Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
[size=+2]TRULY PATHETIC! STILL NO EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT YOUR ELECTRIC COMET MODEL![/size]

Sol88! You're not very good at this game, are you? Over nine years you've been beaking off about how much better your electric comet model is, and still after all this time, absolutely no supporting evidence for your "ec" model! NONE! NOTHING! NADA! PATHETIC! TRULY PATHETIC! What a waste!

Tell me, Sol88, have you had any experience with your local judicial system? Do you know what evidence is? Do you know how to defend your point of view? If you have no supporting scientific evidence to present at your "electric comet trial", then we must conclude that there is no electric comet! *** Now, as far as I'm concerned, this nine-year trial has turned out to be an EPIC FAILURE for the electric comet crowd! As you have nothing "new" to add perhaps we can close this thread! However, before that happens, why don't you actually try to show us some physical evidence that supports your electric comet claims! All I see here is an ongoing litany of the same useless "ec" posts containing NOTHING of value or utility! Give me something to work with! Give me something I can use to make predictions about how your electric comet behaves under various circumstances! In other words, stop citing and/or bashing mainstream papers! Truth is, they cannot help your cause anyway! Remember, ...

As the resident expert in electric comets, YOU need to show us the "eu" science!

For example, how are you going to actually prove your electric comets are made of rock? What genuine "electrical science" will you apply? Or will you simply fall back to the standard "looks like a bunny" schtick! If you're going to use mainstream science, what physical concepts are you sufficiently adept at using? We know for a fact that you are not competent in plasma physics (or the use of a search engine)! Perhaps you possess skills in spectroscopy or comet geology?

Sol88! Do you ever wonder why you're the only one here that sees the utility of your electric comet? What are the rest of us missing? Why are you unable to scientifically explain your model? Why do you constantly and consistently FAIL to develop the fundamental "eu" science required to advance your model? I'm still waiting for you to show me how you would use electrostatics, electrodynamics, and orbital mechanics, to prove that eccentricity is responsible for the charging and discharging of your electric comet! Perhaps you could also show us how eccentricity does not cause charge separation at 12 out of 13 celestial objects tabulated below! You know what I'm talkin' about!

As an aside, I also note that you ask an inordinate number of questions! If you actually wanted to learn something, that would be awesome! However, I see you thumb your nose at any answer that contradicts or conflicts with your religious beliefs! That is a significant failing, my friend! While asking questions is important to this exercise, it is but one small piece of the puzzle! Now, I've heard tell that an "eu" claim to fame is critical thinking! So, when are you going to start thinking critically about your own model and provide us with some evidence? When are you going to start thinking about your electric sparkle rock!

So, Sol88! Are you ready for some fun and games? Here's that eccentricity table again! Remember, your electric comet model will eventually have to deal with it! It will never go away! Until you deal with it, it will provide sufficient evidence that your electric comet is an ABJECT FAILURE! And as you've noted, the internet never forgets!

Object ID | a | e | i | q | Q
Astrd: 2001 KD55 | 3.344 | 0.6235 | 9.98 | 1.26 | 5.43
Astrd: 2014 LS26 | 3.364 | 0.6289 | 10.86 | 1.25 | 5.48
Astrd: 2000 DQ110 | 3.361 | 0.6297 | 58.28 | 1.25 | 5.48
Astrd: 2016 RP33 | 3.334 | 0.6343 | 23.04 | 1.22 | 5.45
Astrd: 2014 XN40 | 3.381 | 0.6349 | 14.20 | 1.24 | 5.53
Astrd: 1986 RA | 3.327 | 0.6358 | 19.13 | 1.21 | 5.44
Comet: 67P/C-G | 3.463 | 0.6414 | 7.05 | 1.24 | 5.69
Astrd: 2014 HW177 | 3.302 | 0.6437 | 13.00 | 1.18 | 5.43
Astrd: 1995 QN3 | 3.300 | 0.6450 | 14.79 | 1.17 | 5.43
Astrd: 2014 HY196 | 3.526 | 0.6561 | 42.29 | 1.21 | 5.84
Astrd: 2016 WX8 | 3.529 | 0.6572 | 13.29 | 1.21 | 5.85
Astrd: 2016 LA2 | 3.565 | 0.6748 | 17.43 | 1.16 | 5.97
Astrd: 2011 YY28 | 3.388 | 0.6765 | 7.35 | 1.10 | 5.68

Columns: a = Semi-major axis (AU), e = Eccentricity, i = Inclination, q = Perihelion (AU), Q = Aphelion (AU). All data extracted from the JPL SBDB. Please note, the tabulated data, above, is a trivial subset of a greater whole.

*** By the way, there is no electric comet! I am unaware of any physical mechanisms that can support its operation! Simply put. the electric comet is physically impossible!
 
^^^Indagator

*** By the way, there is no electric comet! I am unaware of any physical mechanisms that can support its operation! Simply put. the electric comet is physically impossible!

Why?

Which bit specifically is impossible?

Are you Tom Bridgeman ????

'cos

And of course there's the persistent question about Electric Universe models that remain unanswered:

How would/could a net charge on the comet nucleus be maintained in interplanetary plasma?
Where's the battery or generator that maintains the potential between the comet nucleus and the solar wind?

Have yo been keeping up at all Indagator???

No one here is will to answer this because if they do truthful it's and of thread!

Will you have a go at answering Tom's persistent questions?

This has DIRECT bearing on the question you've asked me in the above post. Though we can save ourselves a whole heap of time you answer these questions by Tom Bridgeman, 'cos like I said they sound very familiar!
 
Last edited:
ORBIT DETERMINATION OF ROSETTA AROUND COMET 67P/CHURYUMOV-GERASIMENKO Bernard Godard(1), Frank Budnik(2), Pablo Mu˜noz(3), Trevor Morley(1), and Vishnu Janarthanan(4)

jd116, would the above paper be a fair call on the mainstreams modelling for the comets mass based on Rosetta orbit determination?

If you agree we have some basis for further discussion. jt, Indagator, the man, tusenfem, you know the real brains, feel free to pitch in.
 
i would hope you are clever enough to look at a figure and mentally compare the sw and com electrons and ions

So how far from the nucleus did you say before the electrons and ions “get together” per J.Decca’s paper?

So if I predicted cometary plasma double layers, does that mean I can claim the credit for them when they are PROVEN? The internet never forgets.

At the moment YOU still call them Ambipolar electric fields.

Double layers, how long have I been bang’n on about them?

Now, there they are!


Sol88!

The gentleman's name is Deca! As a courtesy, please correct that error in future posts.

True story! Scientists and engineers love to solve problems! The same cannot be said of those that follow the "eu religion" --- To date, I find that they prefer to bully, deflect, and blindly spout unscientific dogma without thought! Why? Because they have NO science!

As an optimist, I do hope you are better than a mindless missionary? To that end, Sol88, stop being lazy and put some effort into answering your own questions! Raise your game! Start thinking and acting like a scientist! Or FAIL! Your choice! Regarding your combative question about neutralization .... From Figure 1 in Deca et al (2017),

(1) "Overlay" panel 1(b) on top of 1(e). What do you see?
(2) "Overlay" panel 1(d) on top of 1(g). What do you see? And finally, while not as obvious or mechanically efficient, ...
(3) "Overlay" panel 1(c) on top of 1(h).

Cometary electrons eventually end up neutralizing the solar wind protons, and solar wind electrons eventually neutralize the cometary ions.
Clear as mud? Probably not!

So if I predicted cometary plasma double layers, does that mean I can claim the credit for them when they are PROVEN? The internet never forgets.

Regarding your ridiculous double layer prediction comment ...

Credit? NOT a frickin' chance! First you actually have to make a prediction!

In order to actually predict something, you must show where these double layers will form! How they form! How thick they will be! Their areal extent! How long they will last in a "turbulent" environment! The potential difference between the layers! What effects the double layers will have on particle transport in the overall plasma environment! It is obvious that you do not have the skills to discuss plasma science, or predict plasma behaviour! And forget about double layers!

Sol88! It is safe to say that you and the "eu/ec" will never, ever get to claim credit for predicting something because you people never, ever do any work! Stop FAILING and start doing some science! Dig?

Double layers, ...

Now, there they are!


Where? More "ec" unicorns? Can you provide some dimensions? A map to their location? Evidence? Anything? ANOTHER EPIC FAIL! Without the physics and math there are no double layers! Sol88! You lack scientific credibility! You know nothing of plasma physics! Double layers will produce a very specific "fingerprint" in the model results! Please provide specific details!

Something to think about as we move forward, Sol88! Science is iterative! If you, the resident "ec" expert, can't answer the simple questions we ask of you, you're going to hate the truly diabolical questions that follow! By the way, how's your electric comet "spherical cow" approximation coming for Jean Tate?

PostScript - Sol88! If you would like to discuss the gritty details of the Deca et al (2017) paper, it would be my pleasure to expand on its contents.
 
Sol88!

The gentleman's name is Deca! As a courtesy, please correct that error in future posts.

True story! Scientists and engineers love to solve problems! The same cannot be said of those that follow the "eu religion" --- To date, I find that they prefer to bully, deflect, and blindly spout unscientific dogma without thought! Why? Because they have NO science!

As an optimist, I do hope you are better than a mindless missionary? To that end, Sol88, stop being lazy and put some effort into answering your own questions! Raise your game! Start thinking and acting like a scientist! Or FAIL! Your choice! Regarding your combative question about neutralization .... From Figure 1 in Deca et al (2017),

(1) "Overlay" panel 1(b) on top of 1(e). What do you see?
(2) "Overlay" panel 1(d) on top of 1(g). What do you see? And finally, while not as obvious or mechanically efficient, ...
(3) "Overlay" panel 1(c) on top of 1(h).

Clear as mud? Probably not!



Regarding your ridiculous double layer prediction comment ...

Credit? NOT a frickin' chance! First you actually have to make a prediction!

In order to actually predict something, you must show where these double layers will form! How they form! How thick they will be! Their areal extent! How long they will last in a "turbulent" environment! The potential difference between the layers! What effects the double layers will have on particle transport in the overall plasma environment! It is obvious that you do not have the skills to discuss plasma science, or predict plasma behaviour! And forget about double layers!

Sol88! It is safe to say that you and the "eu/ec" will never, ever get to claim credit for predicting something because you people never, ever do any work! Stop FAILING and start doing some science! Dig?




Where? More "ec" unicorns? Can you provide some dimensions? A map to their location? Evidence? Anything? ANOTHER EPIC FAIL! Without the physics and math there are no double layers! Sol88! You lack scientific credibility! You know nothing of plasma physics! Double layers will produce a very specific "fingerprint" in the model results! Please provide specific details!

Something to think about as we move forward, Sol88! Science is iterative! If you, the resident "ec" expert, can't answer the simple questions we ask of you, you're going to hate the truly diabolical questions that follow! By the way, how's your electric comet "spherical cow" approximation coming for Jean Tate?

PostScript - Sol88! If you would like to discuss the gritty details of the Deca et al (2017) paper, it would be my pleasure to expand on its contents.


So the solar plasma is back to quasi neutral by 1500km from the nucleus then?

This is what J.Deca's paper show yeah?

And since it's your pleasure to expand on J.Deca's papers contents.

  1. What maintains this charge separation?
  2. What causes the charges to seperate?

as asked by Tom Bridgeman and other smart cookies here in this thread, though I note no one has the cojones to answer, can you Indagator

The charge separation described by Deca causes an electric field centred on the nucleus that Behar et al expanded on

Perhaps you cold expand on this as well?
The third term, the ambipolar electric field E ambipolar , is expected to be significant close to the nucleus. At zero order, this electric field points radially outward from the nucleus. It might be one of the reasons why close to the nucleus the modelled
proton trajectories in Figure 7 depart from the observed velocity
vectors. Another effect arising from the ambipolar term is
a polarisation electric field due to the different motion of the
cometary new-born electrons and ions.

are you able to expand on the bolded statement?
 
Last edited:
ORBIT DETERMINATION OF ROSETTA AROUND COMET 67P/CHURYUMOV-GERASIMENKO Bernard Godard(1), Frank Budnik(2), Pablo Mu˜noz(3), Trevor Morley(1), and Vishnu Janarthanan(4)

jd116, would the above paper be a fair call on the mainstreams modelling for the comets mass based on Rosetta orbit determination?

If you agree we have some basis for further discussion. jt, Indagator, the man, tusenfem, you know the real brains, feel free to pitch in.

For those who would like to find this paper (as Sol usually cannot be bothered to actually give the link to papers): it is here (direct pdf download). It is a conference paper from 2015 for the "25th international symposium on space flight dynamics".

It is probably the state of the art with respect to Rosetta, but lots of math, so I am not sure if it is up Sol's alley.
 
ORBIT DETERMINATION OF ROSETTA AROUND COMET 67P/CHURYUMOV-GERASIMENKO Bernard Godard(1), Frank Budnik(2), Pablo Mu˜noz(3), Trevor Morley(1), and Vishnu Janarthanan(4)

jd116, would the above paper be a fair call on the mainstreams modelling for the comets mass based on Rosetta orbit determination?

If you agree we have some basis for further discussion. jt, Indagator, the man, tusenfem, you know the real brains, feel free to pitch in.

Of course it is accurate. The spacecraft was successfully navigated around the comet for two years using the measured density, and therefore gravity. There is no way around that for EU wooists. If you think there is, then show us, numerically, how it is possible to keep a spacecraft in orbit using the wrong measurements. Cut the crap, and show us the science.
 
Errrrm, yes! How are you accelerating the solar wind, dear? Where are the neutrinos coming from? What stops the Sun from neutralising rather quickly? And various other objections based on actual science, as opposed to the crap talked by idiots like Scott and Thornhill. Yip?
What is your scientific level, dear? Bachelors? PhD? What in? Clue us in, and then we can talk woo, yes? (please, ffs, do not say you are a ^&*^£$% electrical engineer; that will not go well!).

"How are you accelerating the solar wind, dear?"

Are you serious?
This is a major win for the EU model.
From: en wikipedia org/wiki/Solar_wind#Acceleration

The Sun's corona, or extended outer layer, is a region of plasma that is heated to over a million kelvin. As a result of thermal collisions, the particles within the inner corona have a range and distribution of speeds described by a Maxwellian distribution. The mean velocity of these particles is about 145 km/s, which is well below the solar escape velocity of 618 km/s. However, a few of the particles achieve energies sufficient to reach the terminal velocity of 400 km/s, which allows them to feed the solar wind. At the same temperature, electrons, due to their much smaller mass, reach escape velocity and build up an electric field that further accelerates ions away from the Sun.[26]

The thermal model cannot account for the acceleration.

As I said, I am open minded, and I check everything. This acceleration is an EU win. I do not care about any side here. I do not have a list of all the discrepancies between the models. I just know some of them.

Therefore I cannot comment on neutrinos. I have no clue about them.

I guess the Sun is not going to neutralize because as it is mention in the Wiki quote, electrons are faster, they have different 'fall' trajectory than heavier and slower protons. They have different geodesic. The electrons 'stay in the orbit' and protons fall down.
There is an electron layer around the Earth as well. The Earth is positively charged compare to that layer and the outer space. It is not neutralizing as well, so why would the Sun neutralized?

I have to admit objectively that EU model is correct about some stuff.
Is there any other explanation for the solar wind acceleration that is not electric? I know some bits and pieces and I might have missed something here. Please, show me other explanation.
 
As I said, I am open minded, and I check everything. This acceleration is an EU win. I do not care about any side here. I do not have a list of all the discrepancies between the models. I just know some of them.

<snip>

I have to admit objectively that EU model is correct about some stuff.
Is there any other explanation for the solar wind acceleration that is not electric? I know some bits and pieces and I might have missed something here. Please, show me other explanation.

One reason why the SW cannot be accelerated "electrically" is that it is neutral, you cannot accelerated electrons and ions in the same direction with an electric field. I am skeptical of the last sentence.

Looking at the book byLamers & Cassinelli (Introduction to stellar winds) you get large sum up of possible drivers of winds:

  • Isothermal winds
  • Non-isothermal winds
  • Coronal winds
  • Sound wave driven winds
  • Dust driven winds
  • Line driven winds
  • (Magnetic rotator theory)
  • Alfven wave driven winds

So, don't go for Wiki, the acceleration section is highly insufficient.
 
Last edited:
This acceleration is an EU win. I do not care about any side here. I do not have a list of all the discrepancies between the models. I just know some of them.

Umm, no, it isn't. If you checked, then you'll find that in the ES model the Sun is positively charged. How are electrons and ions both moving AWAY from the Sun at the same velocity? According to Scott's daft idea, the solar wind is composed only of positive ions. His knowledge of astrophysics is minimal to say the least! A former JPL astrophysicist will explain far better than I can:

http://www.tim-thompson.com/electric-sun.html#acceleration
 
I know you’re new to this thread, so some relevant background:

The main focus of this thread is the ELECTRIC COMET model. A key part of that is the Electric Sun idea. Proponents of both, per Chunderbolts, believe that SAFIRE is a valid scientific test of those ideas.

Hence my questions.

If you do not intend to discuss SAFIRE in this context, please say so.

I am interested to discuss SAFIRE. Especially double layers, composition, motion of ions in the double layers, what types of plasma regimes SAFIRE gets, ...
 
Of course it is accurate. The spacecraft was successfully navigated around the comet for two years using the measured density, and therefore gravity. There is no way around that for EU wooists. If you think there is, then show us, numerically, how it is possible to keep a spacecraft in orbit using the wrong measurements. Cut the crap, and show us the science.

Fig. 2. The main forces acting on the spacecraft are the comet gravity which is almost radial, the Sun third-body gravity, the Solar Radiation Pressure (SRP) which points away from the Sun and the drag force due to the coma.

Coulomb’s law Needs to be added as both objects are charged!! :D

The electrostatic force is variable but constant.

The slight but constant repelling force is interpreted as less mass.

Coulomb’s law is NOT taken into account, though it could be modeled as the non-gravitational force.

Toms simplistic calculation had the nucleus totally discharging and the potential difference becoming 0.

Seems this is not the case, jd116. :D see the answer Indagator gives in the question I put to him above.
 
Last edited:
One reason why the SW cannot be accelerated "electrically" is that it is neutral, you cannot accelerated electrons and ions in the same direction with an electric field. I am skeptical of the last sentence.

Looking at the book byLamers & Cassinelli (Introduction to stellar winds) you get large sum up of possible drivers of winds:

  • Isothermal winds
  • Non-isothermal winds
  • Coronal winds
  • Sound wave driven winds
  • Dust driven winds
  • Line driven winds
  • (Magnetic rotator theory)
  • Alfven wave driven winds

So, don't go for Wiki, the acceleration section is highly insufficient.

Except at a comet! :D
 
Coulomb’s law is NOT taken into account, though it could be modeled as the non-gravitational force.

Why would it be? The charges are insignificant, and have no effect. Unless you'd like to put these charges into an equation, instead of misunderstanding what you quote, for once.

Toms simplistic calculation had the nucleus totally discharging and the potential difference becoming 0.

Nope, that is just you failing to understand maths again. How long it takes to discharge is irrelevant. You need 100+ gigavolts on the nucleus, and it isn't there. End of.
 
Last edited:
Umm, no, it isn't. If you checked, then you'll find that in the ES model the Sun is positively charged. How are electrons and ions both moving AWAY from the Sun at the same velocity? According to Scott's daft idea, the solar wind is composed only of positive ions. His knowledge of astrophysics is minimal to say the least! A former JPL astrophysicist will explain far better than I can:

This is from your link:
The specific mechanism for heating the corona indeed remains unknown.
...
So the coronal heating mechanism is the same thing as the accelerating mechanism for solar wind ions.

This is from Wiki:
While early models of the solar wind relied primarily on thermal energy to accelerate the material, by the 1960s it was clear that thermal acceleration alone cannot account for the high speed of solar wind.

Your source does not explain the acceleration at all. What are you talking about?

When the electrons separate from the proton (H) then the electrons are so fast that they do not need any acceleration. They have escape velocity already. Statistically one half of them would fly away on its own and they are being slowed down by the position ions on their 'flying away'.
That's how I see it. I might be wrong. :)
No big deal.
 
When the electrons separate from the proton (H) then the electrons are so fast that they do not need any acceleration. They have escape velocity already. Statistically one half of them would fly away on its own and they are being slowed down by the position ions on their 'flying away'.
That's how I see it. I might be wrong.

You are. The solar wind is charge neutral. For every H+ there is an electron. For heavier ions, such as O6+, there are the requisite number of electrons to balance that charge. You need all the electrons heading out. And what is accelerating the ions? An electric field? How is it accelerating the ions, and having no effect on the oppositely charged electrons? Sorry, been there, done that. This electric sun nonsense has been debunked to hell and back, here and elsewhere, for years. It is a very silly idea, with zero credible science to back it up, and not a jot of evidence.
 
You're new here, SDG, so you probably are unaware ...
"How are you accelerating the solar wind, dear?"

Are you serious?
This is a major win for the EU model.
From: en wikipedia org/wiki/Solar_wind#Acceleration



The thermal model cannot account for the acceleration.

As I said, I am open minded, and I check everything. This acceleration is an EU win. I do not care about any side here. I do not have a list of all the discrepancies between the models. I just know some of them.

Therefore I cannot comment on neutrinos. I have no clue about them.

I guess the Sun is not going to neutralize because as it is mention in the Wiki quote, electrons are faster, they have different 'fall' trajectory than heavier and slower protons. They have different geodesic. The electrons 'stay in the orbit' and protons fall down.
There is an electron layer around the Earth as well. The Earth is positively charged compare to that layer and the outer space. It is not neutralizing as well, so why would the Sun neutralized?

I have to admit objectively that EU model is correct about some stuff.
Is there any other explanation for the solar wind acceleration that is not electric? I know some bits and pieces and I might have missed something here. Please, show me other explanation.
... that this is not appropriate for this thread. There are several other - very long! - threads here in ISF which are more appropriate. For example, Electric universe theories here.

I think you'll find that this topic - the extent to which the EU/ES can, objectively and in an independently verifiable way - account for the solar wind acceleration has been extensively discussed, and that EU/ES proponents came up short.

SDG said:
I am interested to discuss SAFIRE. Especially double layers, composition, motion of ions in the double layers, what types of plasma regimes SAFIRE gets, ...
Thanks for the response.

I think that unless you wish to restrict your scope to the extent to which SAFIRE is a valid scientific test of "the Electric Sun", this thread is definitely not for you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom