Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
For starters, his administration completely botched the withdrawal in Afghanistan.
For all the talk from some quarters about it being botched, nobody has yet managed to point out exactly what's so wrong.

The fact that the Taliban took over? There was never any way to withdraw without that happening, so it isn't a matter of doing it wrong; it's just a matter of whether to do it at all or not (which is why those who are against it, like Lindsey Graham, don't say how else to do it; they just say it shouldn't ever be done at all).

How fast that happened? That's about what the locals did, not what we did.

The huge battle raging around the last of our forces and all of our people who are dying in the process of our movie-like desperate last-second scramble to escape? Oops, wait, that's not happening; it's been impressively peaceful.

There's no apparent sign of anything "disastrous" about it beyond "I'm just really desperate for something to call a disaster while Biden is President".

I think inflation, gas prices, and the border situation are also to blame.
The gas price isn't even particularly high; it's just where it always is this time of year, which everybody's used to. But his immigration policy is pretty much unchanged from Trump's, he's fiddling around on student debt & college costs, and he's not even coming anywhere near showing any signs of awareness of the existence of other issues directly addressing Americans' well-being, like health care (remember what he promised he'd do while campaigning?), the ballooning health-care debt crisis, or the rent/mortgage crisis. (The moritorium on that last one's been delayed again, but after a crucial deadline, and without any consideration of how to handle the transition the next time it ends.) Also, the plague is getting worse again, and, although that's still more Trump's fault (for causing many in his party to go out of their way to do everything they can to deliberately make it worse), some things just tend to unfairly get associated with whoever's President when they happen.

even the left leaning media seem to be turning on him.
No, the lefties are saying this is the best thing he's done and it makes him look better than he did before. One of them is where I found out about this poll from. If you meant the big old media companies that aren't Fox or even farther right like OANN, they've long been pro-war, not left-leaning.
 
Because of the chaos. Polls are a reflection of people's feelings at that moment in time. And Biden has been getting hammered by the foreign policy pundits and that dominated the news this last week.
But it means little in the long run. If the withdrawal goes well, Biden's numbers will rise again. Probably to even higher numbers. Because overall, America wanted out.

That Biden is being criticized by some fellow Dems and by what the right likes to call the "fake news" is telling. I wonder how Fox "actual news" would have handled the same situation if it had happened under Trump. We know how Carlson, Hannity, and other Fox pundits, OAN and Newsmax would have handled it.
 
Maybe you should think outside the very blue district you live in.
America wanted out, but not in the way it is happening.And if the evacuation goes bad..which it easily could. Biden has to get Americans AND the Afghan allies out.That is a failure is not an option mission.
And it looks as it won't be complete by the 31st.
And, yes, Biden deserved to be plummled for his handling of the withdrawal.

They won't care in the long run.

Yes if it goes badly that could have an impact. But if it doesn't, this will become a thing of the past. And I disagree with you that Biden deserved to be plummeted over his handling.

Deserve has nothing to do with it. I also think it's Monday morning quarterbacking.
 
Anybody here old enough to have even a childhood memory of when Truman fired MacArthur? I am.

And the right wing yelling, shrieking, bellowing, harrumphing, and chuntering were just as loud and dire

and as vapid

as they are today.
 
Last edited:
Blaming Biden for high gas prices is a knee jerk reaction and not based on facts (normal for this post-fact political era) . According to Politifact:

Gas prices have gone up under President Joe Biden, continuing an upward trend that began in May 2020 (under Trump).


• The increase is largely due to supply and demand, energy experts say, rather than presidential policies.

• The coronavirus pandemic prompted a big fall in oil demand and gasoline prices, due to declines in driving and air travel. As the economy has slowly rebounded, growing demand has boosted prices at the pump.

Are gas prices going up?

Yes, according to federal data, gas prices have mostly been going up since they bottomed out at $1.87 a gallon in late April 2020. With gas prices reaching $2.72 in late February 2021, that’s an increase of 45% within about 10 months.

Part of that has come on Biden’s watch — prices have risen about 10% since he took office in January 2021. The bulk of the increase came under Trump.

Fox News, ... anchor Bill Hemmer said on March 1, "Gas prices are going higher, and if you don't think that Middle America takes notice of that, think again. We are seeing prices now that we frankly haven't seen in years."

Are gas prices higher than they’ve been "in years"?

No. Today’s prices are the highest they’ve been in about 18 months.

Gas prices were similar to or higher than their current level for much of the time between October 2017 and January 2020 — that is, more than two years of Trump’s presidency. Prices were higher than today for all of the time between March 2018 and November 2018, and all of the time between April 2019 and August 2019.

Some critics of Biden have said that his cancellation of the Keystone XL pipeline early in his presidency would quickly result in higher gasoline prices. But we previously found that, for several reasons, that’s not the case.

For starters, the pipeline wasn’t operating yet.
"Revoking it does nothing to today’s balance" of supply and demand, said Mark Finley, a fellow at the Center for Energy Studies at Rice University.
In addition, most of the oil to be carried by the Keystone XL pipeline would have been exported, meaning U.S. customers should see little direct effect on prices.
 
Around here gas prices have not really changed since Memorial Day.

Yes, it went up before that but recall that last Memorial Day the price of a barrel of oil was in negative territory due to this mishandled pandemic.
 
Around here gas prices have not really changed since Memorial Day.

Yes, it went up before that but recall that last Memorial Day the price of a barrel of oil was in negative territory due to this mishandled pandemic.

They just went up another 10 cents around here. But I'm kind of expecting them to drop pretty soon. Oil prices have been falling and if COVID starts surging again don't expect them to go back up anytime soon.
 
To where? no one wanted these people. I mean it is a crap storm now that we see they will be killed if they stay but everyone always knew that and we have been crappy to people like translators since forever. Why would we expect that to change?
Why is what bigoted (or at best blithely unconcerned) people want given equal or higher priority than what people who helped us and now stand under threat of violent reprisal need to be safe?

Why is this trotted out as if it makes some kind of reasonable sense?
 
Yeah, it took Biden seven months to screw something up. In his first six months, Trump continued his litany of lies by claiming his inauguration crowd was much larger than it was and claimed that millions of illegal immigrants had voted for HRC including 'dead people' (sound familiar?), ordered the construction of a useless wall that Mexico never paid for, had an extreme conservative put on the SC, appointed Steve Bannon (!) to be a permanent member of the Principals Committee while allowing the Joint Chief of Staff and the director of national intelligence to only attend National Security Council meetings when he thought the topic was 'pertinent', appointed Michael Flynn (!) as National Security Adviser, withdrew from the Paris Climate Agreement (cuz climate change is a 'China hoax' ), rolled back around two dozen environmental rules and regulations, tried to implement a “total and complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States”, did away with regulations that made it harder for mentally ill people to buy guns and prohibited broadband providers from tracking online activity of customers without their permission. And, like As Seen On TV...there's more! So much more.

One or two whataboutisms would have probably been sufficient.

Not that things Trump did years ago now have anything to do with what Biden could have been doing since attaining office, but I digress.
 
Like what? Getting people vaccinated? Lowering the death rate from Covid because of it (no thanks to the anti-vaxxers and anti-maskers). And when it comes to a president "lying", I suggest you not go there. It's like bringing a knife to a gun fight.



I see the truth hurts. Too bad.
What has Biden actually done to push vaccines, though?

My region is still at all of 40% with a 0.3% weekly increase.

It seems largely still lead by state and local policy which varies place to place, so if you're going the "his focus has been on other stuff" route, maybe at least pick things that look like real victories and not other stalled quagmires with equally disappointing outcomes.

He's not a disgusting, petty tyrant is great, don't get me wrong. But that still leaves us with a rather mediocre, drifting on inertia kind of leader.
 
Last edited:
What has Biden actually done to push vaccines, though?

Well, let's see. In his first week in office:

On Jan. 26 , the President outlined the first three steps his team will take as part of a National Action Strategy for responding to the pandemic. First, the Administration will increase minimum weekly shipments of vaccines to states to 10 million doses, from the current 8.6 million. Next, Biden guaranteed these shipment numbers for the next three weeks, which allows states to plan out for the next month how many people they can vaccinate. (Uncertainty about the number of doses they were receiving with each shipment was a big complaint during the first weeks of the rollout under the Trump Administration’s’ Operation Warp Speed.) Finally, the federal government purchased 200 million additional doses of vaccines from Moderna and Pfizer-BioNTech, ensuring the government has enough to inoculate the entire American public with two doses by the end of the summer—whether or not any other vaccines are approved in the interim.
https://time.com/5933825/biden-new-vaccine-plan/

Since then, over 50% of Americans 12 yrs and over have been vaccinated in less than 7 months.

My region is still at all of 40% with a 0.3% weekly increase.

That's Biden's fault? Is the 40% due to lack of availability of the vaccine? Or is it due to the people where you live choosing not to be vaccinated?

It seems largely still lead by state and local policy which varies place to place, so if you're going the "his focus has been on other stuff" route, maybe at least pick things that look like real victories and not other stalled quagmires with equally disappointing outcomes.

I'm not "going there" at all. That seems to be your "I want to blame Biden" routine. Has it occurred to you that it's the job of the state governors and their health departments to do that and not Biden's....who has made sure they get the vaccines themselves?

He's not a disgusting, petty tyrant is great, don't get me wrong. But that still leaves us with a rather mediocre, drifting on inertia kind of leader.

You're really going to have to get over Bernie losing.
 
I'm in no way barring you from saying anything.

Get off your god damn cross.

Then why tell my that "One or two whataboutisms would have probably been sufficient,"? I suggest you get the damn chip off your shoulder.





Says the person deflecting criticism with a tired old tactic.

You avoided the point by going off on a Trump tangent, so less hypocrisy, please.

You really need to get over Bernie losing.
 
For all the talk from some quarters about it being botched, nobody has yet managed to point out exactly what's so wrong.

The fact that the Taliban took over? There was never any way to withdraw without that happening, so it isn't a matter of doing it wrong; it's just a matter of whether to do it at all or not (which is why those who are against it, like Lindsey Graham, don't say how else to do it; they just say it shouldn't ever be done at all).

How fast that happened? That's about what the locals did, not what we did.

The huge battle raging around the last of our forces and all of our people who are dying in the process of our movie-like desperate last-second scramble to escape? Oops, wait, that's not happening; it's been impressively peaceful.

There's no apparent sign of anything "disastrous" about it beyond "I'm just really desperate for something to call a disaster while Biden is President".

You hit upon one of the concerns with the phrase "desperate last-second scramble to escape". I mean, that's not a good thing, is it? And who is in control? Our friends the Taliban. Most of the Americans and allies that remain are behind Taliban lines. All of this is due to poor planning on the part of the Biden Administration acting unilaterally with no coordination with NATO and other allies we worked with over the past 20 years.

Intelligence was another massive failure. Did Biden have any the country was going to fall to the Taliban so fast? Hard to say. He told us with a straight face that it was highly unlikely, that we'd see no Saigon like scenes, that he wasn't aware of any criticism from any of our allies, and that Americans weren't having any trouble at all getting to the airport. Most of this was refuted in real time as he was saying it. He seems to have almost no idea of what is happening.

No, the lefties are saying this is the best thing he's done and it makes him look better than he did before. One of them is where I found out about this poll from. If you meant the big old media companies that aren't Fox or even farther right like OANN, they've long been pro-war, not left-leaning.

I'm talking talking about the NY Times, Wapo, CNN, the rest of the alphabet networks, the economist, the BBC, lots of podcasters on the left (Sam Harris, etc.), leftists on twitter, left leaning celebrities, world leaders, etc, etc, etc, even a few left leaning ISF posters.

I can't imagine who or where is saying "this is the best thing he's done and it makes him look better than he did before". I'm sure there is some strange corner of the Internet.
 
Then why tell my that "One or two whataboutisms would have probably been sufficient,"? I suggest you get the damn chip off your shoulder.















You really need to get over Bernie losing.
I can see I need to get my tin foil hat dusted off.

Impugning my motives repeatedly tells me you have nothing to really say.
 
Last edited:
Well, let's see. In his first week in office:





https://time.com/5933825/biden-new-vaccine-plan/



Since then, over 50% of Americans 12 yrs and over have been vaccinated in less than 7 months.







That's Biden's fault? Is the 40% due to lack of availability of the vaccine? Or is it due to the people where you live choosing not to be vaccinated?







I'm not "going there" at all. That seems to be your "I want to blame Biden" routine. Has it occurred to you that it's the job of the state governors and their health departments to do that and not Biden's....who has made sure they get the vaccines themselves?







You're really going to have to get over Bernie losing.
Oh, he put out some statements basically taking credit for a logistical operation already in progress.

Anyone with a sense of what the problem is could have told you last year that delivery was never the major hurdle, so this just lands to me as another failure to lead in a meaningful way.

We've withdrawn.from Afghanistan but the issue is how and why.

We got soldiers out only to have to send some back in, so the timely withdrawal has become a blunder in that respect.

We've responded to an epidemic, but the issue is how and why.

Batches of vaccine are being destroyed for lack of recipients, so timely delivery is actually quite a blunder in that sense.

This all reads like the higher priority is political point scoring and victories on paper that don't pan out in concrete terms.
 
You hit upon one of the concerns with the phrase "desperate last-second scramble to escape". I mean, that's not a good thing, is it? And who is in control? Our friends the Taliban. Most of the Americans and allies that remain are behind Taliban lines. All of this is due to poor planning on the part of the Biden Administration acting unilaterally with no coordination with NATO and other allies we worked with over the past 20 years.


Intelligence was another massive failure. Did Biden have any the country was going to fall to the Taliban so fast? Hard to say. He told us with a straight face that it was highly unlikely, that we'd see no Saigon like scenes, that he wasn't aware of any criticism from any of our allies, and that Americans weren't having any trouble at all getting to the airport. Most of this was refuted in real time as he was saying it. He seems to have almost no idea of what is happening.
Intelligence might be a failure. But is that Biden's fault or the intelligence agencies?


I'm talking talking about the NY Times, Wapo, CNN, the rest of the alphabet networks, the economist, the BBC, lots of podcasters on the left (Sam Harris, etc.), leftists on twitter, left leaning celebrities, world leaders, etc, etc, etc, even a few left leaning ISF posters.

I can't imagine who or where is saying "this is the best thing he's done and it makes him look better than he did before". I'm sure there is some strange corner of the Internet.
A lot of that news media isn't "leftist." Just because ulta right wing whackos call them that doesn't make it true. This statement is a perfect example of the dishonesty of the whackos like FOX, OAN, etc. They call anyone who doesn't toe the latest right wing spin as leftist. Ronald Reagan's policies would be called leftist today by the whackos.
Generally speaking, the media takes a militaristic spin.
 
For starters, his administration completely botched the withdrawal in Afghanistan. Yes, the majority was onboard with withdrawing, but it was done with astounding incompetence. On top of that, Biden told blatantly lies throughout - many that were quickly revealed by his own Administration.

Really? We've gotten over 51,000 people out without firing a shot, including over 5,000 Americans. You consider that completely botched?
 
Unfortunately (or fortunately, depending on which side of the political aisle one is on) It fell to Biden. He owns it by pure virtue of being President. Would Trump be any better? No. Would he be worse? Maybe.

Maybe? Definitely. Trump would fairly certainly be shouting fake news all over the place, praising the Taliban to try to appease them (to no effect), getting involved in ways that just made everything about the withdrawal more chaotic, more costly, and less effective... more could be safely predicted based on Trump's record, but it's quite safe to say that it'd be even uglier.

Though the Muslim ban is a good one. The Biden Administration is letting Afghans in the country. Trump and is supporters would likely not, due to racism.

I think that "likely" can be upgraded a bit. Under the Trump Administration, Stephen Miller and co outright sabotaged the ability of the US to fulfill its promises to the Afghans helping us and ground that to a halt. Trump might have let in a couple as a show, maybe, though.

I mean I would be all for letting in lots of Afghan refugees but of course we could only have even started doing that in maybe February,

Ideally. In reality, the part of the government handling that was left sabotaged and crippled and trying to deal with the humanitarian and administrative crisis of the southern border took firm priority for multiple reasons. The Trump Administration left a bunch of huge messes to clean up.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom