The certainty of God's existence.

I am equal to you as a person, but you are lagging behind in other areas. No insult simply an observation. If you would not insist in being difficult we could be civil to each other.

So what would it take to make peace with you? Really.

; {>
Stop being such a smug twat. Be honest in your responses. While it may be overwhelming to answer so many responses, your answers are arrogant, dismissive and exceedingly dishonest.

I can be very civil with honest religious folk. I have no patience towards the dishonest. I have no patience towards those who hide their claims behind some silly semantic game. As already mentioned the KCA(despite the multitude of flaws) only "prove" there is a cause to the beginning of the universe. End of story. For theist to force this non-sequitur to "therefore it is god and that is Jesus, hallelujah!!!" is about as dishonest as it gets. And I'm you're definitely intelligent enough to know this.

If you have evidence, bring it forth instead of playing games. Otherwise I can call truce.
 
Last edited:
Which ones are well reasoned ? Its difficult to keep up with 50 e mail notifications a day from one site.

; {>
I find out by reading them, generally. I thought mine aren't too bad, and I collected a whole bunch of them especially for you, because they all asked the thing I want to know about your argument.

A few pointers: Turn off notifications; ignore insulting posts. Done.
 
Last edited:
Stop being such a smug twat. Be honest in your responses. While it may be overwhelming to answer so many responses, your answers are arrogant, dismissive and exceedingly dishonest.

I can be very civil with honest religious folk. I have no patience towards the dishonest. I have no patience towards those who hide their claims behind some silly semantic game. As already mentioned the KCA(despite the multitude of flaws) only "prove" there is a cause to the beginning of the universe. End of story. For theist to force this non-sequitur to "therefore it is god and that is Jesus, hallelujah!!!" is about as dishonest as it gets. And I'm you're definitely intelligent enough to know this.

If you have evidence, bring it forth instead of playing games. Otherwise I can call truce.

Well you do know what this is don't you? Its WAR! Hee hee. You can't understand the basic tenets of the KCA (or you seem not to) and calling a cosmological argument dishonest is silly. You would be booed off any stage at any academic venue saying such things like that. BTW, The KCA (which has never been defeated) is only one of many cosmological arguments. Additionally Its only one component of a few that I use to validate that God exists.

No, your problem is that you are frustrated and can not accept that you can not compete in this debate. I will ignore any future post from you that has a shred of a personal remark in it. I went against my better judgment by even responding to you. If you insist on making this personal you will be ignored as you should be.

; }>
 
Last edited:
Sorry, I just edited the portion you quoted to better fit RevDisturba's question. I guess that's poor form, except I didn't know. Well, too late...
A few pointers: Turn off notifications; ignore insulting posts. Done.

That shotgun approach gets all of the members even the good ones. I have a better idea. use the ignore feature on the members that are here to troll and start trouble !

; }>
 
You can't understand the basic tenets of the KCA (or you seem not to) and calling a cosmological argument dishonest is silly. You would be booed off any stage at any academic venue saying such things like that. BTW, The KCA (which has never been defeated) is only one of many cosmological arguments. Additionally Its only one component of a few that I use to validate that God exists.
Let's play.
I'll give you:
C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.

Now get from C3 to Jesus.
 
Which ones are well reasoned ? Its difficult to keep up with 50 e mail notifications a day from one site.

; {>
You appear to be spending an inordinate amount of time with posts that are not part of the debate.

You claimed my disambiguation of your argument was not equivalent to yours and that it was not a logical syllogism.

I asked how the logical structure of mine differed from the logical structure of yours. I would also like to know why you don't think the premisses are equivalent.

For example what do you mean by the "beginning" of a series of causal events, if you don't mean a causal event with no predecessor causal event?

If a causal event at the "beginning" of a series of causal events has a predecessor causal event then in what way is it a beginning? In short, clarify what you mean by the "beginning" of a series of causal events.

I have made it easy by formatting it in a table with the equivalent premisses and conclusions side by side.

Also where are your justifications for P3 and P6? (In the case of P3 I think we can both agree that an informal inductive intuition about nature is not strong enough for the premiss of a metaphysical argument about God).
 
That shotgun approach gets all of the members even the good ones. I have a better idea. use the ignore feature on the members that are here to troll and start trouble !

; }>
That works, but only if you are sure nobody ever does both. What I do is subscribe to the thread, check my subscribed threads when I feel like it and have time, and read from the first unread post. Finding out if a post is well reasoned usually takes only a few lines.

If you do this you can then respond to the portions of well reasoned posts you find lacking or faulty in a well reasoned rebuttal, which I will then happily read, in its entirety.
I don't care too much for the bickering. It's true that it's amusing to read at times, but it always distracts from the topic in that it clutters and makes for easy hiding.
 
BTW, The KCA (which has never been defeated)
It doesn't need to be - it has never been demonstrated to be true or even plausible.

If you cannot justify the assumptions upon which it rests then it fails.
 
RevDisturbia | Robin
|D1: An event is an entity that is the cause of it's successor if it has a successor and the effect of it's predecessor if it has a predecessor
|D2: A universe is an ordered set of events.
P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.|P1: An ordered set of events is either infinite or has an event without a predecessor.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible.|P2: An actual infinity is impossible
C1: Therefore, the universe must have had a beginning.|C1: The universe has an event without a predecessor.
P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.|P3: In an ordered set of events, any event that does not have a predecessor has a predecessor.
P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.|P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
C2: The universe must have been caused by something.|C2: The first event in the universe has a predecessor
P5: The cause of the universe is eternal.|P5: The predecessor of the first event in the universe has no predecessors or successors
P6: The only way an eternal cause could produce something bound by time is for it to freely choose to.|P6: The only way that an event with no predecessors or successors could have a successor with predecessors and successors is for it to have a predecessor (an intention).
P7: If P5 and P6, then C3.|P7: If P5 and P6 then C3
C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.|C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.
RevDisturbia has claimed the argument in the right hand column is not a logical syllogism. Can anybody tell me the difference in logical structure between the argument in the right hand column and the argument in the left hand column?


The only important difference is the Rev's P5, but he's already excluded it at P2, where infinity is declared to be impossible. Both P3s lead thus inevitably to those pesky turtles.
 
The only important difference is the Rev's P5, but he's already excluded it at P2, where infinity is declared to be impossible. Both P3s lead thus inevitably to those pesky turtles.
My P5 was the only way I could understand how "eternal" fitted in here. A big mistake many people make about timelessness is just to turn it into a sort of meta-time. If you have an environment in which you have change and cause and effect you just get a different kind of time.

Clearly eternity needs to be something in which there is no time at all. So an event within eternity could have no causes and have no effects. Otherwise it would just, as you say, turn into the sort of thing ruled out in P2.

And I think my rendering of this is consistent with traditional theology where eternal is described as changeless or that all states withing eternity are simultaneous.
 
Last edited:
I am equal to you as a person, but you are lagging behind in other areas. No insult simply an observation. If you would not insist in being difficult we could be civil to each other.

So what would it take to make peace with you? Really.
Logic and evidence.
 
Well you do know what this is don't you? Its WAR! Hee hee. You can't understand the basic tenets of the KCA (or you seem not to) and calling a cosmological argument dishonest is silly.
It is dishonest.

It not only rests upon multiple false or unsupported assertions, but requires such semantic trickery that you rejected it as false immediately when it was laid out explicitly.

You would be booed off any stage at any academic venue saying such things like that.
Argmentum ad populum, and yes, I think we have a bingo! The lady at the back - one of our moderators will be down to check your card in a moment.

BTW, The KCA (which has never been defeated) is only one of many cosmological arguments.
All of them riddled with fallacies.

Additionally Its only one component of a few that I use to validate that God exists.
Is it the best one? If so, you have a problem. If not, why not present your best argument?

No, your problem is that you are frustrated and can not accept that you can not compete in this debate.
Okay, everyone start a new card please. And we have ad hominem.

I will ignore any future post from you that has a shred of a personal remark in it. I went against my better judgment by even responding to you. If you insist on making this personal you will be ignored as you should be.
Tu quoque.
 
It seems that the one side keeps logically arguing for a first cause, and the other side says why can't it go back forever or why is the first cause "personal". Did I miss the post where it was explained how we know First Cause=God?
 
As usual similarly with other things of the heart and mind, atheists cannot see the kinds and degrees of human certainty, because they have inured themselves from seeing beyond their medical condition of hating God, which hatred of God is due to their also medical condition of fearing God, and likewise their anger is due to their fear of God.

Did you just admit that you fear and loathe The Flying Spaghetti Monster?

You see there are many people who don't believe in God or who don't give any importance to God, and they go about life without any axe to grind against God; but only people with a medical condition of morbid fear of God which I call theophobia write massively, lividly, rabidly, acerbically against God and fellow humans who know for certain that God does exist.

Sounds like you're describing rabid theists, those who have to proclaim the existence of god(s) so they don't have to think.

Take the writings of atheists like Dawkins, Hitchens, Harris, and their emulants, they are conspicuously betraying [pun intended] their medical condition of morbid fear of God.

Where can I read up on that diagnosis. Cite please?

Back to certainty about God's existence, that post you responded to is an invitation for atheists to think about the kinds and degrees of certainty.

The first kind and degree of certainty is for things which like your nose and your external sex organ and also you whole physical being you can touch with your hands, as also others can touch with their hands.

Doing that too much leaves you blind to the truth.

The certainty of God is another kind and degree of human certainty.

We call that belief.

Then there is the pseudo certainty of people atheists who insist that there is no God.

We call that evidence based.

I am about through but not yet, and still perhaps yes, with this thread: because it has served me very well for me myself to have come to the idea that as mankind cannot achieve absolute certainty in anything, still mankind can and do enjoy different kinds of and different degrees of certainty, and also kinds of pseudo certainty like the kind atheists with the medical malaise of theophobia feel that they are certain God does not exist.

The well of stupid is seemingly bottomless.

I am now absorbed in thinking about the medical condition of extremist exhibitionist atheists who suffer the medical condition which I think most appropriately deserves to be termed theophobia.

Let's use the term gerry-maundering. (thanks to Darth Rotor)

The fear of God for healthy people is the beginning of wisdom.

For the psychologically ill, maladjusted atheists, it is the beginning of anger and hatred against God.​





Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom