Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
So, you prefer diversion to actually answering questions or addressing challenges to the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory) head on?


Some direct questions, then, about the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory). These refer to the following aspects of the ELECTRIC COMET model:

1) comets are rocks
1a) the rock is rock, a natural substance, a solid aggregate of one or more minerals or mineraloids
1b) the rock has a bulk density in the range 1.9±1.1×103 kgm−31d) the main minerals are hydrated minerals, silicate, carbonates, clays, olivine, and iron


JTA: Please provide a plausible combination of hydrated minerals, silicate, carbonates, clays, olivine, and iron which, in the form of solid rock, have a bulk density the range 1.9±1.1×103 kgm−3
JTB: Please show - in detail - how rock with a bulk density the range 1.9±1.1×103 kgm−3 is consistent with the estimated density of 67P.
Try here first.

<snip>

Scientists Gaining Clearer Picture of Comet Makeup and Origin
Um, nope ... nothing there which addresses either of my questions.

But maybe that's just me; would you please explain - in detail, with numbers and calculations - how that addresses either of my questions?
 
Well you may be able add the double layer as evidence as well.

Cheers jean tate

Conclusions. Collisional cooling of electrons following a radial outward path is not sufficient to explain the observations. We suggest that the ambipolar electric field keeps electrons in the inner coma for a much longer time, giving them time to dissipate energy by collisions with the neutrals. We conclude that better models are required to describe the plasma environment of comets. They need to include at least two populations of electrons and the ambipolar field.
Cold electrons at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
 
Um, nope ... nothing there which addresses either of my questions.

But maybe that's just me; would you please explain - in detail, with numbers and calculations - how that addresses either of my questions?

You mean use the same calculations to do the difference between an asteroid and a comet?

The ones mainstream use?

:confused:
 
The big lobe of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko comet: morphological and spectrophotometric evidences of layering as from OSIRIS data

Consolidated cometary materials located at different structural levels are characterized by different brightness and revealed due to the selective removal of large volumes. This variegation can be attributed to a different texture of the outcrop surface and/or to a different content of refractory materials.

Mmmm.....comets are looking rockier and rockier!

I’m still having trouble reconciling 80% porous nucleus and consolidated layering of refractory material that is as hard as MUPUS tried tried to penetrate!

EVERY new paper is looking less and less in support of the 1950’s model of dirty Snowballs!

See the REAL scientist are more than happy to hint at what’s really going on but NO ONE has the cojones to say what needs to be said.
 
2 July 2018: A promise to go through his MUPUS stupidity yet again!

What the MUPUS data in the original paper showed (and he knows) is that the data is consistent with sintered ices....... <snip>

I can't imagine why Sol would want to discuss the MUPUS data. However, should he wish to, let's start with the thermal inertia of his 'rock', shall we?

.....and the local thermal inertia was 85 ± 35 J m−2 K−1s-1/2.

Thermal and mechanical properties of the near-surface layers of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
Spohn, T. et al.
https://www.researchgate.net/profil...erasimenko/links/55d317d608ae0a3417225c15.pdf

Now, maybe Sol could do some research into the thermal inertia of various rocks. Good luck finding any that come even close to that value.
 
Mmmm.....comets are looking rockier and rockier!

Only if one is too uneducated to understand science. What was the thermal inertia of this 'rock'? What is exposed when chunks of this rock fall off of cliffs? How big a hole was made in this 'rock' when hit by an impactor? Plenty of online crater calculators out there, as RC has told you a squillion times. Use one.
Pareidolia is fine if you want to show little kiddies bunnies in the sky. It isn't science, however. You may need to relay that information to your loony mate, Thornhill.
 
Last edited:
The big lobe of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko comet: morphological and spectrophotometric evidences of layering as from OSIRIS data



Mmmm.....comets are looking rockier and rockier!

I’m still having trouble reconciling 80% porous nucleus and consolidated layering of refractory material that is as hard as MUPUS tried tried to penetrate!

EVERY new paper is looking less and less in support of the 1950’s model of dirty Snowballs!

See the REAL scientist are more than happy to hint at what’s really going on but NO ONE has the cojones to say what needs to be said.

Maybe you should read the paper, hmmmn? I realise that it is paywalled, but that didn't stop me. Even linking to it would be a help:

The big lobe of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko comet: morphological and spectrophotometric evidences of layering as from OSIRIS data
Ferrari, S. et al
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/advance-article-abstract/doi/10.1093/mnras/sty1656/5042950

The high activity close to the perihelion induces a higher erosion rate in the southern hemisphere, and a thinner surface dust coating, partially showing the underlying ice-rich layer and resulting in an overall less red colour of the nucleus (Fornasier et al. 2016). In particular, during perihelion, the illuminated southern hemisphere is more active than the unlit northern one (Keller et al. 2017), which accumulates airfall that originates from the active South. This implies that nowadays the cometary surface is continuously reworked, and volatiles (De Sanctis et al. 2015), as well as the finest fraction of unconsolidated materials (e.g.Lai et al. 2016; Pajola et al. 2017a), are moved from a site to the other depending on the illumination conditions and nearly independently of any physio-regional boundary. In addition, a strong illumination and an effective thermal gradient (Pajola et al. 2017a) induce the exposure of fresh materials that, later, are gradually depleted of their volatiles content (Fornasier et al.2016; Pajola et al. 2017a).

So, why link to a paper that tells us what we already knew? i.e. that the EC woo is dead?
 
You mean use the same calculations to do the difference between an asteroid and a comet?

The ones mainstream use?

:confused:

Why don't you start with Indagator's questions? What makes comets have a far lower density than asteroids, and why are many, many asteroids on comet-like orbits not behaving like comets? It should be the idiot Thornhill answering these questions, given that he invented this garbage. We also have a member here who co-authored said garbage. However, it looks like you've been hung out to dry, Solly, so you'll have to do the explaining, as the self-appointed spokesperson for the aforementioned garbage.
So, let's have some answers, eh?
 
It is only you who keeps on insisting that scientists use an outdated model.

Albeit an outdated model that is far closer to reality than T & T managed to come up with, despite having access to a further 56 years worth of data!
 
The big lobe of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko comet: morphological and spectrophotometric evidences of layering as from OSIRIS data



Mmmm.....comets are looking rockier and rockier!

I’m still having trouble reconciling 80% porous nucleus and consolidated layering of refractory material that is as hard as MUPUS tried tried to penetrate!

EVERY new paper is looking less and less in support of the 1950’s model of dirty Snowballs!

See the REAL scientist are more than happy to hint at what’s really going on but NO ONE has the cojones to say what needs to be said.
Indeed, the false dichotomy force is strong within you, young Sol88.

But speaking of cojones, have you considered the hard data which shows that the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory) - you know, what this thread is about and what you should be posting about - is "late"? That if you hadn't nailed its feet, it'd be flat on its back, having shuffled off its mortal coil (no matter how beautiful its plumage)?
 
Well you may be able add the double layer as evidence as well.

Cheers jean tate

Cold electrons at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
All in good time, Sol88, all in good time.

Here's a suggestion: instead of wandering all over the landscape (and pinin' for the fjords), why not concentrate on the questions I asked you? They're actually quite straight-forward (no need for nasty plasma physics equations), and should be easy to answer. As a bonus, I think you'll find the answers pretty firmly show that the hard observational data is inconsistent with the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory), which should come as a relief to you, no doubt.
 
You mean use the same calculations to do the difference between an asteroid and a comet?

The ones mainstream use?

:confused:
No.

Let me try and simplify this for you. Here are the questions again:

These refer to the following aspects of the ELECTRIC COMET model:

1) comets are rocks
1a) the rock is rock, a natural substance, a solid aggregate of one or more minerals or mineraloids
1b) the rock has a bulk density in the range 1.9±1.1×103 kgm−31d) the main minerals are hydrated minerals, silicate, carbonates, clays, olivine, and iron


JTA: Please provide a plausible combination of hydrated minerals, silicate, carbonates, clays, olivine, and iron which, in the form of solid rock, have a bulk density the range 1.9±1.1×103 kgm−3
JTB: Please show - in detail - how rock with a bulk density the range 1.9±1.1×103 kgm−3 is consistent with the estimated density of 67P.

Now I don't want to tell you how to go about answering these, but here are some suggestions:

1) find values for the densities of hydrated minerals, silicate, carbonates, clays, olivine, and iron. For all but the last two, you may consider finding ranges rather than single values

2) confirm what others have posted as the density of 67P

3) tackle JTB first; with numbers from 1) and a value from 2), you can conclude - with considerable certainty - that the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory) is either consistent with hard, observational data, or it is not.
 
Now I don't want to tell you how to go about answering these, but here are some suggestions:

1) find values for the densities of hydrated minerals, silicate, carbonates, clays, olivine, and iron. For all but the last two, you may consider finding ranges rather than single values

2) confirm what others have posted as the density of 67P

3) tackle JTB first; with numbers from 1) and a value from 2), you can conclude - with considerable certainty - that the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory) is either consistent with hard, observational data, or it is not.

A very easy reference for the bolded might come from Table 2 of the paper I linked above:

Spitzer Spectral Observations of the Deep Impact Ejecta
Lisse, C. et al.
http://planetary.brown.edu/pdfs/3610.pdf
 
Usual lies. No double layers detected at any comets

Well you may be able add the double layer as evidence as well.
3 July 2018: Usual lies. No double layers detected at any comets, especially in Cold electrons at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
Conclusions. Collisional cooling of electrons following a radial outward path is not sufficient to explain the observations. We suggest that the ambipolar electric field keeps electrons in the inner coma for a much longer time, giving them time to dissipate energy by collisions with the neutrals. We conclude that better models are required to describe the plasma environment of comets. They need to include at least two populations of electrons and the ambipolar field.

Nothing to do with:
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
Stupid "same calculations" question to derail from his many comet delusions

You mean use the same calculations to do the difference between an asteroid and a comet?
3 July 2018: Stupid "same calculations" question to derail from his many comet delusions.

He was asked for the EC calculations by EC proponents to support his assertions about the EC "model".
JTA: Please provide a plausible combination of hydrated minerals, silicate, carbonates, clays, olivine, and iron which, in the form of solid rock, have a bulk density the range 1.9±1.1×103 kgm−3
JTB: Please show - in detail - how rock with a bulk density the range 1.9±1.1×103 kgm−3 is consistent with the estimated density of 67P.

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom