Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Tragic. I’m reminded of John Kerry asking how you ask someone to be the last one killed in a failed war, or words to that effect.

Horrible that these Marines were asked to be just that.

Sure. It must be terrible to be risking life for what has now been publicly acknowledged as a lost cause.

It's important to remember that there is no death-free option. Remaining in Afghanistan almost certainly meant even more American soldiers dying. The recent cease-fire was a condition extracted from the Taliban on the explicit promise of withdrawal. Remaining behind would mean an immediate resumption of insurgency by the Taliban, which by all indications is in as strong of a position as they have ever been.

Whatever loss of life that happens now as part of the withdrawal will probably be a bargain compared to what years of remaining behind would have cost, and that's not even factoring in the PTSD suicides that dwarf combat casualties for vets of the Afghan campaign.

The best way to prevent soldiers from dying in pointless wars is to not start them. That's the lesson of Vietnam that we apparently forgot. Hopefully we remember this tragedy when the war hawks inevitably start squawking again.
 
Last edited:
Corpses not even cold but the GOP weighs in:

https://www.cnn.com/2021/08/26/politics/republicans-kabul-biden/index

I am by no means saying Biden does not share reponsbility for this, but to make politics out of it right away is a sad commentary on what a totla mess this once great country is in.
And of course they don't mention the bad deal Trump made which set this up.
Putin, CHina nd many in the Mideast are rejocing at the spectacle of this country ripping itself apart.
I am not optimistic about the future of the US at this moment. One party seems to have jettisoned any commitment to Democracy in it's lust for power, and the other seems to be inept and ,worse, is showing signss of being taken over by it's won militant wing.
 
Last edited:
Sure. It must be terrible to be risking life for what has now been publicly acknowledged as a lost cause.

It's important to remember that there is no death-free option. Remaining in Afghanistan almost certainly meant even more American soldiers dying. The recent cease-fire was a condition extracted from the Taliban on the explicit promise of withdrawal. Remaining behind would mean an immediate resumption of insurgency by the Taliban, which by all indications is in as strong of a position as they have ever been.

Whatever loss of life that happens now as part of the withdrawal will probably be a bargain compared to what years of remaining behind would have cost, and that's not even factoring in the PTSD suicides that dwarf combat casualties for vets of the Afghan campaign.

The best way to prevent soldiers from dying in pointless wars is to not start them. That's the lesson of Vietnam that we apparently forgot. Hopefully we remember this tragedy when the war hawks inevitably start squawking again.

And if we have a 9/11 cale attack we turn the other cheek?
 
Tragic. I’m reminded of John Kerry asking how you ask someone to be the last one killed in a failed war, or words to that effect, referring to Vietnam.

Horrible that these Marines were asked to do just that.

Thats not true. Americans haven't genuinely fought in Afghanistan for months. If anything, the war has been over since Trump signed his "deal" with the Taliban as far as the Americans are concerned.

These people died in an attempt to help evacuate American residents and others, not fighting a war.
 
Thats not true. Americans haven't genuinely fought in Afghanistan for months. If anything, the war has been over since Trump signed his "deal" with the Taliban as far as the Americans are concerned.

These people died in an attempt to help evacuate American residents and others, not fighting a war.

The ceasefire was a condition of a deal that promised withdrawal. Failure to leave would mean an immediate resumption of hostilities.

the withdrawal is far from perfect, but I think it's naive to assume there was a 0 casualty option available.
 
Nice dodge to my question.

It's not a dodge. Invading the entire middle east as a response to 9/11 objectively made our country less safe. If Osama Bin Laden's goal was to destabilize our country and drag us into a long, pointless war that made the US a lot of enemies, he succeeded beyond his wildest dreams.

Hopefully it's not a foolish error that will be repeated in the future.

ETA: as unpalatable as it might seem, doing nothing would have been less of a disaster.
 
Last edited:
The best way to prevent soldiers from dying in pointless wars is to not start them. That's the lesson of Vietnam that we apparently forgot. Hopefully we remember this tragedy when the war hawks inevitably start squawking again.

I guess the US should have done nothing after 9/11 even-though the Taliban knowingly hosted Osama bin laden and Al-Qaeda. In fact the Taliban knew that their "friends" were actively planning, training and funding terrorist attacks against the US from Afghanistan and by all accounts actively supported them.

After the USS Cole attack the US sent cruise missiles against Al-Qaeda camps in Afghanistan and the international community cranked up sanctions against the Taliban, but they did not stop supporting Al-Qaeda.
 
I guess the US should have done nothing after 9/11 even-though the Taliban knowingly hosted Osama bin laden and Al-Qaeda. In fact the Taliban knew that their "friends" were actively planning, training and funding terrorist attacks against the US from Afghanistan and by all accounts actively supported them.

After the USS Cole attack the US sent cruise missiles against Al-Qaeda camps in Afghanistan and the international community cranked up sanctions against the Taliban, but they did not stop supporting Al-Qaeda.

You got me, there was no other option but an open ended, 20 year war with no real objective, plus an unrelated invasion of Iraq that had something to do with the attacks for... reasons.

I'd happily argue about what the appropriate response to 9/11 was, and why it shouldn't have been a blank check for Bush to invade the entire middle east, but that's far off topic for this thread about Biden and his good decision to finally end this turd of a war.

What should Biden have done that 20 years and 3 other presidents couldn't accomplish?

ETA: It's easy to see why this war was allowed to drag on so long. The steady trickle of body bags and human misery was easy to ignore, but a brief period of chaos to effectuate a withdrawal is seen as politically unforgiveable.

As far as I can tell, this supposed outrage is almost entirely contained to the pundit classes. My suspicion is that, in 6 months time, the public will be happy this was done and the natsec ghouls will still be fuming that their forever war was aborted.
 
Last edited:
It's not a dodge. Invading the entire middle east as a response to 9/11 objectively made our country less safe. If Osama Bin Laden's goal was to destabilize our country and drag us into a long, pointless war that made the US a lot of enemies, he succeeded beyond his wildest dreams.

Hopefully it's not a foolish error that will be repeated in the future.

ETA: as unpalatable as it might seem, doing nothing would have been less of a disaster.

Go try to sell that to anybody the US outside a few "progressives".
 
Go try to sell that to anybody the US outside a few "progressives".

Popularity giveth, popularity taketh away.

The war hawks got the war they wanted and it turned into an unmitigated disaster. Now public opinion has turned.

Dr. Seuss said:
Don't cry because it's over, smile because Northrop Grumman made a fortune
 
Last edited:
Go try to sell that to anybody the US outside a few "progressives".

It should be best thought of as a like a good old fashioned public lynching to re establish order in society. The blood of the innocent is really the only way to appease the mob after all.
 
Part of this was that the Afghan government didn't want evacuations to start sooner because it would be seen as a vote of no confidence in them, causing them to fall faster. It looks like many of the decisions were based on the Afghan government holding out longer and they did what they thought they could to keep the chances of them holding out high.



But they did fall much faster than even the pessimist thought, so all the steps that were taken to mitigate the speed of the fall aggravated the problems with the exit once it had.
They can't evacuate early because then it would fall apart faster is such a hopeless pretzel of fail "I can't even."

Again it stinks of political considerations and things done for the sake of appearances going above what is best for human persons in harm's way.
 
They can't evacuate early because then it would fall apart faster is such a hopeless pretzel of fail "I can't even."

Again it stinks of political considerations and things done for the sake of appearances going above what is best for human persons in harm's way.

That's a question I wonder about a lot, and probably one we'll not get an answer for a long time, if ever.

Was Biden receiving intel that was telling him that the Afghan government would stand up for any amount of time and then was surprised when it collapsed instantly? Or was he just playing the political game, knowing full well that things were moving towards an utter calamity?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom