The certainty of God's existence.

Hee hee sneaky. It is both. Time does not exist 'before' t-0. Some events are after t-0 but at least one has to be either 'before' t-0 or 'outside' time.
Depending on how you want to look at it, that is a non-sequitur, special pleading, or utterly meaningless. Or all three at once.

Certainly it invalidates your entire argument.
 
More importantly, however, the author of that piece doesn't seem to grasp the basic math needed to appreciate Hilbert's story. You can't do arithmetic on "infinite numbers" as you can with finite numbers. That doesn't mean that infinities are meaningless; on the contrary, Hilbert's Hotel is an example of how you can validly reason about infinite sets, and how it can be counterintuitive if you try to apply the same standards as with "normal" numbers.
Prescisely.

Hilbert's "Paradox" is not that actual infinities are absurd, much less impossible. It's that you can't treat infinities as though they were merely very large. To claim that actual infinities are absurd is completely unsupported, simply a failure of imagination.
 
That statement confuses me. You had no reason to go into set theory? Yet, you cite a set theory example to support your arguments? This will get interesting when you start with Godel's ontological argument.

I don't use Godels Ontological argument as a primary explanation for the existence of God. I did mention Godel's theory to make another unrelated point. The cosmological argument as per William Craig's modern version of the KCA best describes how the universe began in my personal opinion. : {>
 
Originally Posted by ddt View Post
More importantly, however, the author of that piece doesn't seem to grasp the basic math needed to appreciate Hilbert's story. You can't do arithmetic on "infinite numbers" as you can with finite numbers. That doesn't mean that infinities are meaningless; on the contrary, Hilbert's Hotel is an example of how you can validly reason about infinite sets, and how it can be counterintuitive if you try to apply the same standards as with "normal" numbers.

PixyMisa writes>Prescisely.
"Hilbert's "Paradox" is not that actual infinities are absurd, much less impossible. It's that you can't treat infinities as though they were merely very large. To claim that actual infinities are absurd is completely unsupported, simply a failure of imagination."

Disagree! See below Dr Craig is much more to the point and eloquent in describing why he is correct and the naysayers are wholly incorrect. I have read and agree with Dr Craig in totality.



Subject: Swinburne on the Kalam Cosmological Argument


Question:

Dr. Craig,

In The Existence of God, by Richard Swinburne, he critiques your Kalam Cosmological Argument, because he disagrees with your position on the possibility of an infinite number of things in time. Its on pg. 138 of the Second Edition in the footnotes. What is your response to his critique? I think I agree with your position, but I would like to see how you’d argue it.

See the entire article at;

http://www.reasonablefaith.org/site/News2?page=NewsArticle&id=5911

PT
 
Last edited:
PixyMisa said:
I grant none of your premises.

P1 is untrue.
P2 is unsupported.
P3 is untrue.
P5 is mere speculation.
P6 is nonsensical.

Those concerns have been addressed. 1...Name something that does not have a cause. 2..Study basic big bang cosmology, you will discover your error. 3..If one and two are correct # 3 is, and it is. Now, I am sorry your other posts are personal in nature. If you can find some that aren’t I will answer your valid (ie non personal) replies. And look up syllogism while you are at it.

; {>
 
Those concerns have been addressed. 1...Name something that does not have a cause. 2..Study basic big bang cosmology, you will discover your error. 3..If one and two are correct # 3 is, and it is. Now, I am sorry your other posts are personal in nature. If you can find some that aren’t I will answer your valid (ie non personal) replies. And look up syllogism while you are at it.

; {>

If we're right, the universe doesn't have a cause. If you're right, YHVH doesn't have a cause. So, either we're right, or there's a paradox. And in a world where a paradox is possible, there's no point in trying to prove anything through reason.

Also, you still need to address the circular time possibility.
 
Disagree! See below Dr Craig is much more to the point and eloquent in describing why he is correct and the naysayers are wholly incorrect.
No he isn't.

I read it. He doesn't ever address the point. He merely reasserts the previous, unjustified, claim that Hilbert's Paradox shows that actual infinities are impossible.

This wasn't true before, and it's not true now. Infinities behave differently to finite numbers. Anyone who's studied calculus understands this. This says nothing about whether actual infinities are possible. And this is only one of at least half a dozen claims on which the argument you laid out fails.
 
All right, I guess I'll restate things in a more serious way. I don't "deny the existence of God." I am not an atheist. I do deny that there is any way in which to logically prove the "certainty of God's existence." I am not a theist. I choose to mindfully experience God as I understand the transcendence of God, so I am a contemplative. There is no understanding and no certainty; to speak about God is to fill a bowl which must be empty (there is also no bowl, no fullness, and no emptiness), so I am a mystic. The human mind is the most astonishing thing there is. :) I'm still trying to figure out a good theology for that. But really, yyreg, why not respond to some of these things? Why not prove that you want to do something with this thread besides baiting atheists?

You are young (if your avatar is you).Before I was your age I was a atheist. I figured that when I left the God of my parents a dollar (a large sum for a boy back then) and God didn't take it, he didn't exist. When I was your age I was a wiccan, a witch or warlock, a nature loving pagan. After that didn't pan* out out I moved on to eastern mysticism while a guest of uncle sam in south east Asia, Buddhism to be exact. I took a lot of good stuff with me when I became disillusioned with all the Gods and no good god. It was like eating rabbit food when I wanted a rare steak.

So being hedonistic and unwilling to give up my pleasures I studied and dabbled in LeVay satanism, nah too many nuts in that religion. I then was a agnostic dabbling in this and that but something was missing. To cut this way short, in college it was fashionable to say God is dead and Darwin is god I became rebellious against my rabid secular professors, and quit the regular schools (I went to many colleges as I traveled) I began researching in earnest joining seminary and the rest is history.

The moral of the story? You will find your path soon enough. Just don't die before you settle on Christianity :D...

; {>

* Pan one of my fav's ; www.theoi.com/Georgikos/Pan.html -
 
Last edited:
Those concerns have been addressed.
No they haven't.

1...Name something that does not have a cause.
Virtual particles. Alpha emission. Neutron decay.

2..Study basic big bang cosmology, you will discover your error.
What error?

3..If one and two are correct # 3 is, and it is.
What are you referring to? What are these "one", "two", and "# 3"?

Now, I am sorry your other posts are personal in nature. If you can find some that aren’t I will answer your valid (ie non personal) replies. And look up syllogism while you are at it.
You have failed to support any of your premises. As others have indicated, your logic is none too solid either.
 
You are young (if your avatar is you).Before I was your age I was a atheist. I figured that when I left the God of my parents a dollar (a large sum for a boy back then) and God didn't take it, he didn't exist. When I was your age I was a wiccan, a witch or warlock, after that didn't pan* out out I moved on to eastern mysticism while a guest of uncle sam in south east Asia, Buddhism to be exact. I took a lot of good stuff with me when I became disillusioned with all the Gods and no good god. It was like eating rabbit food when I wanted a rare steak.

So being hedonistic and unwilling to give up my pleasures I studied and dabbled in LeVay satanism, nah too many nuts in that religion. I then was a agnostic dabbling in this and that but something was missing. To cut this way short, in college it was fashionable to say God is dead and Darwin is god I became rebellious against my rabid secular professors, and quit the regular schools (I went to many colleges as I traveled) I began researching in earnest joining seminary and the rest is history.

The moral of the story? You will find your path soon enough. Just don't die before you settle on Christianity :D...

; {>

How you know you've found your path? You might still switch back to atheism.
 
You are young (if your avatar is you).Before I was your age I was a atheist. I figured that when I left the God of my parents a dollar (a large sum for a boy back then) and God didn't take it, he didn't exist. When I was your age I was a wiccan, a witch or warlock, after that didn't pan* out out I moved on to eastern mysticism while a guest of uncle sam in south east Asia, Buddhism to be exact. I took a lot of good stuff with me when I became disillusioned with all the Gods and no good god. It was like eating rabbit food when I wanted a rare steak.

So being hedonistic and unwilling to give up my pleasures I studied and dabbled in LeVay satanism, nah too many nuts in that religion. I then was a agnostic dabbling in this and that but something was missing. To cut this way short, in college it was fashionable to say God is dead and Darwin is god I became rebellious against my rabid secular professors, and quit the regular schools (I went to many colleges as I traveled) I began researching in earnest joining seminary and the rest is history.

The moral of the story? You will find your path soon enough. Just don't die before you settle on Christianity
You do realise that even if your failed attempt at an argument were sound (and again, I'll note that none of the premises are supported, and several are false-to-fact) it still would say nothing as to what the cause of the Big Bang was, much less which of thousands of religions (if any!) were correct?
 
No he isn't.

I read it. He doesn't ever address the point. He merely reasserts the previous, unjustified, claim that Hilbert's Paradox shows that actual infinities are impossible.

This wasn't true before, and it's not true now. Infinities behave differently to finite numbers. Anyone who's studied calculus understands this. This says nothing about whether actual infinities are possible. And this is only one of at least half a dozen claims on which the argument you laid out fails.

Did you read the article? If you say you did I am going to call you about specifically about one point you make (above).

; {>
 
How you know you've found your path? You might still switch back to atheism.

So far I have found a good path it has all the markers and I have yet to become lost on it. I have been trudging the good path for the last umm' 13 years. That's a record for me. If say the Higgs* was found I may revisit my beliefs and add that discovery to the means test, they get one every day anyway. If the evidence ever tips the balance scales to the atheists favor I would change. So far the evidence beam is tilted heavily for a god dependent universe.

; {>

*......Higgs boson - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
The Higgs boson is a massive scalar elementary particle predicted to exist by the Standard Model in particle physics. At present there are no known ...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Higgs_boson

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Higgs_boson
 
Last edited:
You do realise that even if your failed attempt at an argument were sound (and again, I'll note that none of the premises are supported, and several are false-to-fact) it still would say nothing as to what the cause of the Big Bang was, much less which of thousands of religions (if any!) were correct?

I think you misunderstood Dr Craig*. More on that in a min. If the KCA premises were correct it certainly would be a valid argument and thus lend credence to the big bang and its cause. With all due respect, I don't think you understand what a simple syllogism is.

; {>

PixyMisa what do you think this means;

(Dr. Craig) "In the first place, the argument does not try to prove the logical impossibility of the existence of an actually infinite number of things, but its metaphysical impossibility. I have emphasized that the argument does not in any way deny that Cantor’s set-theoretical universe is, given its axioms and conventions, logically consistent, in that no contradiction has be shown to follow from its axioms."
 
Last edited:
Now, I am sorry your other posts are personal in nature.
I just want to address this point as well.

Sorry, but you are completely wrong.

None of my posts in this thread have been personal.

All have addressed either your argument directly, or your comments concerning your argument.

I said, in response to your comment that:

I have found that a theist in a predominantly atheist or secular forum quickly becomes overwhelmed by the number of rebuttals.

Yes, being wrong often has that effect.

This is not a personal remark. It addresses your argument, and the situation you find yourself in because of the failure thereof - which, as you can see, is a topic you yourself raised.

I put to you that the reason you find yourself overwhelmed with rebuttals is that your argument is so easily rebutted.

And look up syllogism while you are at it.
I know what a syllogism is, thank you.
 
I think you misunderstood Dr Craig. More on that in a min.
Very well.

If the KCA premises were correct it certainly would be a valid argument and thus lend credence to the big bang and its cause.
For it to be sound, the premises must be correct and the logic valid. The KCA has serious problems in both respects. The Wikipedia page outlines a number of these.

With all due respect, I don't think you understand what a simple syllogism is.
With all due respect, piffle.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom