PixyMisa said:
RevDisturba, perhaps you could address my "proof" that God does not exist?
It may be instructive to see what flaws you can find in it, and then compare it to your own argument.
he PAC (Pixy's Antecosmological Counterargment)
P1. The Universe, by observation, began at some point.
P2. Time is a property of the Universe.
C1. Therefore time itself began at some point.
Well you could of said The Universe, began>>>to exist<<<<< at some point.Then it would be correct. I don’t know what began means unless you did mean to begin to exist. I don’t think that time being a property of the universe would validate that it began at some point. It may not unless you are using big bang cosmology.
P3. Cause precedes effect.
P4. Precedence is a reference to time.
C2. Therefore there can be no cause and effect without time.
C3. Since time is a property of the Universe itself, and cause and effect is meaningless without reference to time, the Universe cannot have a cause.
P5. God is defined as the primal cause.
C4. God does not exist.
P3. False
P4 May be false
C2 False. Lets say we are looking at book. The pages are numbered 1,2,3 and so on.
C3
Lets look at P4 Its false as well. Because “Causality contrasted with conditionals
Conditional statements are not statements of causality. An important distinction is that statements of causality require the antecedent to precede the consequent in time,
whereas conditional statements do not require this temporal order.
With all due respect PixyMisa, there are so many fallacies in your claim that it fails to be a logical syllogism taken in any order. And it fails as a simple argument.
; {>