Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jean Tate


Density and porosity are in error because of the RSI experiment.

Errrr, no. For anybody with an IQ above that of something that is not dead, let us clear this up for the thickos;
It is irrelevant. burkes, what the RSI measured. Understand? Bit thick, aren't we? The spacecraft (Rosetta, dears) orbited the comet for two years, morons. Correct? How did the people back in Europe know how to perform these orbits? Many of them bound orbits? How thick do you need to be to not be able to figure that out?
Seriously, go away Sol; you are just too stupid to have any sort of conversation with.
 
Because I say the come nucleus is rock and the intense electric fields have more of and influence here than any sublimation or radiation pressure!

As i’ve stated for quite some time now.

Sol, no offence, but you are scientifically illiterate. Correct? So, why should we give a Buckley's about what you think? Be honest; you are a bit stupid, yes? Science really isn't your thing. Stick to.............. whatever it is you do, yes? Just leave science alone, because it is well beyond you, dear. As shown.
 
No, you burke! The bloody spacecraft performed innumerable bound orbits around the comet, you loon. If the gravity wasn't what was measured, you burke, then the spacecraft would have hit the comet. Yes?
Jeez, how thick does one need to be to live in Sol's world? Science really isn't your thing, is it Sol? Lay off it, dear. Lol.

What we've got here is failure to communicate

You are interpreting the LACK of gravity or mass and dividing that “calculated’
mass by the physical size of the nucleus and viola!

Some density figure that is absolutely snookering you on a whole heap of other dirsnowball assumptions! :blush:

Now the electric comet has postulated that since comet nuclei are a polarised dialectric immersing within a complicated series of electric fields, Tom Bridgman simplistic calculation are @#$%!

Can you answer Tom Bridgemans quesion?

2. How long would it take for the charge on the nucleus to neutralize?

3.Now how long will it take for the nucleus to neutralize charge?

With the data and modeling from these papers?

Cometary ion dynamics observed in the close vicinity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko during the intermediate activity period

Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

The root of a comet tail –Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko





I don’t have the maths skills to PROVE it to you but I can PROVE Tom was wrong in his assumptions from the LATEST release of papers.

You should note however that NO comprehensive modeling of the electrons has taken place only the protons and ions.

Who ever is the first to do this....:eek:

Pesky electrons...:blush:
 
Last edited:
Sol, no offence, but you are scientifically illiterate. Correct? So, why should we give a Buckley's about what you think? Be honest; you are a bit stupid, yes? Science really isn't your thing. Stick to.............. whatever it is you do, yes? Just leave science alone, because it is well beyond you, dear. As shown.

Let’s see how your science is then jd116? :D

Can you answer your hero Tom Bridgeman, the saviour of the dirtysnowball model, question as brought to your attention in the above post?

We can’t really move forward until we come to some agreement on Tom Bridgeman’s mis guided assertions.
 
Last edited:
I don’t have the maths skills to PROVE it to you but I can PROVE Tom was wrong in his assumptions from the LATEST release of papers.

Oh Jesus. Seriously? You don't even know which equation to use, you waster! How can you prove anyone wrong, you eejit?
 
Let’s see how your science is then jd116? :D

Can you answer your hero Tom Bridgeman, the saviour of the dirtysnowball model, question as brought to your attention in the above post?

We can’t really move forward until we come to some agreement on Tom Bridgeman’s mis guided assertions.

Yep, dear, Bridgman and Harvey Rutt got it right. And you are clueless. Correct? Go back to primary school Sol. Assuming you ever attended one. Stop pretending that you understand things that are obviously well beyond you. OK?
 
Last edited:
COME ON SOL! Which equation are you using, dear? Which figures are you plugging in? Let's see it, yes? Quit the crap, and show us the money, yes? Or shut up.
 
We can’t really move forward until we come to some agreement on Tom Bridgeman’s mis guided assertions.

You haven't got the faintest clue what Tom was talking about, nor the equations he used. As I've already mentioned, you are scientifically illiterate. So..... a fairly pointless conversation, yes? Learn first grade maths, and we can perhaps take it from there.......
 
^^^^Dahell is that about? Seriously? Give it up, Sol, you're a loon.

And of course there's the persistent question about Electric Universe models that remain unanswered:

How would/could a net charge on the comet nucleus be maintained in interplanetary plasma?

Where's the battery or generator that maintains the potential between the comet nucleus and the solar wind?
LINK

Since the question now seems answered and since you are using this equation for your argument, dontcha think we should clear this up first? Might help you with your complete lack of vision regarding Rosetta, bound orbits and navigation issues and charges.

Can’t or won’t jd116? :D
 
Last edited:
http://dealingwithcreationisminastronomy.blogspot.com/search?q=Electric+comet

And of course there's the persistent question about Electric Universe models that remain unanswered:

How would/could a net charge on the comet nucleus be maintained in interplanetary plasma?
Where's the battery or generator that maintains the potential between the comet nucleus and the solar wind?

So the persistent question really now needs to be, is how much charge on the surface of the nucleus is inducuced via the polarisation electric field?

Why do I have to try and justify Tom Bridgemans misunderstandings?

Nothing wrong with his maths!
 
So Tom was WRONG in his assumptions. Now someone here willing to have another crack at his incorrect calculations?

Tom was in so far "wrong" that he took the assumptions of the EC and worked with it.
Now you complain about the fact that real scientists have shown that those EC assumptions most likely will not hold because of several effects, e.g. deflection of the solar wind, etc.
So, basically EC has a problem, because their assumptions are incorrect.
And the fact that no one wants to help you with the math, that's your problem. Apparently your friends at thunderdolts are not willing or incapable (probably the latter) to help you, and when we do the math for you, you start complaining that we have done it incorrectly.
The only solution here is that you enter university and start taking coursed in math, electrostatics/dynamics, astronomy, plasma physics, etc.
 
Is the nucleus being electricaly polarised via the charge separation maintained by its orbital motion thru the solar plasma flow, tusenfem?

And what if it would? And I am not saying that it does.
When are we going to get some numbers from you, what do you want to achiever? Is it Rosetta kept in orbit by electrostatic force? (then you have a problem with Philae falling perfectly to the nucleus under Newtonian gravity) Or do you want EDM of the surface? (then you have the problem of the RPC measurements not observing any signature that would agree with large electromagnetic discharges)

And by the way, how large is large and how huge is huge in the electric universe, just so us mainsheeple and the lurkers get an idea.
 
- what field aligned current along the tail?

I was hoping you could tell the lurkers about them? LINK

I assume you are talking about the field aligned electron beam in one of the figures. Yes, that can happen, but only when reconnnection is happening in the tail. Unfortunately, the EC/ES/EU community does not believe in magnetic reconnection, so you should forget about these electron beams.

It is also a very old picture, describing the situation around comet 1P/Halley, which absolutely does not hold for 67P, because of the different sized and the different activity levels .
 
Last edited:
Jean Tate

Density and porosity are in error because of the RSI experiment.

You think the comet is NOT rock because of the RSI experiment.

I think the data has been misinterpreted, and seeing how me ‘ol mate Tom Bridgeman, is the only mainstream big banger to have a crack at the calculations and was wrong in his assumptions then I think we are well and truly “in the game”.

Because I say the come nucleus is rock and the intense electric fields have more of and influence here than any sublimation or radiation pressure!

As i’ve stated for quite some time now.

Have you found and analyzed the RSI data that are on PSA?

you have stated a lot for quite some time, and most of is was nonsense
 
Can you answer your hero Tom Bridgeman, the saviour of the dirtysnowball model, question as brought to your attention in the above post?

I do hope that you understand (but I doubt it) that Tom Bridgeman's calculations have absolutely nothing to do whether the comet is a dirty snowball, an asteroid or a Reece's peanutbutter cup.
The calculations are very simple electrostatics, that you might even have done at highschool (assuming you went to one, down-under).
 
Since the question now seems answered and since you are using this equation for your argument, dontcha think we should clear this up first? Might help you with your complete lack of vision regarding Rosetta, bound orbits and navigation issues and charges.

Can’t or won’t jd116?

Where is your 100+ gigavolts on the nucleus to mimic a lower gravity? Show us the detection, show us the maths. Tell us why this wouldn't have torn the comet apart, or Philae, or Rosetta. I don't think you understand Coulomb's law, do you? Show us which figures you are putting into that equation.
 
So the persistent question really now needs to be, is how much charge on the surface of the nucleus is inducuced via the polarisation electric field?

You've been told. You need 100+ gigavolts. Now, where is it?
 
I assume you are talking about the field aligned electron beam in one of the figures. Yes, that can happen, but only when reconnnection is happening in the tail.

but but but.... :blush: :rolleyes:

Reconnection happens (though slightly different in the EU) but it will be found to be a standard KINETIC PLASMA EFFECT !

Electron beams are real, electric fields are real, double layers and KINETIC PLASMA EFFECTS are real!

and that me 'ol mate is an effect of such KINETIC PLASMA EFFECTS! :D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom