Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Is the dust charged?

Does the plasma contain dust?

Are there electric fields?

Are there plasma boundaries?

:D

:thumbsup:

Lol. Sorry, you cannot hide the fact that you made a fool of yourself by posting a diagram of plasma boundaries and equated it with dust. Read the caption.
 
Please explain to me and the lurkers how outgassing is guessed at.

See how ya go, ;)

Don't obfuscate. Answer the question. Who is qualified to make the statement you originally made?

Your assumptions on cometary outgassing are incorrect leading to a whole raft a issues in interpreting the data!

Please answer the question in my reply, and stop Gishing;

Really? Says who? And what are their qualifications to be saying it? Thornhill? Nope, unqualified. Talbott? Ditto. You? Lol. Anyone else? Didn't think so.

I'll answer it for you - there is nobody. Prove me wrong.
 
Lol. Sorry, you cannot hide the fact that you made a fool of yourself by posting a diagram of plasma boundaries and equated it with dust. Read the caption.

Ha ha ha :p

Please tell us what the charged dust is doing?

I mean if you can ‘cos you know
Much to figure out about plasma stuff..........but at least I realise that!
.

So off you go and learn about dusty plasma.
 
Last edited:
Please explain to me and the lurkers how outgassing is guessed at.

See how ya go, ;)

What has that got to do with anything????????? We were talking about the indisputable evidence that DCs are formed at comets. And artificial comets. This is not in dispute. At least not from anybody that has a clue what they're talking about.
 
Ha ha ha :p

Please tell us what the charged dust is doing?

I mean if you can ‘cos you know .

So off you go and learn about dusty plasma.

What the hell has dust got to do with that diagram? Zilch. Go find a paper on the dust and educate yourself, instead of wasting people's time on here with your inanities.
 
What the hell has dust got to do with that diagram? Zilch. Go find a paper on the dust and educate yourself, instead of wasting people's time on here with your inanities.

Dense or what much???

Let me put it more simply for you, try and understand.

Is there any dust inside the “diamagnetic” cavity?

Calls into question the interpretation of a ‘diamagnetic cavity”

The simulation results show that a magnetic field-free region is formed and the recovery phase of the magnetic field magnitude is faster than the declining phase.
 
Last edited:
Dense or what much???

Let me put it more simply for you, try and understand.

Is there any dust inside the “diamagnetic” cavity?

Calls into question the interpretation of a ‘diamagnetic cavity”

Huh? J.H. Christ. What has the dust got to do with anything? There is dust being lifted off the comet by the outgassing. You can see it in pictures. Obviously there is bloody dust in the cavity!!!!! There is no problem with the interpretation of a DC. Have a look at the magnetometer data, and then get yourself a dictionary and look up "diamagnetic". Show me the magnetic field inside the cavity.
 
The simulation results show that a magnetic field-free region is formed and the recovery phase of the magnetic field magnitude is faster than the declining phase.
Apossible mechanism for the formation of magnetic field dropouts in the coma of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

If you look at the magnetic field signatures just outside the DC you find that hter are often "steepened waves", i.e. waves that signatures that ramp up and quickly drop down. I am sure there is a pictuer of that is Rajkumar's paper, but I forgot my hard drive at work so I cannot look it up.
(okay have a version of the paper now, look at figure 1C in the grey area)
These waves are also visible in the plasma data, that Rajkumar is discussing. Interestingly, inside the DC the same plasma signatures are found, but then, of course, without a magnetic signature.
The idea is that these waves are travelling towards the cavity, and the cross the boudary, where the "leave behind" their magnetic signature, and travel on as an unmagnetize plasma wave.
Note that the signatures in density n and magnetic field B look similar. And see that l1 in figure 2 looks similar to the density variations outside the DC (in the grey areas)
There is a current on the boundary of the DC (there has to be) but I am not sure if it has any effect on the waves that are crossing it.

I have to read the paper to get acquainted again with their findings, but now there is the slalom in Wengen on TV, so ...

Same as Huang saw?
 
Last edited:
Huh? J.H. Christ. What has the dust got to do with anything? There is dust being lifted off the comet by the outgassing. You can see it in pictures. Obviously there is bloody dust in the cavity!!!!! There is no problem with the interpretation of a DC. Have a look at the magnetometer data, and then get yourself a dictionary and look up "diamagnetic". Show me the magnetic field inside the cavity.

Right, back to square one, how do they guess at the outgassing on 67p?

Shall we wheel out on Yu. V. Skorov? Or is he still in the bad books?

Go on :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Right, back to square one, how do they guess at the outgassing on 67p?

Shall we wheel out on Yu. V. Skorov? Or is he still in the bad books?

Go on :rolleyes:

Nice try. Stop avoiding the question. What has the outgassing rate got to do with anything, when we already know that a DC is present? We obviously know that the rate is high enough to cause a DC. As seen in the data from over 30 years ago. End of story. There is a DC. There is zero magnetic field within it. Hence the name. Get over it.
 
Nice try. Stop avoiding the question. What has the outgassing rate got to do with anything, when we already know that a DC is present? We obviously know that the rate is high enough to cause a DC. As seen in the data from over 30 years ago. End of story. There is a DC. There is zero magnetic field within it. Hence the name. Get over it.

Ummmm..... everything in a dirtysnowball fantasy land :blush:

There are (at least) two reasons why the diamagnetic region might not be associated with a global diamagnetic cavity surrounding the nucleus: (i) the total gas production rate is not sufcient to create such a large diamagnetic cavity, and (ii) the large number and short duration of these magnetic eld-free regions. As Goetz et al. (2016a) discussed, the total gas production rate must be larger than 3×1028 s−1 at1.3autocreateanextendedcavityexpandingto around 170km.Hansenetal.(2016) obtained a total gas production rate of ∼1028 s−1 at 1.3 au from a multi-instrumental analysis of Rosetta observations, which is a factor of 3 smaller than the gas production rate necessary to push the diamagnetic cavity boundary out to the Rosetta’s location.

We also argue that the minimum magnetic eld magnitude is not necessarily zero, as assumed by Goetz et al. (2016a). It can be some small eld, like a few nT.
Huang. Apossible mechanism for the formation of magnetic field dropouts in the coma of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko
 
Last edited:
Shall we wheel out on Yu. V. Skorov? Or is he still in the bad books?

And what would that have to do with anything? Skorov, if you read a number of the papers he's authored or co-authored, is basically saying that the gas drag from sublimation does not appear to be high enough to account for the smaller dust grains. He is suggesting that the smaller grains are part of larger grains, cemented together with ice, that then sublimates within the coma, leading to the breaking up of the larger conglomerates into their smaller constituents. This would fit well with the data from GIADA, regarding the nature of the grains, and also with the ROSINA H2O detections being higher than other instruments, suggesting a distributed source within the coma. Failing to see the problem.
 
Ummmm..... everything in a dirtysnowball fantasy land :blush:

Huang. Apossible mechanism for the formation of magnetic field dropouts in the coma of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

For God's sake, will you actually listen?
He is making a proposal, not backed up by evidence, for another interpretation of the field dropouts at 67P. He is NOT questioning the existence of the DC. Either at 67P, or at Halley, or during AMPTE. Understand? No, diidn't think so.
 
Huh? J.H. Christ. What has the dust got to do with anything? There is dust being lifted off the comet by the outgassing. You can see it in pictures. Obviously there is bloody dust in the cavity!!!!! There is no problem with the interpretation of a DC. Have a look at the magnetometer data, and then get yourself a dictionary and look up "diamagnetic". Show me the magnetic field inside the cavity.

Conclusions. In the framework of the presented model, which can be considered common in terms of assumptions and physical parameters in the cometary community, the dust removal by a gas drag force is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding to 1.3 AU. Awayoutof this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.
Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Yu. V. Skorov 10.1051/0004-6361/201630000

the dust removal by a gas drag force outgassing is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding to 1.3 AU.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom