Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
We are not talking about "gotcha" questions here. We are taklkkng about DUMB questions.
Can't you take off the political lenses for one minute?

Political lens or otherwise, there's often not much difference between gotcha questions and dumb questions. They both reflect basic ignorance of the facts. And again, covering the White House is no proof of integrity or sophistication.
 
Last edited:
They are motivated by power. They can probably best obtain that power if they are seen to be "the reasonable ones" in the Taliban/ISIS dynamic.

Why would you think that? The Taliban didn’t gain power by being reasonable. That has never been their brand.
 
For some reason the question “why are Americans dying in Afghanistan?” was not considered an interesting or important question until someone decided to end the war.

https://twitter.com/mattyglesias/status/1431045904090517506

The decision to continue the war all these years had nothing to do with saving US lives, and a lot to do with powerful individuals avoiding the political and personal embarrassment of publicly admitting the war was a mistake.
 
Last edited:
With all the apologetics going on here,the whole thread should be moved to Religion and Philosophy.
 
We hear a lot about how Afghanistan was not a real country, but a conglomeration of tribes. And none of the outsiders like Russia and the US could integrate these tribes with a cohesive government. Why is the Taliban different? The divisions in that part of the world don't seem to be any more solvable with the Taliban than with anyone else.
 
Biden should resign for this.

But I also think a lot of former presidents should have resigned for less. So it doesn't mean much.
 
We hear a lot about how Afghanistan was not a real country, but a conglomeration of tribes. And none of the outsiders like Russia and the US could integrate these tribes with a cohesive government. Why is the Taliban different? The divisions in that part of the world don't seem to be any more solvable with the Taliban than with anyone else.

It isn't, it'll let local leaders do their own thing and only intervene when it deems necessary.

This is in contrast to the "colonial powers" who have tried to implement an alien form of government on a national level.
 
It isn't, it'll let local leaders do their own thing and only intervene when it deems necessary.

In addition, the Taliban were never in complete control of the country even before 9/11. There will probably be a re-emergence of the Northern Alliance which may keep the Taliban out of some areas of Afghanistan.
 
I would imagine that the Taliban is as riddled with ISISK infiltrators as the Afghan military is with Taliban.
 
I would imagine that the Taliban is as riddled with ISISK infiltrators as the Afghan military is with Taliban.

Not necessarily. Ideologues hate each other, first for their iota-size differences in doctrine, and second because they're competitors.

To be sure (christ, I wish we could be sure about anything in that ****** up part of the world), down at the illiterate mud sill of Islamic death cults there may be confusion of sympathies. Allah smiles on the slayer of infidels, dontcha know.

But the Toweliban is in the majority, they have the most munitions, and they give orders down the chain. It's in the low-level fighters' best interests to cleave to their Einzatsgruppen and obey. More fun, too.
 
Seven minutes of The Young Turks worth watching just to see how sharp Biden actually is. Any claim he's the least bit senile is absurd. The piece is good overall as well with Fox News' Doocy trying to blame Biden for the US soldiers' deaths today when the only alternative was to stay longer and probably add more troops to do so.


I remember during the primaries some members, including Bernie supporters, claiming that Biden had dementia and that it was being covered up by family members and Dem politicians. :boggled:
 
It isn't, it'll let local leaders do their own thing and only intervene when it deems necessary.

This is in contrast to the "colonial powers" who have tried to implement an alien form of government on a national level.



Nonsense. The Taliban , last times, tried to control local leaders;that is what led to a lot of the fighting.
And a great many Afghans regard the Taliaban as being just a puppet force for Pakistan.
Why are so many "Progressives" trying to put such a good face on the Taliban?
 
And the Taliban is not a manolithic force. One of the problems is no one is sure if the lower leval Taliban commanders will obey the top level commanders.
 
I admit, I want an explanation about the list of US and Afghan US employees that apparently fell into Taliban Hands.
 
And the Taliban is not a manolithic force. One of the problems is no one is sure if the lower leval Taliban commanders will obey the top level commanders.

Well . . . they may not be monolithic, but they are certainly manolithic...
 
Nonsense. The Taliban , last times, tried to control local leaders;that is what led to a lot of the fighting.
And a great many Afghans regard the Taliaban as being just a puppet force for Pakistan.
Why are so many "Progressives" trying to put such a good face on the Taliban?

You need to learn to differentiate between posting facts and speculation from supporting/putting a good face on the Taliban. That's black and white thinking vs being able to see shades of gray.
 
And if we have a 9/11 cale attack we turn the other cheek?

The original 9/11 attack was motivated by the lingering consequences of the end of the Ottoman Empire and WWI, the stricter international law and rights regimes of post WWII, the creation of the state of Israel, and such religious grievances as the protection of East Timor from Islamic rule. The discourse around human rights and the existence of Israel were enough for the West to feel it was wholly in the right, particularly at that juncture in time, when thoughts had naively strayed to "the end of history" and the definitive triumph of liberal democracy. However wise or flawed the military responses to 9/11 in Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria and elsewhere, initially they were largely applauded as the proper response by those in authority to the challenges made to the rule of law and human rights.

It's an entirely different world now in so many ways. To begin with, there is no cheek-turning analogy to apply, as there has been constant war for an entire generation, well past the tit-for-tat of initial conflict. The West, US in particular, now own a large series of actions which arguably include war crimes, torture, and a callous disregard for allies on and off the battlefield. At home and abroad, the US has dethroned itself as an example of the values it has claimed to represent, the 45th presidency marking a strident departure from all previous administrations since the nation's founding, its first open and unabashed flirting with totalitarianism. Nearly all illusion of what the US could nobly represent is gone; it's just another dubious player in great power games, no more, no less. The coming 2022 and 2024 elections will determine a great deal in this regard, either marking a shocking nadir the nation rebounds from as a people and culture, or the collapse of the American century. Isreal, for its part, has shown that yesterday's victims can easily be tomorrow's hangmen; we now know each generation must step out of the cave, and no one may wear laurels for more than a day.

TL;DR: If there is any to be any slapping, none of the cheeks are innocent, all hands are red, no fair crying foul anymore.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom