Both are valid.
It's useful to make an analysis of the argument as a whole, but it is also useful to point out all the individual fallacies. If an argument contains 97 individual fallacies, there's not much of a whole to address.
Okay, well, since tone of voice is hard to tell on the intertubes, I thought I should make sure that you knew I wasn't knocking your posting style. It's very effective. I would probably do it myself, but I don't know all the names of the different logical fallacies, so I have to explain everything.
Yes along with the bible which scholars have deemed accurate.
Source please.
And what evidence do they use to prove the Bible accurate? It has been hundreds, no, thousands of times that there was no Flood, no Garden, probably no Temple.
There are cosmological arguments and others (24 ontological arguments in all I think). How many have we covered here? Umm' one and a half?
By all means, bring 'em out!
I'm being serious, Rev. I enjoy theological arguments like the ones we have here on Randi. They're interesting. They get the ol' brain muscles workin'. If you have any arguments you haven't used yet, I would really like to hear them.
Then there are many other evidences.
Once again, if you have evidence to support your claims, by all means bring it out!
BTW there is no tangible evidence for a spirit, go figure!
Wait... didn't you just say that there
was evidence for this spirit? Besides that, this is special pleading. You claim that you have evidence for the existence of your god, then say that there can't possibly be any evidence for it because it's not a tangible being. So how do you plan to convince us?
No worries, circumstantial evidence will get you executed and sometimes circumstantial evidence is all we have.
Not exactly sure what this sentence means. Moving on.
BTW we have been over all of this many times before. It gets so old to hear the lie repeated that there is no evidence to the existence of God. There are tons of it.
As I've said, please show us! I'd sincerely like to see it!
The reason I don't believe you is because its wishful thinking. If you had proof you would post it. Please show your sources where the archeological evidence of biblical events etc has been debunked. And there is too much to list in this page.
So there's too much debunking to list on this page, eh? So you support me.
Nah, I know that's not what you mean. So here's what I came up with using about 5 minutes' time on Google:
Debunking the Shroud of Turin
How Archaeology Killed the Bible
Shroud of Turin Debunked (Again)
:/
Most of the search results appear to be about the Shroud, but the second link is very nice. He starts talking about archaeology at 11:42. Of course, I don't normally look up stuff like this, so I don't know any good sites to go to. I'm pretty sure someone else here can give more examples.
Spoken like a true atheist apologist. I mean really any sane person reading something like that would belly laugh you.Again pure comedy. Yes some are Christian apologists but many are professional archeologists. And they all publish in the same professional journals etc, you simply are just making this up I would like to see you verify these statements with sources. I have asked that many times only to be ignored.
For someone who is extremely sensitive to insults, you seem to be quick to hand them out.
Anyway, I realize why you laughed at the first part. I worded it incorrectly. I should have said
Scholarly backing without evidence doesn't matter. But I have posted links above. I suggest watching the videos in the second one.
Is that the punch line? What evidence? Give me a source.
Given above.
Again I have evidence for the existence of God so your whole argument is an exercise in bad comedy.
Once again, please, give us this evidence so we can see it! If God really does exist, you're leaving us out in the cold by not convincing us!
God exists get used to that fact.
Bare assertion.
We have evidence, this isn't the 1920's where you can make unsupported baseless claims and statements and hope people believe you.
Yet this is exactly what you are doing when you refuse to show us your evidence.
The only people that will believe you are the atheist apologists. And that they would believe unsupported incredible claims demonstrates how desperate they have become in the last ten to twenty years.
Replace "atheist" with "Christian" in that sentence and you are 100% correct.
As I have said I came to my faith by science.
But you have said that science is superseded by the Bible.
The bible is accurate what does that have to do with anything?
First of all, it is not accurate. I have given you links above to show why it is not accurate.
Secondly, it is extremely important. The greater part of your argument is based upon the truth of the Bible and its teachings.
Its how one interpenetrates the bible where problems can begin. That was one of the driving forces of why I took Theology in school, to learn how to interpret the original manuscripts and the methods used etc.
If you took a pro-Christian theology course, then your opinion is most likely biased. You cannot be expected to make neutral statements.
You on the other hand seem to guess and interject wishful thinking as fact in your answers.
Can you give us some examples of where we have guessed or used wishful thinking? Links to the posts? If we are guilty of this, show us where and we will attempt to correct it.
And right back at you.
I am waiting as I type this for verification of the wild claims you made a couple of posts ago.....
; {>
Once again, given above.
Wrong. If the FSM had the attributes of my God he or it would be God.
Aren't you made in God's image? Therefore, you have the attributes of God. Therefore, you are God. Seriously, RevDisturba, this is nonsense. The nature of God is ineffable; how do you know that God doesn't choose to manifest himself as a flying spaghetti monster?
Call it what you want (as you aren't standing in front of me).
Ooh, death threats. We're really respecting you now.
All the other reasons I gave would support my claims. Please explain why relying on the bible relies on circular reasoning? That is a atheistic apologetic internet lie. And I might add its one of the dumbest one that I have heard in some time.
It is very much circular reasoning, and it is not a lie. You use the Bible to prove that God exists. But the Bible is only true if God exists. You assume what you are trying to prove. Therefore, circular logic.
I would of thought that some one with European blood in them would do better than that.
How do you know I have European blood? I could be living in Fiji for all you know.
Lastly what religion if any do you practice? Its remarkable how quite everyone has been when I ask that. What are you all' afraid of?
Well, first of all, we're atheists. Although many of us used to practice Christianity, or some variant of it. I myself am a former Roman Catholic.
But I am not "afraid" of religion. I simply choose not to practice it because it lacks evidence to support it. I am, however, afraid of needles. Urgh... just the thought of it makes me go oogy.
I was simply asking if you and PA were brother and sister.
; {>
Then let us put your mind at ease. I know no one on this forum in real life (well, my dad used to be on here, but I don't think he is any more, and anyway I know his username).
How is it racist? All races are represented in Europe? You have never heard of Teutonic engineering meaning good engineering? Reaching aren't we? I am sorry it still is dumb.
; {>
Yes. It was a dumb comment. It is one that made this entire forum's respect of you drop by several levels.
So, to summarize, RevDisturba:
- Links to debunking of Biblical archaeological claims have been given. Please watch the second one, starting at 11:42.
- I am not Pixy's brother (were that I was so lucky...).
- Using the Bible to prove God's existence is, indeed, circular logic.
- Please give us your evidence! I really am interested to hear it!