Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
For God's sake, will you actually listen?
He is making a proposal, not backed up by evidence, for another interpretation of the field dropouts at 67P. He is NOT questioning the existence of the DC. Either at 67P, or at Halley, or during AMPTE. Understand? No, diidn't think so.

He is making a proposal, not backed up by as much evidence data as everyone else, for another interpretation of the field dropouts at 67p

Bang spot on the money sport! Bang on :thumbsup:
 
He is NOT questioning the existence of the DC. Either at 67P, or at Halley, or during AMPTE.


There are (at least) two reasons why the diamagnetic region might not be associated with a global diamagnetic cavity surrounding the nucleus: (i) the total gas production rate is not sufcient to create such a large diamagnetic cavity, and (ii) the large number and short duration of these magnetic eld-free regions. As Goetz et al. (2016a) discussed, the total gas production rate must be larger than 3×1028 s−1 at1.3autocreatea extended cavityb expanding to around 170km.Hansenetal.(2016) obtained a total gas production rate of ∼1028 s−1 at 1.3 au from a multi-instrumental analysis of Rosetta observations, which is a factor of 3 smaller than the gas production rate necessary to push the diamagnetic cavity boundary out to the Rosetta’s location.

How are you interpreting Huang? Factor of 3 too small?

And again we are at the same bloody question that you can not answer! And it’s the corner stone of the dirtysnowball!!

How do the guess the outgassing rate?
 
Last edited:
Stop obfuscating. Huang is not questioning the existence or formation mechanisms of a DC. How many times do I have to say it?

The diamagnetic cavity is an important plasma boundary in the inner coma region near an active comet. It was first observed by the Giotto spacecraft at comet 1P/Halley in 1986.

In this paper, we suggest that the observed diamagnetic regions Goetz et al. (2016a,b) may not be associated with the ‘classical’ diamagnetic cavity observed at comet 1P/Halley

It was also observed during the AMPTE artificial comet experiments, prior to Halley. It is a proven fact. Huang knows this, and says it, as above. He is not questioning its existence at 67P. He is questioning, without evidence to back it up (see Tusenfem's posts on this) whether or not the signatures seen at 67P were actually part of a global DC, or something else. The consensus says that he is wrong. And even were he to be right, it doesn't alter the fact that DCs are observed at Halley and AMPTE., and will be present at 67P.

A possible mechanism for the formation of magnetic field dropouts in the coma of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko
Huang, Z. et al
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/462/Suppl_1/S468/2627203
 
Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Yu. V. Skorov 10.1051/0004-6361/201630000

the dust removal by a gas drag force outgassing is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding to 1.3 AU.

How many &#%%£%&* times??????

These particles must be the product of a disintegration of larger dust aggregates in the coma.

What drives the dust activity of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko?
B. Gundlach, J. Blum, H. U. Keller and Y. V. Skorov
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/full_html/2015/11/aa25828-15/aa25828-15.html

Stop going over the same old things that have already been dealt with.
 
How many &#%%£%&* times??????



What drives the dust activity of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko?
B. Gundlach, J. Blum, H. U. Keller and Y. V. Skorov
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/full_html/2015/11/aa25828-15/aa25828-15.html

Stop going over the same old things that have already been dealt with.

:boggled:

This work extends the models and results described in Skorov & Blum (2012), Gundlach et al. (2015) by explicitly including the diffusivity resistance of the dust layer and consistent heat conductivity into the interior. As a result, the previous conclusions are updated, pointing even further into the direction that small (<1 mm) dust grains cannot be lifted at all from the nucleus by ice sublimation (H2O, CO2, or CO).

So he improved on that paper :)
 
Outgassing rate and how they guessed at it, jd116?

Has a direct bearing on this discussion.
 
Outgassing rate and how they guessed at it, jd116?

Has a direct bearing on this discussion.

No, it hasn't. The DC exists, therefore the outgassing rate must be high enough for it to form. By definition. Otherwise it wouldn't be seen, eh?
 
Stop obfuscating. Huang is not questioning the existence or formation mechanisms of a DC. How many times do I have to say it?





It was also observed during the AMPTE artificial comet experiments, prior to Halley. It is a proven fact. Huang knows this, and says it, as above. He is not questioning its existence at 67P. He is questioning, without evidence to back it up (see Tusenfem's posts on this) whether or not the signatures seen at 67P were actually part of a global DC, or something else. The consensus says that he is wrong. And even were he to be right, it doesn't alter the fact that DCs are observed at Halley and AMPTE., and will be present at 67P.

A possible mechanism for the formation of magnetic field dropouts in the coma of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko
Huang, Z. et al
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/462/Suppl_1/S468/2627203

The consensus says????? Thought we were doing science? Tested in the lab real plasma science or the consensus is the dirty snowball is in fact correct, beacause the consensus says so?
 
:boggled:



So he improved on that paper :)

In terms of the modelling. It does not alter the conclusion that smaller grains must come from the disintegration of larger grains. Otherwise they'd have stated that implicitly. Old news. Move on.
 
The consensus says????? Thought we were doing science? Tested in the lab real plasma science or the consensus is the dirty snowball is in fact correct, beacause the consensus says so?

And the modelling. Or are you only reading Huang's papers? Which are not backed up by the evidence? How about his later paper on the subject? Happy to acknowledge MRx in the dayside coma?

EDIT:
And it still doesn't alter the fact that a DC is known to form. As observed.
 
Last edited:
Outgassing rate and how they guessed at it, jd116?

Has a direct bearing on this discussion.

They don't 'guess'; they model. Descriptions of the models can be seen in this paper, and references therein:

Evolution of water production of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an empirical model and a multi-instrument study
Hansen, K. C. el al.
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/462/Suppl_1/S491/2672995

Note that the spherically symmetrical Haser model, which has commonly been used in the past, appears to underestimate the production rate compared to the more realistic and sophisticated models described in the above paper.
 
Good job, Sol! Bog down the thread in irrelevant details of the science in hopes folks will forget comets aren't rocks. You’ve created the illusion of controversy in a manner that would make a creationist proud.
 
Good job, Sol! Bog down the thread in irrelevant details of the science in hopes folks will forget comets aren't rocks. You’ve created the illusion of controversy in a manner that would make a creationist proud.

Something that Tom Bridgman commented on somewhere on his blog - the EU zealots have similar debating tactics to creationists.
 
Good job, Sol! Bog down the thread in irrelevant details of the science in hopes folks will forget comets aren't rocks. You’ve created the illusion of controversy in a manner that would make a creationist proud.

So comet science is settled?

irrelevant details of the science??

outgassing is irrelevant?

Electric fields can not happen at a comet, this was reinforced many times during this thread but now ......
 
So comet science is settled?

irrelevant details of the science??

outgassing is irrelevant?

Electric fields can not happen at a comet, this was reinforced many times during this thread but now ......


Let’s see, what do we have here? Looks like the usual strawmanning, JAQing and attempts to shift the burden. How about you provide real evidence for the EC and not just links to random papers containing the words “electron” and “magnet” pretending they support the EC?
 
Let’s see, what do we have here? Looks like the usual strawmanning, JAQing and attempts to shift the burden. How about you provide real evidence for the EC and not just links to random papers containing the words “electron” and “magnet” pretending they support the EC?

There are (at least) two reasons why the diamagnetic region might not be associated with a global diamagnetic cavity surrounding the nucleus: (i) the total gas production rate is not sufcient to create such a large diamagnetic cavity, and (ii) the large number and short duration of these magnetic eld-free regions. As Goetz et al. (2016a) discussed, the total gas production rate must be larger than 3×1028 s−1 at1.3autocreatea extended cavityb expanding to around 170km.Hansenetal.(2016) obtained a total gas production rate of ∼1028 s−1 at 1.3 au from a multi-instrumental analysis of Rosetta observations, which is a factor of 3 smaller than the gas production rate necessary to push the diamagnetic cavity boundary out to the Rosetta’s location.
A possible mechanism for the formation of magnetic field dropouts in the coma of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko
Huang, Z. et al
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/artic...1/S468/2627203

Have a real go then ya muppet!
 
Let’s see, what do we have here? Looks like the usual strawmanning, JAQing and attempts to shift the burden. How about you provide real evidence for the EC and not just links to random papers containing the words “electron” and “magnet” pretending they support the EC?

I'd like to ask what you class as evidence if peer reviewed papers are not!

all I'm posting is cometary science is no where near settled!

and the dirtysnowball has some MAJOR FATAL issues

e.g

In this paper, we suggest that the observed diamagnetic regions
Goetz et al. (2016a,b) may not be associated with the ‘classical’
diamagnetic cavity observed at comet 1P/Halley Neubauer et al.
(1986) and explained by Cravens (1986) and Ip & Axford (1987).
We raise the possibility that the observed diamagnetic regions are
small-scale phenomena caused by short-lived increases of the local
electron pressure
.

So Fred please feel free to add something constructive. :)
 
Let’s see, what do we have here? Looks like the usual strawmanning, JAQing and attempts to shift the burden. How about you provide real evidence for the EC and not just links to random papers containing the words “electron” and “magnet” pretending they support the EC?

Again, just to highlight the mainstream are just forcing the dirtysnowball theory into a new theory of comets...they are electrical in nature!

The high correlation between the dust brightness and the water production rate then indicates that the ratio of dust surface area to water production is nearly constant over the entire perihelion passage. The simplest way to explain such a strong correlation would be for the dust to gas ratio and the dust size distribution to remain over the same period. If the dust to gas ratio and dust size distribution are not constant, then they would need to evolve consistently so that a change in the dust to gas ratio would be balanced by a change in the size distribution in such a way that the sun light reflecting surface area of the dust coma remained proportional to the water production. It is hard to imagine that this would be the case.
Evolution of water production of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an
empirical model and a multi-instrument study


onto

At perihelion and just after, the dust-to-water mass ratio ranges from 6 to 100 (Fulle et al. 2016). The dust-to-water ratio has been inferred by individual particle detections by the GIADA and OSIRIS instruments (Rotundi et al. 2015).
A large dust-to-water mass ratio implies that the nucleus matrix is non-volatile, so that ground-based experiments (Gr¨un et al. 1993) and thermo-physical models of cometary nuclei (Prialnik, Benkoff & Podolak 2004), assuming an ice matrix, may provide misleading results: they should be repeated assuming a refractory matrix, which has micro-properties far from ices. The larger the dust-to-water ratio, the larger the porosity required to fit the observed nucleus bulk density.
Unexpected and significant findings in comet
67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view


yeah, so it's all good, move along! :rolleyes:
 
Good job, Sol! Bog down the thread in irrelevant details of the science in hopes folks will forget comets aren't rocks. You’ve created the illusion of controversy in a manner that would make a creationist proud.

better engage low gear, sport, boggy conditions ahead!

Around the approach
to perihelion, the formation of a diamagnetic cavity, as observed at
1P/Halley by Giotto (Neubauer et al. 1986), but due to the lower
activity of 67P, was expected at much closer distances, 50–100 km
from the nucleus (Koenders et al. 2015). Navigation issues meant
that Rosetta was flying trajectories above 150 km around perihelion,
but still the cavity was detected (G¨otz et al. 2016a). It is not yet clear
if this is related to activity or the dynamic nature of the boundary
(G¨otz et al. 2016b)
.
10 67P PLASMA Unexpected and significant findings in comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom