The certainty of God's existence.

The ancient Greeks liked to use intuition and reason alone, and now they're dead.

Don't let this happen to you!
 
RevDisturba, for a busy person you do appear to have a lot of time to go off topic :)


Let me just say this on the off-topic stuff - when the worlds greatest Christian apologist gets his definitions of eternity muddled I don't think there is a great threat to secularism happening. If the KCM proves nothing but "the Universe has a cause" then it has said nothing at all about God.

And anyway, what is wrong with secularism? Even Jesus Christ was a secularist. But then you guys always mix up secularism with atheism.

Anyway, I have a simply question that has been on the plate for some time - if you have time for some of this banter you surely have time for to answer a simple on-topic clarification:

When you say "begin" in P1 do you mean it as in "begin to exist", or do you mean as in the beginning of a series of events?
 
Oh and by the way, intuition is hardly a good basis for a metaphysical argument, especially an ontological one. What chance is there that the fundamental nature of existence would be intuitively understandable to minds such as ours?
 
RandFan said:
Is it appropriate for secularists who receive death threats from the religious to want revenge against the religious?

Who wants revenge? I want defense from the nut cases. It (my defense) comes in the form of an attack Bogie basset, and a few concealed carries ie a .38...a .45 and a can of pepper spray, I clank when I walk in some deadly areas. And my spiritual defense is the amour of God. If I had to choose I would choose the latter.

This is what bothers me about religion. It divides people. Personally I think we are all humans and we should be willing to forgive and not hold entire groups accountable for the sins of the extreme.

And this is what bothers me about people who makes false statements about anyone, Christians atheists or wiccans. Those that over actively and ignorantly criticizes Christianity along with most other religions are haters with an agenda. (not exactly you Randy even though you are often wrong in some of your biblical criticisms,, you are a kind of lovable guy even with the distain). I also think that those that criticize all atheists are haters.

So we all have bad apples in the basket. I don’t judge all (insert group here____) by the haters and don’t understand those that do. I will say I have my suspicions why some groups hate but that’s another thread. BTW religion bands together people not divides them. There are billions of Christians that banded together. Then we have a billion or more Islamic faithful brothers and sisters. Then Secular/Nonreligious/Agnostic/Atheist: 1.1 billion, then Hinduism: 900 million, then : 394 million in the Chinese traditional religion, then Buddhism: 376 million then, 300 million primal-indigenous, last but not least , when you add up the Secular/Nonreligious/Agnostic/Atheist: you have an respectable 1.1 billion.

So again I have to disagree with your statement.

http://anotherpalebluedot.blogspot.com/2007/06/major-religions-ranked-by-size.html


I don't hate believers for the many problems I see because of religion. I don't wish them any ill will.

And I don’t hate, or harbor any ill will to the secular humanists atheists etc for the wars of greed and other problems they cause.

Christ did not act in malice or wish malice on anyone.

Well don’t tell that to the moneychangers that he beat out of the temple with a whip. And when he returns he is going to be just a little angry.

Somehow I don't think this helps you at all. I think this is one of the worst scriptures for Christians that exists. The bible is inconsistent and contradictory. I'm not sure though how this obviates the earlier scriptures. It does prove that you can find justification for anything in the Bible.
Vengeance is mine sayeth the lord. --Romans 12:19

The bible for those that take the time to learn how to read it isn’t contradictory. It’s a collection of texts written for two separate ideals. Your scripture simply means what it says. That’s why I am against the death penalty among other reasons.

Are they allowed to hold grudges? Are they allowed not to forgive.

Vengeance isn’t holding grudges. No its; vengeance noun revenge, retaliation, reprisal, retribution, avenging, an eye for an eye, settling of scores, requital, lex talionis << OPPOSITE forgiveness with a vengeance to the utmost, greatly, extremely, to the full, and no mistake, to the nth degree, with no holds barred

But must you forgive?

Of course! Even in our righteous anger we should forgive.
2 Cor 2:10-11 To whom ye forgive any thing, I forgive also: for if I forgave any thing, to whom I forgave it, for your sakes forgave I it in the person of Christ; Lest Satan should get an advantage of us: for we are not ignorant of his devices.

This is what I find so distasteful about many religious sects. yrreg is capable of some of the most vilest attacks but because he is on the lords side it is ok.

Yes there are bad apples as we discussed before. Jim Jones was satanic in my book, but that goes for all groups. If Yrreg has made these attacks in the name of God he will be judged for such.

Why? Christian hate and anger is justified. There is no act that a Christian cannot perform and be forgiven. Remember, the slaughter of the Amalekits, man, woman AND child was out of righteous anger.

If you are a christian you might want to read what repent means in Greek. You must repent for your sins, however the way I read scripture tells me if I know better I will NOT be forgiven for sins I commit with foreknowledge. God is fair.

I can only imagine how much pleasure Christians will enjoy to know that their enemies will suffer.

What self serving silliness. Jesus Christ died for our sins. Can you give me scripture to support that bit of what? Wishful thinking?

The Jews, Hindus, Pagans, Mormons? They were the wrong religion so they must also suffer. Righteous indignation and the pleasure of seeing your enemies suffer is reserved for those who pick the right religion.

Choice, personal choice is the key. If you choose to play chicken in an interstate without a car you will surely die.

Forgive them father, they know not what they do. --Luke 23:34
Rings hollow doesn't it?

Are you forgetting who you are talking to? It rings true, Jesus was telling God that the dummies killing him were ignorant, in a lethal manner. He was asking for their forgiveness as they murdered him.

BTW: It's one of the things that I admire so much about the Amish. They don't believe in righteous anger or righteous contempt. They are consistent in their beliefs of forgiveness and judgement.

You have never seen a whipping have you?

Judge not, that ye be not judged. --Matthew 7:1

I don’t but it seems that many of the bad apple heap it upon the devout. I am just exceedingly happy that we have billions more shovels than your guys, we may need them before its over.

; {>
 
Last edited:
Hi Robin! (the most skilled, kind, best read and most intelligent debater here, including me) Have you given up on me? Will you help me out and direct me to the first post you want me to respond to? Thanks and sorry. Your cordial well thought out rock solid replies take much more time and thinking to reply. (I generally have to research every reply) to and I got caught up in the more flammable or replies.

Please accept my apology you deserved to of been answered first. I wanted to give you a proper answer but ended up disrespecting your turn in line.


; {>

Thank you for your kind words, but my arguments have been demolished on many occasion by others here so I cannot claim to be the most intelligent.

I did not notice this post when I posted my last one, the first question is the one about the meaning of begin in the post above.
 
Oops: thread singularity in progress

Since this thread makes an argument from authority, with google as a proxy for that authority, and since google indexes this forum and will eventually index this thread, sooner or later, this thread will become entirely self referential, and will thus implode on itself, causing it and its creator to exist in a separate, self justified reality, where the only evidence for their conclusions is self generated.

Ooops. Too late, already happened.

Andrew
 
Thank you for your kind words, but my arguments have been demolished on many occasion by others here so I cannot claim to be the most intelligent.

I did not notice this post when I posted my last one, the first question is the one about the meaning of begin in the post above.

You are welkie. As for the other remark, I am am speaking in reference to debating the KCA. I don't know your skills in other areas, and of course IQ is I believe a partly a subjective one.

; }>
 
MikeSun said:
More confusion on your part. Pay attention -- Opinions do not denote ignorance. Your words:
My opinion is you cherry pick information from science and the Bible to fit your beliefs, and reject anything you don't like - fact or not. The fact that you actually quote Bible verses in your posts (and probably day-to-day life) is astonishing for someone who admittedly denies other verses. Following some verses and rejecting others is called cherry picking. If the Bible is the word of God, why only listen to what you want to hear? There's no consistency. You quoting verses while admitting you don't follow the Bible proves that you cherry pick what you like from religious stories, so it's not a stretch to assume you do the same with science.

The only thing I an say is that your opinion is just that.

:eek: You really don't know??

You said ontological arguments are evidence of God. I'll repeat myself (again):

Ontological are evidence as in ; evidence 1. sign or proof: something that gives a sign or proof of the existence or truth of something, or that helps somebody to come to a particular conclusion.

Then there is this ;
Descartes' Ontological Argument (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)
In the same context, Descartes also characterizes the ontological argument as a proof from the "essence" or "nature" of God, arguing that necessary ...
plato.stanford.edu/entries/descartes-ontological/ -

Arguments are NOT evidence. Do I really need to link to dictionaries?

:mad:YES you sure do need to READ a dictionary so you wont be embarrassed trying to post another false statement. You are so wrong, I mean I am just amused that you can go on like this when you know you are wrong. I said ontological arguments are evidence... THEY ARE! Then I defined it by the dictionary and encyclopedia. I am sure you wont let the facts get in your way though.

I feel stupid now for assuming we all understood English.
Ontological arguments are not evidence of God.

:boggled:You should feel ignorant not stupid. We are all ignorant in some areas, just be a man and admit you are wrong.

; {>
 
Last edited:
Since this thread makes an argument from authority, with google as a proxy for that authority, and since google indexes this forum and will eventually index this thread, sooner or later, this thread will become entirely self referential, and will thus implode on itself, causing it and its creator to exist in a separate, self justified reality, where the only evidence for their conclusions is self generated.

Ooops. Too late, already happened.

Andrew

Yeah and I think you were in the implosion. When your thoughts clear up please restate the comment.:flamed:
; }>
 
Robin said:
RevDisturba, for a busy person you do appear to have a lot of time to go off topic

Let me just say this on the off-topic stuff - when the worlds greatest Christian apologist gets his definitions of eternity muddled I don't think there is a great threat to secularism happening. If the KCM proves nothing but "the Universe has a cause" then it has said nothing at all about God.

And anyway, what is wrong with secularism? Even Jesus Christ was a secularist. But then you guys always mix up secularism with atheism.

Well as I said I do these forums for recreation. I am chained to this computer or another for it seems 24/7. The off topic, and even some non robin on topic replies are fun and don’t take too much thinking. Your posts on the other hand sometimes require research and thinking. In other words work. If I want that I can get a job working for someone else!

Let me just say this on the off-topic stuff - when the worlds greatest Christian apologist gets his definitions of eternity muddled I don't think there is a great threat to secularism happening. If the KCM proves nothing but "the Universe has a cause" then it has said nothing at all about God.

"*Cof* Psssst Robin" : it’s the KCA. And Craig is well aware of what eternity means he goes into great detail in some of his more advanced papers about the implications time.

And I highly disagree! That the universe had a cause is a stepping stone where before we only had faith (and it was correct vs. science being wrong, that the universe is static and unchanging, where religion tells us it began and is not static).

And anyway, what is wrong with secularism? Even Jesus Christ was a secularist. But then you guys always mix up secularism with atheism.

I don’t think secularism is bad, it simply has the potential to be very very bad. BTW, Care to expand on the 'Jesus was a secular' remark ?

Anyway, I have a simply question that has been on the plate for some time - if you have time for some of this banter you surely have time for to answer a simple on-topic clarification: When you say "begin" in P1 do you mean it as in "begin to exist", or do you mean as in the beginning of a series of events?

What do you mean by series of events? I mean begin as before the universe began there was nothing material. No space, no time, no energy, no subatomic particles, no quantum loop gravity, no quantum foam, nothing that could be considered material.

I hope that helps.

; {>

After butchering this reply I thinks its time for a hour of sleep....
 
Last edited:
:mad:YES you sure do need to READ a dictionary so you wont be embarrassed trying to post another false statement....I said ontological arguments are evidence... THEY ARE!

Good FSM in alfredo sauce, you are wrong! If ontological arguments are considered evidence, then why would't "intuition" and "reason" (being the basis of said arguments) hold up in court as evidence? You avoided that question once, but rejecting/ignoring the tough questions doesn't make them go away.

:bwall :bwall :bwall :bwall :bwall :bwall
You seem so convinced that an argument "based on intuition and reason" is evidence, I started to doubt myself. So I looked up the word evidence. If you notice, the definition does not contain the words "argument," "intuition," or "reason." So, please read the link and learn what evidence means. Please read all definitions and try to understand them before you reply, that will save me loads of time.

Just guessing at definitions and hoping you're right leaves lots and lots of room for error. (hey! :idea: just like religion!)

And I don’t hate, or harbor any ill will to the secular humanists atheists etc for the wars of greed and other problems they cause.

...the wars. atheists. cause. :covereyes Yes, because nobody fights in the name of God.

I'm glad you posted this. I now realize I'm conversing with someone who does not have a firm grip on reality. Saves me even more time.
 
Oh get off that silly thing. I have already responded to that, maybe you missed it. Jesus Christ beat the money changers out of the temple, his anger was righteous. I feel my little remarks were wholly justified because I had endured so much before I responded, well not even in kind.

If that is the best you can do to demonstrate my hate its just funny that's all. Now I have to clean my keypad off because I spewed my cheerios all over it reading that.

Have a look at some of the comments you have made towards rregg if you want to see real hate.

; {>

We don't hate Yregg,we love him for the many laughs he gives us.You are very amusing too,thank you.
 
You said ontological arguments are evidence of God. I'll repeat myself (again):

Ontological are evidence as in ; evidence 1. sign or proof: something that gives a sign or proof of the existence or truth of something, or that helps somebody to come to a particular conclusion.

Unfortunately, the ontological arguments aren't at all. That is, they are not proof or evidence for anything in particular. They are word games; at best defining something in the most general terms in the real world as "God."

For an analogy, you can easily define that the top, i.e. the highest point of any mountain be called "peak." No problem at all. If there is a mountain, there is also a peak.

Likewise, you can insist that the necessary bits/greatest bits/whatever of reality be called "God." And if there is a reality - and there is - then "God" by definition exists as well. No problem either.

Except that people expect something more than that, and there is really no need for any convoluted eyewashing. ;)

Of course, that you can call stuff names is not what is debated or denied by atheists. Of course we could call the necessary bits of reality (for example) "God." Of course we could call the maximally great thingamajig (along with its now fully meaningless omnis) "God."

But ... underneath the words and letters? Nothing would change at all. There'd still be the particulars left to be hashed out.

We'd be arguing, to switch back in the analogy, whether the peak of our mountain that we've "proven" to exist is made of granite rock, or rather chocolate. Is it covered in pixie dust? Are bigfoots living there? And what does "chocolate" mean anyway? Will any brownish stuff do?


It is not entirely different with the KCA. Only that with the KCA - apart from the utter meaninglessness of its conclusion(s) - you have its unsound premises and its invalidity, that make for gorgeous red herrings, as additional "benefits."
 
Last edited:
So we all have bad apples in the basket. I don’t judge all (insert group here____) by the haters and don’t understand those that do.

And I don’t hate, or harbor any ill will to the secular humanists atheists etc for the wars of greed and other problems they cause.
No, you don't hate them, you merely slander them. Well, okay, technically it's libel.

Well don’t tell that to the moneychangers that he beat out of the temple with a whip. And when he returns he is going to be just a little angry.
Yeah, about that... Isn't he running just a little bit late?

The bible for those that take the time to learn how to read it isn’t contradictory.
If by "how to read" you mean "ignore the contradictions", then that's kind of redundant.

It’s a collection of texts written for two separate ideals. Your scripture simply means what it says. That’s why I am against the death penalty among other reasons.
Well, fine, but I'm still not going to bake poop into my bread.

I don’t but it seems that many of the bad apple heap it upon the devout.
I see. Not just libel, but baseless libel.

I am just exceedingly happy that we have billions more shovels than your guys, we may need them before its over.
You keep your shovels. We keep our coherent science education policy. Fair's fair.
 
And Craig is well aware of what eternity means he goes into great detail in some of his more advanced papers about the implications time.
Cite, please.

And I highly disagree! That the universe had a cause is a stepping stone where before we only had faith (and it was correct vs. science being wrong, that the universe is static and unchanging, where religion tells us it began and is not static).
Texas sharpshooter fallacy.

I don’t think secularism is bad, it simply has the potential to be very very bad.
Really? The United States has been a secular nation since its founding. Where is this very very badness?

What do you mean by series of events? I mean begin as before the universe began there was nothing material. No space, no time, no energy, no subatomic particles, no quantum loop gravity, no quantum foam, nothing that could be considered material.
More to the point, there is no "before the Universe began".
 
A question for you, RevD - in post 895, you said:

I think there are evidences from most of the major branches of science that support the argument that an intelligent agent was responsible for our fantastic universe. Yes secular humanists are aghast at this push for a new scopes monkey trial, and for good reason. They fear their paradigm is threatened.

Heck we won the last one this one should be a cake walk. I think this will be an 'war' of attrition. It doesn't have to be. The only thing we want is a bit of fairness. And equity.No totalitarianism like today, choice instead of a secular railroad and forced (exclusive) neo- Darwinism brain washing by the force of law. Hey we want our own brain washing machine, make mine a maytag.

I've already outlined the reasons why this line of argument is misguided, but I'd be interested in taking this point further - more interested than in the debate over the KCA, to tell the truth. Are you interested in participating in a new thread to discuss this specific topic?
 
This thread has gotten long and difficult to follow all the nuances. Let me see if I understand the several points that have been made:
  1. The certainty of god's existence is uncertain.
  2. Christians look forward with glee to the time when atheists will suffer in Hell for all eternity.
  3. God has a penis but no hands.
  4. Peace has been declared in Northern Ireland.
Does that about cover it?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom