Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Whipple's model says nothing about the formation of cometary tails. For that you have to wait a few years and read Alfvén's paper.

Great!

Which model are we using:

(Durham 2006; Eddington 1910)?

or

Biermann (1951)?

or

Alfven (1957) ‘frozen’ in magnetic field model?

which model are the mainstream using, tusenfem?

from The root of a comet tail - Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov--Gerasimenko

or

the new model Volwerk (2018)?
Additionally, Volwerk
et al. (2018) present an extensive analysis of the magnetic
field observed during the same excursion. The authors found
that the magnetic field was not draped around the nucleus in a
classical sense; instead, the magnetic field direction was mostly
aligned with the IMF direction expected from a Parker spiral
model

Seems Alfven's "frozen in" magnetic field model may need a little tweak!!

MHD anyone???
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure I understand... You say that those two types of tails are observed. But what does the Electric Comet Model predicts ? One of them ? both ? Or none of them ?

Does the Electric Comet Model quantify the size of those tails, for example related to the size of the comet, its composition, its orbit, and so on ?




:Comets follow their elongated paths within a weak electrical field centered on the Sun. In approaching the Sun, a charge imbalance develops between the nucleus and the higher voltage and charge density near the Sun. Growing electrical stresses initiate discharges and the formation of a glowing plasma sheath, appearing as the coma and tail.

:The tails of comets reveal well-defined filaments extending up to tens of millions of miles without dissipating in the vacuum of space. This “violation” of neutral gas behavior in a vacuum is to be expected of a plasma discharge within the ambient electric field of the Sun.
LINK
 
Last edited:
Thanks Sol88, this is very informative.
<snip>

:Comets follow their elongated paths within a weak electrical field centered on the Sun. In approaching the Sun, a charge imbalance develops between the nucleus and the higher voltage and charge density near the Sun. Growing electrical stresses initiate discharges and the formation of a glowing plasma sheath, appearing as the coma and tail.

:The tails of comets reveal well-defined filaments extending up to tens of millions of miles without dissipating in the vacuum of space. This “violation” of neutral gas behavior in a vacuum is to be expected of a plasma discharge within the ambient electric field of the Sun.

LINK
 
:Comets follow their elongated paths within a weak electrical field centered on the Sun. In approaching the Sun, a charge imbalance develops between the nucleus and the higher voltage and charge density near the Sun. Growing electrical stresses initiate discharges and the formation of a glowing plasma sheath, appearing as the coma and tail.

:The tails of comets reveal well-defined filaments extending up to tens of millions of miles without dissipating in the vacuum of space. This “violation” of neutral gas behavior in a vacuum is to be expected of a plasma discharge within the ambient electric field of the Sun.

Thanks for the link. As JeanTate said, providing that link was quite informative.

It doesn't really answer the second part of my question, as the various articles linked don't contain any attempt at establishing a theorical relationship between the various parameters involved (orbit, composition, mass, and whatever else that'd be relevant). They are likely good "introduction for newcomers" documents, but they don't really give details. Can you point me at the relevant documentation?

Thanks!
 
Thanks for the link. As JeanTate said, providing that link was quite informative.

It doesn't really answer the second part of my question, as the various articles linked don't contain any attempt at establishing a theorical relationship between the various parameters involved (orbit, composition, mass, and whatever else that'd be relevant). They are likely good "introduction for newcomers" documents, but they don't really give details. Can you point me at the relevant documentation?

Thanks!

Relevant documentation?

Like in a peer reviewed paper?
 
And you could not be more wrong, but then who is surprised about that?



However, the last set of distributions (Figure 4 (c)) presents the average case seen in the histogram (d) of Figure 3: two beams (cometary and solar wind) flowing 180. apart in the (vy; vz)-plane, with cometary ions purely radial. When aligning the bulk velocity of the solar wind protons with the vy-axis for each 192 s scan, we get a well-focused beam for each day, which proves that the solar wind remains a beam at any time, only deflected and changing direction in the CSEQ frame, associated with rotations of the upstream magnetic field clock angle (Behar et al. 2016). It was verified that the rotation also focuses the proton distributions along the vx dimension (not shown here).

The cometary ions observed further out along the excursion, much faster than the expanding population, were once part of it. The extent of the region in which the ambipolar electric field may dominate has not been investigated yet, and does not appear as a sharp boundary in the present results. Far from trivial, this topic would most likely require the use of self-consistent fully kinetic numerical models.

The root of a comet tail – Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko E. Behar1; 2, H. Nilsson1; 2, P. Henri5, L. Berˇciˇc1; 2, G. Nicolaou1; 4, G. Stenberg Wieser1, M. Wieser1, B. Tabone7, M.Saillenfest6, C. Goetz3

So MHD is still valid in this situation you say tusenfem?
 
Last edited:
The root of a comet tail – Rosetta ion observations at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko E. Behar1; 2, H. Nilsson1; 2, P. Henri5, L. Berˇciˇc1; 2, G. Nicolaou1; 4, G. Stenberg Wieser1, M. Wieser1, B. Tabone7, M.Saillenfest6, C. Goetz3

So MHD is still valid in this situation you say tusenfem?

MHD is valid where MHD is valid. I have explained it to you.
 
Relevant documentation?

Like in a peer reviewed paper?
Not necessarily. I'd like to find a document that goes further than a general description aimed at people with superficial understanding of astrophysics, chemistry and electromagnetism.

In the link you provided, the document titled "The Electric Comet" enumerates things like EDM, wanderic arcs, electrostatic cleaning, and other similar concepts. But it doesn't provide any theorical framework that would allow one to compute, say, the size of the wandering arcs, their frequencies, the influence of cometary composition, and so on.

That's what I'm talking about. It could be chemical reactions explaining some of the observed results. It could be a mathematical analysis linking, say, the observed amount of electrostatic cleaning with distance from the sun and orbital variations.

Given that "The Electric Comet" was written in 2006 (and the EC hypothesis seems even older), surely since then such analysis, modelization and testing against observations were already performed. That's what I'm asking for, peer reviewed or not.

Thanks!
 
Wal Thornhill's deluded and lying "Comet Borrelly rocks core scientific beliefs"

A few of the lies in his Thunderbolts cult "Evidence Confirms Electric Comet Model" blog.

18 May 2018: Links to Wal Thornhill's deluded and lying "Comet Borrelly rocks core scientific beliefs" article.
The main lie is that there are "core beliefs" when there are evidence-based theories, e.g. we trace to orbits of comets back to the locations of the Kuiper Belt and Oort cloud thus that is their origin!

A lie that comets come from the Oort cloud when they also come from the Kuiper Belt.

Argument from incredibility - the Oort cloud is big but also has billions of objects.

An obvious "total lack of comets on hyperbolic orbits" lie: List of hyperbolic comets

We observe that comet ion tails point away from the Sun as predicted for ionized gas being pushed by the solar wind. Thornhill lies with an incorrect "smoke in a strong wind" comparison - comets are not sitting on the surface of the Earth and are not in an atmosphere :eye-poppi.

A blatant "core belief that all objects in the universe are electrically neutral" when the comet tails he is lying about are ion tails :jaw-dropp.

A "comets are merely inert, dirty snowballs evaporating in the heat of the Sun" lie. Comets are dynamic ices and dust balls sublimating due to solar heat and interacting with the solar wind and radiation.

The usual crank insanity of science being "dogma".

A lie that the 1991 Comet Halley flare was a problem for comets made of ices and dust.

A lie that sublimating ices cannot explain narrow jets.

A lie that sublimating ices have to explain the shape of jets after they leave the nucleus (a sometimes "corkscrew shape").

A "low density calculated for some comets" lie. Every comet with a measured density has a density less than that of water and much less than rock.

A lie that the appearance of comets has anting to do with their density.

Some "human facility for self delusion" insanity when describing the discovery that comets tend to be active in small areas. Followed by several lies about jets, e.g. narrow jets are thought to be from "rocket nozzle" shaped chambers, not surface craters; other jets come from pits not craters; there is no "concentrating the heat of the Sun at the bottoms of holes", etc.

X-rays that match those produced in plasma interactions have been found from comet coma. That leads to a "a comet is supposed to be electrically neutral" lie.

A "detection of a forbidden oxygen line at 1128Å" = intense electric field lie. Forbidden lines appear when a plasma is thin enough to allow electronic transitions to happen before collisions stop them.

Delusions of "electrical arc erosion" for the surface of Comet Borrelly.

Irrelevant crater chain lies.

Utter stupidity of a 1871 quote :eek:.
 
MHD is valid where MHD is valid. I have explained it to you.

This radius is much larger than the radial distance covered by Rosetta from the nucleus, and thus kinetic effects on the structure of the tail should be expected, and not the typical MHD-type of tail structure.

Clearly, the near-tail has a completely different structure than simple draped fields.

Assuming that the solar wind - acomet interaction is simply described by Alfvén draping model ( Alfvén 1957)
"A Tail Like No Other" M.Volwerk

So you ARE using Alfvens model?
 
Not necessarily. I'd like to find a document that goes further than a general description aimed at people with superficial understanding of astrophysics, chemistry and electromagnetism.

In the link you provided, the document titled "The Electric Comet" enumerates things like EDM, wanderic arcs, electrostatic cleaning, and other similar concepts. But it doesn't provide any theorical framework that would allow one to compute, say, the size of the wandering arcs, their frequencies, the influence of cometary composition, and so on.

That's what I'm talking about. It could be chemical reactions explaining some of the observed results. It could be a mathematical analysis linking, say, the observed amount of electrostatic cleaning with distance from the sun and orbital variations.

Given that "The Electric Comet" was written in 2006 (and the EC hypothesis seems even older), surely since then such analysis, modelization and testing against observations were already performed. That's what I'm asking for, peer reviewed or not.

Thanks!

Evidence of Electrical Activity on Comet 67P: Towards an Electrochemical Framework for Cometary Phenomena

Knock yourself out!
 
Links to the deluded Thunderbolts cult and the ignorant Franklin Anariba

[Knock yourself out!
17 May 2018: Links to the deluded Thunderbolts cult and the ignorant Franklin Anariba.

The deluded Thunderbolts cult is lying as usual. Franklin Anariba explicitly states that he will not refute the mainstream model of comets made of ices and dust.
As can be ascertained by reading most of the reports published on scientific journals on comet 67P, the main paradigm is the one proposed by Whipple some time ago which can be called the Condensation-Sublimation model. I am not here to refute this model, which I recognize to be of importance near perihelion distances if comets were to contain large amounts of volatiles ices on their surface or in their subsurface. Instead, my intention is bring to everyone’s attention that there could be other mechanisms at work for the origin of water and other chemical species in the cometary coma.
His ignorance of comets and especially 67P starts with the overwhelming evidence of volatile ices on their surface or in their subsurface, e.g. the existence of comet coma, the existence of comet jets, the density of comets showing that those ices have to exist, detection of small amounts of water ices, etc.

Franklin Anariba's major ignorance is being a presenter at the cult conferences as if he has no idea what a science conference looks like, e.g. a conference about astronomy would have astronomers at it! The presenters at EU2017: Wallace Thornhill: the chief liar for Thunderbolts ...

17 November 2015: Cites the deluded Dr. Franklin Anariba (a EU 2013 speaker) in a Thunderbolts cult video.
11 January 2016: I had forgotten about this basic stupidity of the proton implantation idea supported by Haig and Franklin Anariba - it requires that the solar wind reaches the surface of the comet nucleus and this has not been the case for months.


More than 948 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies from 6 July 2009 to 10 May 2018

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
Last edited:
Knock yourself out!
You have a rather strange way of expressing yourself !

The article you linked to is not the kind of document I was talking about. What you linked is, for the most part, a criticis of existing research papers. It establishes no mathematical relationship of any sort modelizing postulated phenomens like EDM, wandering arcs or electrostatic cleaning. One cannot, from that document, build any kind of simulated model that could be matched against reality.

So, I'll try formulating again: do you have links to articles or books proposing the required mathematical relations describing the Electric Comet postulated phenomens?

Thanks!
 
"A Tail Like No Other" M.Volwerk

So you ARE using Alfvens model?

I am using the Rosetta RPC-MAG data, and I study how the magnetic field behaves. First one looks at the data, what do they show, which is all model independent because it is data, it is real (apart from maybe minimal calibration errors). After finding out all there is to see in the data, then you can start working on an interpretation.

For example one might want to know if it agrees with what is expected from Alfvén's 1957 model. And lo-and-behold, it does and it does not, as is clear from the abstract that I posted.

You are too stuck on "models" that "have to be used" when data analysis is just that, data analysis. You cannot go blinded by a preconceived model into data analysis, because then you will not find out anything. You can have in mind that, from earlier experiences, some processes might take place. As an example, nested draping of magnetic field lines as observed by Giotto at Halley. But then, as Rosetta's orbit is completely different from that of Giotto, I have to just again take the data at face value, calculate angles in which the magnetic field points, and then find out that, yes it seems to be happening also at 67P/CG, but it looks different from what is seen at Halley.
 
You have a rather strange way of expressing yourself !

The article you linked to is not the kind of document I was talking about. What you linked is, for the most part, a criticis of existing research papers. It establishes no mathematical relationship of any sort modelizing postulated phenomens like EDM, wandering arcs or electrostatic cleaning. One cannot, from that document, build any kind of simulated model that could be matched against reality.

So, I'll try formulating again: do you have links to articles or books proposing the required mathematical relations describing the Electric Comet postulated phenomens?

Thanks!

No sorry, I don't. All papers are from cranks.

Ummm... plasma physics applied to a rock in the solar wind. I'm sure your smart enogh to go it alone in your search of knowledge

See
tusenfem

I am using the Rosetta RPC-MAG data, and I study how the magnetic field behaves. First one looks at the data, what do they show, which is all model independent because it is data, it is real (apart from maybe minimal calibration errors). After finding out all there is to see in the data, then you can start working on an interpretation.

For example one might want to know if it agrees with what is expected from Alfvén's 1957 model. And lo-and-behold, it does and it does not, as is clear from the abstract that I posted.

You are too stuck on "models" that "have to be used" when data analysis is just that, data analysis. You cannot go blinded by a preconceived model into data analysis, because then you will not find out anything. You can have in mind that, from earlier experiences, some processes might take place. As an example, nested draping of magnetic field lines as observed by Giotto at Halley. But then, as Rosetta's orbit is completely different from that of Giotto, I have to just again take the data at face value, calculate angles in which the magnetic field points, and then find out that, yes it seems to be happening also at 67P/CG, but it looks different from what is seen at Halley.

Hope this helps your search for the truth.
 
Last edited:
I am using the Rosetta RPC-MAG data, and I study how the magnetic field behaves. First one looks at the data, what do they show, which is all model independent because it is data, it is real (apart from maybe minimal calibration errors). After finding out all there is to see in the data, then you can start working on an interpretation.

For example one might want to know if it agrees with what is expected from Alfvén's 1957 model. And lo-and-behold, it does and it does not, as is clear from the abstract that I posted.

You are too stuck on "models" that "have to be used" when data analysis is just that, data analysis. You cannot go blinded by a preconceived model into data analysis, because then you will not find out anything. You can have in mind that, from earlier experiences, some processes might take place. As an example, nested draping of magnetic field lines as observed by Giotto at Halley. But then, as Rosetta's orbit is completely different from that of Giotto, I have to just again take the data at face value, calculate angles in which the magnetic field points, and then find out that, yes it seems to be happening also at 67P/CG, but it looks different from what is seen at Halley.

So why do we still debate over the "dirtysnowball" model?

You know your RPC-MAG data will over turn Whipple's model and plasma is the DOMINATE factor at play here and NOT sublimation along with the infrared and ultraviolet radiation from the Sun.

When these new raft of papers are finally published, I think we'll have plenty of new debates on the dirtysnowball model.

but taking your
which is all model independent because it is data, it is real (apart from maybe minimal calibration errors). After finding out all there is to see in the data, then you can start working on an interpretation.
statement into account, the mainstream have no model and are working on an interpretation.

Brilliant, i feel we are moving forward here as the sublimation model becomes more apparent that it's incorrect.

Not surprising and I don't blame Whipple but....those that forced the data to fit the model :mad::mad::mad:

Your data (RPC-MAG) is telling you there are electric currents flowing up and down the tail. So far we have seen the same looking MAG data from the Ulysses probe for Comet Hyakutake (C/1996 B2), revealing the tail to be at least 3.8 AU in length.

Even if it stopped at 3.8AU that's a heck of a lot of energy to do "work".
 
Last edited:
You have a rather strange way of expressing yourself !

The article you linked to is not the kind of document I was talking about. What you linked is, for the most part, a criticis of existing research papers. It establishes no mathematical relationship of any sort modelizing postulated phenomens like EDM, wandering arcs or electrostatic cleaning. One cannot, from that document, build any kind of simulated model that could be matched against reality.

So, I'll try formulating again: do you have links to articles or books proposing the required mathematical relations describing the Electric Comet postulated phenomens?

Thanks!

Forget Dranariba's "paper", he does not understand a word of what the mainstream papers write.
"Lower hybrid cyclotron waves due to mass-loaded ions" shows he is just collecting sciency sounding terms.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom