tusenfem
Illuminator
- Joined
- May 27, 2008
- Messages
- 3,306
So why do we still debate over the "dirtysnowball" model?
No, the question is: why are YOU still debating the dirty snowball.
You know your RPC-MAG data will over turn Whipple's model and plasma is the DOMINATE factor at play here and NOT sublimation along with the infrared and ultraviolet radiation from the Sun.
MAG data study (surprisingly) magnetic fields, so there is no way that these data can "overturn" Whipple's model.
The plasma, mainly, H2O+, is created by ionization of sublimated water from the cometary nucleus. Unlike the phantasies of the EC community, there is no other way of creating that much heavy ion plasma.
When these new raft of papers are finally published, I think we'll have plenty of new debates on the dirtysnowball model.
So, here it is AGAIN YOU who wants to debate the dirty snowball.
but taking your statement into account, the mainstream have no model and are working on an interpretation.
No, you are as usual misinterpreting my words, but then you don't know how the scientific method works. Read it again (or twice, trice) and maybe you will understand what I said.
Brilliant, i feel we are moving forward here as the sublimation model becomes more apparent that it's incorrect.
Not surprising and I don't blame Whipple but....those that forced the data to fit the model
What are you blathering about ?
Your data (RPC-MAG) is telling you there are electric currents flowing up and down the tail. So far we have seen the same looking MAG data from the Ulysses probe for Comet Hyakutake (C/1996 B2), revealing the tail to be at least 3.8 AU in length.
No, my data do not show that. I have shown that there are current sheets at the dayside of the comet in the current sheet paper.
I do not discuss currents in my tail paper. And if you want my helical wave to be created by an along-the-tail current then you have a big problem. Try and figure out why.
Even if it stopped at 3.8AU that's a heck of a lot of energy to do "work".
And again you don't understand physics. There is no "work" done.


.