Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
So back to your mostly dust jets, crazy.

Do you have a link to this claim?

Can sublimation of volatile ice/s remove dust from the surface?
 
I note that you always write "ice/s", Sol88. What does that "/s" stand for? I guess you mean "H2O ice mixed with some other frozen material"? If so, what material(s) would it be?
 
Thanks RC

I thought they maybe the papers you'd reference.

i note though mainstream are still working on the problem.

It is conceivable, for example, that under the surface of the comet there are cavities filled with compressed gas. Upon sunrise, the radiation begins to warm the overlying surface, cracks develop and the gas escapes. According to another theory, deposits of amorphous ice beneath the surface play a decisive role. In this type of frozen water, the individual molecules are not aligned in a lattice-like structure, as is customary in the case of crystalline ice, but arranged in a far more disorderly fashion. Since the crystalline state is energetically more favorable, energy is released during the transition from amorphous to crystalline ice. Energy input through sunlight can start this transformation.

Exactly which process took place on 3 July of last year is still unclear. "There’s a particular focus now within the Rosetta science community on looking to combine data from 67P with modelling, simulations, and laboratory work here on Earth, to address the question of what drives such activity on comets”, says Dr. Matt Taylor, Rosetta Project Scientist at ESA.

and from the earlier paper
Another possibility is the direct sublimation of pockets of volatile ices like carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide below the surface, heated by the warmth of sunlight penetrating an insulating top layer of dust.

Alternatively, sublimation could be driven by the energy liberated by water ice changing its physical state from amorphous to crystalline then sublimating the more volatile surrounding carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide ices.

CONCERT ruled out cavities I believe? Is this correct RC?

Which leaves one other mainstream option...

Prediction: This last option, state change in water ice, is a dead end.

...AND

We have this 'ol chestnut
Conclusions. In the framework of the presented model, which can be considered common in terms of assumptions and physical parameters in the cometary community, the dust removal by a gas drag force is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding
to 1.3 AU. A way out of this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community
Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-GerasimenkoYu. V. Skorov

Which pretty much leaves nix, for options on jets in general let alone Dr. Jessica Agarwal's July 3, 2016 jet.
 
Last edited:
I note that you always write "ice/s", Sol88. What does that "/s" stand for? I guess you mean "H2O ice mixed with some other frozen material"? If so, what material(s) would it be?

Ice/s are in general Water, Carbon Dioxide and Carbon Monoxide.

These are the ice/s earmarked as the drivers of cometary jet activity.

See Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Yu. V. Skorov

There are plenty of other ice's majicaly mixed in the the main ice/s.

Inventory of the volatiles on comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko from Rosetta/ROSINA

Question is, how are they mixed with the main ice/s?

Coating on dust grains? Individual grains?
 
IMO JeanTate is doing a fine job of keeping the discussion on-topic; let's not encourage discussion of OT mainstream theories.
 
Ice/s are in general Water, Carbon Dioxide and Carbon Monoxide.

These are the ice/s earmarked as the drivers of cometary jet activity.


So, just to be sure I understand what you mean, whenever you write "ice/s", you actually mean "main cometary volatiles" (H2O, CO and CO2) in solid state?

Are other minority volatiles (like methanol) in solid state also covered by your use of the term "ice/s" ? Or just the three main ones?

Sorry if those questions sound dumb, but I think removing any possible confusion in the use of terms is a preliminary must of any scientific discussion.

Oh, and I don't want to sound like a jerk, but I'm not interested in derailing to other questions related to mixing with other material and such - at this point, I'm only interested in understanding the terminology used. And I'm not interested in links to external papers either at this stage. I just wanted your own definition of the term.

In any case, thanks in advance for your answer!
 
Thanks Sol88.

I have little time, again, today, so an update of the “Sol88 approved ELECTRIC COMET model” will have to wait, as will my responses to your other, recent, posts. On Saturday or Sunday.
Ummm... you do know what broadband means in relation to the EM spectrum, don’t you?

So go back and read my answer to your question again.
You might want to reconsider this, and post a somewhat different response.

As it stands, I read your two posts - responses to JT05 - to permit ~three different, logical next questions:

A typo, wrong word/phrase, not what you intended at all.

Standard meaning, leading to questions like “when did Huawei instal WiMAX base stations on selected comets?”

ELECTRIC COMET model peculiar meaning, totally non-standard, which only you can explain.
 
So, just to be sure I understand what you mean, whenever you write "ice/s", you actually mean "main cometary volatiles" (H2O, CO and CO2) in solid state?

Are other minority volatiles (like methanol) in solid state also covered by your use of the term "ice/s" ? Or just the three main ones?

Sorry if those questions sound dumb, but I think removing any possible confusion in the use of terms is a preliminary must of any scientific discussion.

Oh, and I don't want to sound like a jerk, but I'm not interested in derailing to other questions related to mixing with other material and such - at this point, I'm only interested in understanding the terminology used. And I'm not interested in links to external papers either at this stage. I just wanted your own definition of the term.

In any case, thanks in advance for your answer!

Sol has ignored everything except their own fantasy for many years, they never acknowledge any reality about say about alcohol or VOCs in comets much less polyaromatic hydro carbons.

Sol88 does not believe orbital mechanics can be used to derive object density or even that ice forms exist on earth that even remotely approximate commentary surfaces. Or that plow walls on earth can wreck cars in cold weather.
 
Irrelevancy and the usual lies to derail from the electric comet insanity

I thought they maybe the papers you'd reference.
11 May 2018: Irrelevancy and the usual lies to derail from the electric comet insanity.
The working mainstream comet model is still irrelevant to those insane delusions about comets, e.g. that they are rocks.

Comet sinkholes generate jets is that the electric comet is insanely wrong because these are "electrical discharges" from the walls of pits when school children know they happen from the highest points :eye-poppi.

Rosetta reveals dust jet is that the electric comet is insanely wrong because there are no electrical discharges seen when school children know how obvious lightning is :eye-poppi.

CONCERT ruled out rock and large interior cavities ("that is fairly homogeneous on the scale of tens of metres"). Google 'CONCERT 67P cavities nucleus' to get on the first page:
27 December 2017 Sol88: Idiotic CONCERT/MUPAS lie about 67P.

More than 948 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies from 6 July 2009 to 10 May 2018

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
 
Last edited:
lies about what he wrote, that paper and comets as usual

See Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Yu. V. Skorov
lauwenmark, Sol88 lies about what he wrote, that paper and comets as usual.

Sol88 lies that that "ice/s" is about ices at all.
The electric comet lunacy is that there are no or "minimal" ices on comets. Real comets have had ices detected on their surface. Real comets have measured densities less than that of water. Real comets have water ice grains blasted off them in an impact (Deep impact on Comet Tempel 1). Real comets issue gases that come from sublimated ices. Sol88 lies by putting ices in quotes when ices really exist.

Sol88 lies about the Skorov, et. al paper being about jets.
Dust can be lifted from the surface of comet nuclei by jets. The jet are caused by several mechanisms. We have seen them issuing from the walls of pits on 67P. We have traced then to fractured cliff walls. We have traced them to dust-covered plains. None of this is the subject of that paper!
Skorov, et. al. wrote about a model of the sublimation of ices on the surface lifting dust grains which is not cometary jets. Skorov, et. al. does not support the insanity of comets being rocks. Skorov, et. al. suggests modification of mainstream assumptions.
Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-GerasimenkoYu. V. Skorov, et. al.
Context. Mainly for historical reasons, nearly all of the current thermophysical models of dust activity rely on the poorly justified assumption of cohesionless dust lifted by a gas drag force against the weak nucleus gravity. The interpretation of Rosetta data and our understanding of comet activity is particularly sensitive to this assumption.

Aims. We investigate the role that cohesion forces among the dust grains play in the evolution of temperature and pressure at the ice-dust interface and the resulting dust activity (lifting).

Methods. We used a 1D thermophysical numerical model that provides a realistic description of cohesion forces among dust aggregates. Several conditions of solar illumination on the nucleus are investigated for the H2O, CO, and CO2 ices below the dust layer. We examine a wide range of dust grain sizes.

Results. The simulations confirm an increase in temperature and pressure at the ice boundary between the two model layers with respect to exposed pure ice. Furthermore, we show that a non-monotonic behavior of temperature and pressure versus layer thickness is expected at the ice-dust interface for fine aggregates (of sizes ≤30 μm), but not for the larger grains. The ratio of vapor pressure to the physically determined tensile strength for various agglomerate sizes and layer thicknesses provides further evidence that the gas drag is not sufficient to remove dust grains of sizes <1 mm, which is a result of taking cohesion forces among the particles into account.

Conclusions. In the framework of the presented model, which can be considered common in terms of assumptions and physical parameters in the cometary community, the dust removal by a gas drag force is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding to 1.3 AU. A way out of this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.
Skorov, et. al. is not the implied lie of no dust from real comets. What the results of the model are is that dust grains of sizes <1 mm are not lifted by gas drag. If the model is correct then small dust grains are lifted or created by other mechanisms.

Sol88 lies about that paper being relevant to this thread.
The topic of this thread has been pointed out to him many times. This thread is about the electric comet lunacy. There have been futile attempts over many years to explain the real physics of comets to him but he has "drunk the Kool-Aid" of the electric comet cult.
The fallacy of false dichotomy has been pointed out to him any times. We have working science about comets that fits the observations. He has ignorant and even insane fantasies about comets that have no supporting observations.

Sol88 lies about "majicaly mixed". The formation of comets from a mixture of gases automatically means a mixture of ices.
 
Last edited:
So, just to be sure I understand what you mean, whenever you write "ice/s", you actually mean "main cometary volatiles" (H2O, CO and CO2) in solid state?

Are other minority volatiles (like methanol) in solid state also covered by your use of the term "ice/s" ? Or just the three main ones?

Sorry if those questions sound dumb, but I think removing any possible confusion in the use of terms is a preliminary must of any scientific discussion.

Oh, and I don't want to sound like a jerk, but I'm not interested in derailing to other questions related to mixing with other material and such - at this point, I'm only interested in understanding the terminology used. And I'm not interested in links to external papers either at this stage. I just wanted your own definition of the term.

In any case, thanks in advance for your answer!

H20, CO and CO2 are suspected by the mainstream as the 3 main drivers of cometary activity e.g. Jets from ices sublimating entraining the dust with it.

I guess the others volatiles are also solid, including oxygen.

So we have shed loads of Hydogen, Oxygen and Carbon and strong electric fields.
 
Why "ice/s", and not just "ices"?


Why ice at all???

The mainstream require the ice to be there somewhere.... :blush:

Meanwhile over on the ELECTRIC COMET, we have rock.

Happy to call it ices if we can reference this thread again in the future to clarify what we are talking about.

Though to be fair we really only talk about water ice as the main driver.
 
Sol has ignored everything except their own fantasy for many years, they never acknowledge any reality about say about alcohol or VOCs in comets much less polyaromatic hydro carbons.

Sol88 does not believe orbital mechanics can be used to derive object density or even that ice forms exist on earth that even remotely approximate commentary surfaces. Or that plow walls on earth can wreck cars in cold weather.


:D:D :thumbsup:

Or that the engineers designing the Philea lander EXPECTED and ICY SURFACE!

I’m sure they lived somewhere where it is very cold and were fully aware of how hard ice can be.

But rock is harder... :p
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom