The certainty of God's existence.

When I take off my glasses, all these posts sort of blur together, so I guess I'm going to go whoop it up outside, instead, with my atheist hat.
 
So were talking about Yahweh then.

You offered Yahweh a dollar and He didn't take it so you concluded He didn't exist. Since then you tried many spiritual paths but eventually ended up back with Yahweh.

You'd have saved yourself a lot of time and trouble if you would have just taken the dollar to one of the many Money Collection Points that Yahweh has established, your local church.

But then I would not truly believe, and living a lie is worse than death. Besides I have my own church which is more of a free bean kitchen than a real church.

Except we are without a building. The last christian owner didn't like the riff raff that the christian mission would be bringing around...there are (real) atheists then there are (not so real) atheists, the same goes for Christians or any group...Some good some bad eh?

; {>
 
Well time for Chruch (going to the woods today with my new basset hound, Mr B. Jesus). BBS.

; }>
 
he PAC (Pixy's Antecosmological Counterargment)

P1. The Universe, by observation, began at some point.
P2. Time is a property of the Universe.
C1. Therefore time itself began at some point.

Well you could of said The Universe, began>>>to exist<<<<< at some point.Then it would be correct. I don’t know what began means unless you did mean to begin to exist.
It depends on how you view the Universe, but I'll accept your amendment.

I don’t think that time being a property of the universe would validate that it began at some point.
You have a model in which a property precedes the object of which it is a property? Please elucidate.

It may not unless you are using big bang cosmology.
See P1.

P3. Cause precedes effect.
P4. Precedence is a reference to time.
C2. Therefore there can be no cause and effect without time.
C3. Since time is a property of the Universe itself, and cause and effect is meaningless without reference to time, the Universe cannot have a cause.
P5. God is defined as the primal cause.
C4. God does not exist.

P3. False
Indeed? Counterexamples, if you would be so kind.

P4 May be false
Not so, as I have already demonstrated. Anything that forces a strict causal order acquires the nature of time.

C2 False. Lets say we are looking at book. The pages are numbered 1,2,3 and so on.
Yes, I generally find this to be the case.

Were you going somewhere with this?

Lets look at P4 Its false as well. Because “Causality contrasted with conditionals
Conditional statements are not statements of causality.
So? Is this intended somehow to be relevant?

An important distinction is that statements of causality require the antecedent to precede the consequent in time, whereas conditional statements do not require this temporal order.
So you were not making statements of causality when you said:

P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible.
C1: Therefore, the universe must have had a beginning.
P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.
P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
C2: The universe must have been caused by something.
P5: The cause of the universe is eternal.
P6: The only way an eternal cause could produce something bound by time is for it to freely choose to.
P7: If P5 and P6, then C3.
C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.
If you say so, I'll believe you, but I do suggest you choose your words more carefully henceforth.

With all due respect PixyMisa, there are so many fallacies in your claim that it fails to be a logical syllogism taken in any order.
I eagerly await your pointing out these fallacies.

And it fails as a simple argument.
Sorry, you have failed in your argument. But thus we learn.
 
Last edited:
Someone that can employ critical thinking and think outside the box would say the North Star, Polaris. Now do you want to know what is north of the north star? ;)

; {>

That someone would be wrong. North is defined by the surface of a sphere. Polaris does not lie on the surface of the sphere in question.
 
I don't think that now so why should I then? I am a pastor and I never teach there is a burning hell for anything but the devil and his angles. Maybe a few unrepentant people may get the hot seat but I doubt it.

; {>
Then why did you say that one should choose Christianity prior to death? What are the consequences of failing to do so?
 
RevDisturbia, I know you are answering a number of different posters, but I would appreciate it if you could find some time to address what I consider to be quite important issues.

First and foremost - what is your justifcation for P6?
P6: The only way an eternal cause could produce something bound by time is for it to freely choose to.
Secondly what is your justification for P3?
P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.
 
Good. I'm not the only one who caught that ;)

...I didn't want to say anything because he had a :D in there.

Yeah I am fully aware that it is a Guy Fawkes mask that V wears, I'm a die hard fan of the graphic novel series :D
 
You have a model in which a property precedes the object of which it is a property? Please elucidate.
For example:

There is a "super universe" which contains our universe.

It has always existed.

Universes such as ours blossom and die within this "super universe" like bubbles in a flask of champagne.

Each individual universe acquires the property of time when it begins to exist, just as a living creature acquires the property of time when it begins to exist.

Time itself existed before the birth of this universe, and will continue after this universe dies.
 
An important distinction is that statements of causality require the antecedent to precede the consequent in time...
Oops, you just contradicted your own argument. Or does God precede the universe in time?
 
I don't use Godels Ontological argument as a primary explanation for the existence of God. I did mention Godel's theory to make another unrelated point. The cosmological argument as per William Craig's modern version of the KCA best describes how the universe began in my personal opinion. : {>

Could you elucidate on what you meant when you wrote:
RevDisturba said:
I did not go into set theory for a reason.
to which I replied:
ddt said:
That statement confuses me. You had no reason to go into set theory? Yet, you cite a set theory example to support your arguments?

I also note that you haven't answered my question about the original blog post you quoted from. Why do you abandon it and now quote from a page from Dr. Craig?
 
Disagree! See below Dr Craig is much more to the point and eloquent in describing why he is correct and the naysayers are wholly incorrect. I have read and agree with Dr Craig in totality.
[...]
http://www.reasonablefaith.org/site/News2?page=NewsArticle&id=5911
It's quite hard to follow without knowing what Craig and Swinburne wrote in the first place, as this is a reaction of Craig to a reaction of Swinburne to Craig's initial defence of the KCA.

He says: "Hilbert’s Hotel, the illustration I use". So can you quote how Craig uses Hilbert's Hotel - merely as an illustration or as a centerpiece of his arguments?

Furthermore, Craig supports his argument with the following:
2. A beginningless series of events in time entails an actually infinite number of things.
which calls for more questions than answers. What is a "beginningless series of events"? What's an "event"?

Let's take the movement of the Earth through the Universe. Movement at each point in time is a different event. As we've seen before, there are uncountably infinite points in time. So if I take the series of events "the earth moves at time t" for all t > 1 and t < 2, I have a beginningless series (as t=1 is absent from this series), but I don't need an infinite number of things. Right?
 
Hi Rev,
Well time for Chruch (going to the woods today with my new basset hound, Mr B. Jesus). BBS.
When you're back, I'd be interested in hearing your thoughts on this. I don't think these particular objections have been discussed in this thread.

thx.
 
For example:

There is a "super universe" which contains our universe.

It has always existed.

Universes such as ours blossom and die within this "super universe" like bubbles in a flask of champagne.

Each individual universe acquires the property of time when it begins to exist, just as a living creature acquires the property of time when it begins to exist.

Time itself existed before the birth of this universe, and will continue after this universe dies.
Okay, I'm with you. Sort of. It's not actually the same property, though - what passes for time in the super universe cannot be (because of how we define universes) the same thing as time in our Universe. Which means that it can't come before the Universe, by our definition of time.

Which is a question of semantics, of course. More generally, it raises the problem of regression, yet another gaping hole in the KCA.
 
Someone that can employ critical thinking and think outside the box would say the North Star, Polaris. Now do you want to know what is north of the north star? ;)

; {>
.
That's in a pretty sparse location in our galaxy, looking out from the center, opposite the Milky Way.
M31 does a nice job of circling Polaris over a year's time.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom