Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
^^^Indagator



Why?

Which bit specifically is impossible?
That comets are "solid rock"?

(there's more of course ...)

Are you Tom Bridgeman ????

'cos



Have yo been keeping up at all Indagator???

No one here is will to answer this because if they do truthful it's and of thread!

Will you have a go at answering Tom's persistent questions?

This has DIRECT bearing on the question you've asked me in the above post. Though we can save ourselves a whole heap of time you answer these questions by Tom Bridgeman, 'cos like I said they sound very familiar!
You have it backwards, as usual.

This thread is about the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory).

So far, you are the only one who claims to have any understanding of the ELECTRIC COMET model. Therefore it is only you who can truly answer such questions.

Don't you feel, um, strange that in nine years you have not been able to defend the very thing you came here to promote?
 
ORBIT DETERMINATION OF ROSETTA AROUND COMET 67P/CHURYUMOV-GERASIMENKO Bernard Godard(1), Frank Budnik(2), Pablo Mu˜noz(3), Trevor Morley(1), and Vishnu Janarthanan(4)

jd116, would the above paper be a fair call on the mainstreams modelling for the comets mass based on Rosetta orbit determination?

If you agree we have some basis for further discussion. jt, Indagator, the man, tusenfem, you know the real brains, feel free to pitch in.
When, may I be so bold as to ask, will we see something equivalent from you, Sol88?

You know, something which incorporates Coulomb's law, and is based on the ELECTRIC COMET model?
 
So the solar plasma is back to quasi neutral by 1500km from the nucleus then?

This is what J.Deca's paper show yeah?

And since it's your pleasure to expand on J.Deca's papers contents.

  1. What maintains this charge separation?
  2. What causes the charges to seperate?

as asked by Tom Bridgeman and other smart cookies here in this thread, though I note no one has the cojones to answer, can you Indagator

The charge separation described by Deca causes an electric field centred on the nucleus that Behar et al expanded on

Perhaps you cold expand on this as well?

are you able to expand on the bolded statement?
When, may I be so bold as to ask, will we see something from you, Sol88, on what relevance this has to the ELECTRIC COMET model?

And by "relevance" I don't mean random strings of words that are equivalent to the INVISIBLE PINK UNICORN model, I mean quantitative analyses.

Do you have the cojones to answer?
 
Coulomb’s law Needs to be added as both objects are charged!! :D
Cool! :)

When, may I be so bold as to ask, will you have the cojones to do the work to incorporate Coulomb's law, and post estimates of q1q2 consistent with all relevant data and a density consistent with that of "rock"? Not just for 67P.

The electrostatic force is variable but constant.

The slight but constant repelling force is interpreted as less mass.

Coulomb’s law is NOT taken into account, though it could be modeled as the non-gravitational force.

Toms simplistic calculation had the nucleus totally discharging and the potential difference becoming 0.

Seems this is not the case, jd116. :D see the answer Indagator gives in the question I put to him above.
Cool! :)

When, may I be so bold as to ask, will you have the cojones to do the work to incorporate Coulomb's law, and post estimates of q1q2 consistent with all relevant data and a density consistent with that of "rock"? Not just for 67P.
 
You’d be surprised at what they have in common!

So, how are those numbers coming?
What is the necessary charge of the comet to maintain Rosetta in orbit?
How does the charge of the comet change from negative to positive (or the other way around) when Rosetta's potential changes from positive to negative (or the other way around) and is this not in contradiction with the EC idea that the comet is constantly "in equilibrium with the solar wind electric field"?
Are your buddies at thunder not helping you to give you the numbers and the math?
 
You’d be surprised at what they have in common!
They are both composed of baryonic matter?

They both have a lot of hydrogen?

They both have observational characteristics which are wildly inconsistent with Electric Universe fantasies?

That Sol88 thinks - without anything substantive to back his thinking up - that both are "electric"?
 
Is it valid for for J.Deca’s model from his paper?
And this is relevant to the ELECTRIC COMET model how, specifically?

Please Sol88, no more handwaving non-responses, no more the equivalent of INVISIBLE PINK UNICORN models.

Please reply with something scientific, something quantitative, and something directly relevant to the ELECTRIC COMET model.
 
<snip>

Are your buddies at thunder not helping you to give you the numbers and the math?
There's a terrific post by ben_m, somewhere in some EU thread here at ISF (sadly, I couldn't find it).

It imagines a numerate EU acolyte sitting down to do a simple calculation, not unlike applying Coulomb's law to the observed motion of Rosetta in its orbit around 67P. The acolyte more or less gets it right ... but discovers that the answer is so dramatically different from what they believed (EU nonsense) that they are shocked! Rather than admit this glaring inconsistency, they chose to keep quiet.

It's possible that there are one or two people over at Chunderbolts who can "do the math(s)", and the reason they haven't helped Sol88 out is that they know they'll destroy his fervently held belief in the ELECTRIC COMET model.

This also might explain why the ELECTRIC COMET model thread there is so quiet ...
 
So, how are those numbers coming?
What is the necessary charge of the comet to maintain Rosetta in orbit?
How does the charge of the comet change from negative to positive (or the other way around) when Rosetta's potential changes from positive to negative (or the other way around) and is this not in contradiction with the EC idea that the comet is constantly "in equilibrium with the solar wind electric field"?
Are your buddies at thunder not helping you to give you the numbers and the math?

It’s NOT maintaining Rosetta’s orbit, it’s fooling it into thinking there is less mass because of the repelling force plug those numbers in so the flight controllers can adjust Rosetta’s orbits.

ʻOumuamua and it’s non gravitational acceleration will be found to be the same non modeled force.
 
Last edited:
And this is relevant to the ELECTRIC COMET model how, specifically?

Please Sol88, no more handwaving non-responses, no more the equivalent of INVISIBLE PINK UNICORN models.

Please reply with something scientific, something quantitative, and something directly relevant to the ELECTRIC COMET model.

Ok ok then from a brand new mainstream paper with the FIRST ever use of the term polarisation electric field.

The third term, the ambipolar electric field E ambipolar , is expected to be signicant close to the nucleus. At zero order, this electric eld points radially outward from the nucleus.

What’s a Another effect arising from the ambipolar term is a polarisation electric field due to the different motion of the cometary new-born electrons and ions. The gyroradius of the cometary ions can be much larger than the interaction region, itself larger than the cometary electron gyroradius, which induces a charge separation, and in turn a polarisation electric field. This electric field contribution is explored in the analytical work of Nilsson et al. (2018), and results in one additional acceleration of the cometary ions with an anti-sunward component.
The root of a comet tail –Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko E. Behar

Do you know what this term means wrt a comet nucleus?

And one wonders how significant this electric field close to the nucleus actually is? :D would’d you hazard a guess jt? ELECTRIC COMET REQUIRES this electric field now confirmed by the mainstream. I say there double layers though, as you probably know.

Reminds of the same argument someone had on here, on the electrons and ions EVENTUALLY NEUTRALISING! somewhere! :thumbsup:
 
It’s NOT maintaining Rosetta’s orbit, it’s fooling it into thinking there is less mass because of the repelling force plug those numbers in so the flight controllers can adjust Rosetta’s orbits.

And what is the required charge on the comet? Give us the numbers.
 
It’s NOT maintaining Rosetta’s orbit, it’s fooling it into thinking there is less mass because of the repelling force plug those numbers in so the flight controllers can adjust Rosetta’s orbits.

Oh, I see, now it is only "disturbances" on the orbit of Rosetta.
 
Ok ok then from a brand new mainstream paper with the FIRST ever use of the term polarisation electric field.

The root of a comet tail –Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko E. Behar

Do you know what this term means wrt a comet nucleus?

It means NOTHING with respect to the nucleus, it is a plasma phenomenon. Like is stated in the text that you quoted.
Newly ionized gas splits in a heavy positive ion and a light negative electron. These start to gyrate around the magnetic field, both moving in different directions for obvious reasons. The ion's gyro radius is much larger than that of the electron, thereby this newly ionized gas particle creates a polarization electric field over a scale of the ion gyro radius. You could have discovered this if you had actually taken a book in your hands and looked it up, e.g. in Baumjohann & Treumann or in Kivelson & Russell or in Russell, Luhmann & Strangeway.

And one wonders how significant this electric field close to the nucleus actually is? :D would’d you hazard a guess jt? ELECTRIC COMET REQUIRES this electric field now confirmed by the mainstream. I say there double layers though, as you probably know.

Well, probably on the same scale as the other electric fields in that paper, but we will have to wait for Hans Nilsson's paper, which I have not seen yet.

Reminds of the same argument someone had on here, on the electrons and ions EVENTUALLY NEUTRALISING! somewhere!

Yeah, we know how good you are with looking at data.
 
Why would it be? The charges are insignificant, and have no effect. Unless you'd like to put these charges into an equation, instead of misunderstanding what you quote, for once.



Nope, that is just you failing to understand maths again. How long it takes to discharge is irrelevant. You need 100+ gigavolts on the nucleus, and it isn't there. End of.
jd, with respect, I think you are approaching this in a sub-optimal manner.

Not that what you post is necessarily incorrect, but it’s not directly pertinent.

As I am like a broken record in saying, this thread is about the ELECTRIC COMET model. And Sol88 is the only one posting here who really knows what that is.

So far, he has been extraordinarily reluctant to discuss anything scientific, with respect to the ELECTRIC COMET model, preferring all manner of diversions, obfuscation, and nonsense.

It’s almost as if he lacks the cojones to directly address his beloved ELECTRIC COMET model, perhaps for fear that he will discover for himself that it’s nothing more than malarkey.

So why not constantly ask him to do some real science? Download data, crunch numbers, build quantitative models, etc? And stop taking the bait he so often dangles.
 
Ok ok then from a brand new mainstream paper with the FIRST ever use of the term polarisation electric field.



The root of a comet tail –Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko E. Behar

Do you know what this term means wrt a comet nucleus?

And one wonders how significant this electric field close to the nucleus actually is? :D would’d you hazard a guess jt? ELECTRIC COMET REQUIRES this electric field now confirmed by the mainstream. I say there double layers though, as you probably know.

Reminds of the same argument someone had on here, on the electrons and ions EVENTUALLY NEUTRALISING! somewhere! :thumbsup:
So, once again, a diversion, a refusal to do some actual science? Why am I not surprised? :rolleyes:

The ELECTRIC COMET model requires that comets are solid “rock”, with densities at least four times greater than what has been observed, in several comets (not just 67P).

If you, Sol88, cannot show - with quantitative analyses using actual data - that the observed motion of various probes (not just Rosetta) is consistent with comets having densities consistent with sold “rock”, then the ELECTRIC COMET model has no legs. And all your quote mining will be for naught; none of the papers you cite will be worth anything at all (with respect to your beloved ELECTRIC COMET model).
 
It’s NOT maintaining Rosetta’s orbit, it’s fooling it into thinking there is less mass because of the repelling force plug those numbers in so the flight controllers can adjust Rosetta’s orbits.

ʻOumuamua and it’s non gravitational acceleration will be found to be the same non modeled force.
No, Sol88, you are thoroughly mistaken.

This has nothing to do with the ELECTRIC COMET model; it’s an INVISIBLE PINK UNICORN effect.

But hey, I’m totally open to being shown to be wrong.

Download the data, build a quantitative model, and show us that the ELECTRIC COMET model is consistent with all relevant data.

You have the condones to do that, don’t you?
 
It imagines a numerate EU acolyte sitting down to do a simple calculation, not unlike applying Coulomb's law to the observed motion of Rosetta in its orbit around 67P. The acolyte more or less gets it right ... but discovers that the answer is so dramatically different from what they believed (EU nonsense) that they are shocked! Rather than admit this glaring inconsistency, they chose to keep quiet.


This is exactly why Sol goes into his shuck and jive when challenged to do a simple BOTE calculation. He knows it will end in disaster. Anti-science woomongers flee math like Superman does kryptonite.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom