Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Good job, Sol! Bog down the thread in irrelevant details of the science in hopes folks will forget comets aren't rocks. You’ve created the illusion of controversy in a manner that would make a creationist proud.

Just what I was thinking! You took the letters right off of my keyboard.
 
Comets are small solar system bodies consisting of a mixture of volatile and refractory materials, which were left over after the formation of the outer planets.

Are they?
 
Proven???

😂

WavesAndElectricFieldsAssociatedWithTheFirstAMPTEArtificialComet

All electric!

And just for clarity you are saying there is 0nT within the diamagnetic cavity?

‘Cos there is some questions being raised but we’ll keep them quite.

All these diamagnetic regions were observed much further from the nucleus than the predicted distances of the diamagnetic cavity boundary. The physical mechanism responsible for these diamagnetic regions is still unclear.

In this paper, we consider an alternative scenario. Our main argument against the diamagnetic cavity ‘ngers’ advocated by Goetz et al. (2016a,b) is that the neutral gas production rate is not sufcient to create such alarge diamagnetic cavity.

We also argue that the minimum magnetic eld magnitude is not necessarily zero, as assumed by Goetz et al. (2016a). It can be some small eld, like a few nT.

In this paper, we consider a generic process that temporarily increases the local electron pressure in a magnetic ux tube. Such process could involve interaction with an energetic electron beam with the coma Gan & Cravens (1990)or some other process. However, Rosetta observations do not show increased energetic electron uxes in the vicinity of diamagnetic dropouts (Madanian et al. 2016a,b; Nemeth et al. 2016). On the other hand the spacecraft potential stays very negative during the magnetic dropouts (Eriksson, private communication). Assuming the spacecraft surfaces (including solar array cover glasses) are still as conductive as they were at launch, and as properly grounded,this must be driven by electrons of sufciently high energy. Such are plentifully available: photoelectrons at 10 eV are suf cient for driving spacecraft potential to the observed negative potentials of the same order. Such low-energy electrons cannot be observed by the Ion and Electron Sensor (IES) instrument Burch et al. (2007) because IES can only observe electrons that overcome the spacecraft potential if negative or not even at all. Further investigation is necessary, but at this point we argue that a localized increase of thermal electron pressure is not inconsistent with the Rosetta observations and we will use this process as a placeholder for the source of observed magnetic dropouts.

Very similar to the AMPTE experiment.

So yeah, controversial ay!
 
And just beacause I asked about the dust within the diamagnetic cavity...

Ambipolar diffusion in complex plasma PHYSICAL REVIEW E 75, 046403 2007

A self-consistent model of the ambipolar diffusion of electrons and ions in complex dusty plasmas ac- counting for the local electric fields, the dust grain charging process, and the interaction of the plasma particles with the dust grains and neutrals is presented. The dependence of the diffusion coefficient on the interaction of the electrons and ions with the dust grains as well as with the neutrals are investigated. It is shown that increase of the dust density leads to a reduction of the diffusion scale length, and this effect is enhanced at higher electron densities. The dependence of the diffusion scale length on the neutral gas pressure is found to be given by a power law, where the absolute value of the power exponent decreases with increase of the dust density. The electric field gradient and its effects are shown to be significant and should thus be taken into account in studies of complex plasmas with not very small dust densities. The possibility of observing localized coherent dissipative nonlinear dust ion-acoustic structures in an asymmetrically discharged double plasma is discussed.

Well well well, dust is very important. Even the super duper space plasma physicist has not included the charged dust component.
 
Just for fun and because dust is back in the mix.

Conclusions. In the framework of the presented model, which can be considered common in terms of assumptions and physical parameters in the cometary community, the dust removal by a gas drag force is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding to 1.3 AU. Awayoutof this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.

Circle the wagons boys!
 
Last edited:
I forgot about god-of-the-gaps and false dilemma. Nothing still but dust=rocks and plasma=lightning bolts.

Geez. looks like your starting to grasp these complex ideas Fred!

Unexpected and significant findings in comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view Marco Fulle,1‹ N. Altobelli,2 B. Buratti,3 M. Choukroun,3 M. Fulchignoni,4 E. Gr¨un,5 M. G. G. T. Taylor 6 and P. Weissman7


2 THE NUCLEUS SHAPE
The shape of the nucleus of 67P (Preusker et al. 2015; Thomas et al. 2015a) was largely unexpected
not by the EC mob.

3 A HIGH DUST-TO-WATER RATIO
The dust-to-water mass ratio is a fundamental parameter governing
cometary activity and constraining 67P’s origin....snip...A large dust-to-water mass ratio implies that the nucleus matrix
is non-volatile, so that ground-based experiments (Gr¨un et al. 1993)
and thermo-physical models of cometary nuclei (Prialnik, Benkoff
& Podolak 2004), assuming an ice matrix, may provide misleading
results: they should be repeated assuming a refractorymatrix, which
has micro-properties far from ices.
Ec, not a problem!

4 ACTIVE AREAS HARD TO FIND
Coma features have always been modelled in terms of water and
dust ejection from the nucleus surface (Crifo et al. 2004). For most
comets, ground-based observations cannot define the nucleus shape,
which in most cases was simplified to a sphere. If the nucleus shape
is far from a sphere, its topography becomes the most important
source of coma features

snip

In order to model the dust coma, 3D coma models need to input how dust and gas
interact at the nucleus surface: the Rosetta Mission is still missing
this information. How dust can leave the nucleus surface is still not
understood (Gundlach et al. 2015).(
As would be expected in the EC, the dust is charged!

5 NO DISTRIBUTED WATER SOURCES
The sources of water vapour and other gases can be the nucleus
surface and the dust particles in the coma. In the second case,
they are referred to as distributed sources. It is a tradition derived
from ground-based observations to infer the presence of distributed
sources when the gas column density is a power law of the nucleus
distance with an index shallower than −1. Rubin et al. (2011) have
shown that this approach (applied to coma gas density when the
index is shallower than −2) is misleading when applied to in situ
data.
No ice with the dust in the coma???? None expected in the EC though not ruled out with spontaneous ice formation whith in a plasma!

6 SEASONS DRIVE ACTUAL ACTIVITY
It is hard to imagine a process more chaotic than dust ejection from a nucleus
surface, which in fact is still not understood (Gundlach et al. 2015).
So said Yu. V. Skorov

THERMO-PHYSICAL MODELS FAIL
The 67P surface has a very low thermal inertia, close to 20 J K−1 m−2 s−0.5 (Schloerb et al. 2015), which is probably due to the porosity at scale >1 mm among the compact particles mainly composing the nucleus surface layer.

snip

Even if the nucleus were composed of pure ice from a depth of 1.5 cm downwards, the entire surface of 67P would release a negligible water fraction of that observed (Gulkis et al. 2015; Keller et al. 2015b). This proves that all the water-vapour is coming from the uppermost surface layer thinner than 1 cm...

snip

This fact further suggests that a force independent of vapour pressure is breaking the link between dust and the nucleus surface, after which the dust is accelerated in the coma by vapour drag. A second consequence is that local thermodynamical equilibrium (LTE) cannot be applied in models of water
and dust ejection from comets. The fact that all thermo-physical models of comets assume LTE (Prialnik et al. 2004) may explain why they fail most predictions.
add some fudge factors and someone yelled out DIAMAGNETIC CAVITY!!!!

8 67P ORIGIN AND COLLISIONAL HISTORY
Decades ago, Weissman (1986) suggested that comets are primordial
rubble piles, formed by the gentle accretion of cometesimals,
without strong modifications occurring during the later collisional
phase. This scenario is at odds with some of the current models of
early Solar system evolution, where comets are collisional rubble
piles (Morbidelli & Rickman 2015). Rickman et al. (2015) show
that the shape of 67P is due to the accretion of two lobes at speeds
less than 20 m s−1, in order to preserve the low nucleus bulk density
(P¨atzold et al. 2016). The two lobes may be primordial rubble piles,
or rubble piles of collisional fragments, as suggested by parallel
cracks observed in Hathor region (Rickman et al. 2015). Massironi
et al. (2015) detect layers of unknown origin with independent orientation
in the two lobes, some hundred metres thick in the Seth
and Hathor regions.
again with the "Comets are small solar system bodies consisting of a mixture of volatile and refractory materials, which were left over after the formation of the outer planets." basically mainstream are just guessing

9 FIRST LINK TO MOLECULAR CLOUDS
Molecular oxygen was completely unexpected in its high abundance
of 4 per cent relative to water. It is highly reactive, suggesting
an origin directly on the ice mantles of interstellar dust grains (Bieler
et al. 2015a).

snip

Mousis et al. (2016) find that
supervolatiles are trapped in clathrates or possibly in crystalline
ices. In this case, if supervolatiles are frozen in contact with water
ice (Bar-nun et al. 1987), 67P cannot have been warmer than 40 K,
in order to explain their observed abundances (Davidsson et al.
2016). The poor correlation between the outgassing of water and
some supervolatiles (Luspay-Kuti et al. 2015) suggests that many
are not frozen in contact with water ice. In this case, the required
temperature to store them becomes worryingly low, about 20K (Barnun
et al. 1987; Davidsson et al. 2016). Bubbles of O2 trapped in the 'ice' like bubbles in soda water!

10 67/P PLASMA
nuff'n too see hear, all very quite!

Maybe you could help them out Fred! seems they have a few issues dilemma's to work out yet :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Interesting read that one

Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko: Hardening of the sub-surface layer


5 Conclusions
We performed numerical simulations of the long–term sintering of ice–dust
granular mixtures of different granulation in order to constrain the granulation
of the Rosetta target comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko. We find that a
hardened layer at least a meter thick forms beneath the dust. This hardening
can only be observed in the models when the ice grains are smaller than a few
tens of microns in radius.

ok fair enough.

On comets, tensile strength controls
the ejection of grains, or agglomerates of grains. Ejection is possible only when
the gas pressure beneath exceeds the tensile strength of the material. In our
work we discuss both tensile strength and crushing strength. Our model parameters
were chosen to reflect the conditions at the Philae landing site on
comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko.
Hello again Mr Yu. V. Skorov

What's the bulk porosity of the nucleus again?

Why is the dust not lifted of this sintered layer of "ice" via sublimation?
 
As far as I know, up to now there have been no dusty plasma phenomena found in spacecraft data apart from finding that the electron density is different from the ion density because of dust charging. There are many theoretical and numerical papers, and some laboratory experiments, but the characteristic dust-ion-acoustic and the dust-acoustic waves have not been observed in nature.
 
Do you think it's important, Tusenfem?

I find a "reverse" plasma very interesting in the context of 67P.

Would dust traveling outward from the nucleus under the influence of a ambipolar diffusion region, leave any signature in the total magnetic field? or attenuate the signal?
 
As far as I know, up to now there have been no dusty plasma phenomena found in spacecraft data apart from finding that the electron density is different from the ion density because of dust charging. There are many theoretical and numerical papers, and some laboratory experiments, but the characteristic dust-ion-acoustic and the dust-acoustic waves have not been observed in nature.


so
maybe valid on the assumption that finding that the electron density is different from the ion density because of dust charging?
 
Last edited:
interesting as well from the diamagnetic cavity perspective!

Consequences of Cusp Trapping

Rob Sheldon
National Space Science & Technology Center
J. Chen, T.Fritz
Boston University
May 28, 2002

But Diamagnetic Cavities?
Since this region has weak fields, trapped plasma will distort the field.
As the plasma drifts around the minimum |B|, it produces a “cusp ring current” that opposes the cusp field and makes a diamagnetic cavity.

How are these diamagnetic cavities related to the quadrupole trapped plasma?

Same as at comets? we know there is one located at 1P and 67P, so...

Plasma is Diamagnetic
??? What it can also exclude other magnetic fields, like the solar wind?

maybe charged dust come into play here as well?
 
Last edited:
Do you think it's important, Tusenfem?

I find a "reverse" plasma very interesting in the context of 67P.

Would dust traveling outward from the nucleus under the influence of a ambipolar diffusion region, leave any signature in the total magnetic field? or attenuate the signal?

I think it is interesting.
As we don't measure anything, I guess it is not really important.
I have no idea what a reverse plasma is, so you will be the expert on that.
As we don't measure anything in the magnetometer data (so far) from the dust, I guess the answer is no.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom