Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
He'll caucus with the Democrats. He doesn't get to hold sway over the Senate if Republicans have 51 senators.

Ah but he would still have the controlling as otherwise it would be a tie and it goes to Harris. It all depends on who he thinks will give him the most power in control of the senate.

Still probably best to caucus with the democrats as Mitch is just fine with nothing getting done. Being an impediment to passing anything only matters if you care if anything gets passed.
 
His Domestic approval is at 44 something (with over 50% disapproving), so I think it's almost certain his numbers have fallen. Especially with Afghanistan.
the numbers are down, but it's driven by the lack of progress or even apparent effort on domestic issues.
 
Data is from early August, before everyone saw what a cluster **** Afghanistan turned into. We'll see if his numbers hold up.
"Turned" into? Afghanistan was always a cluster ****, and any expectation that the withdrawal wouldn't also be was hopelessly naive. I'm surprised it didn't turn out worse.

But falling public opinion is hardly surprising considering their ignorance.

Why is Afghanistan falling to the Taliban so fast?
Lt Col Daniel L Davis (ret)
Sat 14 Aug 2021

The Taliban has been seizing territory in Afghanistan at an alarming rate, having captured all or parts of 10 provincial capitals from the Afghan National Defense Security Forces (ANDSF) in the past week. Far from representing a reason for Joe Biden to halt the withdrawal, however, this rapid deterioration in Afghan security has exposed the bankruptcy of US policies...

For the better part of at least the past 15 years, senior US civilian and uniformed leaders have been publicly telling the American people that the war in Afghanistan was necessary for US security, making progress, and supporting an Afghan security force that was performing well. All of it, from the beginning, was a lie...

“You know, you really shouldn’t be surprised” by how fast the Afghan military is collapsing, Sopko said in congressional testimony in late July. For at least nine consecutive years, Sopko continued, the Sigar had been “highlighting problems with our train, advise and assist mission with the Afghan military.” Why did the American public not know about this weakness earlier?

So now the public finally 'discovers' the truth (which wasn't hard to guess) and it's all Biden's fault? Of course is it, to someone with no critical thinking skills and the memory of a goldfish. It's not just ignorant consumers of news who are at fault though - the news media itself has been pushing this 'Biden failure' angle ever since they realized that the deadline was real. Why? Because bad news sells, and they needed to make as much out of it as possible before it was over (when we will go back to ignoring Afghanistan because who cares about a few towel-heads).

But what is the main reason Biden's approval is dropping? The usual one - democrats:-

Democrats' months of dithering are sandbagging Biden's popularity
President Biden's popularity is in bad shape. The FiveThirtyEight poll average has him at 43.5 percent approval, which is approaching former President Donald Trump territory — and more than 10 points down from Biden's peak in March.

Now, there are surely a number of factors behind this fall. The mainstream media had a jingoistic panic attack over U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan, and the ongoing pandemic is horribly unpleasant and depressing. The economy is in rough shape, too. All this surely took a toll on Biden's numbers.

But it's also not a coincidence that Biden's peak popularity came after his party quickly passed the huge American Rescue Plan (ARP), or that he's now at a low point after seven months of incomprehensible Democratic dithering in Congress over his Build Back Better agenda. It shows how his party's recent lack of political virtues like confidence, boldness, and aggression has sapped his popularity...

Speaking personally — as someone well to Biden's left who nevertheless recognizes his original, full-priced agenda as a big step forward — it's been a profoundly demoralizing seven months. Watching the party twiddle its thumbs trying to make sense of the erratic and self-contradictory garbage coming out of Sens. Joe Manchin (D-W.V.) and Kyrsten Sinema (D-Ariz.) to get something worth passing through Congress is both boring and maddening.

The same democrats who just recently 'discovered' what a cluster **** Afghanistan was, now are 'bored and demoralized' by the reality of politics. Where is the confidence, boldness, and aggression we expected? Perhaps we should have voted for Trump instead!
 
Last edited:
I will say Biden did a bad job evacuating Afghanistan when someone points me to a country where citizens think they did a great job evacuating. No group seems to think the country they reside in did a good job.
 
Sens. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.) and Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) squabbled behind closed doors Wednesday, with Manchin using a raised-fist goose egg to tell his colleague he can live without any of President Biden's social spending plan, Axios has learned.

https://www.axios.com/manchin-sanders-reconciliation-fight-789c8441-fa49-404f-9d36-4adaa8e1d908.html

I love this story so much. I find it particularly amusing when an earnest but clueless group runs into the buzzsaw of reality. There are some democrats that probably should have known better, but the reality that Manchin controlled the agenda was obvious since January.

In the article, he said just pass the infrastructure bill and wait six months to see what happens. Instead of doing that, they played around with a plan they didn't have the votes for when they could have already been on the six month wait with a passed infrastructure bill.
 
Manchin is "young" enough to want another term. His next election is 2024. He will want to be remembered for something other than a powerful vote...if he votes...rather than voting no. He has to juggle his coal backers and democratic working class voters. Though he trashes entitlements, infrastructure jobs will be attractive in his state. Therefore he will in the end vote for a whittled down bill with zero climate money.
 
There was a political cartoon I saw yesterday. It was set on Halloween at the "Sinemanchin" house, with Manchin and Sinema standing on their doorstep with looks of utter terror on their faces. They were being confronted by a Trick-or-Treater dressed as the Bill from the old Schoolhouse Rock "I'm Just a Bill" short, saying "I'm a Bill that actually passed Congress."
 
https://www.axios.com/manchin-sanders-reconciliation-fight-789c8441-fa49-404f-9d36-4adaa8e1d908.html

I love this story so much. I find it particularly amusing when an earnest but clueless group runs into the buzzsaw of reality. There are some democrats that probably should have known better, but the reality that Manchin controlled the agenda was obvious since January.

In the article, he said just pass the infrastructure bill and wait six months to see what happens. Instead of doing that, they played around with a plan they didn't have the votes for when they could have already been on the six month wait with a passed infrastructure bill.

That the Democrats weren't on top of messaging and setting expectations low since day 1 is probably the big error here.

It's even worse than the Obama years that Republicans went full obstructionist. At least in that scenario the Democrats could partially deflect blame for inaction on the opposite party taking a deliberately obstructionist approach.

This time around the problem is that Democrats are obstructing their own party head. Much blame is being placed on Manchin and Sinema, but the broader problem is that the party is not unified enough to govern on the razer thin margin they secured last election. On paper the Democrats have total control (barely) of government, but in practice they are still largely paralyzed.

Republicans showed that obstructing government was an effective political ploy, and it will likely be even more effective now that it's the supposed majority party obstructing itself.

I guess Biden has little choice but to accept whatever insanely neutered bill Manchin and Sinema are willing to accept and pretend it's some great accomplishment, but any hope of having material conditions significantly improved for large swaths of the voting public before the next election seems lost.

Biden is riding out his paralyzed presidency, unless Democrats can somehow broaden their majority in the Senate.
 
Biden wanted to pass a very progressive bill whilst pretending that it's just business as usual, in the hope of appealing to a moderate center.
That backfired because Republicans will call every Democrat a socialist/communist and Democrats want more than just a continuation of Obama.
 
I guess Biden has little choice but to accept whatever insanely neutered bill Manchin and Sinema are willing to accept and pretend it's some great accomplishment, but any hope of having material conditions significantly improved for large swaths of the voting public before the next election seems lost.

Biden is riding out his paralyzed presidency, unless Democrats can somehow broaden their majority in the Senate.

To your last point, what was the most liberal spending bill Obama proposed? I went looking, and I think it was the 800 billion ARRA act. Manchin supports a bill bigger than that, and it isn't because of inflation.

The baseline is relative. You call it neutered. But if you told 2009 Bernie Sanders that he could get a 1+ trillion appropriation instead of ARRA, with a means tested child tax credit monthly payment that no one was even proposing, he might have thought that was more progressive.
 
To your last point, what was the most liberal spending bill Obama proposed? I went looking, and I think it was the 800 billion ARRA act. Manchin supports a bill bigger than that, and it isn't because of inflation.

The baseline is relative. You call it neutered. But if you told 2009 Bernie Sanders that he could get a 1+ trillion appropriation instead of ARRA, with a means tested child tax credit monthly payment that no one was even proposing, he might have thought that was more progressive.

I don't think Obama was much of a spender, nor anywhere near as progressive as his campaign materials would have the public believe. He governed quite conservatively. Biden doesn't enjoy the same level of wild celebrity status that Obama benefited from, and conditions and expectations seem to have shifted quite a bit since those days.
 
I don't think Obama was much of a spender, nor anywhere near as progressive as his campaign materials would have the public believe. He governed quite conservatively. Biden doesn't enjoy the same level of wild celebrity status that Obama benefited from, and conditions and expectations seem to have shifted quite a bit since those days.

That is what I'm saying. Expectations shifting doesn't change the reality that Manchin is supporting the most progressive spending legislation progressives have gotten in decades, if ever. Thinking they could have gotten more doesn't make it less progressive.

But this is the progressive victory....They shifted the discourse so much that they got a senator from west Virginia to support a trillion in spending.
 
That is what I'm saying. Expectations shifting doesn't change the reality that Manchin is supporting the most progressive spending legislation progressives have gotten in decades, if ever. Thinking they could have gotten more doesn't make it less progressive.

But this is the progressive victory....They shifted the discourse so much that they got a senator from west Virginia to support a trillion in spending.

The question is whether the increase in willingness to spend is keeping apace with the increased need (or perceived need).

Things are much worse now than it was 10 years ago. it could be more and still not even close to good enough.
 
The question is whether the increase in willingness to spend is keeping apace with the increased need (or perceived need).

Things are much worse now than it was 10 years ago. it could be more and still not even close to good enough.

That seems like a pretty irrelevant question. It not being good enough doesn't change anything.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom