Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
A delusion that the words ELECTRIC comet are an answer to physics questions

It wont and DOES NOT neutralise, ...
20 July 2018: A delusion that the words ELECTRIC COMET are an answer to questions asking for numbers, times, coherent explanations bases on physics. :eye-poppi.

If it is "eccentric orbital motion" then where is the calculation using math and physics that it is "eccentric orbital motion"?
 
Last edited:
Well since it's a new term here in this thread and your are more clever than me, perhaps you could tell me and the lurkers here exactly what a polarization electric field is, wrt cometary nuclei and their motion thru the solar wind plasma?

Is a comet a dielectric moving thru the solar wind plasma?

nice try
 
2, 3 & 4 are first grade easy as well.
2. How long would it take for the charge on the nucleus to neutralize?
3. Now how long will it take for the nucleus to neutralize charge?
4. What happens then, and why?

It wont and DOES NOT neutralise, though it tries its damnedest too equalise with the surrounding plasma. It never quite does because of its eccentric orbital motion.

So 2,3 and 4 are moot points for the ELECTRIC COMET

You do realise, I hope, that you have give no answers to the questions?
Just putting down a link to a paper which does not even mention cometary surface charge as an answer to a question about how the comet gets charged seem strange, to say the least.
Thus we shall conclude that EC has no answers (what a surprise).
 

Another effect arising from the ambipolar term is a polarisation electric field due to the different motion of the cometary new-born electrons and ions. The gyroradius of the cometary ions can be much larger than the interaction region, itself larger than the cometary electron gyroradius, which induces a charge separation, and in turn a polarisation electric field. This electric field contribution is explored in the analytical work of Nilsson et al. (2018), and results in one additional acceleration of the cometary ions with an anti-sunward component.
The root of a comet tail –Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

So you won’t or can’t explain the highlighted? :D

I’m sure a large percentage of readers here would unfamiliar with the term in relation to cometary bodies and I thought, stupidly, that you might shed some light.

Rc said he won’t sure the secret handshake with me. :rolleyes:
 
You do realise, I hope, that you have give no answers to the questions?
Just putting down a link to a paper which does not even mention cometary surface charge as an answer to a question about how the comet gets charged seem strange, to say the least.
Thus we shall conclude that EC has no answers (what a surprise).

Sorry I did not realise.

I asked you a question a couple posts back about charge neutralisation and you refused to post your answer to...
Cometary electrons eventually end up neutralizing the solar wind protons, and solar wind electrons eventually neutralize the cometary ions.
J.Decca Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

So how far away from the nucleus does this occur again?

Q 2&3 have the same answer which does affect 4!

The third term, the ambipolar electric field E ambipolar , is expected to be signicant close to the nucleus. At zero order, this electric field points radially outward from the nucleus.
The root of a comet tail –Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko E. Behar

How does this electric field effect Toms assumption and his calculation for electrostatic repulsion of Rosetta and the dust?

2. How long would it take for the charge on the nucleus to neutralize?

3.Now how long will it take for the nucleus to neutralize charge?

Tusenfem?

Jd116, I can’t do the maths, can you help me with Toms calculations using E. Behar’s modeling?
 
Last edited:
Sorry I did not realise.

I asked you a question a couple posts back about charge neutralisation and you refused to post your answer to...
J.Decca Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

So how far away from the nucleus does this occur again?

Have you ever taken the time to actually look at figure 1 of Deca? And by the way it is DECA, with ONE C!



I think not, otherwise you would not ask this question, or you looked at the figure and you don't understand it in combination with what is written in the text of the paper.

Q 2&3 have the same answer which does affect 4!

The root of a comet tail –Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko E. Behar

How does this electric field effect Toms assumption and his calculation for electrostatic repulsion of Rosetta and the dust?

Well, how strong is the field, and how strong is the field that you need to keep Rosetta in orbit by electrostatic force only?
Of course Rosetta's potential varies over the course of the mission between positive and negative 30 Volts, so you might have to change the charge of your magical electric comet.

Jd116, I can’t do the maths, can you help me with Toms calculations using E. Behar’s modeling?

Aren't your homeys at Thunderdolts helping you with the math?

Nothing that Etienne or Jan have modeled will have any significance on your magical "Rosetta is kept in orbit by electrostatic forces", because the charges needed on the comet are just crazy, as has been shown to you in this thread.
You will not accept this, but it might be time to actually learn a little electrostatics and electrodynamics. The book "Physics" by Allonso & Finn might be low-level enough that you might understand the basics.
 
I’m sure a large percentage of readers here would unfamiliar with the term in relation to cometary bodies and I thought, stupidly, that you might shed some light.

I am sure that you are very unfamiliar with this term, because you cannot be bothered by actually going to a library and look up some stuff in actual books that might teach you something.

Forces have a different effect on different masses.
 
Have you ever taken the time to actually look at figure 1 of Deca? And by the way it is DECA, with ONE C!

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/254845b518e1493e77.jpg[/qimg]

I think not, otherwise you would not ask this question, or you looked at the figure and you don't understand it in combination with what is written in the text of the paper.



Well, how strong is the field, and how strong is the field that you need to keep Rosetta in orbit by electrostatic force only?
Of course Rosetta's potential varies over the course of the mission between positive and negative 30 Volts, so you might have to change the charge of your magical electric comet.



Aren't your homeys at Thunderdolts helping you with the math?

Nothing that Etienne or Jan have modeled will have any significance on your magical "Rosetta is kept in orbit by electrostatic forces", because the charges needed on the comet are just crazy, as has been shown to you in this thread.
You will not accept this, but it might be time to actually learn a little electrostatics and electrodynamics. The book "Physics" by Allonso & Finn might be low-level enough that you might understand the basics.

So the electron and ions do neutralise each other EVENTUALLY as J.Deca says.

No bow shock develops, as expected for a weakly outgassing comet [22]. The heavy cometary ions are accelerated by the convective electric field, to be eventually picked up far downstream, whereas solar wind protons deflect in the opposite direction in accordance with momentumconservation. Downstream of the nucleus, Figs. 1(d) and 1(g) show a fanlike structure [15] and density fluctuations or filamentation [43] that can be associated with the so-called “singing comet” waves [25]. Focusing on the electron dynamics next [Figs. 1(b), 1(d), 1(f), and 1(h)], we find that, to first order, the electrons behave as two separate fluids: a solar wind and a cometary electron fluid. We observe a spatial separation of the cometary electrons with respect to the cometary ions, and of the solar wind electrons with respect to the solar wind protons. Cometary electrons eventually end up neutralizing the solar wind protons, and solar wind electrons eventually neutralize the cometary ions.

Right thanks for clearing that up tusenfem. I thought my original question of how far the neutralisation takes place was a simple one. :thumbsup:

:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I am sure that you are very unfamiliar with this term, because you cannot be bothered by actually going to a library and look up some stuff in actual books that might teach you something.

Forces have a different effect on different masses.

So you do know what the term polarisation electric field wrt the comet nucleus then?

Just like in the picture, ay! :D
 
Last edited:
So the electron and ions do neutralise each other EVENTUALLY as J.Deca says.

Right thanks for clearing that up tusenfem. I thought my original question of how far the neutralisation takes place was a simple one.

This is my way to show "the lurkers" how incapable you are.
Did you look at the figure now?
Did you compare the SW ion and com electrons?
Did you compare the SW electrons and com ions?
Did you look at the densities in the colorbar?
Did you do ANYTHING? Don't answer that, it's retorical.
 
Does the PSA have the RSI data tusenfem?

What difference would that make? Just look at the bound orbits of Rosetta. That tells you that the gravity they measured was correct. Otherwise it would have ended badly, eh?
 
Jd116, I can’t do the maths, can you help me with Toms calculations using E. Behar’s modeling?

Behar's model has nothing to do with the calculation. To offset the gravity, and make it seem less than it actually is, you need only Coulomb's law. As shown by Harvey and Tom, this involves knowing the measured density, the assumed density, and the charges on the spacecraft and comet. To work out the voltage on the comet, we need only to estimate the capacitance of the comet and the spacecraft. As we already know the voltage on the spacecraft, it is trivial to show that the voltage required on the comet would be colossal. Given that Philae landed on it without any indication of this immense, impossible voltage, then we know it isn't there.
None of that has any relevance to what is happening in the coma.
 
It wont and DOES NOT neutralise, though it tries its damnedest too equalise with the surrounding plasma. It never quite does because of its eccentric orbital motion.

What has eccentric motion got to do with anything? Why doesn't it happen to asteroids on cometary orbits?
And the surrounding plasma is getting nowhere near the nucleus for long periods. See solar wind cavity and diamagnetic cavity.
 
E-Glider: Active Electrostatic Flight for Airless Body Exploration

Measurements of the electrostatic potential of Rosetta at comet 67P


Some thing to work off of.
 
Behar's model has nothing to do with the calculation. To offset the gravity, and make it seem less than it actually is, you need only Coulomb's law. As shown by Harvey and Tom, this involves knowing the measured density, the assumed density, and the charges on the spacecraft and comet. To work out the voltage on the comet, we need only to estimate the capacitance of the comet and the spacecraft. As we already know the voltage on the spacecraft, it is trivial to show that the voltage required on the comet would be colossal. Given that Philae landed on it without any indication of this immense, impossible voltage, then we know it isn't there.
None of that has any relevance to what is happening in the coma.

You are correct! :thumbsup:

:D

Or more correctly Toms calculations have nothing to do with actual reality.
 
Last edited:
You are correct! :thumbsup:

:D

Or more correctly Toms calculations have nothing to do with actual reality.

What? He and Harvey, both PhDs who know far more about the subject than you ever will, independently arrived at the same way of working out the necessary charge. If you think otherwise, then tell us which equation you are using, instead of posting rubbish. Give us the numbers, or give up.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom