Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
jd, with respect, I think you are approaching this in a sub-optimal manner.

Not that what you post is necessarily incorrect, but it’s not directly pertinent.

As I am like a broken record in saying, this thread is about the ELECTRIC COMET model. And Sol88 is the only one posting here who really knows what that is.

So far, he has been extraordinarily reluctant to discuss anything scientific, with respect to the ELECTRIC COMET model, preferring all manner of diversions, obfuscation, and nonsense.

It’s almost as if he lacks the cojones to directly address his beloved ELECTRIC COMET model, perhaps for fear that he will discover for himself that it’s nothing more than malarkey.

So why not constantly ask him to do some real science? Download data, crunch numbers, build quantitative models, etc? And stop taking the bait he so often dangles.


^^^^This, in spades. Sol's game is the false dilemma. If he can find a misplaced comma in a mainstream paper, the EC has to be correct :rolleyes: The last thing he wants to discuss is the EC theory, because it is nonexistent. Let’s not let him change the topic; it’s his (transparent) attempt to shift the burden of proof.
 
One reason why the SW cannot be accelerated "electrically" is that it is neutral, you cannot accelerated electrons and ions in the same direction with an electric field. I am skeptical of the last sentence.

Looking at the book byLamers & Cassinelli (Introduction to stellar winds) you get large sum up of possible drivers of winds:

  • Isothermal winds
  • Non-isothermal winds
  • Coronal winds
  • Sound wave driven winds
  • Dust driven winds
  • Line driven winds
  • (Magnetic rotator theory)
  • Alfven wave driven winds

So, don't go for Wiki, the acceleration section is highly insufficient.

Thank you, I'll do more reading.

Having said that, one of the considered causes of the acceleration is a surface magnetic field.
https://arxiv.org/abs/1709.07800

Where is the magnetic field coming from?
Is it moving charges generating the magnetic field?
It is important to realize we deal with the same "coin that has two sides".

The double layers, moving charges, ... are important to study in order to understand the plasma behavior in the Sun. It appears to me that is what SAFIRE is doing.
 
goodness, what is it with ec/es/eu proponents and double layers?
do they get a lollypop every time they say the word?
 
goodness, what is it with ec/es/eu proponents and double layers?
do they get a lollypop every time they say the word?

I am trying to sort lots of information. Please, tell me, what is wrong with the double layers?
 
I am trying to sort lots of information. Please, tell me, what is wrong with the double layers?

nothing wrong with them, i wrote my phd thesis about them
it's just that they pop up randomly in sentences like yours:

"The double layers, moving charges, ... are important to study in order to understand the plasma behavior in the Sun."

double layers may be there, e.g. in coronal loops, but i doubt they are important to understand the plasma behaviour of the sun.

it is plasma, convective in one shell, where seed magnetic field loops are stretched and folded by the alpha-omega dynamo, creating the strong magnetic fields we see on the sun.
those seed fields are created by the random motion of the ions and electrons, and some have no time to dissipate, before they get amplified by the dynamo action.

i have no idea, though, what this coin is with two sides

eta:
magnetic activity isone of the processes to heat the corona, i did not list that. coronal heating and sw acceleration are strongly created topics. apparently the author's field of research is magnetic reconnection for coronal heating, and that colours her paper, which is fine, but here are many processes to heat the corona.
 
Last edited:
The double layers, moving charges, ... are important to study in order to understand the plasma behavior in the Sun. It appears to me that is what SAFIRE is doing.


You do understand that the heat of the Sun is not generated by electricity or plasma, right?
 
nothing wrong with them, i wrote my phd thesis about them
it's just that they pop up randomly in sentences like yours:

"The double layers, moving charges, ... are important to study in order to understand the plasma behavior in the Sun."

double layers may be there, e.g. in coronal loops, but i doubt they are important to understand the plasma behaviour of the sun.

it is plasma, convective in one shell, where seed magnetic field loops are stretched and folded by the alpha-omega dynamo, creating the strong magnetic fields we see on the sun.
those seed fields are created by the random motion of the ions and electrons, and some have no time to dissipate, before they get amplified by the dynamo action.

i have no idea, though, what this coin is with two sides

eta:
magnetic activity isone of the processes to heat the corona, i did not list that. coronal heating and sw acceleration are strongly created topics. apparently the author's field of research is magnetic reconnection for coronal heating, and that colours her paper, which is fine, but here are many processes to heat the corona.
I imagine we deal with the electromagnetic effects here.
Moving charges in the electric field will generate magnetic field.
Magnetic field will cause the charges to move, separate and to 'feed' the electric field.

What I have in mind is that when the H looses the electron then proton will 'fall' differently than electron. They have different velocities and therefore they have different geodesics. This simple effect of different geodesics might be one of the contributing factors to creation of the electric and magnetic fields.

This last paragraph is my view/observation. This is not part of any EU model as far as I know. I do not think that what I proposed can be found in any EU literature.
Nevertheless it points to the electromagnetism as the primary cause of the acceleration.
 
I imagine we deal with the electromagnetic effects here.
Moving charges in the electric field will generate magnetic field.
Magnetic field will cause the charges to move, separate and to 'feed' the electric field.

What I have in mind is that when the H looses the electron then proton will 'fall' differently than electron. They have different velocities and therefore they have different geodesics. This simple effect of different geodesics might be one of the contributing factors to creation of the electric and magnetic fields.

This last paragraph is my view/observation. This is not part of any EU model as far as I know. I do not think that what I proposed can be found in any EU literature.
Nevertheless it points to the electromagnetism as the primary cause of the acceleration.
That there will, in general, be charge separation in a plasma in the (approximately spherical) gravitational field of a star, planet, or moon has been known since ~the 1920s (Tom Bridgman, I think, wrote several blog posts on this). However, it is too small an effect to be relevant for the Sun’s solar wind (it may be significant in neutron stars, or even white dwarfs, I simply do not know).

More generally, I think you’d be better off discussing this in the Cosmoquest Forum than here.

Also, you might consider learning more about plasma physics, solar astrophysics, etc, before posting your own views.
 
This is a major win for the EU model.
That is one of many EU lies, SDG. The electric sun cannot explain the acceleration of the solar wind because it does not describe any real star.

The electric sun is insane because it results in the Sun being a white dwarf.
This is the Sun which will probably end up as a white dwarf in about 5 billion years. This is a white dwarf. They are not the same.

Real science can explain acceleration of the solar wind. It has a problem with the high speed component.

Do not be so open-minded that your brain falls out of your head :D!
Learn about the "god of the gaps" argument (a gap in knowledge does not allow anything to be inserted).
Learn about the logical fallacy of false dichotomy (evidence against theory A is not evidence for theory B unless these are the only 2 possible theories).
Learn about astronomy.
Realize that physics cranks exist. If you talk to EU people ask for EU specific papers published in appropriate, peer-reviewed journals. Do not accept any paper that does not explicitly mention EU. You will learn that there are only a handful of electric sun papers by Donald Scott - a retired electric engineer.
 
Therefore I cannot comment on neutrinos. I have no clue about them.
Solar neutrinos are easy to understand. Fusion produces electron neutrinos. We detect those electron neutrinos and the other 2 types of neutrinos (neutrino oscillation) from the Sun in amounts that match the amount of fusion needed to power the Sun. Thus fusion must power the Sun.

Any stable ball of plasma like the Sun has to have conditions that allow fusion at their core. Thus that fusion must be at the core of the Sun.

Fusion also produces gamma rays. One of the reasons that electric sun is insanely bad is that its fusion in the photosphere fires the Earth with gamma rays.
 
This is from your link:
The coronal heating problem has valid physical explanations.

On the "Electric Sun" Hypothesis
This one is for the most part taken care of in the section above. The temperature of the corona, after all, is just the kinetic energy of corona particles translated into temperature units. So the coronal heating mechanism is the same thing as the accelerating mechanism for solar wind ions. However, I will make a slight departure here and consider Scott's comments, allegedly in favor of the electric sun hypothesis.

Begin Quote
Any student of physics who has heard of electric charge and electric fields, knows that the way to get electrically charged particles to accelerate is to apply an electric field to them. The acceleration of the positively charged solar "wind" particles is a purely electrical phenomenon. It is accurately predicted by the electric sun model.
End Quote

The solar wind is not made of "positive ions". It is made of "positive ions" (mostly protons), and negative ions (mostly electrons). The electric sun model not only fails to explain why there are negative electrons in the solar wind, it actually predicts that the positively charged sun should attract electrons, not repel them. Far from being a "prediction" of the electric sun model, the solar wind in fact is a contradiction of the electric sun model and serves to falsify the hypothesis.

It is also worth noting that, according to Maxwell's equations, a time variable magnetic field will generate an electric field, which will accelerate a charged particle. This is a point which the proponents of the electric sun have totally overlooked, never mentioned, and essentially denied, by insisting that only static electric fields will do.

Source: Try out the ACE Real Time Solar Wind Page, and see what the solar wind is doing now (whenever "now" is).
Tim Thompson is pointing out that an electrical engineer writing about the solar wind does not know about electromagnetism or the solar wind.
A positively charged Sun repels positive ions and attract electrons!
 
An insane "RSI experiment" lie to derail from his electric comet insanity

Density and porosity are in error because of the RSI experiment.
24 July 2018: An insane "RSI experiment" lie to derail from his electric comet insanity.

RSI
RSI (Radio Science Investigation). Frequency shifts in the spacecraft's radio signals will be used to measure the mass and gravity of the comet nucleus in order to deduce its density and internal structure, to define the comet's orbit, and to study its inner coma. RSI has already determined the mass and density of the asteroid Lutetia during the flyby in 2010, and studied the solar corona during the periods when the spacecraft, as seen from Earth, was passing behind the Sun (in 2006 and 2010).

It was RSI that measured the mass of 67P which gave a density of 0.533 ± 0.006 g/cc.

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic. Stupidly thinks that a ambipolar electric field is a double layer.
 
A "comet is NOT rock..." lie to detail from his electric comet insanity.

You think the comet is NOT rock because of the RSI experiment.
24 July 2018: A "comet is NOT rock because of the RSI experiment" lie to detail from his electric comet insanity.

Rational, knowledgeable people know that the mass and so density of comet 67P has been measured by at least 2 independent means. Its orbit gave its mass. Gravitational effects on Rosetta gave its mass. Both measurement give a density agreeing with each other and less than that of water. Not sure if the other common method of measuring mass from changes in orbit from outgassing has been applied to 67P.

Rational, knowledgeable people know that 67P is not the only comet that exists :jaw-dropp! The average density of many comets measured by the above methods (plus the trajectory of Deep Impact ejecta on Tempel 1) is ~0.6 g/cc.

Nothing to do with:
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic. Stupidly thinks that a ambipolar electric field is a double layer.
 
Last edited:
Lies about Tom Bridgman's questions for electric comet proponents

...Why do I have to try and justify Tom Bridgemans misunderstandings?
24 July 2018: Lies about Tom Bridgman's questions for electric comet proponents.

The questions are for him or his Thunderbolt cult prophets to answer.
There is no question about his latest "polarisation electric field" delusions.

The only understanding needed is that the electric comet insanity has a charged comet. The questions are about that charge. If it is zero then we have a literally insane lie that the mass of 67P has been measured wrongly because of a charge on the comet. Otherwise electric comet proponents have to produce evidence that comets are charged to the extent needs and the sign needed to turn a density of ~3.0 g/cc into 0.533 ± 0.006 g/cm3.

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic. Stupidly thinks that a ambipolar electric field is a double layer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom