Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
They can't evacuate early because then it would fall apart faster is such a hopeless pretzel of fail "I can't even."

Again it stinks of political considerations and things done for the sake of appearances going above what is best for human persons in harm's way.

I think it sounds more like preventing a run on the banks.
 
I guess the US should have done nothing after 9/11 even-though the Taliban knowingly hosted Osama bin laden and Al-Qaeda. In fact the Taliban knew that their "friends" were actively planning, training and funding terrorist attacks against the US from Afghanistan and by all accounts actively supported them.
....

No one says that. Going into Afghanistan to get Bin Laden was universally supported, but the Bush administration failed to send enough ground troops to seal the Pakistan border, allowing Bin Laden to escape. But after destroying Tora Bora and routing the Taliban, the U.S. should have gotten out. The mistake was to spend 20 years trying to install a U.S.-style democracy in a corrupt, medieval, tribal theocracy.

And no one today seems to think that invading Iraq under false pretenses was a good idea, or even that the Iraqi people are better off today than they would have been under Saddam or his successors.
 
Who should be punched back?

ISIS-K - they have announced responsibility.

Then, after evacuating everyone, bomb all the military equipment we left there for the Afghan army. It's a crap ton of weapons and gear. Taliban has already broken their 'promises'.

Targeted drone strikes in short order. Then we are done.
 
ISIS-K - they have announced responsibility.

Then, after evacuating everyone, bomb all the military equipment we left there for the Afghan army. It's a crap ton of weapons and gear. Taliban has already broken their 'promises'.

Targeted drone strikes in short order. Then we are done.

what promise did the Taliban break?
 
That's a question I wonder about a lot, and probably one we'll not get an answer for a long time, if ever.



Was Biden receiving intel that was telling him that the Afghan government would stand up for any amount of time and then was surprised when it collapsed instantly? Or was he just playing the political game, knowing full well that things were moving towards an utter calamity?
Any halfway competent operation involves staffers assigned to vehemently argue in favor of opposed positions. This is how a vigorous policy debate can take place without actual opposition figures becoming aware of the process taking place. Also, it helps prepare responses to detractors.

If that happened, those arguments were overridden and thus (in hindsight, I grant you) it was the wrong decision. If that didn't happen, we have bigger problems.
 
The next 9/11 type attack will almost certainly come from groups that didn't exist until we started our forever wars in the middle east.

No one says that. Going into Afghanistan to get Bin Laden was universally supported, but the Bush administration failed to send enough ground troops to seal the Pakistan border, allowing Bin Laden to escape. But after destroying Tora Bora and routing the Taliban, the U.S. should have gotten out. The mistake was to spend 20 years trying to install a U.S.-style democracy in a corrupt, medieval, tribal theocracy.

And no one today seems to think that invading Iraq under false pretenses was a good idea, or even that the Iraqi people are better off today than they would have been under Saddam or his successors.

That seems like an impossible task. This is a 1600 mile border of some of the toughest terrain in the world.
 
ISIS-K - they have announced responsibility.

Then, after evacuating everyone, bomb all the military equipment we left there for the Afghan army. It's a crap ton of weapons and gear. Taliban has already broken their 'promises'.

Targeted drone strikes in short order. Then we are done.

I don't know why they didn't already disable all that stuff. I agree we should still do something.


In the case of the Taliban, however, now is a perfect time to team up with them over this. ISIS-K is an enemy of the Taliban. ISIS wants a stricter Islamic state than the Taliban does. That could be useful.

Surprisingly Biden announced this splinter group was a terror threat a week or so ago. And the announcement for people to stop gathering at a particular gate was in response to intel of a planned attack. I want to know what the marines were doing there. Apparently they were checking papers to let people in and that put them in close contact with the crowd.

There is more here than we yet know. Dozens and dozens of Afghanis killed was a surprise to hear this morning along with the increased numbers of Marines killed.
 
Last edited:
Biden just made a number of promises. The future of his presidency might well depend on his ability to carry them out.
 
Any halfway competent operation involves staffers assigned to vehemently argue in favor of opposed positions. This is how a vigorous policy debate can take place without actual opposition figures becoming aware of the process taking place. Also, it helps prepare responses to detractors.

If that happened, those arguments were overridden and thus (in hindsight, I grant you) it was the wrong decision. If that didn't happen, we have bigger problems.

Which is why we need an invesigatin of the intelligence failure.
This is ha huge one, a Pearl Harbor/Battle of the BUlge?9/11 level intelligence failure.
Heads need to roll.
 
Biden impressed me more in this news donference more then he has so far in this crisis.
Pretty clear, the war on terror is not over, we have just pulled out of bad position in it.
 
In the case of the Taliban, however, now is a perfect time to team up with them over this. ISIS-K is an enemy of the Taliban. ISIS wants a stricter Islamic state than the Taliban does. That could be useful.

Why the hell would the Taliban help us? They may not like ISIS, but they like this attack. There’s no reason for them to help us go after ISIS, not now.
 
Biden just made a number of promises. The future of his presidency might well depend on his ability to carry them out.

You might be right but the next election is more than three years away.

And I'm convinced that how Biden handles the pandemic and the economy will be far more important to voters at that time.
 
Why the hell would the Taliban help us? They may not like ISIS, but they like this attack. There’s no reason for them to help us go after ISIS, not now.

You don't know that. The Taliban is not ISIS. They now have to govern. It's a different set of priorities. .
 
Watching the News confference with the Press secretary, and I think we just set a record for reporters asking stupid questions.
God,they are so clueless on anything to do with military or national security questions.
 
You might be right but the next election is more than three years away.



And I'm convinced that how Biden handles the pandemic and the economy will be far more important to voters at that time.
We seem to have whiffed on the whole census redistricting and any election law reforms. So 2022 is all but in the bag.. His Presidency will be hampered afterwards.

But hey, our own caucus can't agree on a budget, not much may change.
 
And I think they will be clueless in governeing. Medieval Mentalties don't do well in the modern world.

I don't disagree with that. But my guess is the new government still will be more mercenary than anything. What makes the most sense financially.
 
Watching the News confference with the Press secretary, and I think we just set a record for reporters asking stupid questions.
God,they are so clueless on anything to do with military or national security questions.

I'm afraid they will break it tomorrow.
 
That seems like an impossible task. This is a 1600 mile border of some of the toughest terrain in the world.


Not the whole border, just the routes from Tora Bora. At one point Bin Laden was thought to be less than two miles from U.S. troops. There seems to be pretty broad consensus that failed tactics allowed Bin Laden to escape.
The ultimate fault for the failure to capture bin Laden lies not in the U.S. effort, but in the U.S. strategy. Franks and Rumsfeld decided to attempt to deliver a swift and economical knockout blow to the Taliban through airpower and the limited application of troops on the ground. Instead of employing the Powell Doctrine of overwhelming force, the Afghan model for Operation Enduring Freedom depended on airpower and on highly mobile paramilitary teams, working in concert with opposition warlords and tribal leaders. Franks capped the number of boots on the ground at 10,000.

For this reason — the relative scarcity of U.S. soldiers — Franks and Rumsfeld refused to send more troops to Tora Bora to block, capture, or kill bin Laden. But soldiers and scholars alike have since argued that there were sufficient troops available in Afghanistan and nearby Uzbekistan to mount a genuine assault on bin Laden’s position at Tora Bora. And they could have been augmented within about a week by reinforcements from the Persian Gulf and the United States.
https://foreignpolicy.com/2009/12/11/how-osama-bin-laden-escaped-2/

"Tora Bora was just a case of military incompetence," argues Richard Clarke, at the time, a White House counter-terrorism adviser.

"They had plenty of time, they had the people, they had the information - this was not a matter of miscommunication. This was a matter of general officers deciding not to do it because they didn't think it was their mission."
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-14190032
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom