Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Lies by citing an ices and dust comet paper when his comet delusions include no ices

Inventory of the volatiles on comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko from Rosetta/ROSINA
14 May 2018: Lies by citing an ices and dust comet paper when his many comet delusions include no ices (or "minimal").

Inventory of the volatiles on comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko from Rosetta/ROSINA
Results. We detect almost all species currently known to be present in cometary coma with ROSINA DFMS. As DFMS measured the composition locally, we cannot derive a global abundance, but we compare measurements from the summer and the winter hemisphere with known abundances from other comets. Differences between relative abundances between summer and winter hemispheres are large, which points to a possible evolution of the cometary surface. This comet appears to be very rich in CO2 and ethane. Heavy oxygenated compounds such as ethylene glycol are underabundant at 3 AU, probably due to their high sublimation temperatures, but nevertheless, their presence proves that Kuiper belt comets also contain complex organic molecules.


More than 948 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies from 6 July 2009 to 10 May 2018

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
JT09:
3ab) a lower range ~1 V to ~1 kV out to aphelion and the nucleus is receiving electrons
3c) comets themselves are negatively charged with respect to the local solar wind


These two seem mutually contradictory: if the nucleus is receiving electrons as it travels from perihelion to aphelion, how can it be negatively charged with respect to the local solar wind?

An object immersed in plasma will take on the charge of the space surrounding the object.

If both the object and the plasma surrounding it move relative to each other... THE ELECTRIC COMET


So in general moving toward the Sun = Increasing electric field. Moving away from the Sun = Decreasing electric field

The more eccentric the orbit the faster the nucleus has to try and equalize with the increasing electric potential.
 
So in general moving toward the Sun = Increasing electric field. Moving away from the Sun = Decreasing electric field

The more eccentric the orbit the faster the nucleus has to try and equalize with the increasing electric potential.

WHICH electric field? Please provide evidence for this "interplanetary electric field" that is supposed to exist.
 
Thanks Sol88.
An object immersed in plasma will take on the charge of the space surrounding the object.

If both the object and the plasma surrounding it move relative to each other... THE ELECTRIC COMET


So in general moving toward the Sun = Increasing electric field. Moving away from the Sun = Decreasing electric field

The more eccentric the orbit the faster the nucleus has to try and equalize with the increasing electric potential.
To me, this is somewhat ambiguous, so I'll be following up with questions that seek clarification. Later.

For now, I think it's becoming increasingly likely that we may need a change ... perhaps a better name is the MAGIC COMET model? :)
 
My numbering sequence got out of hand, there's a JT07, JT09, and JT10, but no JT08. :jaw-dropp

That's because I somehow failed to post what I'd prepared, as JT08, yesterday (I'll do a consolidation in a few days' time). So here it is.

JT08: This question seeks to clarify the meanings of the various terms for parts of a comet. In the latest version of the ELECTRIC COMET model (bold added):
1) comets are rocky objects
2) the nucleus of a comet contains no ices for sublimation
3d) there are (nested/stairstep transformer/capacitor) double layers at comets
3e) these double layers form the comets' comas
6) the charged dust so machined forms highly collimated, bursting jets; these are the jets we observe


There seems to be a small contradiction in 1) vs the rest: comet seems to refer to more than the rocky nucleus (in the ELECTRIC COMET model); specifically, a comet has a (non-rocky) coma and jets which are collimated charged dust in addition to a rocky nucleus. Not mentioned are tails.

Can you clarify please, Sol88? Specifically, does the ELECTRIC COMET model include tails? If so, what are they? Also, do some comets have more than one tail? If so, how does the ELECTRIC COMET model account for the varying number of tails?
 
Unless Sol88 substantially reduces the backlog of unanswered JT questions in the next day or three, this will be the last new JT for this week.

JT11:
4a) the Sun's radial electric field is increasing with decreasing heliocentric distance

Also, from Sol88's recent post (yet to be incorporated into the ELECTRIC COMET model, bold added): "So in general moving toward the Sun = Increasing electric field. Moving away from the Sun = Decreasing electric field"

JT06 (source) already asks about the radial component; this question is about others.

How does the Sun's radial electric field vary in the two other spatial dimensions (e.g. a latitude/longitude system)?
How does it vary in time?
As with JT06, please give at least a semi-quantitative answer.
 
My numbering sequence got out of hand, there's a JT07, JT09, and JT10, but no JT08. :jaw-dropp

That's because I somehow failed to post what I'd prepared, as JT08, yesterday (I'll do a consolidation in a few days' time). So here it is.

JT08: This question seeks to clarify the meanings of the various terms for parts of a comet. In the latest version of the ELECTRIC COMET model (bold added):
1) comets are rocky objects
2) the nucleus of a comet contains no ices for sublimation
3d) there are (nested/stairstep transformer/capacitor) double layers at comets
3e) these double layers form the comets' comas
6) the charged dust so machined forms highly collimated, bursting jets; these are the jets we observe


Snipped.

Can you clarify please, Sol88? Specifically, does the ELECTRIC COMET model include tails? If so, what are they? Also, do some comets have more than one tail? If so, how does the ELECTRIC COMET model account for the varying number of tails?

Ohhh you bloody ripper, comet tails :D thanks jt :thumbsup:

Two types of tails are observed, I believe, Dust and Plasma.

The dust will be the electrically neutral dust that has previously been machined of the rocky nucleus.

The plasma tail will be another nail in the coffin for the dirtysnowball model.

It forms part of the the overall current system at comets.

Think the EU’s favourite, Birkeland Currents and I’d hazard a guess they’d be nested concentric cylinders of current to and from the comet.

From the Ulysses data, the plasma tail seems to extend quite some distance behind the nucleus.

There is a paper due out SOMETIME in the, I hope, not to distant future by the RPC team. I believe Martin Volwerk is the PI.

If you are not 100% sure on what Whipple’s model predicted on the structure of cometary tails, you maybe able to ask tusenfem what would be expected from a dirtysnowball enduring all that heat and radiation pressure.

You may like to narrow the scope of the question to either just the dust tail or just the plasma tail, if you’d like.

Or without having to wait for the paper “A tail like no other: RPC-MAG's view of Rosetta's tail excursion at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko”
M. Volwerk, C. Goetz, I. Richter, M. Delva, K. Ostaszewski, K. Schwingenschuh, K.-H. Glassmeier to be published, you may like to see if the PI would like to play and narrow the scope even more. Ask what surprises there were between the expected data, from Whipple’s Model and the data returned from 67P to the RPC team. :boxedin:
 
Last edited:
We’ll stick to jt08 for the time being if that’s ok Jean tate?

Gets messy otherwise.
 
Two types of tails are observed, I believe, Dust and Plasma.

True

The dust will be the electrically neutral dust that has previously been machined of the rocky nucleus.

False

The plasma tail will be another nail in the coffin for the dirtysnowball model.

???

It forms part of the the overall current system at comets.

They may be part of A current system, e.g. the cross tail current between the regions of oppositely directed magnetic field.

Think the EU’s favourite, Birkeland Currents and I’d hazard a guess they’d be nested concentric cylinders of current to and from the comet.

As Birkeland currents (in the Earth's magnetosphere) are field aligned currents, how can it be possible that they are concentric cylinders of current, as the main current in the tail would be, like in the Earth's magnetotail, flowing across the field (and across would mean perpendicular to the magnetic field, so NOT field aligned.

From the Ulysses data, the plasma tail seems to extend quite some distance behind the nucleus.

Magnetic disturbances can apparently be well conserved in specific cases.

There is a paper due out SOMETIME in the, I hope, not to distant future by the RPC team. I believe Martin Volwerk is the PI.

Not PI (I am only a CoI on RPC) but I guess you mean first author.

If you are not 100% sure on what Whipple’s model predicted on the structure of cometary tails, you maybe able to ask tusenfem what would be expected from a dirtysnowball enduring all that heat and radiation pressure.

Whipple's model says nothing about the formation of cometary tails. For that you have to wait a few years and read Alfvén's paper.

You may like to narrow the scope of the question to either just the dust tail or just the plasma tail, if you’d like.

??

Or without having to wait for the paper “A tail like no other: RPC-MAG's view of Rosetta's tail excursion at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko”
M. Volwerk, C. Goetz, I. Richter, M. Delva, K. Ostaszewski, K. Schwingenschuh, K.-H. Glassmeier to be published, you may like to see if the PI would like to play and narrow the scope even more. Ask what surprises there were between the expected data, from Whipple’s Model and the data returned from 67P to the RPC team.

As the tail has nothing to do with Whipple's model, there were no surprises in that respect. Here, once more, the Abstract of the paper:

Volwerk et al. said:
Context. The Rosetta Plasma Consortium (RPC) magnetometer (MAG) data during the tail excursion in March - April 2016 are used to investigate the magnetic structure of and activity in the tail region of the weakly outgassing comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko (67P/CG).
Aims. The goal of this study is to compare the large scale (near) tail structure with that of earlier missions to strong outgassing comets, and the small scale turbulent energy cascade (un)related to the singing comet phenomenon.
Methods. The usual methods of space plasma physics are used to analyse the magnetometer data, such as minimum variance analysis,
spectral analysis, and power law fitting. Also the cone angle and clock angle of the magnetic field are calculated to interpret the data.
Results. It is found that comet 67P/CG does not have a classical draped magnetic field and no bi-lobal tail structure at this late stage of the mission when the comet is already at 2.7 AU distance from the Sun. The main magnetic field direction seems to be more across the tail direction, which may implicate an asymmetric pick-up cloud. During periods of singing comet activity the propagation direction of the waves is at large angles with respect to the magnetic field and to the radial direction towards the comet. Turbulent cascade of magnetic energy from large to small scales is different in the presence of singing as without it.
 
Originally Posted by Sol88 View Post
From the Ulysses data, the plasma tail seems to extend quite some distance behind the nucleus.
Magnetic disturbances can apparently be well conserved in specific cases.


How far back do you think they might go and still be detectable, tusenfem?

Or what might be disturbing the magnetic field, so far back?
 
Two types of tails are observed, I believe, Dust and Plasma.

The dust will be the electrically neutral dust that has previously been machined of the rocky nucleus.

The plasma tail (...) forms part of the the overall current system at comets.
I'm not sure I understand... You say that those two types of tails are observed. But what does the Electric Comet Model predicts ? One of them ? both ? Or none of them ?

Does the Electric Comet Model quantify the size of those tails, for example related to the size of the comet, its composition, its orbit, and so on ?
 
Thanks Sol88, and you're welcome. :)
Ohhh you bloody ripper, comet tails :D thanks jt :thumbsup:

Two types of tails are observed, I believe, Dust and Plasma.

The dust will be the electrically neutral dust that has previously been machined of the rocky nucleus.

The plasma tail will be another nail in the coffin for the dirtysnowball model.

It forms part of the the overall current system at comets.

Think the EU’s favourite, Birkeland Currents and I’d hazard a guess they’d be nested concentric cylinders of current to and from the comet.

From the Ulysses data, the plasma tail seems to extend quite some distance behind the nucleus.

There is a paper due out SOMETIME in the, I hope, not to distant future by the RPC team. I believe Martin Volwerk is the PI.

If you are not 100% sure on what Whipple’s model predicted on the structure of cometary tails, you maybe able to ask tusenfem what would be expected from a dirtysnowball enduring all that heat and radiation pressure.

You may like to narrow the scope of the question to either just the dust tail or just the plasma tail, if you’d like.

Or without having to wait for the paper “A tail like no other: RPC-MAG's view of Rosetta's tail excursion at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko”
M. Volwerk, C. Goetz, I. Richter, M. Delva, K. Ostaszewski, K. Schwingenschuh, K.-H. Glassmeier to be published, you may like to see if the PI would like to play and narrow the scope even more. Ask what surprises there were between the expected data, from Whipple’s Model and the data returned from 67P to the RPC team. :boxedin:
 
We’ll stick to jt08 for the time being if that’s ok Jean tate?

Gets messy otherwise.
That's fine Sol88. All the unanswered questions are still there, waiting for when you have time to answer them.

From your earlier post:
Sol88 said:
You may like to narrow the scope of the question to either just the dust tail or just the plasma tail, if you’d like.
I'm not in the driver's seat here, Sol88, you are.

This thread is about the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory). At least among ISF members who've posted here recently, you are the only one who claims to know what this is.

My questions have, so far, been aimed at trying to get a basic, clear statement of what this ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory) is (and what it is not). I've asked 11 such questions so far, and estimate that I will need to ask ~40 others before there is such a clear, basic statement.

I hope that helps, and happy answering! :)
 
True



They may be part of A current system, e.g. the cross tail current between the regions of oppositely directed magnetic field.



As Birkeland currents (in the Earth's magnetosphere) are field aligned currents, how can it be possible that they are concentric cylinders of current, as the main current in the tail would be, like in the Earth's magnetotail, flowing across the field (and across would mean perpendicular to the magnetic field, so NOT field aligned.



Magnetic disturbances can apparently be well conserved in specific cases.


Whipple's model says nothing about the formation of cometary tails. For that you have to wait a few years and read Alfvén's paper.


As the tail has nothing to do with Whipple's model, there were no surprises in that respect. Here, once more, the Abstract of the paper:



Have you had a chance to read The root of a comet tail - Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov--Gerasimenko ?
 
Last edited:
Usual ices and dust comet paper idiocy to derail from his many comet delusions

16 May 2018: Usual ices and dust comet paper idiocy to derail from his many comet delusions.

The paper compares data on the first 1000 km of the ion tail of 67P to a mainstream model. The interaction between comet ion tails and solar wind has been researched since 1957, including 11 probes.
The shape of these visible ion tails gives a major clue to the existence of both the solar wind and the interplanetary magnetic field (IMF),as for instance elaborated by Alfven (1957).


All the electric comet has is ignorant delusions, not actual models.

More than 948 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies from 6 July 2009 to 10 May 2018

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom