Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Clueless parrot comes to mind. Hey rc?

3000kg m3 for the compact dust coming from the nucleus of which has a bulk density of 500kg m3
So therefore the comet must be highly porous!

EXCEPT for the little bit the MUPUS-PEN tapped on that was as hard as very well consolidated refractory material like that returned from the stardust mission and observed by Rosetta!

Is that your limited understanding of the situation rc?

Lol. 'Clueless' is a bit rich coming from someone who doesn't understand the difference between the density of a dust particle and bulk density. Lern to scienz! Some little bits of dust are high density. Some are very low density (< 1 kg/m3). Ice is an altogether different density. And then we have pores, which have zero density. It isn't rocket science. Unless you are an EU follower. The whole of this mixture can then be 'weighed', as set out in the following article;

http://blogs.esa.int/rosetta/2014/08/21/determining-the-mass-of-comet-67pc-g/

The article is easy to understand, as it assumes little prior scientific knowledge, which will definitely be the case for any EU readers.

Of course, there are other means for determining the make up of the comet, which have been used on this mission and previous ones;
We can smack it with a projectile traveling at ~ 10 km/s.
We can do a Jeremy Clarkson, and smack it with a hammer.
We can send radio waves right through the comet from Rosetta to Philae.
We can look at bits of the comet that have fallen off of cliffs.
We can use MIRO to determine the thermal inertia of the comet's surface and near surface.

All of those methods show us that the comet is nothing like any sort of rock known to man. So, what is it, EU woosters? Answers on a postcard.
 
Last edited:
So where is the missing density needed for your rock?

Ahhh, they'll tell you that it is all due to G not being constant. In fact, it can be altered due to some sort of unobserved electrical woo occurring between orbiting bodies. Which is total rubbish, of course, and they have never mathematically worked out the forces necessary to accomplish this apparent reduction in mass, as measured by Rosetta at 67P. Just the usual unscientific word salad. So, someone who isn't scientifically illiterate had to do it for them;

http://blogs.esa.int/rosetta/2015/04/09/giada-investigates-comets-fluffy-dust-grains/#comment-432278

Which was posted by;

https://www.ecs.soton.ac.uk/people/hnr

So, there we go. According to the EU geniuses, 67P has a charge of 35 GV!
Strange that we didn't notice that.
 
So you can do your song and dance all you’d like jd116 but the evidence is in!

Comets seem to contain more and more “dust” and less and less “ice”.

Seems your much beloved and referenced Tempel 1 interpretation maybe in error, jd116

So. I'll do it again;
crater is way too big to have been made in rock.
Solid ice was ejected from the impact.
Water vapour was ejected from the impact.

Please explain what sort of rock would lead to these observations? I'll save you the trouble of looking for an answer - none. So please show where the error is.
 
Wonder if they had used KNOWN densities from returned comet samples?

Stardust


Once again the misrepresentation of the density of individual grains as the bulk density of the comet. You’ve been corrected on this numerous times. Let’s start calling this what it’s become: a lie.
 
The mainstream are hamstrung because of the quesstimated bulk density. The highest measured dust grain density is up near 3000kgm3.

So too keep from looking like complete goose’s they’ve used 515 ≤ ρ ≤1635 kg m-3 when they should of used 515 ≤ ρ ≤3000 kg m-3.

Structure and elastic parameters of the near surface of Abydos site on comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko, as obtained by SESAME/CASSE listening to the MUPUS insertion phase so the bulk porosity of the nucleus governs the selected range of 515 ≤ ρ ≤1635 kg m-3
This is also in line with the stardust mission findings.

Stardust's Big Surprise

Also backed up by GIADA’s findings GIADA: shining a light on the monitoring of the comet dust production from the nucleus of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko 10.1051/0004-6361/201526208


So, i’ll concede is is NOT ROCK but WELL CONSOLIDATED REFRACTORY MINERALS.

OK so now you concede that given "WELL CONSOLIDATED REFRACTORY MINERALS" you wouldn't expect it to have a uniform density of "3000kgm3". As if it was just one big block of the densest dust grain?

Heck, let's try that anyway.

Wave speed and bulk elastic property relation...


http://www.hyperphysics.de/hyperphysics/hbase/sound/souspe2.html#c1


So wave speed remains the same and we just about double the density. That likewise doubles the calculated bulk elastic properties.

That gets you just above plywood but about a 3rd of polytcarbonate and well below nylon in rigidity. As a maximal.

While bringing you to the mid-range of Typical wood T and thermoplastics for stiffness. Again as a maximal. Still an order of magnitude off from rock.

ETA:

Once again the misrepresentation of the density of individual grains as the bulk density of the comet. You’ve been corrected on this numerous times. Let’s start calling this what it’s become: a lie.

Lie or not, it still doesn't even get him close to the values required for the elastic properties of rock. So irrelevant lie would be more apt nomenclature. As noted before density is not a factor in elastic properties. As density and wave speed can be used to calculate elastic properties, even perhaps using a density similar to rock, what Sol88 actually needed was the measured wave speeds to be different (about 10 times faster).

Again from page 16 here...

http://www-mdp.eng.cam.ac.uk/web/library/enginfo/cueddatabooks/materials.pdf

We can see polymers, thermoplastics and elastomers can have similar and for some the same density as brick, stone and concrete but far less stiffness.

ETA2: Oops, sorry forgot it was speed squared so Sol88 really only needed 3 times the measured wave speed.
 
Last edited:
And again just so you are a least aware jd116

Err, yes. I'm quite well aware of the CONSERT findings. You do realise that it is very unlikely that they would have gotten any sort of signal through the lobe if it had been solid rock? That alone should tell you that this ain't no rock. However, that would involve understanding the experiment. And even if they had got a signal, it would have looked very different from what was found.
In addition, they calculate the dielectric permittivity of the nucleus to be 1.27. This is nothing like rock. You can see some measurements of various rock types in table 2 of this paper:

Dielectric and hardness measurements of planetary analog rocks in support of in-situ subsurface sampling
ElShafie, A. & Heggy, E.
http://kiss.caltech.edu/papers/surface/papers/dielectric.pdf

The lowest I can see is pumice, at ~ 1.90.

Pure ice is 3.0; meteoritic dust is 5.0; vacuum is 1.0, per;

Finite difference time domain simulation of radar wave propagation through comet nuclei dielectric models
Carley, R. A. & Heggy, E.
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1945-5100.2008.tb00695.x/pdf

Measurements were taken at Mars with the MARSIS instrument, of the South Polar Layered Deposits (SPLD).
The upper layers had permittivities of ~ 3.0 - 5.0. Much as one would expect for an icy material with some rock inclusion. The basal layer was much higher, as expected for solid rock:

Dielectric properties of the Martian south polar layered deposits: MARSIS data inversion using Bayesian inference and genetic algorithm
Zhang, Z. et al.
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1029/2007JE002941/full

All of which shows that these people know what they are doing, and know what they are looking at. And the conclusion, from multiple lines of evidence, is that there is no rock to be found at a comet.
 
Last edited:
Lol. 'Clueless' is a bit rich coming from someone who doesn't understand the difference between the density of a dust particle and bulk density. Lern to scienz! Some little bits of dust are high density. Some are very low density (< 1 kg/m3). Ice is an altogether different density. And then we have pores, which have zero density. It isn't rocket science. Unless you are an EU follower. The whole of this mixture can then be 'weighed', as set out in the following article;

http://blogs.esa.int/rosetta/2014/08/21/determining-the-mass-of-comet-67pc-g/

The article is easy to understand, as it assumes little prior scientific knowledge, which will definitely be the case for any EU readers.

Of course, there are other means for determining the make up of the comet, which have been used on this mission and previous ones;
We can smack it with a projectile traveling at ~ 10 km/s.
We can do a Jeremy Clarkson, and smack it with a hammer.
We can send radio waves right through the comet from Rosetta to Philae.
We can look at bits of the comet that have fallen off of cliffs.
We can use MIRO to determine the thermal inertia of the comet's surface and near surface.

All of those methods show us that the comet is nothing like any sort of rock known to man. So, what is it, EU woosters? Answers on a postcard.

So fluffy ducks all the way down!

A fuzzy photo of a suspected impact crater is not proof of anything.

So far NOTHING the mainstream dreamers have come up with proves ANYTHING wrt the composition of the nucleus.

So why don’t the mainstream model comets as mostly dust and little ice?


As suggested,
11 CONCLUSIONS The classical model of comets as dirty ice balls (Whipple 1950)has focused most models of comets on ices. The more we visit comets, the dustier they appear. With 67P’s dust-to-water ratio of 6 (and possibly larger), it is now necessary to spend much more time in modelling the non-volatile matrices with a modest content of ices inside. Jean-Pierre Bibring proposes a new word naming this stuff, ‘organic(e)s’, where the modest content of ices (within brackets) well summarizes the dominant non-volatile component. Between the sizes of 0.1 and 1 mm, 99 per cent of the dust mass is in the form of compact particles, denser than the nucleus. This implies that much of the nucleus mass is in the form of mineral aggregates (silicates and suldes), so that a better denition may be ‘mineral organic(e)s’.

So why don’t the mainstream?
 
Last edited:
The nucleus is a charged object! That happens to be mostly well consolidated refractory material including crystalline silica.

Still batting zero on the “ice” btw jd116
 
A fuzzy photo of a suspected impact crater is not proof of anything.

Yep, it is proof of a crater that wasn't there before, and is far too big to have been made in rock.

So far NOTHING the mainstream dreamers have come up with proves ANYTHING wrt the composition of the nucleus.

Nope, just proves that you are incapable of reading and/or comprehension. That impact was analysed by more than one instrument. What they see is as expected - dust, water vapour and water ice. So we know for sure that those materials are present. We also know that CO2 ice is present. And CO. And various other ices. We know that there are organics. What has never been seen is rock. Ever.
 
Once again the misrepresentation of the density of individual grains as the bulk density of the comet. You’ve been corrected on this numerous times. Let’s start calling this what it’s become: a lie.


The Dust is from the comet, yes?

The comet is made of dust and ices? (the dirtysnowball, Whipple)

The comet contains more dust than ice?

The compact dust is 3000kg m3 the fluffy dust is made up of compact particles?

The volume of the the nucleus = x

The mass = y

Therefore the nucleus = 80% porous!

:D
 
The Dust is from the comet, yes?

The comet is made of dust and ices? (the dirtysnowball, Whipple)

The comet contains more dust than ice?

The compact dust is 3000kg m3 the fluffy dust is made up of compact particles?

The volume of the the nucleus = x

The mass = y

Therefore the nucleus = 80% porous!

:D

Nope. You are just scientifically illiterate. The fluffy dust is not made up of compact dust! Jesus H. Christ. If it were, how would it have a density of < 1 kg/m3?
My observation that EU followers need a considerable level of scientific illiteracy is being borne out beautifully here!
 
Nope. You are just scientifically illiterate. The fluffy dust is not made up of compact dust! Jesus H. Christ. If it were, how would it have a density of < 1 kg/m3?
My observation that EU followers need a considerable level of scientific illiteracy is being borne out beautifully here!

So the nucleus is made up from fluffy dust? with a percentage of compact dust and very little "ice"

Is this how i'm to understand you jd116?
 
So the nucleus is made up from fluffy dust? with a percentage of compact dust and very little "ice"

Is this how i'm to understand you jd116?

There is plenty of ice, just not as much as people originally envisaged. At the time they envisaged this, it is not surprising that it wasn't particularly accurate, as we'd never visited a comet. Now that we have, each mission tells us a little more. So, we know there is more dust than originally thought. We know some of it is compact, some of it is fluffy (i.e. likely primordial). Different comets will have different dust/ ice ratios, depending on where they have been orbiting. JFCs, such as 67P, which have close-ish perihelia, may have a higher dust/ ice ratio than say Hale-Bopp, an Oort cloud comet which has had far fewer turns around the Sun. They are difficult to visit, because they tend to turn up unexpectedly.
If we take the dust/ ice volume ratio at the high end of the estimates, and say 6:1 - with 80% porosity - that means that of the 18.7 km3;
~ 15 km3 is empty space, ~ 3.2 km3 is dust, and ~0.5 km3 is ice. That is ~ 5 x 108 kg of ice (half a billion kg; = 500 000 tonnes).
 
There is plenty of ice, just not as much as people originally envisaged. At the time they envisaged this, it is not surprising that it wasn't particularly accurate, as we'd never visited a comet. Now that we have, each mission tells us a little more. So, we know there is more dust than originally thought. We know some of it is compact, some of it is fluffy (i.e. likely primordial). Different comets will have different dust/ ice ratios, depending on where they have been orbiting. JFCs, such as 67P, which have close-ish perihelia, may have a higher dust/ ice ratio than say Hale-Bopp, an Oort cloud comet which has had far fewer turns around the Sun. They are difficult to visit, because they tend to turn up unexpectedly.
If we take the dust/ ice volume ratio at the high end of the estimates, and say 6:1 - with 80% porosity - that means that of the 18.7 km3;
~ 15 km3 is empty space, ~ 3.2 km3 is dust, and ~0.5 km3 is ice. That is ~ 5 x 108 kg of ice (half a billion kg; = 500 000 tonnes).

Thank you JD116. :)

I think I now know your understanding on the structure of the nucleus.

Just one more thing this time specifically for the "ice" component.

Is it mixed in with the dust? or like Tempel 1 pure refractory free ice, some x meters below the surface which is composed of silca minerals at around 2500kg m3?

DEEP IMPACT: THE FIRST SECOND. H. J. Melosh and the Deep Impact Team, Lunar and Planetary Lab
(University of Arizona, Tucson AZ 85721, [email protected]).


Detection of water ice grains after the DEEP IMPACT onto Comet P/Tempel 1 R. Schulz1, A. Owens2, P. M. Rodriguez-Pascual3, D. Lumb2, C. Erd2, and J. A. Stüwe4

The distribution of water ice in the interior of Comet Tempel 1 Jessica M. Sunshine a,∗, Olivier Groussin b, Peter H. Schultz c, Michael F. A’Hearn a,Lori M. Feaga a, Tony L. Farnham a, Kenneth P. Klaasen d
The results imply an internal stratigraphy for Tempel 1 consisting of devolatilized materials transitioning to unaltered components at a depth of approximately one meter. At greater depths, which are thermally isolated from the surface, water ice is present. Up to depths of 10 to 20 m, the maximum depths excavated by the impact, these pristine materials consist of very fine grained (∼1 ± 1 μm) water ice particles, which are free from refractory impurities.

as per the above papers?





Is the "dusty" material layered as observed 67P?

Geomorphology of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko Samuel P. D. Birch,1‹ Y. Tang,2 A. G. Hayes,1,2 R. L. Kirk,3 D. Bodewits,4 H. Campins,5 Y. Fernandez,5 R. de Freitas Bart,2 N. W. Kutsop,2 H. Sierks,6 J. M. Soderblom,7 S. W. Squyres1,2 and J-B. Vincent6,8

Our mapping reveals strong latitudinal dependences for emplaced units and a highly heterogeneous surface. Layered bedrock (beddust???) units that represent the exposed nucleus of 67P/C-G are dominant at southern latitudes, while topographically smooth, dust covered regions dominate the Northern hemisphere. Equatorial latitudes are dominated by smooth terrain units that show evidence for flow structures.

I know it's not bedrock, so it must be beddust??? :boggled:

Think we are moving in the right direction jd116! :thumbsup:
 
Thank you JD116. :)

I think I now know your understanding on the structure of the nucleus.

Just one more thing this time specifically for the "ice" component.

Is it mixed in with the dust? or like Tempel 1 pure refractory free ice, some x meters below the surface which is composed of silca minerals at around 2500kg m3?

DEEP IMPACT: THE FIRST SECOND. H. J. Melosh and the Deep Impact Team, Lunar and Planetary Lab
(University of Arizona, Tucson AZ 85721, [email protected]).


Detection of water ice grains after the DEEP IMPACT onto Comet P/Tempel 1 R. Schulz1, A. Owens2, P. M. Rodriguez-Pascual3, D. Lumb2, C. Erd2, and J. A. Stüwe4

The distribution of water ice in the interior of Comet Tempel 1 Jessica M. Sunshine a,∗, Olivier Groussin b, Peter H. Schultz c, Michael F. A’Hearn a,Lori M. Feaga a, Tony L. Farnham a, Kenneth P. Klaasen d

as per the above papers?





Is the "dusty" material layered as observed 67P?

Geomorphology of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko Samuel P. D. Birch,1‹ Y. Tang,2 A. G. Hayes,1,2 R. L. Kirk,3 D. Bodewits,4 H. Campins,5 Y. Fernandez,5 R. de Freitas Bart,2 N. W. Kutsop,2 H. Sierks,6 J. M. Soderblom,7 S. W. Squyres1,2 and J-B. Vincent6,8



I know it's not bedrock, so it must be beddust??? :boggled:

Think we are moving in the right direction jd116! :thumbsup:

Well, without ploughing through the literature again, my take on it would be that there is a mixture of ice and dust below the surface. As the ice that was seen at Tempel 1 and Hartley 2 was pure, based on its survival time against sublimation, then one has to assume that the two are mixed areally, rather than intimately. In other words, the ice and dust are separate, rather than the dust being within the ice. This scenario may change near-surface, as sublimating ice refreezes (sinters), as it may well freeze within the voids of fluffy particles.
It should be noted that there was good evidence that the dust/ ice ratio at Tempel 1 was probably greater than 1 (from Rosetta's OSIRIS, no less):

A large dust/ice ratio in the nucleus of comet 9P/Tempel 1
Küppers, M. et al.
https://www.nature.com/articles/nature04236 (paywalled)
 
What if you ran the same calculation as above with a upper ratio of 100:1?

If we take the dust/ ice volume ratio at the high end of the estimates, and say 6:1 - with 80% porosity - that means that of the 18.7 km3;
~ 15 km3 is empty space, ~ 3.2 km3 is dust, and ~0.5 km3 is ice. That is ~ 5 x 108 kg of ice (half a billion kg; = 500 000 tonnes).

At perihelion and just after, the dust-to-water mass ratio ranges from 6 to 100 (Fulle et al. 2016). The dust-to-water ratio has been inferred by individual particle detections by the GIADA and OSIRIS instruments (Rotundi et al. 2015).
Unexpected and significant findings in comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view doi:10.1093/mnras/stw1663

I'd assume dust to water mass ratio is more or less the same as dust/gas ratio?

what is the km3 of empty space?

Also, what is in that "empty space" is????? Nothing? Gas? the vacuum of space?

My mental picture is becoming clearer, thank you JD116 I was WAY off.
 
Last edited:
A large dust-to-water mass ratio implies that the nucleus matrix
is non-volatile, so that ground-based experiments (Gr¨un et al. 1993)
and thermo-physical models of cometary nuclei (Prialnik, Benkoff
& Podolak 2004), assuming an ice matrix, may provide misleading
results: they should be repeated assuming a refractorymatrix, which
has micro-properties far from ices. The larger the dust-to-water
ratio, the larger the porosity required to fit the observed nucleus
bulk density. The RSI (P¨atzold et al. 2016) and the CONSERT
(Kofman et al. 2015) experiments exclude macro-porosity at scales
above 100 m. CONSERT experiment provides a micro-porosity
between 75 per cent and 85 per cent (Kofman et al. 2015). Hapke
models provide a surface porosity of 87 per cent (Fornasier et al.
2015).

Mental picture forming.

At sunrise, VIRTIS observes up to
15 per cent of water ice on the surface of the Hapi smooth plain
(De Sanctis et al. 2015), a nucleus region close to the northern pole
(Thomas et al. 2015a). This water is coming from 67P’s interior and
is frozen inside the cold upper surface layers during the night (De
Sanctis et al. 2015).

So the water vapour percolates thru the "empty space" to arrive at the surface and lift the dust of into "jets"?

Well, without ploughing through the literature again, my take on it would be that there is a mixture of ice and dust below the surface.
Thought you'd have it memerised by now. This is scripture for the dirtysnowball model.

So pure "ice" somewhere under the surface of well consolidated layered fractured refractory material.

Throw in some dust and "empty space" and we have 67P??
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom