The certainty of God's existence.

The right psychology of atheists who have found in atheism a pearl of great price.

[...]

Ah, you will tell me that the best way to know the merits of atheist certainty that there is no God, is to examine atheists.


Yes, of course, you can always examine yourselves to know your true worth.

But I will examine ex-atheists because they had been there done that, and rejected their previous lifestyle and thought system of being and living as atheists.

When you have left atheist lifestyle and thought system or unsystem, tell me and I will interview you.





Yrreg


Anyway I will pass on to you atheists here who are writing furiously in defense of your atheist lifestyle an insight from yours truly.


I should really be writing fables in the style of Aesop, but here goes:

A group of tourists in a strange city went shopping in the local flea market and came to a nondescript stall selling cheap ersatz pearls -- any pearl for just 10 cents.

Before leaving for the tour he just happened to have taken a quick course on operating a pawn shop, imagining that he might set up such a business on retirement.

In this quick course he learned how to appraise jewel materials, like diamonds, pearls, platinum, gold, silver, etc.

He rummaged through the fake pearls and saw to his great delighted surprise that there was a big genuine pearl among all the fake ones which even looked better than the genuine one.

He quickly bought the genuine pearl just paying 10 cents.

Later in the evening dinner with other tourists in the group there was a big discussion on who bought the most beautiful pearl for just 10 cents.

He did not say anything, he kept quiet, and the next morning he and his wife left in a hurry for home, giving the token excuse that an emergency call from home required their presence there at the soonest.

The true reason was because they could not wait to cash in on the big genuine pearl, in order to right away finance their contemplated pawn shop, with the man first resigning pronto from his lifelong employment.
​

So, if you guys found a big genuine pearl of great price with the denial of God for a lifestyle, why are you so fervid in convincing yourselves writing messages in web forums about the worth of your atheist big genuine pearl?

Keep quiet, go away and live a happy comfortable life in sweet retirement with your big genuine pearl of great price in an atheist worldview-lifestyle.




Yrreg
 
Certainly (doing my best three stooges impersonation). Cause and effect would seem to need time wouldn't it? A egg breaks but doesn't unbreak, time has an arrow but its a strange arrow indeed. Why? According to physics an egg should unbreak just as easily as it breaks. Events are like seeds in rye bread. Slice the bread and you see the seeds (events). You can see how the seeds are located spatially with no regard to time. Time is not required.
The problem with this is twofold.

First while entropy serves as the arrow of time, there is no equivalent or analogue for space. Even if you lay out objects in a spatial domain in a sequence as an analogue for an event (an actual event being something that specifies a time domain, so this is only an analogue), it can be read in either direction, or many directions, perhaps infinitely many, since there is more than one dimension of space. If you force upon it a single dimension and a directional arrow, then you have time itself, not space, so the argument fails anyway.

Second, the argument fails to support your larger argument, because space is just as much a property of the Universe as time, so you can't substitute it in time's place anyway.
 
Hey Yrreg if you like rational, logical ontological arguments what do you think about Kurt Godels ontological argument for the existence of God? I am happy that one of the greatest mathematical minds of history beleived in God and expressed it in a logical expression. ; {>

Or the KCA (being a rational logical argument for the existence of God)

ie

P1: If the universe has no beginning, there have been an infinite number of events.
P2: An infinite number of events is an absurdity and is impossible.
C1: Therefore, the universe must have had a beginning.
P3: Everything which has a beginning must have been caused by something.
P4: If C1 and P3, then C2.
C2: The universe must have been caused by something.
P5: The cause of the universe is eternal.
P6: The only way an eternal cause could produce something bound by time is for it to freely choose to.
P7: If P5 and P6, then C3.
C3: The cause of the universe must be personal.
Kurt Godel went the schizophrenic route. He starved himself to death because he was afraid his food was poison. If God existed why allow this to happen to him?

This in Wiki.

Death
In later life, Gödel suffered periods of mental instability and illness. He had an obsessive fear of being poisoned; he wouldn't eat unless his wife, Adele, tasted his food for him. Late in 1977, Adele was hospitalized for six months and could not taste Gödel's food anymore. In her absence, he refused to eat, eventually starving himself to death. He weighed 65 pounds (approximately 30 kg) when he died. His death certificate reported that he died of "malnutrition and inanition caused by personality disturbance" in Princeton Hospital on January 14, 1978.
 
I am afraid you will have to be more descriptive than that. Please expand on that comment?

; }>

You mean like this?
Foster Zygote said:
Ah yes, the Kalām cosmological argument:

Premise 1. Everything that begins to exist has a cause.

Premise 2. The universe began to exist.

Conclusion: The universe must have a cause.

This is nothing more than the "first cause" argument proposed by people like Maimonides and Aquinas. It boils down to "I assert that the universe had a creator and I assert that said creator was my god". The same old problems apply to this argument. First, we don't know that the universe had a beginning. It could be self contained and finite, but without an actual beginning or end, like the surface of a sphere. Second, it exempts the "first cause" i.e. "God" from the restrictions placed on the universe. It simply assumes an infinite regress and then asserts a convenient eternal construct to terminate the regress. Third, even if it was a valid argument, it does nothing to justify the faith of the Abrahamic religions of Rambam, Aquinas or the Kalām philosophy.
 
The moral of the story? You will find your path soon enough. Just don't die before you settle on Christianity :D...

Do you believe that your god would have condemned you to eternal damnation if you had died prior to choosing Christianity?
 
PixiMisa said:
The problem with this is twofold.

Pixie said:
there is no equivalent or analogue for space.

Eddington said:
that has no analogue in space (Eddington 1928, 68)

First while entropy serves as the arrow of time, there is no equivalent or analogue for space. Even if you lay out objects in a spatial domain in a sequence as an analogue for an event (an actual event being something that specifies a time domain, so this is only an analogue), it can be read in either direction, or many directions, perhaps infinitely many, since there is more than one dimension of space.

What does this have to do with cause and effect? You are essentially agreeing with me at least the part I can make sense of. I said there was a arrow of time (there are many actually). I was speaking specifically about the casual arrow of time, to what arrow were you referring to?

If you force upon it a single dimension and a directional arrow, then you have time itself, not space, so the argument fails anyway.

Well….no not at all! Space time, I usually denote it as such but sometimes only say ‘time‘, however in this kind of discussion anyone should be aware I am not speaking of intuitive time, is the merging of time and space. You can separate them. You can have space and time. Your statement makes no sense to me. Ok lets do it as you say and take a dimension such as length then add a directional arrow say the The psychological and or perceptual arrow of time. How does that make a bit of sense?

Second, the argument fails to support your larger argument, because space is just as much a property of the Universe as time, so you can't substitute it in time's place anyway.

That makes no sense either! What and why do you think I am substituting (whatever) in times place?

; {>
 
Originally Posted by RevDisturba View Post
I figured that when I left the God of my parents a dollar (a large sum for a boy back then) and God didn't take it, he didn't exist.

_______________________________________________________________________

If you don't mind me asking, who exactly was the God of your parents?


At that time my father was an atheist/agnostic my mother was a Christian. But I was thinking Christian. I became an closet atheist in the third grade.

; {>
 
Do you believe that your god would have condemned you to eternal damnation if you had died prior to choosing Christianity?

I don't think that now so why should I then? I am a pastor and I never teach there is a burning hell for anything but the devil and his angles. Maybe a few unrepentant people may get the hot seat but I doubt it.

; {>
 
What does this have to do with cause and effect? You are essentially agreeing with me at least the part I can make sense of. I said there was a arrow of time (there are many actually). I was speaking specifically about the casual arrow of time, to what arrow were you referring to?
There isn't actually a definitive causal arrow of time, but we apply entropy as such, and it works well enough.

Well….no not at all! Space time, I usually denote it as such but sometimes only say ‘time‘, however in this kind of discussion anyone should be aware I am not speaking of intuitive time, is the merging of time and space. You can separate them. You can have space and time. Your statement makes no sense to me. Ok lets do it as you say and take a dimension such as length then add a directional arrow say the The psychological and or perceptual arrow of time. How does that make a bit of sense?
Time, as you note, is just one of four dimensions in space-time. The difference is the arrow of time that we infer from entropy. If you wish to substitute space for time in an analogue to the normal causal sequence, you can only do it consistently by applying a directional arrow to your selected spatial dimension. And if you do that, you have a time dimension.

That makes no sense either! What and why do you think I am substituting (whatever) in times place?
Your own words:
Certainly (doing my best three stooges impersonation). Cause and effect would seem to need time wouldn't it? A egg breaks but doesn't unbreak, time has an arrow but its a strange arrow indeed. Why? According to physics an egg should unbreak just as easily as it breaks. Events are like seeds in rye bread. Slice the bread and you see the seeds (events). You can see how the seeds are located spatially with no regard to time. Time is not required.
You are subsititing a spatial dimension for a temporal dimension. You can only do that if you turn the spatial dimension into a temporal dimension. Thus your argument fails, twice.
 
Last edited:
...I was thinking Christian.


So were talking about Yahweh then.

You offered Yahweh a dollar and He didn't take it so you concluded He didn't exist. Since then you tried many spiritual paths but eventually ended up back with Yahweh.

You'd have saved yourself a lot of time and trouble if you would have just taken the dollar to one of the many Money Collection Points that Yahweh has established, your local church.
 
I don't think that now so why should I then? I am a pastor and I never teach there is a burning hell for anything but the devil and his angles. Maybe a few unrepentant people may get the hot seat but I doubt it.

; {>

What if you are wrong?
 
PixyMisa said:
RevDisturba, perhaps you could address my "proof" that God does not exist?

It may be instructive to see what flaws you can find in it, and then compare it to your own argument.

he PAC (Pixy's Antecosmological Counterargment)

P1. The Universe, by observation, began at some point.
P2. Time is a property of the Universe.
C1. Therefore time itself began at some point.

Well you could of said The Universe, began>>>to exist<<<<< at some point.Then it would be correct. I don’t know what began means unless you did mean to begin to exist. I don’t think that time being a property of the universe would validate that it began at some point. It may not unless you are using big bang cosmology.

P3. Cause precedes effect.
P4. Precedence is a reference to time.
C2. Therefore there can be no cause and effect without time.
C3. Since time is a property of the Universe itself, and cause and effect is meaningless without reference to time, the Universe cannot have a cause.
P5. God is defined as the primal cause.
C4. God does not exist.

P3. False
P4 May be false
C2 False. Lets say we are looking at book. The pages are numbered 1,2,3 and so on.
C3

Lets look at P4 Its false as well. Because “Causality contrasted with conditionals
Conditional statements are not statements of causality. An important distinction is that statements of causality require the antecedent to precede the consequent in time, whereas conditional statements do not require this temporal order.

With all due respect PixyMisa, there are so many fallacies in your claim that it fails to be a logical syllogism taken in any order. And it fails as a simple argument.

; {>
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom