The certainty of God's existence.

Wrong, wrong, wrong. Gods realm is not this universe. God created this universe to run on natural law. God is a spirit, and God lives in an atemporal realm. God is or can be omnipotent in his realm. Our universe is designed to run on rules of probability and uncertainty,

It's a sweet fairy tale and all, and it's amusing to see you relegate God to an unnecessary being (now that people have explained why your whole 'one universe, one try' theory is unsupported). The only place left for your God to hide is in some other ill-defined dimension.
 
Pure agent, are you and Pixi born from the same seed? Your styles the same, in more ways than one. No insult intended its a serious question.

; {>

No idea. I don't know anyone on this forum in real life, so for all I know Pixy could by my brother. Or sister. Or whatever. I'm a little fuzzy as to the genders of the majority of the members here.
But if you're implying that one of us is a sock puppet, then I must disappoint you. I must point out the following differences in our posts:

- Pixy tends to slice up quotations, making a break whenever he/she sees a logical fallacy. I wait until the end of the paragraph or sentence to jump in.
- Pixy favors one- or two-word replies, generally making a list of the logical fallacies in whatever sentence he/she is currently analyzing. My replies are wordier.
- I mock. Pixy doesn't.
 
Maybe much older than 5k, I don't agree with the traditional bibical dating in some areas.
Technically, there is only a little over five thousand years of history, since history began with the invention of writing.

But that's just by the by. I have no idea what you think you are talking about here. There is no historical evidence for the existence of the God of Abraham whatsoever.
 
No idea. I don't know anyone on this forum in real life, so for all I know Pixy could by my brother. Or sister.
I'm pretty sure that neither of my siblings has played Castlevania, so probably not. :)

- Pixy tends to slice up quotations, making a break whenever he/she sees a logical fallacy. I wait until the end of the paragraph or sentence to jump in.
Known as "fisking", after Robert Fisk, a reporter given to filing hopelessly inaccurate or fallacy-ridden stories, and thus a target for exactly this sort of counterargument.

When the poster in question is making an interesting (but wrong) point or is partly correct, I'll provide a longer and more in depth response, or ask questions to elicit further details. I don't know everything, and I'm not always right.

When the poster in question does nothing but regurgitate fallacies, though, fisking is in order.

Or, failing that, Pixying: :notm

- Pixy favors one- or two-word replies, generally making a list of the logical fallacies in whatever sentence he/she is currently analyzing. My replies are wordier.
Both are valid.

It's useful to make an analysis of the argument as a whole, but it is also useful to point out all the individual fallacies. If an argument contains 97 individual fallacies, there's not much of a whole to address.

- I mock. Pixy doesn't.
I like to stand back and allow my opponents to do that to themselves. ;)
 
Last edited:
Maybe much older than 5k, I don't agree with the traditional bibical dating in some areas.
; {>

Using the Bible to establish dates for historical events is fraught with problems. On rare occasions Biblical references can be cross referenced with extra-Biblical sources such as the Merneptah Stele, but all in all there is little in the Bible that has been independently corroborated. Just because a text written in the sixth century B.C.E. talks about the creation of the world, and some other clerics attempt to establish a date in history for this creation by counting generations in a genealogy doesn't make the book of Genesis a historical account of the creation of the universe.

At the very best, Biblical history can go back to around 1375 B.C.E. when the Shasu people of southern Canaan may have worshiped a god that developed into the god of Abraham.
 
Because it's true.
Does your god have any real evidence for its existence?

Yes along with the bible which scholars have deemed accurate.

The holy book that you claim serves as evidence for its existence... doesn't. Circular logic to say that the Bible, written by men inspired by god, proves that god exists. It doesn't.

There are cosmological arguments and others (24 ontological arguments in all I think). How many have we covered here? Umm' one and a half? Then there are many other evidences. BTW there is no tangible evidence for a spirit, go figure! No worries, circumstantial evidence will get you executed and sometimes circumstantial evidence is all we have. BTW we have been over all of this many times before. It gets so old to hear the lie repeated that there is no evidence to the existence of God. There are tons of it.

Your god also has NO archaeological evidence to back it up. You may not believe me, but all the evidence for the truth of the Bible - what little there is of it - has been debunked.

The reason I don't believe you is because its wishful thinking. If you had proof you would post it. Please show your sources where the archeological evidence of biblical events etc has been debunked. And there is too much to list in this page.

There is no archaeological evidence that supports the Bible.
Scholarly backing matters very little.

Spoken like a true atheist apologist. I mean really any sane person reading something like that would belly laugh you.

These men who support the existence of God are biased by their beliefs.

Again pure comedy. Yes some are Christian apologists but many are professional archeologists. And they all publish in the same professional journals etc, you simply are just making this up I would like to see you verify these statements with sources. I have asked that many times only to be ignored.

They ignore the evidence - or lack of it - that says that there is no God.

Is that the punch line? What evidence? Give me a source.

It's been said before, but I'll say it again. The Flying Spaghetti Monster is not real. That is the entire POINT of the Flying Spaghetti Monster argument. The argument goes like this:

THEIST: "God exists.">>Brevity snip<<<
i Monster exists, too?"

It may help you to learn what you are arguing against before you make baseless claims about it.

Again I have evidence for the existence of God so your whole argument is an exercise in bad comedy. God exists get used to that fact. We have evidence, this isn't the 1920's where you can make unsupported baseless claims and statements and hope people believe you. The only people that will believe you are the atheist apologists. And that they would believe unsupported incredible claims demonstrates how desperate they have become in the last ten to twenty years.

; {>
 
Last edited:
Again I have evidence for the existence of God so your whole argument is an exercise in bad comdey.


Do you have any evidence to support that statement? Your "evidence" based on cosmology wouldn't be any use in the context of your objection to the FSM analogy as it would equally be evidence for any other creator god, including the FSM. Your "evidence" from the Bible relies on circular reasoning. Got anything else?
 
God exists get used to that fact. We have evidence {>

I'm coming to this thread cold having not read the previous 46 pages in their entirety so I hope you will grant me a little leeway if I'm repeating.

I'm pleased to hear that someone finally has evidence of the existence of God, I hadn't previously seen any.

Could you help me out here? I don't want to go through the whole gamut of info you have so could you outline lets say your Top 3 pieces of evidence?

I'm waiting to be converted here.
 
So not only do you not trust science, you don't trust your own holy book? Where the hell do you get your information from, then?

As I have said I came to my faith by science. The bible is accurate what does that have to do with anything? Its how one interpenetrates the bible where problems can begin. That was one of the driving forces of why I took Theology in school, to learn how to interpret the original manuscripts and the methods used etc. You on the other hand seem to guess and interject wishful thinking as fact in your answers. I am waiting as I type this for verification of the wild claims you made a couple of posts ago.....

; {>
 
Do you have any evidence to support that statement? Your "evidence" based on cosmology wouldn't be any use in the context of your objection to the FSM analogy as it would equally be evidence for any other creator god, including the FSM. Your "evidence" from the Bible relies on circular reasoning. Got anything else?

Wrong. If the FSM had the attributes of my God he or it would be God. Call it what you want (as you aren't standing in front of me).

All the other reasons I gave would support my claims. Please explain why relying on the bible relies on circular reasoning? That is a atheistic apologetic internet lie. And I might add its one of the dumbest one that I have heard in some time. I would of thought that some one with European blood in them would do better than that.

Lastly what religion if any do you practice? Its remarkable how quite everyone has been when I ask that. What are you all' afraid of?

; {>
 
Yes along with the bible which scholars have deemed accurate.
Yes what?

And what scholars have deemed what parts of the Bible to be accurate about what, and what is their evidence for these claims?

There are cosmological arguments
There are cosmological argument-like-objects.

and others 24 in all I think.
None of which are sound or constitute evidence.

Then there is many other evidences.
"Evidences"?

Anyway, name one of these... Evidences.

BTW there is no tangible evidence for a spirit, go figure!
Special pleading.

No worries, circumstantial evidence will get you executed and sometimes that's all we have.
False.

BTW we have been over all of this many times before.
Yes, we have. And you're still wrong.

It gets so old to hear the lie repeated that there is no evidence to the existence of God. There are tons of it.
Then why are you unable to present any?

The reason I don't believe you is because its wishful thinking. If you had proof you would post it. Please show your sources where the archeological evidence of biblical events etc has been debunked. And there is too much to list in this page.
What archeological evidence of biblical events?

Spoken like a true atheist apologist.
Ad hominem.

I mean really any sane person reading something like that would belly laugh you.
Ad hominem.

Scholarly backing, in and of itself, doesn't matter. Scholarly backing supported by evidence would matter. It's the evidence that counts.

Again pure comedy. Yes some are Christian apologists but many are professional archeologists. And they all publish in the same professional journals etc, you simply are just making this up I would like to see you verify these statements with sources. I have asked that many times only to be ignored.
What professional archeologists have produced evidence supporting what Biblical events, and how is this evidence for the existence of God?

Again I have evidence for the existence of God so your whole argument is an exercise in bad comedy.
Then present this evidence.

God exists get used to that fact.
Bare assertion.

We have evidence
Curiously, there is no evidence for this evidence.

this isn't the 1920's where you can make unsupported baseless claims and statements and hope people believe you.
Apparently, it is.

The only people that will believe you are the atheist apologists.
Strawman, tu quoque, ad hominem.

And that they would believe unsupported incredible claims demonstrates how desperate they have become in the last ten to twenty years.
Strawman, tu quoque, ad hominem, argumentum ad populum.
 
I'm coming to this thread cold having not read the previous 46 pages in their entirety so I hope you will grant me a little leeway if I'm repeating.

I'm pleased to hear that someone finally has evidence of the existence of God, I hadn't previously seen any.

Could you help me out here? I don't want to go through the whole gamut of info you have so could you outline lets say your Top 3 pieces of evidence?

I'm waiting to be converted here.

I don't need any more converts, I have a full house. Come back later ...please.

If you are serious e mail me I always can make room for one more Templar knight at the table.

; {>

Or I will look for the posts where there is point and counter point...I don't have time just now....
 
Last edited:
As I have said I came to my faith by science.
What science?

The bible is accurate what does that have to do with anything?
What part of the Bible is accurate about what, and what is your evidence for this?

Its how one interpenetrates the bible where problems can begin.
Personally, I read the Bible rather than interpenetrating it.

That was one of the driving forces of why I took Theology in school, to learn how to interpret the original manuscripts and the methods used etc.
Well, there's your problem!

You on the other hand seem to guess and interject wishful thinking as fact in your answers.
Strawman, tu quoque.
 
I don't need any more converts, I have a full house. Come back later ...please.
So you don't actually have this evidence you just claimed you have?

If you are serious e mail me I always can make room for one more Templar knight at the table.
I'm serious.

If you have evidence, present it.

If you don't have evidence, don't claim that you do.
 
Yes what?

And what scholars have deemed what parts of the Bible to be accurate about what, and what is their evidence for these claims?>>>>Whao whap..damn DP gnats...brevity snip<<<
Strawman, tu quoque, ad hominem, argumentum ad populum.

Pixi you are so aggravating that I almost like you, at least you are consistent.

Gotta go folks .....

; {>

ps

Hi the fair of fairest Pam! I have to walk bogie...as you can see I am a bit feeling better...Will e mail you soon...
 
Wrong. If the FSM had the attributes of my God he or it would be God. Call it what you want (as you aren't standing in front of me).

; {>

We don't call your god(s) FSM. We don't claim FSM is a god.

Here's a dictionary entry on analogy. Please read it and report back that you finally understand.
some learn faster than others.

; {>
Ironic, isn't it?
 
... Please show your sources where the archeological evidence of biblical events etc has been debunked. And there is too much to list in this page. ...

Could you shout me a link to this archeological evidence, please?
 
So bomb me you fake.
And here I thought you wanted polite discourse. Afterall, you claimed to be severely offended at the use of FSM, since you consider it a mockery of god. Well. I guess we are only allowed to not offend YOU. You, however, have no problem offending others.


If your Muslim you are radicalized Muslim and I don't recognize false prophets.
The central belief of all muslims is the "words", "There is no god but Allah, and Muhammad is his prophet."

You're preaching of god and jesus as the son of god is highly offensive. It's like the use of the n-word. You said it yourself, You don't use the N-word arround african americans, so you shouldn't use god or Jesus arround me.

I have many Muslim friends and we all discuss God in the terms I use.

One more thing we all worship the same God genius. Don't you know your own religion?

; {>
This is false.
 
Snip

All the other reasons I gave would support my claims. Please explain why relying on the bible relies on circular reasoning? That is a atheistic apologetic internet lie. And I might add its one of the dumbest one that I have heard in some time. I would of thought that some one with European blood in them would do better than that.

What does having European blood have to do with anything?

Relying on the Bible to prove the existence of God is circular reasoning because you are using the source of the claim as evidence for the claim: Why do you believe in God? Because I believe in the Bible and the Bible says God is real. Why do you believe in the Bible? Because it is the word of God. How do you know it is the word of God? Because it says so in the Bible!

Lastly what religion if any do you practice? Its remarkable how quite everyone has been when I ask that. What are you all' afraid of? ; {>

I'm a Unitarian Universalist. I would guess most of the people you are addressing don't have a religion, so it's not very mysterious that they would be silent on the matter. If you asked them what their philosophy or world-view or life-stance is, some of them might answer, as we have some humanists, buddhists, etc. about. In other words, it's the wrong question, and it's rather obviously the wrong question to be asking atheists. Not to psychoanalyze overmuch, but is there a reason why you would assume that if someone doesn't answer a question it must be because they are afraid of something? My first thought would be that I phrased the question wrong.

I have to say, Rev, you're way more interesting than yrreG, it's too bad he isn't back yet, having you post side-by-side would illustrate how much more responsive you are to comments, and how much more reasonable you are. OTH, having yrreG around may have left me much easier to please when it comes to standards of discussion.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom