The certainty of God's existence.

When I was your age I was a wiccan, a witch or warlock, a nature loving pagan. After that didn't pan* out out I moved on to eastern mysticism while a guest of uncle sam in south east Asia, Buddhism to be exact. I took a lot of good stuff with me when I became disillusioned with all the Gods and no good god. It was like eating rabbit food when I wanted a rare steak.

So being hedonistic and unwilling to give up my pleasures I studied and dabbled in LeVay satanism, nah too many nuts in that religion. I then was a agnostic dabbling in this and that but something was missing. To cut this way short, in college it was fashionable to say God is dead and Darwin is god I became rebellious against my rabid secular professors, and quit the regular schools (I went to many colleges as I traveled) I began researching in earnest joining seminary and the rest is history.

The moral of the story? You will find your path soon enough. Just don't die before you settle on Christianity ...

; {>
[/quote]

Um, well,thanks, I guess... but I'm not that young (clean living, you know.)I don't do wicca, or Eastern mysticism (it's just fun to link to 101 Zen Stories) and definitely not LaVey satanism. I was baptized Mormon, was sent to Guru Maharaji Ji (no guarantee on correct spelling) Sunday school, was dragged around to various weird churches, went to Baptist and Assembly of God Sunday schools, went to Lutheran school for a year and a half, went to Catholic schools for six and a half years, and was an evangelical Christian in college. Whoever has read all of John Shelby Spong has pretty much covered the equivalent of my faith journey since that time. As a matter of fact, I am a Christian, but that's true in the way that he would define the word. Here's his personal page. Not Wikipedia! I am not the kind of Christian who will ever be caught starting a thread about "the certainty of God's existence". There is, there can be, no certainty. I am, like Spong, a wordless mystic. Of course, he still writes books, so I also do posts. :)

But I mean, come on-- we all know that this thread isn't going to end up proving anything! Yes, I've actually read through the whole thing, every post, and it just isn't going anywhere; it's cycling over and over the same ground. In another thread, for example, I'm in a discussion about whether or not an anti-obesity drug which works for the average person will ever be possible. I'm arguing that it won't. We can't be sure which side will turn out to actually be right (will there be a drug someday, or won't there?), but we're each presenting citable research that can be defended and proven to be either correct or incorrect, and our arguments can be examined for logic and either utilized or discarded. There's a foreseeable end to it all. The underlying reason is that everyone on that thread essentially agrees on what a weight-loss drug is, and on what a future one would be. By contrast, there is no definition of God on which everyone here agrees. That's why in theory, back-and-forth argument about the certainty of God's existence could go on until the sun runs out of energy, and nobody would be any further ahead (although everyone is clearly going to run out patience long before that.) I don't really want proof of God's existence, which is good, because there isn't going to be any. Why try to prove? Why try to know what can't be known? Why try to believe? All of these things drive us away from mindfulness (no, NOT a Buddhist version-- more like Marsha Linehan's stuff, just take out the BPD part.
 
Last edited:
I don't think that Aquinas would ever suggest that God preceded the Universe in time.
.
The prototypical Aristotle-Aquinas "first cause" must exist outside time, to be the "first cause" which is itself uncaused.
Much more than that, it becomes a semantic nightmare to contemplate with any sense of logic.
 
RevDisturbia said:
To cut this way short, in college it was fashionable to say God is dead and Darwin is god I became rebellious against my rabid secular professors, and quit the regular schools
Just by the way, how come we always hear that US college professors are all rabid secularists, starting each lecture by challenging God to flick chalk off their shoulder or to knock them off the podium, and yet when any actual research is done it is shown that among US college and university professors atheist only number about 10% and that even atheist and agnostics together comprise a little over 20% of them. The rest have some sort of belief in God and the largest group, about 35% believe without any doubts.

http://religion.ssrc.org/reforum/Gross_Simmons.pdf

Even if all of the atheistic professors were 'rabid' RevDisturbia would only be rebelling against 10% of the faculty.

Why is it that Christians always like to portray themselves as a brave minority standing against the prevailing trend?
 
I really appreciate good books, whoever wrote whatever good book.

Good music too. And movies. Whoever does that stuff, wow.

Keep it up.

How do I multitask?

Would you believe I just do? I find I can safely and economically listen to music, watch a movie, read a book, answer email, write code, cook and consume a nutritious meal, and breeze through another fluffy pink yrreg post without ever leaving the house.

Sometimes, I get up and go for a walk, or ride my bike.


And I like pie.
 
Why is it that Christians always like to portray themselves as a brave minority standing against the prevailing trend?
Maybe it makes them feel more authentic, like they're THIS CLOSE to being tossed into the arena with a pride of ravenous lions, and then God will see just how devoted they are.

Or maybe they just enjoy make-believe.
 
.
The prototypical Aristotle-Aquinas "first cause" must exist outside time, to be the "first cause" which is itself uncaused.
That is more or less what I was getting at.
Much more than that, it becomes a semantic nightmare to contemplate with any sense of logic.
I agree. Aquinas' notion of something out of time is rather stronger than what RevDisturbia is suggesting. As I read it, for Aquinas something eternal is something which does not even have sequence of events - where all states are simultaneous. But then the idea of a "first" cause becomes problematic. I have often toyed with devising a language capable of dealing with the idea, but it is, as you suggest, a semantic nightmare.
 
The title of this thread of which yours truly is the author is:


The certainty of God's existence.
​


I am certain of the existence of God, maker of everything in the whole totality of existence which includes the physical universe, and author of the intelligent scheme of order prevailing in the whole totality of existence as described.


Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was certain of the existence of fairies at the bottom of the garden. He was as certain of the fairies as he was of the nose on his face. He even had photographic evidence of the fairies. Do you believe in fairies at the bottom of the garden? If not, then why are you so angry at the fairies?


Now you ask atheists here what they are certain of, and see what kinds of answers you will get.


First off they want you to explain what you mean by being certain.

So you tell them since they know English, just answer what you atheists are certain of, understanding the phrase certain of as children in grade school and market vendors and policemen and ordinary citizens understand certain of.


I am certain that your certainty is faulty, illogical and absurd. I am as certain of this as I am of the nose on my face.


But since I have already said so much on which account you will more likely than not witness that the atheists here will just keep to frivolities or engage in corn.

Corn? As in corny, i.e., in non-constructive and thus unproductive and therefore useless drivels, trying to look so stupid and hoping people readers here will at least get the impression, that for being so intelligent they prefer to act so dumb and irrelevant to the matter on hand.


What is the opposite of corn? Is it fish? Fish!*


*Warning: must be a fan of Bottom for this to make sense (UK comedy series and live shows starring Rik Mayal as Richard Richard and Adrian Edmonson as Edward Elizabeth Hitler).
 
We are both here for the fun? and some learning? Okay, let's work together for the...

I really appreciate good books, whoever wrote whatever good book.

Good music too. And movies. Whoever does that stuff, wow.

Keep it up.

How do I multitask?

Would you believe I just do? I find I can safely and economically listen to music, watch a movie, read a book, answer email, write code, cook and consume a nutritious meal, and breeze through another fluffy pink yrreg post without ever leaving the house.

Sometimes, I get up and go for a walk, or ride my bike.



We are both here for the fun? and some learning? Okay, let's work together for the learning.


I am asking whether atheists are certain about anything at all.

In my own case I am certain about my nose and my penis and many other things of my physical body.

In addition I am certain of God, maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe and author of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in the totality of existence as described.


Are you bokonon an atheist?

Tell me some things you are certain of, like for example your nose and your sex organ like in my case my penis.

Then we can proceed together to the issue of this thread on the certainty of God's existence.


Together, let us have fun and at the same time some learning, at least in regard to the psychology of atheists as also of theists, the likes of myself who call myself a rational theist.


What is a rational theist? For myself as calling myself a rational theist, I mean one who knows the certainty of God's existence from his faculty of reason.


If you be an atheist, pray, tell me what is it for you to call yourself an atheist.


Anyway, our interest at this moment is for us to give some mutually agreed on examples of things we are certain of.


So, tell me as an atheist are there things you are certain of in regard to their existence outside your mind?





Yrreg
 
I am asking whether atheists are certain about anything at all.

<snip vulgarity>

In addition I am certain of God, maker of everything in the whole totality of existence including the physical universe and author of the scheme of intelligent order prevailing in the totality of existence as described.


I am certain you are wrong regarding your certainty of God.


What is a rational theist? For myself as calling myself a rational theist, I mean one who knows the certainty of God's existence from his faculty of reason.


I am certain it is impossible to arrive at certainty of God through reasoning alone.


If you be an atheist, pray, tell me what is it for you to call yourself an atheist.


It means I don't believe in any gods. For me, personally, the only reason I don't believe in gods is because of lack of evidence and my certainty that it is impossible to arrive at certainty of God through reasoning alone.
 
When have you ever mutually agreed to anything? You just ignore everything everyone says and spew the same preaching nonsense over and over and over and over and over.

Your god would most certainly not be pleased with your ignorance of your fellow man. I'd say 'see you in hell' but when I get there, I'd prefer if you stayed away from me.
 
In my own case I am certain about my nose and my penis and many other things of my physical body.


You may want to rethink your certainty.

NOVA Online said:
Just as Philip Martinez could fool his brain into thinking his missing left arm had magically reappeared, anyone—even someone with all body parts intact—can trick his or her brain into thinking phantom thoughts, Ramachandran discovered. Want to fool yourself into thinking your nose is three feet long or that a rubber hand is actually your own? Read on.

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/mind/note_nf6.html
 
You do have guts but not properly used, instead aribitrarily against reason.

I choose to deny wilfully God's existence no matter what the reasons are for denying because I don't give any care for reasons whatever.


You may go away now and live to your heart's content without any care for the God that your heart and your mind are certain about but for your arbitrary wilful choice to disregard Him.


Like someone if you will in Christian mythology.



You do have guts but not properly used, instead arbitrarily against reason.

You see even though man is endowed with free choice, nonetheless there is use and abuse of free choice, just as there is use and abuse of private property.

The abuse of free choice is to choose to be or to do something which your reason knows to be wrong.

Just as the abuse of private property consists in employing your private property to no beneficial purpose to yourself or to mankind at large, for example burning your house because you want to wickedly show others you do have a house to burn -- the law will not fault you for burning your own house whatever your wicked desire, unless it is a danger to other homes.



Sure, I grant you the free choice to act against your reason; now you may go away.





Yrreg
 
I am asking whether atheists are certain about anything at all.
Within certain epistemological limits, yes. I'm certain I love my wife and children. I'm certain that if I don't pay my taxes there will be hell to pay instead. I'm certain that the arguments in favor of god are silly and absurd.
 
Last edited:
Yrreg, if you're only going to respond to 'bait' posts and 'joke' posts that have no merit in their argument and are strictly meant to just 'bait' you, then obviously, you're argument has no merit.

I'm certain of this because God told me.
 
Don't believe him, he is not taking my words in context.

I'm guessing that you missed his post in which Yrreg declared that atheists are incapable of experiencing love and beauty in their lives and then suggested that they should just commit suicide.


Don't believe him, he is not taking my words in context.


I will chalenge him to give the link to those words.




Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom