Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
OK.

At one time, you signed up for this, as a key and unalterable - indeed foundational - part of the ELECTRIC COMET model:

0) Comets and asteroids have been blasted from Earth by electric discharges during multiple Venus flybys in recent times to be recorded in myths. Thus comets are rocky bodies like asteroids. The name of the source planet varies according to which Thunderbolts prophet we look at, e.g. it may be Mars.

But then in this post, you changed your mind.

Did I?

I have no idea if they came from planetary bodies? Neither do you?

Next please!
 
Again, whatever language this is, Sol88, it is not English, and I do not understand it.

Would you please reply to my two questions? In English? Here they are again:

An atom is electrically neutral, yet it contains a positively charged nucleus and one or more negatively charged electrons. Is this, per the Sol88 definition, “charge separation”?

If not, why not?

Off topic, sorry.

This is charge separation of the solar wind plasma we are discussing.

Nice red herring anyWhooo !
 
Not that outdated. There is a higher dust/ ice ratio than imagined by Whipple. We know that a lot of the surface is covered in organics, and the surface is very dark. However, he was basically on the money.

Yup, for his acolytes!
 
Yes, you did.

I have no idea if they came from planetary bodies?

<snip>
Well, at one time - per your own posts in this thread - you did have exactly that idea (more than one time, in fact).

It is a sad fact that as one ages, one's memory begins to fail. It's a good thing that the internet never forgets what you have posted, Sol88.
 
No, they aren't. A handful haver been detected in the main belt. They are on non-cometary orbits!

I say yes you say no. :D

1I/2017 U1 Ended that little party for ya’s :D

Bet if we looked, we’d find more “odd” asteroids.
 
Yes, you did.


Well, at one time - per your own posts in this thread - you did have exactly that idea (more than one time, in fact).

It is a sad fact that as one ages, one's memory begins to fail. It's a good thing that the internet never forgets what you have posted, Sol88.

Where did I change my mind?

They may very well be from planetary bodies.

How do you know there not?

One wonders where all that clay and carbonates could come from because the mainstream have no idea.

As usual. :blush:
 
Again, whatever language this is, Sol88, it is not English, and I do not understand it.

Would you please reply to my two questions? In English? Here they are again:

An atom is electrically neutral, yet it contains a positively charged nucleus and one or more negatively charged electrons. Is this, per the Sol88 definition, “charge separation”?

If not, why not?
Off topic, sorry.

This is charge separation of the solar wind plasma we are discussing.

Nice red herring anyWhooo !
Well, thank you for the clarification, Sol88.

Next question on clarifying what the idiosyncratic, Sol88, "charge separation" definition is:

In a plasma, there are electrons (negatively charged) and ions (can be both positive or negative), as well as neutral species (perhaps). In some plasmas there are positrons (+vely charged), muons (both charges), pions (ditto), and more.

The charged species are separated. Is this, per the Sol88 definition, “charge separation”? If not, why not?
 
Where did I change my mind?

They may very well be from planetary bodies.

<snip>
Sorry, Sol88, I do not feel like being your personal slave/servant/librarian/conscience/whatever any more.

Instead I'd like to understand what the idiosyncratic, Sol88, definition of "charge separation" is.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom