanen, the target object of the international Rosetta mission.

The RSI experiment will use the spacecraft's radio carrier frequencies at X-band (8.4 GHz) and S-band (2.3 GHz) in order to measure slight changes of the orbit velocity via the classical Doppler effect induced by the gravity attraction of the comet nucleus. Based on an estimate of the background Doppler noise, it is expected that a mass determination (assuming a representative radius of 700 m and a bulk density of 500 kg/m3) at an accuracy of 0.1% can be achieved if the spacecraft's orbit is iteratively reduced below 7 km altitude.

The gravity field of degree and order two can be detected for reasonable tracking times below 5 km altitude. The major competing forces acting on the spacecraft are the radiation pressure and the gas mass flux from cometary activity. While the radiation pressure may be predicted, it is recommended to begin a gravity mapping campaign well before the onset of outgassing activity (>3.25 AU heliocentric distance). Radial acceleration by water outgassing is larger by orders of magnitude than the accelerations from the low degree and order gravity field and will mask the contributions from the gravity Field. .
Gravity field determination of a Comet Nucleus: Rosetta at P/Wirtanen M. P¨atzold and mob

This IS how the bulk density of the comet is guessed at, correct jd116?

Looks like the :pixie2 mainstream has struck again!


Mmmmmm.....what would someone looking at electromagnetic/plasma effects make from this?? :scarper:


Happy to :duel with you jd116.

The major competing forces acting on the spacecraft are to include electrostatic/dynamic repulsion being misinterpreted as low mass/low density be cause you KNOW comets are made from mainly ice with some dust!!!

Tell me about Asteroid 21 Lutetia: low mass, high density, jd116. this is the opposite from the above, asteroids are KNOWN to be ROCKS or consolidated dust!

Abstract

Asteroid 21 Lutetia was approached by the Rosetta spacecraft on 10 July 2010. The additional Doppler shift of the spacecraft radio signals imposed by 21 Lutetia's gravitational perturbation on the flyby trajectory were used to determine the mass of the asteroid. Calibrating and correcting for all Doppler contributions not associated with Lutetia, a least-squares fit to the residual frequency observations from 4 hours before to 6 hours after closest approach yields a mass of (1.700 ± 0.017) × 10(18) kilograms. Using the volume model of Lutetia determined by the Rosetta Optical, Spectroscopic, and Infrared Remote Imaging System (OSIRIS) camera, the bulk density, an important parameter for clues to its composition and interior, is (3.4 ± 0.3) × 10(3) kilograms per cubic meter.

rookie mistake 'ol mate!
 
Last edited:
Mmmmmm.....what would someone looking at electromagnetic/plasma effects make from this??
Nothing. It is irrelevant.

The major competing forces acting on the spacecraft are to include electrostatic repulsion being misinterpreted as low mass/low density be cause you KNOW comets are made from mainly ice with some dust!!!

Nope. There was a very bright chap on the Rosetta blog who got sick of hearing that crap, so did the maths. Given the charge on Rosetta, you'd need ~ 35 GV on the comet. Lol. And every time the spacecraft charged up differently; its orbit would be all over the place! And according to the EU cranks, isn't the comet supposed to pick up more charge as it nears the Sun? Or is it the other way round? Either way, the orbital parameters would be screwed up, and the flight control would be wondering what the hell was going on. They weren't, because it didn't happen, due to it being a very silly idea by someone who doesn't understand much science.

Lutetia:
This high bulk density is unexpected in view of the low value of the measured mass. It is one of the highest bulk densities known for asteroids (5). Assuming that Lutetia has a modest macroporosity of 12%, it would imply that the bulk density of its material constituents would exceed that of stony meteorites. Unless Lutetia has anomalously low porosity compared to other asteroids in its size range, its high density likely indicates a nonchondritic bulk composition enriched in high atomic number like iron. It may also be evidence for a partial differentiation of the asteroid body as proposed by Weiss et al.

Asteroid 21 Lutetia: Low Mass, High Density
Pätzold, M. et al
http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.466.4102&rep=rep1&type=pdf
 
After your done spitt'n the dummy there, we can move onto the global "gas" production rate model and how crap it is! :o
 
Nothing. It is irrelevant.
jd116

.............and there's the problem folks :duck:

There is electricity in space, it just doesn't do anything!!!!

jd116 seems to be completely ignorant on electrodynamics!

seems we would be :deadhorse again jd116, sad mate sad.

oh well.
 
Last edited:
After your done spitt'n the dummy there, we can move onto the global "gas" production rate model and how crap it is! :o

Lol. I've just shown you up to be completely wrong, and I'm spitting the dummy? No, you're the dummy, dummy.
Here is Prof. Harvey Rutt's calculation on the idiot Thornhill's electrostatic garbage:
http://blogs.esa.int/rosetta/2015/04/09/giada-investigates-comets-fluffy-dust-grains/#comment-432278

Go cry to Wal. Get him to check the maths. Oh, yeah, he doesn't do maths, does he? None of you lot do.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom