The certainty of God's existence.

Wrong. If the FSM had the attributes of my God he or it would be God.
Your "wrong" is wrong.

This has been pointed out to you before, and you've acknowledged it as a gap in your argument, and never properly addressed it. Even if there were evidence for a creator, that would not in itself support Christian theology over any other religion or philosophy that posited a created. Such as Pastafarianism.

All the other reasons I gave would support my claims.
Except that none of them actualy stand up to even cursory examination.

Please explain why relying on the bible relies on circular reasoning?
Why should we think that anything written in the Bible is correct? It's certainly not accurate with regard to established historical fact.

That is a atheistic apologetic internet lie.
Ad hominem.

And I might add its one of the dumbest one that I have heard in some time.
Ad hominem.

I would of thought that some one with European blood in them would do better than that.
What the hell?

No, seriously, RevD, what was that there? To me, it looks exactly like the sort of blatant racism you were falsely comparing to the notion of the Flying Spaghetti Monster.

Lastly what religion if any do you practice?
I'm an ignostic. And no, that is not a typo.

Its remarkable how quite everyone has been when I ask that.
It would be unremarkable even if it were true. Which - of course - it isn't.

What are you all' afraid of?
Ad hominem, strawman.
 
Last edited:
The bible is accurate...
Just off the top of my head...

The author of Mark makes a number of errors regarding the geography of first century Palestine. He also makes errors regarding Jewish custom.

The Authors of Luke and Matthew give two completely different genealogies of Joseph the husband of Mary.

The book of Job mentions pillars of heaven. This reflects the common belief among many ancient cultures of the region that the sky was supported above the Earth by pillars or mountains.

Genesis contains copies of two traditional versions of the creation narrative that each give a different order of creation.

How many children did Saul's daughter Michal have, zero or five?

Did those with Saul at his conversion hear a voice?

There is no archaeological evidence to support the tale of the Hebrew's bloody invasion and genocide of Canaan. Archaeological evidence supports the theory that there was actually a revolution that grew out of a class struggle between the ruling elites and the working class.
 
Last edited:
Wrong. If the FSM had the attributes of my God he or it would be God. Call it what you want (as you aren't standing in front of me).


But if you want to exclude the FSM, you need to provide evidence that supports your god while excluding the FSM. Merely stating (or even proving, which you have so far failed to do) that the universe must have been designed by a benevolent being would fit either.

Are the words in the parenthesis intended to be some sort of threat, by the way?

Please explain why relying on the bible relies on circular reasoning?


Because the Bible relies on being the word of God for its authority. It presupposes God's existence.

Lastly what religion if any do you practice? Its remarkable how quite everyone has been when I ask that. What are you all' afraid of?


None. And nothing (not even your threats).

It's remarkable that anyone piggybacking on Yrreg's threads could have missed that the people Yrreg is arguing with are people who don't believe in gods.
 
I would of thought that some one with European blood in them would do better than that.
Why, are Europeans racially superior to non-Europeans?

It's hard to imagine a context in which such a statement doesn't have racist connotations. This is especially ironic given your attempts to equate the use of an argument by analogy with racist slurs. However I'm willing to give you the benefit of the doubt and reserve judgment until you've had the opportunity to explain how this is not a racist remark.

Lastly what religion if any do you practice? Its remarkable how quite everyone has been when I ask that. What are you all' afraid of?
You've asked that a lot? Well, the obvious conclusion is that they're terrified of you, right?
 
Please explain why relying on the bible relies on circular reasoning?
Because, the bible claims there is a god and then you go forward and use examples from the bible to support that god.

It would be like a person claiming that Huckleberry Finn and Tom Sawyer are real. Then going on to explain that they are friends, and then using the book "The Adventures of Tom Sawyer" to prove this point. Certainly, within the narrative they are friends, but that doesn't mean that they are real.

Same thing with biblical accounts. Unless you have extra-biblical evidence, all you have is boat ride down the Mississippi.

That is a atheistic apologetic internet lie. And I might add, its one of the dumbest one that I have heard in some time.
That's, as been pointed out, is merely an ad hominem attack. You attempt to belittle your opponents through disparaging comments about an argument. However, you failed to offer up any argument that refutes the point.

I would of thought that some one with European blood in them would do better than that.
I think you mean to say:
"I would have thought that someone..."
As in, I would have thought someone who continues to belittle others would be more careful with their grammar.
 
Last edited:
As I have said I came to my faith by science. The bible is accurate what does that have to do with anything? Its how one interpenetrates the bible where problems can begin. That was one of the driving forces of why I took Theology in school, to learn how to interpret the original manuscripts and the methods used etc. You on the other hand seem to guess and interject wishful thinking as fact in your answers.
I can't read your mind or know the thought process you took to get to faith by science. At best science has nothing to say about any religious belief (faith). At worst it puts it all in the dust bin.

I'm not trying to be rude but I came to atheism kicking and screaming and I'm not saying that for rhetorical effect. I mean it. I made a commitment to the truth and all along the journey I had to jettison previously held opinions because they didn't stand to scrutiny and that really bothered me. I wanted to believe. If an objective and honest view of science could lead one to faith I would have it today.

It was my commitment to the truth that brought me to this point in my life. I didn't like atheists or secularists. Everyone I knew and loved believed in god. I liked my associations and friendships more than any complaint I had. I kept going to church for awhile after I no longer beleived.

Please note: my faith in god was strong enough that I paid my own way on a two year mission. I sacrificed much for my faith. I've read Josh McDowells evidence that demands a verdict and other apologetics but in the end it couldn't spackle over the gaping hole that is ostensibly religious truth. There is little to none outside of some historical facts. It's all wishful thinking AKA faith. Which is why the call it faith.

Nuget of wisdom for the day: Beliefs that are verified by science are no longer called faith.

I am waiting as I type this for verification of the wild claims you made a couple of posts ago.....
Perhaps you will have to wait as long as I have had to wait for you.
 
I don't need any more converts, I have a full house. Come back later ...please.

If you are serious e mail me I always can make room for one more Templar knight at the table.

; {>

Or I will look for the posts where there is point and counter point...I don't have time just now....

Should I take that as a no?

A genuine request was made in good faith.

Can you outline your most convincing 3 pieces of evidence?

Presumably it would be rather straightforward for you to do that if it existed.
 
Now Pixy why would you go and say that? Does the FSM have a bible or five thousand years of history to support it ? Do they have archeological evidence to support their existence? Do they have any scholarly backing at all? No...WAIT, come to think about it.... your beloved science supports them as real. And that is incredibly telling of what trusting a con man too far can get you !

; }>

Oh nooes not evidence the bible is true, which parts pray tell?

The bible gives as much credence to god as does The Prisoner of Azhaban to Harry Potter, some ideas can be old and still wrong.
 
Wrong. If the FSM had the attributes of my God he or it would be God. Call it what you want (as you aren't standing in front of me).

All the other reasons I gave would support my claims. Please explain why relying on the bible relies on circular reasoning? That is a atheistic apologetic internet lie. And I might add its one of the dumbest one that I have heard in some time. I would of thought that some one with European blood in them would do better than that.

Lastly what religion if any do you practice? Its remarkable how quite everyone has been when I ask that. What are you all' afraid of?

; {>

Is this an entry in Count the Fallacies?

A racist to boot, figures!
 
It's a sweet fairy tale and all, and it's amusing to see you relegate God to an unnecessary being (now that people have explained why your whole 'one universe, one try' theory is unsupported). The only place left for your God to hide is in some other ill-defined dimension.


Clearly God, heaven, and hell are all parallel universes with alternate laws of physics. The multiverse is proven.

I would of thought that some one with European blood in them would do better than that.


Now I am personally offended.

Lastly what religion if any do you practice?


I do not practice any religion. I have attended services at a mosque in Istanbul, at a monastery at Koyasan, and at a cathedral in Florence (didn't do communion there, for obvious reasons). Do you believe that atheists are afraid of religion? Unfamiliar with its trappings?
 
Lastly what religion if any do you practice? Its remarkable how quite everyone has been when I ask that. What are you all' afraid of?

Why on earth would you think a group of atheists and agnostics practice any religion at all? Do you have trouble grasping definitions?

And what is that apostrophe doing after the word all in your post?
 
How is it racist? All races are represented in Europe? You have never heard of Teutonic engineering meaning good engineering? Reaching aren't we? I am sorry it still is dumb.

; {>

Does that make your use of 'European blood' meaningless?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom