Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Last edited:
Basically “two winds colliding” is an in incorrect assumption from the dirtysnowball model!
 
Basically “two winds colliding” is an in incorrect assumption from the dirtysnowball model!

It isn't an assumption. It was theorised, and then observed in-situ. If you believe otherwise, then you are about 3 decades late in making your objection. Let me put in in simple terms; solar wind and IMF goes in one direction; from the Sun, towards the comet(!). Cometary neutrals go in another direction; toward the Sun, from the comet(!). A bit simplistic, but that is the crux of it.
 

Definitely interesting. However, you didn't even finish reading the abstract:

It is suggested that they are large-scale unmagnetized plasma enhancements, transmitted from the very dynamical outer magnetized region to the inner magnetic field-free cavity region.

Seems reasonable. If it were magnetised plasma, what should happen to it when it reaches the piled up magnetic field?
However, I shall now read the full paper for a better view. Given that Charlotte Goetz is a co-author, I'm not expecting any woo to pop out of it.
 
Well, I read the paper. Insofar as I understood it, they concluded as I quoted above, having considered various other explanations. As I've said before, I'm no expert in plasma physics, so the questions floating around my head are;

1) If the plasma density increase is coming from the magnetised region, is it possible for that plasma to be unmagnetised? The authors say so, so I don't doubt it; I just wonder how it works.
2) If unmagnetised plasma exists outside the cavity boundary, how would it cross the piled up magnetic field region without becoming magnetised?
3) If there is a current running around the DCBL, what would that do to unmagnetised electrons and ions?

Luckily, we have a plasma astrophysicist who can answer those questions!
 
Well, I read the paper. Insofar as I understood it, they concluded as I quoted above, having considered various other explanations. As I've said before, I'm no expert in plasma physics, so the questions floating around my head are;

1) If the plasma density increase is coming from the magnetised region, is it possible for that plasma to be unmagnetised? The authors say so, so I don't doubt it; I just wonder how it works.
2) If unmagnetised plasma exists outside the cavity boundary, how would it cross the piled up magnetic field region without becoming magnetised?
3) If there is a current running around the DCBL, what would that do to unmagnetised electrons and ions?

Luckily, we have a plasma astrophysicist who can answer those questions!

If you look at the magnetic field signatures just outside the DC you find that hter are often "steepened waves", i.e. waves that signatures that ramp up and quickly drop down. I am sure there is a pictuer of that is Rajkumar's paper, but I forgot my hard drive at work so I cannot look it up.
(okay have a version of the paper now, look at figure 1C in the grey area)
These waves are also visible in the plasma data, that Rajkumar is discussing. Interestingly, inside the DC the same plasma signatures are found, but then, of course, without a magnetic signature.
The idea is that these waves are travelling towards the cavity, and the cross the boudary, where the "leave behind" their magnetic signature, and travel on as an unmagnetize plasma wave.
Note that the signatures in density n and magnetic field B look similar. And see that l1 in figure 2 looks similar to the density variations outside the DC (in the grey areas)
There is a current on the boundary of the DC (there has to be) but I am not sure if it has any effect on the waves that are crossing it.

I have to read the paper to get acquainted again with their findings, but now there is the slalom in Wengen on TV, so ...
 
If you look at the magnetic field signatures just outside the DC you find that hter are often "steepened waves", i.e. waves that signatures that ramp up and quickly drop down. I am sure there is a pictuer of that is Rajkumar's paper, but I forgot my hard drive at work so I cannot look it up.
(okay have a version of the paper now, look at figure 1C in the grey area)
These waves are also visible in the plasma data, that Rajkumar is discussing. Interestingly, inside the DC the same plasma signatures are found, but then, of course, without a magnetic signature.
The idea is that these waves are travelling towards the cavity, and the cross the boudary, where the "leave behind" their magnetic signature, and travel on as an unmagnetize plasma wave.
Note that the signatures in density n and magnetic field B look similar. And see that l1 in figure 2 looks similar to the density variations outside the DC (in the grey areas)
There is a current on the boundary of the DC (there has to be) but I am not sure if it has any effect on the waves that are crossing it.

I have to read the paper to get acquainted again with their findings, but now there is the slalom in Wengen on TV, so ...

Cheers for that. It was mainly the magnetised --> unmagnetised thing that was stumping me. Much to figure out about plasma stuff..........but at least I realise that!
 
Cheers for that. It was mainly the magnetised --> unmagnetised thing that was stumping me. Much to figure out about plasma stuff..........but at least I realise that!


A quick look at what characterizes a plasma as magnetized...


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_(physics)#Magnetization

Plasma with a magnetic field strong enough to influence the motion of the charged particles is said to be magnetized. A common quantitative criterion is that a particle on average completes at least one gyration around the magnetic field before making a collision

seems to make the loss of that "quantitative criterion" (full gyration before collision) inevitable at least at the collisional interface between the solar wind and the out gassing nucleus.
 
The pervasiveness of the warm electron population at the position of Rosetta around 67P is an effect of the comparatively low activity of the comet. Using neutral gas density measurements by Rosetta Orbiter Spectrometer for Ion and Neutral Analysis (ROSINA)/Comet Pressure Sensor (COPS), Mandt et al. (2016) showed that Rosetta likely stayed outside the electron exobase, where the collision mean free path equals the local scale height of the neutral gas (which for an expanding cometary atmosphere is equal to the distance to the nucleus centre), during the entire mission. Nevertheless, Eriksson et al. (2017) presented observations of cold (around or below 0.1 eV) electrons, interpreted as having undergone cooling close to the nucleus and propagated outward without any significant heating. The most obvious signature of the cold electrons was found to be intermittent, showing up in the data as pulses of typical duration between a few seconds and a few minutes. This is interpreted as filamentation of a cold plasma close to the nucleus, as observed in e.g. the hybrid simulations by Koenders et al. (2015). A similar picture has been presented by Henri et al. (2017) for the intermittent appearance of a magnetic field-free plasma at Rosetta, interpreted as filaments or bubbles rising from an inner diamagnetic cavity.
Measurements of the electrostatic potential of Rosetta at comet 67P

just some more to the mix!
 
Electomagnetic phenomena on or near comets. Yeah, scientists know about that. Funny how you never cite the magnitude of any currents. Wake us up when you have real evidence of your rocks and lightning bolts


:eusa_boohoo:

no, what is more entertaining is watching the ad hoc explanation for the very complex plasma phenomena at comets!!

Your assumptions on cometary outgassing are incorrect leading to a whole raft a issues in interpreting the data!
 
Electomagnetic phenomena on or near comets. Yeah, scientists know about that. Funny how you never cite the magnitude of any currents. Wake us up when you have real evidence of your rocks and lightning bolts

The most obvious signature of the cold electrons was found to be intermittent, showing up in the data as pulses of typical duration between a few seconds and a few minutes. This is interpreted as filamentation of a cold plasma close to the nucleus, as observed in e.g. the hybrid simulations by Koenders et al. (2015). A similar picture has been presented by Henri et al. (2017) for the intermittent appearance of a magnetic field-free plasma at Rosetta, interpreted as filaments or bubbles rising from an inner diamagnetic cavity.

please fill us in on how a dirtysnowball achieves these feats, fred burfle!
 
Electomagnetic phenomena on or near comets. Yeah, scientists know about that. Funny how you never cite the magnitude of any currents. Wake us up when you have real evidence of your rocks and lightning bolts


aHR0cDovL3d3dy5zcGFjZS5jb20vaW1hZ2VzL2kvMDAwLzA1NC81ODcvb3JpZ2luYWwvY29tZXQtNjdwLXJvc2V0dGEtYXBwcm9hY2hpbmcuanBn
Rosetta Navcam

Mmmmmm.....

2iad9xc.jpg

From: Diamagnetic region(s): structure of the unmagnetized plasma around Comet 67P/CG
Mon Not R Astron Soc. 2017;469(Suppl_2):S372-S379. doi:10.1093/mnras/stx1540
Mon Not R Astron Soc | © 2017 The Authors Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Royal Astronomical Society


Is the dust charged????? :)

Come on Fred your a smart cookie, join the dots!
 
Last edited:
:eusa_boohoo:

no, what is more entertaining is watching the ad hoc explanation for the very complex plasma phenomena at comets!!

Your assumptions on cometary outgassing are incorrect leading to a whole raft a issues in interpreting the data!

Really? Says who? And what are their qualifications to be saying it? Thornhill? Nope, unqualified. Talbott? Ditto. You? Lol. Anyone else? Didn't think so. Ta ta. Back to mythology woo-land you go.
 
Really? Says who? And what are their qualifications to be saying it? Thornhill? Nope, unqualified. Talbott? Ditto. You? Lol. Anyone else? Didn't think so. Ta ta. Back to mythology woo-land you go.

Cheers for that. It was mainly the magnetised --> unmagnetised thing that was stumping me. Much to figure out about plasma stuff..........but at least I realise that!

Not sure you fully understand there cob!

:rolleyes:
 
Really? Says who? And what are their qualifications to be saying it? Thornhill? Nope, unqualified. Talbott? Ditto. You? Lol. Anyone else? Didn't think so. Ta ta. Back to mythology woo-land you go.

Please explain to me and the lurkers how outgassing is guessed at.

See how ya go, ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom