Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
This is not what I had in mind, when I talked about your data analysis.
Could you please start with actual data analysis? And not just dropping buzz words?

How about we start with the basic premise of the electric comet?

Is quasi neutrality violated via the motion of the nucleus thru the solar wind?
 
How about we start with the basic premise of the electric comet?

Is quasi neutrality violated via the motion of the nucleus thru the solar wind?

Irrelevant. Why don't we first find the EDM (lol) and the wandering arc discharges (lol), that are the basis of your woo? Without them everything else is irrelevant. Oh, and the water that shouldn't exist, and the rock that doesn't exist.
 
Just read Toms post, thought so.



1.it doesn’t. It only maintains a potential difference thru it’s orbital motion, See 2.

2. Charge seperation, see 1.

So, maybe you’d like to get in touch with Tom Bridgeman and inform him he was incorrect in his assumptions!

:D

Jesus. No, he wasn't. As he and Harvey showed, you need a colossal amount of charge on the comet to cancel out gravity. It isn't there. Understand? I don't expect you do, do you? Bit beyond you this stuff, isn't it? If you think it is there, then show us, instead of posting uneducated, irrelevant garbage to avoid actual scienctific observations. Or lack thereof.
We might as well discuss QM with a chimpanzee.
 
Your tusenfems spokesman’s as well now?

It is irrelevant. Understand? Your woo didn't happen, so how about addressing why not? Show us the discharges in the data. Show us the rock in the data. Show us why the water isn't water. Show us why the diamagnetic cavity doesn't exist. Show us why the solar wind goes into stealth mode, and cannot be detected anywhere near the comet around perihelion.
Stop making crap up, and actually do some science, or simply admit that it is beyond you (which we already know), and that your puerile beliefs are based on nothing more than faith in a couple of con artists.
 
How about we start with the basic premise of the electric comet?

Is quasi neutrality violated via the motion of the nucleus thru the solar wind?

Just write your stuff will you, I don't know what the "basic premise" is, because above you said

Q1. How would/could a net charge on the comet nucleus be maintained in interplanetary plasma?

A1.it doesn’t. It only maintains a potential difference thru it’s orbital motion, See 2.

is that a premise, so start with that, etc.

don't come with questions, come with a paper.
 
Your question was answered.

<snip>
Actually, you didn’t answer anything.

My preference has always been to ask you to describe, explain, and educate me on the ELECTRIC COMET model; however, I did take a peek at the WP on comets. It gives density estimates for five comets. None of those seem consistent with the ELECTRIC COMET model (I also looked the densities of the substances which comprise comets, per the ELECTRIC COMET model; they are all >1.0).

So, it would seem that hard, observational data on five comets is enough to seriously weaken the ELECTRIC COMET model (as scientifically valid), wouldn’t you agree?
 
Actually, you didn’t answer anything.

My preference has always been to ask you to describe, explain, and educate me on the ELECTRIC COMET model; however, I did take a peek at the WP on comets. It gives density estimates for five comets. None of those seem consistent with the ELECTRIC COMET model (I also looked the densities of the substances which comprise comets, per the ELECTRIC COMET model; they are all >1.0).

So, it would seem that hard, observational data on five comets is enough to seriously weaken the ELECTRIC COMET model (as scientifically valid), wouldn’t you agree?

Us: Where is the rock?
Sol: Is there charge separation?

Us: Where are the discharges in the data?
Sol: Is there charge separation?

Us: Why is the density so low?
Sol: Is there charge separation?

Us: How are you making volatiles?
Sol: Is there charge separation?

Us: What is the charge on the comet?
Sol: Is there charge separation?

Us: What day is it?
Sol: Is there charge separation?

Us: Why won't you answer the questions?
Sol: Is there charge separation?

Ad infinitum.
 
Well, is there?

Frankly, my dear, who gives a damn? What if there was? What is it doing? Why do you think Tusenfem is asking for data? That is, data that shows the impossible electric discharges from (to?) the nucleus. An explanation, using scientific data of why the density is measured as being half that of water. Data to show where rock has been detected. Data that shows why asteroids with comet-like orbits don't behave like comets. Et boring cetera.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom