Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, the steady beat of "not Biden's fault per se/there's more important matters at hand/what Trump would have done" isn't too far from the same thing.

Yeah it is. Consider a number of posts are reacting to certain overly critical Debbie Downer stuff as that explains why it might look like we are saying Biden is above criticism.
 
Yeah it is. Consider a number of posts are reacting to certain overly critical Debbie Downer stuff as that explains why it might look like we are saying Biden is above criticism.

Rough summation of one of the main lines of discussion -

A - "This is horrible! Dems are going to lose horribly in 2022 because of this!"
B - "This is horrible, but realistically, this isn't likely to affect 2022 much, if at all."
A - "Biden's above criticism! This is wrong!"
C - "Is it not affecting 2022 really the hill you want to die on, B?"
B - :boggled:
 
Last edited:
The non-politics side of it is an interesting topic also. What does a well executed troop withdrawal from a war torn country who's government is currently collapsing look like? Are we getting in firefights with the Taliban, trying to hold Kabul at all costs? Sending in thousands more troops and more equipment the months leading up to it? How do you ever leave?

Maybe this is it, I don't know.
 
The non-politics side of it is an interesting topic also. What does a well executed troop withdrawal from a war torn country who's government is currently collapsing look like?

The most obvious error is that we should have withdrawn from Kabul (starting with civilians) before we withdrew from Bagram, not the other way around.
 
Bagram is about 50 miles away down a two lane highway through the mountain passes. The logistics of trying to use Bagram to help evacuate are pretty challenging.
 
Rough summation of one of the main lines of discussion -

A - "This is horrible! Dems are going to lose horribly in 2022 because of this!"
B - "This is horrible, but realistically, this isn't likely to affect 2022 much, if at all."
A - "Biden's above criticism! This is wrong!"
C - "Is it not affecting 2022 really the hill you want to die on, B?"
B - :boggled:

That's if you think the news is driving beliefs. If you take a deep breath, slow it down, you can see that a lot of liberals and Democrats are not buying the 'Biden screwed up horribly' narrative. It sells the news. That doesn't mean people are buying it.
 
Bagram is about 50 miles away down a two lane highway through the mountain passes. The logistics of trying to use Bagram to help evacuate are pretty challenging.

The criticism that I have heard is that the US pulled all of its staff out of Bagram in the middle of the night without even informing their Afghan counterparts and effectively stripping the Afghan military of its air power. This is one of the reasons why the Taliban could advance so quickly through the country and it meant they were in Kabul before the evacuation could even begin, let alone be completed.

It wasn't because people from Kabul were going to be driven to Bagram and to evacuate from there.
 
Bagram is about 50 miles away down a two lane highway through the mountain passes. The logistics of trying to use Bagram to help evacuate are pretty challenging.

I'm not sure you understand the point about pulling out of Bagram last. You don't evacuate people through Bagram. You use Bagram to provide air support to your troops while you evacuate people out of Kabul. Only the military based in Bagram evacuate out of Bagram. Which they already did. But they should be the last to leave, precisely because it's a military-only facility that's much more defensible than Kabul.
 
You didn't state your point very clearly so I was left incorrectly guessing what it was you were getting at. I'll agree it's possible they may have held Kabul a bit longer, but as the rest of the country collapsed the the withdrawal began I'm not sure how much longer the government of would have held out. How much longer would Ghani have stayed in the country, for instance?
 
You didn't state your point very clearly so I was left incorrectly guessing what it was you were getting at. I'll agree it's possible they may have held Kabul a bit longer, but as the rest of the country collapsed the the withdrawal began I'm not sure how much longer the government of would have held out. How much longer would Ghani have stayed in the country, for instance?

Whether or not Kabul held out, our troops in Kabul airport would be in a much better position if they could count on air support from Bagram. But my point isn't really about how much of a difference this would have made (since that's inevitably speculation) so much as this was an obvious mistake.
 
Fair enough, I'll agree it's a mistake. My original question was how would a well executed withdrawal look different, so I have some interest in how the magnitude of the mistake would change the execution of the withdrawal.
 
Fair enough, I'll agree it's a mistake. My original question was how would a well executed withdrawal look different, so I have some interest in how the magnitude of the mistake would change the execution of the withdrawal.

We would probably need more information than is publicly available to get a good handle on that.
 
Well, the steady beat of "not Biden's fault per se/there's more important matters at hand/what Trump would have done" isn't too far from the same thing.

For something to be an error there needs to be a clearly better option. And people are not clear on what that should have been.
 
That's if you think the news is driving beliefs. If you take a deep breath, slow it down, you can see that a lot of liberals and Democrats are not buying the 'Biden screwed up horribly' narrative. It sells the news. That doesn't mean people are buying it.

I am open to saying he screwed up horribly but there needs to be a clearly better solution with the information he knew at the time. I really don't see people presenting what he should have done instead.
 
Yeah it is. Consider a number of posts are reacting to certain overly critical Debbie Downer stuff as that explains why it might look like we are saying Biden is above criticism.
Simply referring to criticism in demeaning and dismissive ways yet again reeks of the very responses we objected to from Trump apologists.
 
Get vulnerable people out before withdrawing.

How hard was that?

Which people, who will take them and so forth. I mean we are seeing backlash about them with this softening attitudes, you really think we could have convinced america to take in say 200,000 Afghans before this mess?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom