The certainty of God's existence.

Well let's make the definition a little less vague, presumably this is a maximally great entity defined as:

Def 1 : T(x) means it is possible to form a mental representation of x
Def 2: G(x,y) means x is greater than y
Def 3: M(x) means [latex]\forall x \forall y [ M(x) \wedge T(x) \wedge T(y) \rightarrow G(x,y) ][/latex]
​
If this is wrong someone please correct it.


I think you are trying to say M(x) is maximum greatness and therefore god. If so, it should be more like:

[latex]$$$ \exists x \, M(x) \equiv \forall y (y \ne x \wedge x > y) $$$ [/latex]​

That's trying to say, there is a god, and that god is greater than anything else for which one can form a mental representation. I didn't see where the necessity for a mental representation added much, so I dropped them. You can restore that if need be.
 
Last edited:
I think you are trying to say M(x) is maximum greatness and therefore god. If so, it should be more like:

[latex]$$$ \exists x \, M(x) \equiv \forall y (y \ne x \wedge x > y) $$$ [/latex]​

That's trying to say, there is a god, and that god is greater than anything else for which one can form a mental representation. I didn't see where the necessity for a mental representation added much, so I dropped them. You can restore that if need be.
Here is the statement I am trying to render:

"that which no greater can be thought"

I don't really think that ">" is really what is intended by "greater" in this context - and the meaning of "greater" would seem to be key to the definition.

Also if I left out "thought" then I would not be rendering the statement "that than which no greater can be", or to simplify it "The Greatest".

If Bill will be happy to amend his definition of God as "The Greatest" then I would be happy to lose that part.
 
Last edited:
Here is the statement I am trying to render:

"that which no greater can be thought"

I don't really think that ">" is really what is intended by "greater" in this context - and the meaning of "greater" would seem to be key to the definition.

Also if I left out "thought" then I would not be rendering the statement "that than which no greater can be", or to simplify it "The Greatest".

If Bill will be happy to amend his definition of God as "The Greatest" then I would be happy to lose that part.

That would boil down to something like this, then:

[latex]$$$ \exists God \, [\forall x \in Thinkables \, (x \ne God \Rightarrow God > x)] $$$[/latex]​

Mathematically, the ">" isn't just a numeric comparison operator. It can take on whatever meaning of "greater" is appropriate in this context.
 
That would boil down to something like this, then:

[latex]$$$ \exists God \, [\forall x \in Thinkables \, (x \ne God \Rightarrow God > x)] $$$[/latex]​

Mathematically, the ">" isn't just a numeric comparison operator. It can take on whatever meaning of "greater" is appropriate in this context.
True, but your original formulation provided no context, whereas your new formulation does.

But it still leaves open the question of the basis for the ordering in Thinkables which is still the crux of the definition.

Also I am not sure that a definition of God to be used in a proof that God exists should start by stipulating that God exists.
 
Also I am not sure that a definition of God to be used in a proof that God exists should start by stipulating that God exists.

Indeed. As written, it's an axiom, not a definition. To be a definition, you could replace the existential quantifier with "y = God ==>" then replace all the "God"s in the rest of the statement with "y".

(Pretend this is more Latex. I'm assuming people are tired of it in this thread, so I won't bore them with some more.)
 
Indeed. As written, it's an axiom, not a definition. To be a definition, you could replace the existential quantifier with "y = God ==>" then replace all the "God"s in the rest of the statement with "y".

(Pretend this is more Latex. I'm assuming people are tired of it in this thread, so I won't bore them with some more.)
Only trying to sort out what the definition means is all.
 
I'll be back I think the wicked witch has slipped me a 'mickey'.....I feel like Dorthy in the field of poppies...sleeeeeep sleeeeeeeeeep...

>>..Wicked Witch of the West: And now, my beauties, something with poison in it, I think. Something with poison in it, but attractive to the eye, and soothing to the smell. Poppies... Poppies. Poppies will put them to sleep. Sleep. Now they'll sleep! "

And like Dorthy will sleep ~

; {>
 
Here is the statement I am trying to render:

"that which no greater can be thought"

I don't really think that ">" is really what is intended by "greater" in this context - and the meaning of "greater" would seem to be key to the definition.

Also if I left out "thought" then I would not be rendering the statement "that than which no greater can be", or to simplify it "The Greatest".

If Bill will be happy to amend his definition of God as "The Greatest" then I would be happy to lose that part.

God doesn't have to have (what we perceive as) god attributes in this universe. He is perfect only in his realm. Perfection isn't possible in a temporal system IMO.

; {>
 
God doesn't have to have (what we perceive as) god attributes in this universe. He is perfect only in his realm. ("that which no greater can be thought") Perfection isn't possible in a temporal system IMO.

; {>
 
I thought Adam didn't have a belly button.

There may of been more than one Adam. Physically, I think he would of looked like a normal modern man, you know blonde hair (but shaved) blue eyes.... :D...a tattoo...piercings, a goatee, well endowed, you know kinda like me...Oh yeah he was intelligent too..

; {>
 
Last edited:
God doesn't have to have (what we perceive as) god attributes in this universe. He is perfect only in his realm. ("that which no greater can be thought") Perfection isn't possible in a temporal system IMO.
Exactly the same can be said for the IPU and the FSM.

It's meaningless, RevD.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom