Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
So why do we still debate over the "dirtysnowball" model?

No, the question is: why are YOU still debating the dirty snowball.

You know your RPC-MAG data will over turn Whipple's model and plasma is the DOMINATE factor at play here and NOT sublimation along with the infrared and ultraviolet radiation from the Sun.

MAG data study (surprisingly) magnetic fields, so there is no way that these data can "overturn" Whipple's model.

The plasma, mainly, H2O+, is created by ionization of sublimated water from the cometary nucleus. Unlike the phantasies of the EC community, there is no other way of creating that much heavy ion plasma.

When these new raft of papers are finally published, I think we'll have plenty of new debates on the dirtysnowball model.

So, here it is AGAIN YOU who wants to debate the dirty snowball.

but taking your statement into account, the mainstream have no model and are working on an interpretation.

No, you are as usual misinterpreting my words, but then you don't know how the scientific method works. Read it again (or twice, trice) and maybe you will understand what I said.

Brilliant, i feel we are moving forward here as the sublimation model becomes more apparent that it's incorrect.

Not surprising and I don't blame Whipple but....those that forced the data to fit the model

What are you blathering about ?

Your data (RPC-MAG) is telling you there are electric currents flowing up and down the tail. So far we have seen the same looking MAG data from the Ulysses probe for Comet Hyakutake (C/1996 B2), revealing the tail to be at least 3.8 AU in length.

No, my data do not show that. I have shown that there are current sheets at the dayside of the comet in the current sheet paper.
I do not discuss currents in my tail paper. And if you want my helical wave to be created by an along-the-tail current then you have a big problem. Try and figure out why.

Even if it stopped at 3.8AU that's a heck of a lot of energy to do "work".

And again you don't understand physics. There is no "work" done.
 
No sorry, I don't. All papers are from cranks.

Ummm... plasma physics applied to a rock in the solar wind. I'm sure your smart enogh to go it alone in your search of knowledge

See

Hope this helps your search for the truth.


Psst, Sol, your evasion is showing.

You seem very anxious to steer the conversation back to your false dichotomy.
 
No sorry, I don't. All papers are from cranks.
This is a strange statement for sure. I was under the impression that you were supporting the Electric Comet hypothesis, not considering its published works as "from cranks".

Ummm... plasma physics applied to a rock in the solar wind. I'm sure your smart enogh to go it alone in your search of knowledge
I've never heard that plasma physics applied to a rock in the solar wind resulted in the mentioned effects. And I've not found one that applies plasma physics to the EC theory (else, I wouldn't have asked for it!). You are actually asking me to do what Electric Comet theory designers should have done themselves - apply existing physics to prove their point !

Besides that, your answer is quite baffling, I have to say. You seem irritated because I want to go further than vulgarization, philosophical discourse and criticism of other theories. Certainly there's nothing wrong with all those - but one has to go further than that when it comes to domains like astrophysics, don't you agree?

See

Hope this helps your search for the truth.
Not really, because as it seems, it exactly says what I'm thinking: you first study data, spot any significant information, then attempt to explain it, test your hypothesis, and modify it (or reject it totally) if it didn't stand the test.

The first issue at hand is the nature of the explanation provided. It could belong to the realm of fiction, theology, 'supranatural': "because of gods, because of elves, because of ghosts". It could also belong to the realm of philosophy - the atomism of Democritus or the Noûs of Anaxagoras. Or it could belong to the scientific realm, like Newton's theory of gravitation or Maxwell-Lorenz equations.

The Electric Comet is an hypothesis, that has to be formalized so it can be tested against facts, and modified or rejected if it doesn't match observed data. So far, none of the documents you presented were describing such tests, and, what's more, tests that would make it explain phenomens so far unexplained by other theories. As such, it is an act of faith, a philosophical postulate, but not a scientific theory.

In a way, all documents you shared were defining the Electric Comet not as a positive set of proposals (EC should be happening because A and B and C), but as a negative set against other theories (non-EC doesn't happen because A and B and C). But rejecting all other existing theories is not sufficient to demonstrate your own proposal is true, as nothing prevents another, yet unknown proposal, to be true.

That's why I asked about some formalized mathematical/chemical/etc. form of the Electric Comet hypothesis: so the hypothesis can be tested against observed data. And so my initial question, that you seemed to express distaste of, is just this: The Electric Comet model is an hypothesis born from some observations, some being physical data available, some being the apparent contradictions spotted in other hypotheses. Did it ever go further than the conjecture stage?"

Do I have to understand your answer as a 'yes' or 'no' to it ?
 
Forget Dranariba's "paper", he does not understand a word of what the mainstream papers write.
"Lower hybrid cyclotron waves due to mass-loaded ions" shows he is just collecting sciency sounding terms.
I indeed couldn't take it seriously. I was scratching my head many times while reading it, wondering if my (clearly dated and limited) knowledge in fundamental physics were the issue, or if it was Star Trek technobabble I was reading. I believe it is neither, as Star Trek at least succeeds - at times - at suspending disbelief, and that article doesn't.

More fundamentally, even the content made sense, it would still be flawed due to how it is designed: it is a collection of criticisms against several other theories. It is attempting to say that because some other proposals are not fully satisfying, then they're totally wrong, and Electric Comet is thus the only alternative. That's commonly defined as fundamentalism, not science.
 
The usual stupid "debate over the dirty snowball model" delusion

So why do we still debate over the "dirtysnowball" model?
21 May 2018: The usual stupid "debate over the dirty snowball model" delusion.
The "debate" is about how much ices comets have in comparison to their dust. That is largely settled as more (up to a 6 to 1 ratio as in 67P) ices than dust in an average comet.

21 May 2018: Persistent lie about "Whipple's model" by data from ices and dust comets.

21 May 2018: Insane delusion that RPC-MAG data will show that there is no sublimation on comets.
RPC
RPC (Rosetta Plasma Consortium). In this instrument, five sensors measure the physical properties of the nucleus, examine the structure of the inner coma, monitor cometary activity, and study the comet's interaction with the solar wind.
The Fluxgate Magnetometer (MAG) studied the coma.

21 May 2018: Insane lie that data was forced to fit the model, i.e. faked.

21 May 2018: Delusion that "electric currents" are his electric comet delusions.

21 May 2018: Mindless parroting of the liar Wal Thornhill's insanity that tales are long and so support ignorant comet delusions.
Comet tail
While the solid nucleus of comets is generally less than 50 km across, the coma may be larger than the Sun, and ion tails have been observed to extend 3.8 astronomical units (570 Gm; 350×106 mi).[6]

The Ulysses spacecraft made an unexpected pass through the tail of the comet C/2006 P1 (Comet McNaught), on February 3, 2007.[7] Evidence of the encounter was published in the October 1, 2007 issue of the Astrophysical Journal.[8]
More than 948 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies from 6 July 2009 to 10 May 2018

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
I am using the Rosetta RPC-MAG data, and I study how the magnetic field behaves. First one looks at the data, what do they show, which is all model independent because it is data, it is real (apart from maybe minimal calibration errors). After finding out all there is to see in the data, then you can start working on an interpretation.

I’ll just leave that statement here until the new papers are published. :D

Should be any day now.
 
I’ll just leave that statement here until the new papers are published. :D

Should be any day now.

Lol. This should be interesting. A plasma astrophysicist's paper against a woo merchant who believes Earth used to orbit Saturn! And Venus was spat out of Jupiter! And that craters are due to some sort of electrical woo! And that the Sun is a giant lightbulb powered by an invisible incoming current! Et boring cetera.
Sorry, but there are probably forums where one can discuss the validity of EU lunacy as compared to, say, Jack and The Beanstalk. Neither seem likely in my view. Which is why nobody with an IQ above that of a brain damaged trilobite believes such nonsense. Eh?
 
I need to apologise for the previous remark. Maybe trilobites weren't so stupid. Perhaps I am comparing Thornhill, et al., to creatures that were way beyond them. Scott, Thornhill, Talbott, et al. possibly need to be relegated to the intelligence level of prokaryotes. Seems more fitting. Science is way beyond them. Eh, Sol? Bit thick aren't they?
 
Talking about prokaryotes, welcome back jd116!

New paper out Coma morphology of comet 67P controlled by insolation over irregular nucleus

"Outbursts can often be traced back to a small area on the surface where suddenly frozen water is exposed, for example due to a landslide," explains Dr. Holger Sierks from the MPS, OSIRIS Principal Investigator. "In the case of cometary activity at sunrise, this is different. The frost is distributed fairly evenly over the entire surface." But then why do the gas and dust emissions form jets? Why do they not create a completely homogeneous cloud?

The new study shows for the first time that mainly the unusual shape and jagged topography of the comet are responsible for this phenomenon.

In addition, the new study investigates the influence of the observation geometry. "Basically, every cometary coma is a three-dimensional structure, and each shot of it is just a projection," Sierks says. "Our images can therefore easily give a false impression.

You'd have to be a prokaryote to believe that. After all this time and data the BEST they could come up with is it's the rugged shape of the nucleus that collimates the "jets"! :bigclap

:eusa_liar:
 
You'd have to be a prokaryote to believe that. After all this time and data the BEST they could come up with is it's the rugged shape of the nucleus that collimates the "jets"!

And they have the math and modeling to prove it, more than any EC proponent has ever shown. doi:10.1038/s41550-018-0481-5
 
So does Yu. V. Skorov1, L. Rezac1, P. Hartogh1 and H. U. Keller2 10.1051/0004-6361/201630000
math not count?

Conclusions. In the framework of the presented model, which can be considered common in terms of assumptions and physical parameters in the cometary community, the dust removal by a gas drag force is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding to 1.3 AU. A way out of this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.

The paper Coma morphology of comet 67P controlled by insolation over irregular nucleus is complete crap.

It's NOT what the data is saying, is it tusenfem?
First one looks at the data, what do they show, which is all model independent because it is data, it is real (apart from maybe minimal calibration errors). After finding out all there is to see in the data, then you can start working on an interpretation.

I can completely discredit it using NO MATHAMAGICS at all!

Shameful 1Max-Planck-Institut für Sonnensystemforschung, Göttingen, Germany. 2Institut für Geophysik und extraterrestrische Physik (IGEP), Technische
Universität Braunschweig, Braunschweig, Germany. 3Deutsches Zentrum für Luft- und Raumfahrt (DLR), Institut für Planetenforschung, Asteroiden
und Kometen, Berlin, Germany. 4PI-DSMC, Sindelfingen, Germany. 5INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico, Trieste, Italy. 6LESIA, Observatoire de Paris, PSL
Research University, CNRS, Univ. Paris Diderot, Sorbonne Paris Cité, UPMC Univ. Paris 06, Sorbonne Universités, Meudon Principal Cedex, France. 7NASA
Ames Research Center, Moffett Field, CA, USA. 8Department of Astronomy, University of Maryland, College Park, MD, USA. 9Department of Physics
and Astronomy, University of Padova, Padova, Italy. 10Laboratoire Atmosphères, Milieux et Observations Spatiales, CNRS & Université de Versailles
Saint-Quentin-en-Yvelines, Guyancourt, France. 11Centro de Astrobiologia, CSIC-INTA, Madrid, Spain. 12International Space Science Institute, Bern,
Switzerland. 13Scientific Support Office, European Space Research and Technology Centre/ESA, Noordwijk ZH, The Netherlands. 14INAF, Osservatorio
Astronomico di Padova, Padova, Italy. 15CNR-IFN UOS Padova LUXOR, Padova, Italy. 16Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Pasadena, CA, USA. 17Department of
Industrial Engineering, University of Padova, Padova, Italy. 18University of Trento, Faculty of Engineering, Trento, Italy. 19Aix Marseille Université, CNRS,
LAM (Laboratoire d’Astrophysique de Marseille) UMR 7326, Marseille, France. 20Instituto de Astrofísica de Andalucía -CSIC, Glorieta de la Astronomia,
Granada, Spain. 21Graduate Institute of Astronomy, National Central University, Chung-Li, Taiwan. 22Operations Department, European Space Astronomy
Centre/ESA, Villanueva de la Cañada (Madrid), Spain. 23Department of Physics and Astronomy “G. Galilei”, University of Padova, Padova, Italy. 24Center of
Studies and Activities for Space, CISAS, ‘G. Colombo’, University of Padova, Padova, Italy. 25MTA CSFK Konkoly Observatory, Budapest, Hungary
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
And what, may I ask you Sol88, does anything in your last few posts have to with the ELECTRIC COMET model?

You know, what this thread is about.
 
So does Yu. V. Skorov1, L. Rezac1, P. Hartogh1 and H. U. Keller2 10.1051/0004-6361/201630000
math not count?

I did not comment on that, but Skorov's model apparently cannot explain that some of the dust escapes by gas drag. BUT that is Skorov's model, there are other models. His math may be good, but maybe he does not take everything into account in his model.

The paper Coma morphology of comet 67P controlled by insolation over irregular nucleus is complete crap.

Sure it is, maybe you should write a corrective paper to Nature Astronomy, and show how it is supposed to work.

It's NOT what the data is saying, is it tusenfem?

It is not what WHICH data are saying. You mean that those pictures of dust streams are photoshopped or something? I have not the foggiest what you are complaining about.

I can completely discredit it using NO MATHAMAGICS at all!

Sure you can.


Whatever
 
Knee slapping hilarity!!!

Yu. V. Skorov

So who's wrong?

Just get it in your mind, Skorov's model cannot explain how the dust gets from the surface through gas drag.
We see that dust is coming from the surface, so apparently if Skorov's model cannot explain that, then there is something wrong, and when other people CAN model the escape of the dust from the surface, then they are apparently doing something correctly, knee slapping so even.

The picture is rather clear.
 
Last edited:
Usual lies about a ices and dust comet paper to derail from his many comet delusions

25 May 2018: Usual lies about a ices and dust comet paper to derail from his many comet delusions.

A lie of "jets" - there are real jets. The paper is valid science by smart people.

The electric comet is insanely ignorant delusions and lies from brain dead cultists and their followers, e.g. almost 9 years here of not understanding that 0.6 g/cc is less than 3.0 g/cc.

More than 948 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies from 6 July 2009 to 10 May 2018

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.

18 November 2010: The lies, failures and successes of Thunderbolts Deep Impact predictions by Wal Thornhill
2 December 2014: Sol88 does not notice that Wal Thornhill narrates an ignorant and deluded video about 67P!
18 December 2014: The bad science and delusions in Newton’s Electric Clockwork Solar System by Wal Thornhill.
5 January 2015: Wal Thornhill makes up fantasies about comets
10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.
13 April 2018: A couple of the delusions in Scott's Birkeland current paper.

The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it!

Getting lose to 3 years of the fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.
 
Continues to lie about the Skorov et. al paper

So does Yu. V. Skorov1, L. Rezac1, P. Hartogh1 and H. U. Keller2 10.1051/0004-6361/201630000
25 May 2018: Continues to lie about the Skorov et. al paper.
The paper is that their model does not predict dust grains of sizes <1 mm lifted by gas drag and thus there must be other scientific mechanisms to explain the fact that these dust grains appear in the coma.

Anyone with a couple of brain cells knows an obvious, possible mechanism. Their model predict that large dust grains are lifted and some of these might fragment to make small dust grains.

Another option is that the Skorov et. al paper results are just wrong, e.g. the model has an non-realistic assumption that invalidates it.

Skorov et. al is not about jets. The paper Coma morphology of comet 67P controlled by insolation over irregular nucleus is about jets :eye-poppi.

25 May 2018: A delusion that he can invalidate published science when it takes deep stupidity to believe in his many comet delusions and the lies, etc. of the Thunderbolts cult.

More than 948 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies from 6 July 2009 to 10 May 2018

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.

18 November 2010: The lies, failures and successes of Thunderbolts Deep Impact predictions by Wal Thornhill
10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.
13 April 2018: A couple of the delusions in Scott's Birkeland current paper.

The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it!

Getting lose to 3 years of the fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom