Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
SOme advisors are saying , according to CNN that some of his advisors are saying to stop all evacuation and poull out now.
I could not imagine anything that would be more disasterous for the Biden adminstration then leaving Americans on the ground in Kabul.
For starters, the Dems can kiss 2022 goodbye.
 
It makes it a hell of a lot more difficult.
Bidne might well no be facing either staying in Kabul beyond the deadline or leaving American Citizens behind.
I think the latter would be a total political disaster for Biden and the Dems, let alone the moral issues.

I think you wildly overestimate how much the public cares about people dying in our overseas military adventures.

Americans have been dying in Afghanistan for 20 years, and for most of that time the war was a pointless, rudderless affair that the public was all too happy to ignore. Soldiers went over, bodies came back, and nobody but those close to the deceased really cared all that much.

Unless there's some brinksmanship play by the Taliban to prevent Americans from leaving, I suspect this crisis shall pass and largely be old news by election time.
 
Last edited:
No, it's pretty damn clear that we should have stayed in Bagram.

And now that we know how quickly order disintigrated and people are essentially hostage, we should go get Bagram back. Like now.

I read Psaki's statement about "increased risk to our troops" as a reason to leave Kabul asap, which makes no sense if there are still thousands of Americans (and allies) left behind. We cannot leave anyone behind. :mad:

What is the point of having the strongest military in the world protecting our citizens if the troops cut and run from danger??

I hope there are some damn good reasons I am not considering...like that they are lying and have an aggressive plan to punch back hard and get those people out.
 
Last edited:
I think you wildly overestimate how much the public cares about people dying in our overseas military adventures.

Americans have been dying in Afghanistan for 20 years, and for most of that time the war was a pointless, rudderless affair that the public was all too happy to ignore. Soldiers went over, bodies came back, and nobody but those close to the deceased really cared all that much.

Unless there's some brinksmanship play by the Taliban to prevent Americans from leaving, I suspect this crisis shall pass and largely be old news by election time.
When can we address the humanitarian aspect of this crisis rather than just the soulless political implications?
 
When can we address the humanitarian aspect of this crisis rather than just the soulless political implications?

Beats me.

The humanitarian option was not to invade. That ship sailed 20 years ago. The idea that this war, or any war, was fought for humanitarian interests is a cruel joke. Wars are, almost always, bad for the people who live where they happen.

I have no optimism that much is going to be done for our allies once the last American takes off from Afghanistan. Once Americans are out of danger, the politics of the whole crisis is going to change radically. Any Afghan trying to get out would be well served to do so sooner rather than later.

We owe our allies there a lot, but don't hold your breath on us paying out.

ETA: The most charitable lens to view this crisis through is that Biden and his admin thought that the puppet Afghan government would stand up on its own for a little while, at least long enough to give us ample time to withdraw in an orderly fashion. Seems the instantaneous collapse and takeover by the Taliban has completely screwed things up.
 
Last edited:
And now that we know how quickly order disintigrated and people are essentially hostage, we should go get Bagram back. Like now.

I read Psaki's statement about "increased risk to our troops" as a reason to leave Kabul asap, which makes no sense if there are still thousands of Americans (and allies) left behind. We cannot leave anyone behind. :mad:

What is the point of having the strongest military in the world protecting our citizens if the troops cut and run from danger??

I hope there are some damn good reasons I am not considering...like that they are lying and have an aggressive plan to punch back hard and get those people out.

And i cold politcal terms,if Biden and the Dems think they can sell leaving American Citiznes behind in Afghanistan to the American people, they are crazy.
It might sell in San Francisco and other hard core Progressive areas, but nowhere else.
 
And i cold politcal terms,if Biden and the Dems think they can sell leaving American Citiznes behind in Afghanistan to the American people, they are crazy.
It might sell in San Francisco and other hard core Progressive areas, but nowhere else.

Realistically, I suspect Biden and all will insist on evacuation of all Americans, and will be much more open to quietly abandoning Afghani allies to their fate.

The last American flight out of Kabul is quickly approaching. The mad dash to get on board has begun.
 
Last edited:
And now that we know how quickly order disintigrated and people are essentially hostage, we should go get Bagram back. Like now.

I read Psaki's statement about "increased risk to our troops" as a reason to leave Kabul asap, which makes no sense if there are still thousands of Americans (and allies) left behind. We cannot leave anyone behind. :mad:

What is the point of having the strongest military in the world protecting our citizens if the troops cut and run from danger??

I hope there are some damn good reasons I am not considering...like that they are lying and have an aggressive plan to punch back hard and get those people out.

Who should be punched back?
 
No, it's pretty damn clear that we should have stayed in Bagram.

I remember Trump being lambasted for asserting “I know more about ISIS than the generals do, believe me.” And rightfully so.

Does not seem that far from you asserting you apparently know more about how to withdraw from Afghanistan than the Commander-in-Chief in consultation with his generals do.

At least that’s how it reads to me.
 
My working assumption is that the military weighed many different options and presented them to the Commander-in-Chief together with the possible cost in lives and probability of success. We know how chaotic much of this seems now. We have no way of knowing the potential risks and hazards of leaving Bagram open - and defending it - or the implications of an earlier mobilization of evacuations. Maybe once the dust settles we can have an objective analysis of what went right and what went wrong, but I think it’s far too early to jump to conclusions with the limited knowledge we as civilians have.

Part of this was that the Afghan government didn't want evacuations to start sooner because it would be seen as a vote of no confidence in them, causing them to fall faster. It looks like many of the decisions were based on the Afghan government holding out longer and they did what they thought they could to keep the chances of them holding out high.

But they did fall much faster than even the pessimist thought, so all the steps that were taken to mitigate the speed of the fall aggravated the problems with the exit once it had.
 
Realistically, I suspect Biden and all will insist on evacuation of all Americans, and will be much more open to quietly abandoning Afghani allies to their fate.

The last American flight out of Kabul is quickly approaching. The mad dash to get on board has begun.

Then we might well have to stay past the 31st deadline just to get Americans out.
problem is not the airlift but getting people to the airport.
But that some advisors are advocating a "lets get out now, even if Americans are left behing" does not give mymuch confidence in the kind of advisors Biden has.
 
Part of this was that the Afghan government didn't want evacuations to start sooner because it would be seen as a vote of no confidence in them, causing them to fall faster. It looks like many of the decisions were based on the Afghan government holding out longer and they did what they thought they could to keep the chances of them holding out high.

But they did fall much faster than even the pessimist thought, so all the steps that were taken to mitigate the speed of the fall aggravated the problems with the exit once it had.

I am pretty sure congressional hearins on the whole disaster are pretty much inevitable.
Heads need to roll over the intelligence failure alone.
 
I remember Trump being lambasted for asserting “I know more about ISIS than the generals do, believe me.” And rightfully so.

Does not seem that far from you asserting you apparently know more about how to withdraw from Afghanistan than the Commander-in-Chief in consultation with his generals do.

At least that’s how it reads to me.

You're assuming that Biden's decision was actually informed by the advice of his generals. I don't think it was.
 
You're assuming that Biden's decision was actually informed by the advice of his generals. I don't think it was.

The generals have been telling the civilian authorities for 20 years that they just need a little more time and a few more troops. If that's what they told Biden, it's not a surprise he didn't listen. What's more relevant is that by all accounts the intelligence services and the Afghan government itself told him that the Afghan Army could hold out against the Taliban for some time, maybe as long as 18 months, allowing for an orderly withdrawal. I doubt Biden expected or planned for a complete collapse in a week.

Let's also not forget that Trump set all this in motion by initiating what H.R. McMaster called a "surrender," without even including the Afghan government in the deal, and removing 10,000+ troops. Biden could have done better, but his options were limited.
 
Let's also not forget that Trump set all this in motion by initiating what H.R. McMaster called a "surrender," without even including the Afghan government in the deal, and removing 10,000+ troops. Biden could have done better, but his options were limited.

Biden didn't have to stick with Trump's deal. It was never ratified by Congress, he had the freedom to break it if he felt it was a bad deal. He's broken other deals that Trump made but Congress never ratified.
 
But that some advisors are advocating a "lets get out now, even if Americans are left behing" does not give mymuch confidence in the kind of advisors Biden has.

Where are you seeing that Biden advisors are openly suggesting this? My googling comes up blank.
 
Biden didn't have to stick with Trump's deal. It was never ratified by Congress, he had the freedom to break it if he felt it was a bad deal. He's broken other deals that Trump made but Congress never ratified.


And here's what a combat vet thinks about that:
The status quo of a small military footprint was not an option. Leaving a couple thousand troops would break President Donald Trump’s deal with the Taliban. The troops would require substantial reinforcements to battle the Taliban, which was at peak post-9/11 strength. The United States would be starting a third decade of warfare, still with no political endgame.

Biden made the right decision. There’s no glory in it, but there is integrity. He saw above the politics in Washington, beyond the news cycle, through the challenges of the withdrawal. Biden looked, instead, to the national interest. The United States must focus its foreign policy on countering the Chinese Communist Party and on leading coalitions to address the climate and pandemic emergencies.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/08/25/biden-made-hard-choice-afghanistan-right-one/

Rejecting Trump's deal would have required returning thousands of troops to Afghanistan. Who wanted that?
 

My only quibble here is the suggestion that withdrawing was a bad political move. Withdrawing from Afghanistan has been and remains a politically popular position.

Despite the absolute tantrum that the natsec ghouls and media pundits are throwing, withdrawing from this decades long war remains popular. You wouldn't know it from reading the headlines or the political commentary, but this is simply a case where the political elite are very much out of step with the American public, and have been for many years.

My prediction is that once the dust settles from the chaos of the withdrawal, Biden will emerge from this as popular, if not more so, than before. The pundits that still advocate for this war will never admit that it was a mistake, but public opinion will remain against them.
 
Last edited:
I remember Trump being lambasted for asserting “I know more about ISIS than the generals do, believe me.” And rightfully so.

Does not seem that far from you asserting you apparently know more about how to withdraw from Afghanistan than the Commander-in-Chief in consultation with his generals do.

At least that’s how it reads to me.

I heard in an interview with Rory Stewart (who was a British MP and former British soldier) suggesting that it came down to Biden being presented with “Goldilocks options” of two stupid ones and the sensible one in the middle. Whereas Trump in the past might have chosen the stupid option of maximum bombastic potential - Biden seems to have chosen the most extreme at the other end of the spectrum instead of the one that was “just right”. I don’t know if he is getting his information from reliable sources or in fact if it is just speculation from him but that could be one explanation. One thing we do know is that Biden has cited intelligence that turned out to be wrong and made predictions about what definitely wouldn’t happen that also turned out to be wrong so we definitely can’t assume that there is some deep unknown wisdom behind the decisions.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom