Cont: The Biden Presidency Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nobody cared about Afghanistan the last couple decades when no conceivable victory was possible, and I don't see any reason why anybody is going to care now that we've admitted defeat. Ripping off the band-aid early in the term was a good play, by the time elections roll around nobody will give a ****.

https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?q=Afghanistan&geo=US

I said this over and over at the time. I think this is the lesson that we should have learned from Trump. The news cycles very fast. There is too much going on for people to notice past maybe a month or two.
 
I said this over and over at the time. I think this is the lesson that we should have learned from Trump. The news cycles very fast. There is too much going on for people to notice past maybe a month or two.

It was obvious nobody cared anyway. The war would not have been able to drag on for 20 years with no articulable victory conditions had anyone cared.
 
They cared enough to answer polls saying they wanted it to end, so the effect of ending it can only be positive if anything. Looking for that to somehow politically harm the people who ended it is one of the most foolish things you could think in politics right now. Yes, I know it comes from people who tried really hard to turn it into something bad, but that fizzled pretty quickly. The attempted negative rewriting of it is the part that really has nobody caring.

What's really going to make Afghanistan not matter for the next couple of elections, despite the fact that it was a popular move so it could have been used as an electoral positive, is the complete refusal to do anything or even be seen really trying to do anything on domestic issues.
 
It was obvious nobody cared anyway. The war would not have been able to drag on for 20 years with no articulable victory conditions had anyone cared.

IMV you're right.

But one particular poster (who I generally respect) insisted I had partisan blinders on and I was whistling past the graveyard.
 
Polls
CNN:
Gallup noted that the 88-point gap they measured between Republicans' and Democrats' ratings of Biden stands as "among the largest in more than eight decades," trailing only the divide in opinions about Donald Trump. Across all seven polls, Democrats were on average about 75 percentage points likelier than Republicans to say they approve of Biden.

https://www.cnn.com/2021/10/29/politics/approval-rating-biden-polls/index.html
 
House progressives seem to have postponed the vote to next week. Not surprise. Not sure where Sinema and Manchin stand with latest 1700 page framework/bill.
https://www.cnn.com/2021/10/28/politics/biden-agenda-deal-democrats/index.html
House progressives delayed it?

Well, no. Moving both bills simultaneously has been the plan all along. One of the bills isn't ready.

Let's see here. Manchin/Sinema are on the 1.5t team, progressives are on the 6t team. We're at 1.75t and M/S are still kinda wishy-washy. The bill isn't ready because we've been changing it over time so that M/S now have 94.4% of what they want.

But "progressives" are causing this delay?
 
Last edited:
House progressives delayed it?

Well, no. Moving both bills simultaneously has been the plan all along. One of the bills isn't ready.

Let's see here. Manchin/Sinema are on the 1.5t team, progressives are on the 6t team. We're at 1.75t and M/S are still kinda wishy-washy. The bill isn't ready because we've been changing it over time so that M/S now have 94.4% of what they want.

But "progressives" are causing this delay?

The problem is the progressives have no leverage whatsoever. None. It the Dems had a 60/40 split in the Senate Manchin and Sinema would be irrelevant. Lose one vote and it crashes down.

I'm on the progressives side, but there are political realities that they need to face.
 
Sure, but it's not their intransigence holding anything up.

All I know at the moment is that Pelosi called off the vote and the reason from my understanding is because of the progressives who are not happy. Now that may or may not be true.
 
All I know at the moment is that Pelosi called off the vote and the reason from my understanding is because of the progressives who are not happy. Now that may or may not be true.

I suppose it depends on your viewpoint. If a train is derailed by bandits, and after a long argument nothing happens, you may well fault those who decide to get off it and stop trying to get it back on the tracks, but they're not the bandits.
 
The problem is the progressives have no leverage whatsoever. None. It the Dems had a 60/40 split in the Senate Manchin and Sinema would be irrelevant. Lose one vote and it crashes down.

I'm on the progressives side, but there are political realities that they need to face.
Progressives have no leverage whatsoever...
All I know at the moment is that Pelosi called off the vote and the reason from my understanding is because of the progressives who are not happy. Now that may or may not be true.
Pelosi called off the vote because progressives are unhappy...

[emoji848]

How do you square that circle?
 
I suppose it depends on your viewpoint. If a train is derailed by bandits, and after a long argument nothing happens, you may well fault those who decide to get off it and stop trying to get it back on the tracks, but they're not the bandits.

That analogy sucks.

What good do the progressives think they are accomplishing? Do they think this will get M&S to change their minds?
 
Progressives have no leverage whatsoever...
Pelosi called off the vote because progressives are unhappy...

[emoji848]

How do you square that circle?

Because it won't matter to M or S. Would they prefer that that no bill is passed? M & S seem quite fine with the bill failing.
 
That analogy sucks.

What good do the progressives think they are accomplishing? Do they think this will get M&S to change their minds?
I suppose it as a bad analogy,but perhaps the jumping progressives believe that M&S won't change their minds by any other way, if at all, so they might as well let their point of view be known.

Or, maybe (and it's a distinct possibility) they're doing something dumb. It would not be the first time for them or anyone else.
 
I suppose it as a bad analogy,but perhaps the jumping progressives believe that M&S won't change their minds by any other way, if at all, so they might as well let their point of view be known.

Or, maybe (and it's a distinct possibility) they're doing something dumb. It would not be the first time for them or anyone else.

I don't know. I consider myself a progressive. But over the last 40 years I think progressives far too often have snatched defeat from the claws of victory. Imagine what would happen if Manchin switched parties and McConnell became the majority leader again.
 
I don't know. I consider myself a progressive. But over the last 40 years I think progressives far too often have snatched defeat from the claws of victory. Imagine what would happen if Manchin switched parties and McConnell became the majority leader again.
Not having anything happen wouldn't be the Democrats' fault anymore.
 
The problem is the progressives have no leverage whatsoever. None.
They have precisely what S&M have: the ability to vote for a bill so it passes or vote against it so it doesn't.

I'm on the progressives side, but there are political realities that they need to face.
Why are there no "political realities that" S&M "need to face"?

What good do the progressives think they are accomplishing? Do they think this will get M&S to change their minds?
What good do S&M think they are accomplishing? Do they think this will get progressives to change their minds?

Would they prefer that that no bill is passed?
What's left of it is about the same as nothing anyway, so ya, why not?

M & S seem quite fine with the bill failing.
On that point, we have finally reached a real difference between the two sides: S&M are going out of their way to make it fail, while progressives are merely willing to allow it to fail if S&M manage to damage it badly enough.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom